iPhone app iPad app Android phone app Android tablet app More

Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
GET UPDATES FROM Laura Rogers
 

What Can Danish Hogs Teach Us About Antibiotics?

Posted: 10/13/09 11:13 AM ET

Beautiful Denmark is known throughout the world for its pastries, furniture design and ham.

Yes, ham. Denmark is the largest exporter of pork in the world. The country, not much larger than Massachusetts, produces more than 26 million hogs each year--much of it in an industrialized system--selling nearly 90 percent of its pork to nations around the globe. But more important, Denmark is one of the first countries proactively seeking to reduce the growing public health threat of antibiotic resistance by banning the use of antibiotics in healthy food animals, a practice still widespread in the United States.

American agribusiness often has criticized Denmark's 1998 ban on antibiotics, calling it an outright failure. But compelling new research presented by a Danish scientist earlier this year showed the opposite, revealing that antibiotic use on industrial farms has dropped by half while productivity has increased by 47 percent since 1992. Danish swine production has increased from 18.4 million in 1992 to 27.1 million in 2008. A decrease in antibiotic-resistant bacteria in food animals and meat has followed the reduced use of these vital drugs. A team representing the Pew Campaign on Human Health and Industrial Farming recently traveled to the Scandinavian country to take a first-hand look at the Danish antibiotics ban.

My colleagues and I from The Pew Charitable Trusts met with Danish researchers who have been monitoring antibiotic use in food animals in their country for the past 15 years. Our Danish hosts included Dr. Jan Mousing, Denmark's chief veterinary officer; Dr. Frank Aarestrup, a veterinarian and professor at the National Food Institute at the Technical University of Denmark; and Dr. Henrik Wegener, a medical doctor and a leading microbiologist on antibiotic resistance and director of the National Food Institute at the Technical University of Denmark.

We also met with the Danish Agriculture and Food Council--a powerful lobbying group that represents most of the country's agricultural interests: swine, chickens, beef, dairy cattle and more. And, we spent the better part of a day at an industrial swine farm, with an animated and energetic farmer eager to talk about his work, his pigs and the almost non-existent use of antibiotics on his farm.

All of our meetings confirmed that Denmark's swine industry is successful and growing post-ban. The pork producers and those who represent them are fiercely proud of how they raise their pigs. Contrary to U.S. agribusiness claims about the ban, the average number of pigs produced per sow per year has increased from 21 to 25 (this is an important indicator of swine health and welfare, according to veterinarians). Most important, total antibiotic use has declined by 51 percent since an all-time high in 1992. Plus, the Danish industry group told us that the ban did not increase the cost of meat for the consumer.

Coincidentally, three days after our fact-finding mission ended, another one began--but this time in the form of a delegation of four members of Congress from the U.S. House of Representatives' Agriculture Committee. The world's largest exporter of pork was hosting back-to-back meetings with Americans.

On September 19, a delegation that included House Agriculture Committee Chairman Collin Peterson (D-MN) met with Danish experts. While pressure from U.S. agribusiness and the pharmaceutical industry will be fierce on Congress to continue its stance against the Preservation of Antibiotics for Medical Treatment Act (PAMTA), this trip should do much to clear up potential misconceptions and demonstrate that we can safely and effectively remove routine overuse of antibiotics on industrial farms. This bill would withdraw the use of seven classes of antibiotics vitally important to human health from industrial animal production unless animals or herds are sick with disease, or unless drug companies can prove that their routine use does not harm human health through antibiotic resistance. This legislation is critically important because these are the drugs we depend on to keep ourselves healthy, but which one day could be ineffective partly because of overuse in food animals.

An estimated 90,000 Americans die each year from infections that are increasingly resilient against the most powerful antibiotics. About 70 percent of those infections are associated with bacterial pathogens that are resistant to at least one drug.

While Denmark stopped the practice of using antibiotics to grow animals fatter faster, the full arsenal of these drugs remains available to veterinarians to prescribe treatment for sick animals and herds. This practice is unlike what occurs here in the United States--where up to 70 percent of all antibiotics sold are fed to healthy food animals with no prescription required. The Danes also stipulate that the drugs be sold by a pharmacy, not the prescribing vet. This prudent policy was instituted to limit financial incentives in dispensing antibiotics.

The American Medical Association, American Academy of Pediatrics, Infectious Diseases Society of America and many other health groups agree that we are losing many antibiotics due to decades of unnecessary overuse in both human medicine and agriculture. Moreover, very few new antibiotics are in the pipeline for future approvals.

Denmark's ban on the routine use of antibiotics on food animal farms is a success. The United States has an effective model to draw upon when it comes to protecting public health. We can learn from Denmark, swiftly pass the PAMTA legislation and save our antibiotics so that antibiotics can continue to save us.

 
 
 
Beautiful Denmark is known throughout the world for its pastries, furniture design and ham. Yes, ham. Denmark is the largest exporter of pork in the world. The country, not much larger than Massac...
Beautiful Denmark is known throughout the world for its pastries, furniture design and ham. Yes, ham. Denmark is the largest exporter of pork in the world. The country, not much larger than Massac...
 
 
  • Comments
  • 24
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Bloggers
Recency  | 
Popularity
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
kareemachan
watashi ha tororu ga oroka da to omoi masu。
02:06 PM on 10/18/2009
You listening, agribusiness? It can be done and it should be done.
09:24 PM on 10/15/2009
Another article that speaks about "industrial swine" as if they aren't living, feeling beings.

Pigs ("swine" is the industry term) suffer so much in this hell holes. Anti-biotics or not, it's a crime of nature what we do to them because of our habits and want of pleasure.

