More

Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Leo W. Gerard

GET UPDATES FROM Leo W. Gerard
 

Republicans Try to Convert America Into Pottersville

Posted: 12/26/11 08:31 AM ET

In the iconic Christmas film, It's a Wonderful Life, an angel offers the beleaguered main character, George Bailey, the stark choice between a hometown named for a cruel banker or one created by and for the middle class.

The banker's town, Pottersville, is filled with bars, gambling dens and despair. The people's town of Bedford Falls is made of hope, hard working middle class families, and their homes financed by the Bailey Brothers Building & Loan.

The film's happy ending is the people of Bedford Falls banding together to rescue George Bailey and the Bailey Brothers Building & Loan that had given so many of them a leg up over the years. Republicans seek a different conclusion. They find middle class cooperation and community intolerable. They want the banker, Henry Potter, with his "every man for himself" philosophy to triumph. In the spirit of their self-centered mentor Ayn Rand, Republicans are trying to disfigure America so she resembles Pottersville.

A building and loan association, like the Bailey Brothers', uses the savings of its members to provide mortgages to the depositors. Members essentially pool their money to give each other the opportunity to buy cars and homes. At one point in the film, George Bailey explains this concept to frightened depositors who are trying to withdraw their savings during the panic that led to bank runs in 1929.

Bailey urges the townspeople who had crowded into the building and loan office to withdraw only what they need, not empty their accounts. "We have got to stick together," he tells them, "We have to do this together." A building and loan doesn't function without trust and cooperation.

It works well for Bedford Falls. The mortgages it provides help working people move out of the Potters Field slums and into Bailey Park, where homes well kept by their owners increase in value. Despite the success, Potter condemned this practice, saying it was based on "high ideals without common sense." He criticized the Bailey Brothers Building & Loan for granting a taxi driver a mortgage after Potter's bank had rejected his application. Potter scoffed at such practices, asking if the building and loan was a "business or a charity ward."

This is exactly what Republicans do. They describe beloved American programs like Medicare and Social Security as charities -- using the euphemism "entitlements." Like mortgages from the Bailey Building & Loan, Medicare and Social Security are not charities. They're the American people depositing and pooling their money for the benefit of the American community.

The GOP tries to destroy programs like these that aid the middle class, the vast majority of Americans -- the 99 percent -- while Republicans protect tax breaks and special perks for the rich -- the one percent, the Henry Potters.

This time last year, Republicans demanded extension of tax breaks for the 1 percent, contending tax breaks stimulate the economy.

For the past three months, however, Republicans have fought extension of payroll tax cuts, contending a break benefiting 160 million middle class Americans did not stimulate the economy.

All year, Republicans have demanded an end to programs the middle class created to aid the majority, the 99 percent. The GOP wants to reverse the new banking regulations that were passed in an attempt to prevent another economic collapse caused by risky Wall Street practices. The GOP tried to to rescind the healthcare reform law that prevents insurance companies from terminating coverage when beneficiaries get sick and prohibits the practice of refusing coverage to people with pre-existing conditions.

Influential Republicans this year have called for repealing laws forbidding child labor, laws guaranteeing minimum wage and laws protecting the environment. They've demanded elimination of federal funding for organizations like the Public Broadcasting System that educates preschoolers, Head Start, which provides opportunity to poor children, and Planned Parenthood, which uses 97 percent of its funds to provide general, obstetrical and gynecological medical care to women, many of whom are rural and poor.

Republicans have decided to be the party of Henry Potter, the "meanest man in the county," a man about whom George Bailey's father said: "he's a sick man, frustrated. Sick in his mind, sick in his soul, if he has one."

Like Potter, Republicans deride compassion and community as character defects.

In the Republican world, where greed is good, it was appropriate for Henry Potter to keep the $8,000 in Bailey Building & Loan money that George Bailey's uncle, Billy Bailey, accidentally handed him.

Republicans are attempting to impose that selfish belief system on the selfless American people, people like the citizens of Bedford Falls who rush to the rescue of neighbors.

It won't work, just like it didn't in It's a Wonderful Life. Republicans will fail in their attempt to make America Pottersville because the 99 percent believe avarice is a sin, not a value. The GOP will fail because greed is not the American way.

 

Follow Leo W. Gerard on Twitter: www.twitter.com/uswblogger

 
 
  • Comments
  • 1,691
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Highlights
Bloggers
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2 3 4 5  Next ›  Last »  (18 total)
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Glowbeanie
07:28 PM on 01/01/2012
This is so true. Just like the man whose home was burned down, while firefighters and neighbors, stood in watched...because this man failed to pay his insurance for that month or several. The bottom line is that the wealthy and rich in the country and every nation where the wealthy are few and the poor as getting poorer and growing by the millions. Something is definitely wrong with that picture and needs to be fixed so it can allow the new generations of Americans, placed in dire financial situations crisis by Wall Street, to be able to not suffer total financial ruin due to faulty decisions by Washington, Wall Street, Big Banks, National and multinational corporations, the rich!
10:37 AM on 12/31/2011
Why, oh why, can't we just jettison these corportists? Let them have their Randian utopia. Let's have two Americas: one for the feudalistic/fascist/theocrats, and one for the people who believe in a contract between the citizen and the government, with each doing their part for the general good. I think we are well beyond changing their mind at this point; surgery on this cancer is the only answer.
12:30 PM on 12/28/2011
It's about time organized labor creatively confronted the ideological theater of this struggle.
11:56 PM on 12/27/2011
Sure hope you're right about the outcome, Mr. Gerard! For an extremely thoughtful, scholarly and accomplished treatise that dovetails with and expands upon your thesis, I recommend The Shock Doctrine by Naomi Klein -- a "must read," if ever there was one.
04:36 AM on 12/28/2011
This is an excellent debate featuring Naomi Klein and another person. I suggest you listen very carefully:

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=g2kTy7glZ9s
07:40 AM on 12/28/2011
Yukio, I went to the link you provided,it was not a debate,but selected clips edited to make a case for a particular point of view.This type of editing is used by that Brightbart fellow,and fox.
09:07 AM on 12/28/2011
If you read his article closely it is the same old BS unions have said for years. It is yours take it.
06:46 PM on 12/27/2011
To the comments that conservatives give more to charity than liberals - when you factor out church giving it is not so unequal. I like many of my family am a liberal. The members of my family who still participate in organized religion give more via the catholic church. That doesn't make me happy but that is their choice. For 21 years I have worked with mostly republicans. I couldn't get 2/3 of them to chip for flowers when the secretary was hospitalized. Bottom line I am so sick of hearing hateful rhetoric about "entitlements, bums, welfare" etc. Based on the blather of the self named conservatives I associate with (not by choice and once I retire never again), and the right wing politicians anyone who supports a safety net for seniors and children are evil, unemployed socialists. I paid 34K in federal taxes this last year and I hope our country doesn't not turn it's back on Americans in need.
07:43 AM on 12/28/2011
Peter Schweizer, in Makers and Takers: Why Conservatives Work Harder, Feel Happier, Have Closer Families, Take Fewer Drugs, Give More Generously, Value Honesty More....," documents that Liberals are overall more selfish, more concerned on money, less hardworking, less satisfied emotionally, less honest, and less knowledgeable about politics than Conservatives. In his social survey, Schweizer found that Conservatives donate more money and volunteer more time to charitable causes than