They are intelligent, sensitive creatures, not meant to be put in metal barns their whole life without sunshine, fresh air or ground to root in. Plus all the abuse, fear, and frustration they must endure.

All for our taste buds.

It's just sickening.

It doesn't matter how much they "clean up" these factory farms they are still very cruel and wrong.
05:47 PM on 01/05/2010
I feel I must reply to you so that you know not all pigs live this way. Growing up, we raised our own and they had wonderful lives. Yes, we ended up eating them. But, while they were alive we played with them, pet them, and generally loved them. It taught us kids responsibility and about the cycle of life. I know we were probably the exception rather than the rule. Most pig farms in our area (and there were a ton!) were pretty much the same as ours. The farming way of life is a hard and wonderful one, and one that many wouldn't do for a million dollars. Our families provide food for everyone and get constant criticism and low pay. Please visit a farming family sometime with an open heart and mind!
photo
HUFFPOST COMMUNITY MODERATOR
mexamerican
professor
07:48 AM on 10/14/2009
i don't know what they can teach about antibiotics, but about rethuglican greed, a lot.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
hulagirrrl
02:24 AM on 10/14/2009
Most Western European Countries have banned US meat many years ago, due to the high level of growth hormones. Therefor you will find not only a lower transfat level at your favorite McBurger places but also a better tasting burger.
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
Dana Ullman
Evidence Based Homeopath
10:30 PM on 10/13/2009
There is a certain sad karmic justice to American agrobusiness' hyper-use of antibiotics, leading to increased resistance to antibiotics and increased sick people.

Because Americans over-simplify disease causation and love to blame bacteria and viruses for almost everything (what I call the "outside agitator theory" of disease), it is ironic that antibiotics destroy the inner ecological complexity of living organisms...leading to more serious chronic disease.

Americans are so daft that they do not even seem to know what the word means. It is no wonder that their allopathic medicine leads to short-term benefits and long-term immunological breakdown and mental disease. The good news here is that their mental disease will confuse them so much that they won't even get how really sick they are. THAT IS DAFT...
03:21 AM on 10/14/2009
And the PROOF is where?
04:38 AM on 10/14/2009
Perhaps you haven't read the article - always best to do this before making such comments.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
kareemachan
watashi ha tororu ga oroka da to omoi masu。
02:05 PM on 10/18/2009
RTFA before commenting, roc.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Sheldon101
sheldon101blog.blogspot.com Wakefield transcripts
11:54 AM on 10/14/2009
Actually, it's science that caused the problem by creating antibiotics. Business and science discovered that adding antibiotics to the feed of 'healthy' animals resulted in higher weight. Science has long suspected and now largely proven that this practice results in more antibiotic resistance in humans.

And it's medical community that leading the opposition.

Without our over-simplified view of disease causation, we'd never have discovered antibiotics and antibiotic resistance.
HUFFPOST COMMUNITY MODERATOR
TXfemmom
Grandma with eye on the future
04:39 PM on 10/13/2009
The United States should ban the use of antibiotics in our animals for human consumption. It is used as a regular thing, instead of for a specific animal exhibiting symptoms.

The ban would be extremely difficult to get but it would do so much to make our food safer.
04:18 PM on 10/13/2009
Agrobiz hates facts.. Lies are more profitable..
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
MJinCanada
Safe from zombies until my 2nd cup of coffee
04:00 PM on 10/13/2009
This is great news.

Especially since feeding animals antibiotics is often a way of avoiding the work of taking care of them properly. And we know what happens when hog farms are unsanitary -- H1N1 and other diseases.
02:11 PM on 10/13/2009
"This practice is unlike what occurs here in the United States--where up to 70 percent of all antibiotics sold are fed to healthy food animals with no prescription required. "

This statistic includes ionophores. Ionophores are nutritional supplements that help rumens maintain the right bacteria to breakdown both grain and roughage. Extreme problems would be bloat {runaway bacteria growth) or starvation with a full belly on the other end. Ionophores are not fed to pigs and with the exception of quinine, are not used in human medicine. Abolut half the anitbiotics produced in this country are ionophores consumed in sheep and cattle feed.
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
Angie Cordeiro
We do all things through Grace which empowers us.
12:20 PM on 10/13/2009
"...While Denmark stopped the practice of using antibiotics to grow animals fatter faster, the full arsenal of these drugs remains available to veterinarians to prescribe treatment for sick animals and herds. This practice is unlike what occurs here in the United States--where up to 70 percent of all antibiotics sold are fed to healthy food animals with no prescription required. The Danes also stipulate that the drugs be sold by a pharmacy, not the prescribing vet. This prudent policy was instituted to limit financial incentives in dispensing antibiotics...."

Yep, we are doing the exact same thing to our new born children, requiring over 20 vaccinations before the child is three years old ... we are on auto pilot because TIME is MONEY; have a change to LIFE is ART ...
02:54 PM on 10/13/2009
While establishing prudent antibiotics policy in the US a laudable goal, don't conflate it with your perverse fear of vaccination.

Antibiotic overuse and vaccination policies are very separate and unrelated issues.
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
Angie Cordeiro
We do all things through Grace which empowers us.
03:36 PM on 10/13/2009
The relation being PHARMACEUTICALS going array ;-)
HUFFPOST COMMUNITY MODERATOR
TXfemmom
Grandma with eye on the future
04:38 PM on 10/13/2009
You are trying to compare apples and organces.
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
Angie Cordeiro
We do all things through Grace which empowers us.
05:24 PM on 10/13/2009
Think Different...or not...it's about a healthy BALANCE and right now and for the last fifty years there has been a marked imbalance of pharmaceuticals and less about sustainable local choices ...

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dqof641pWys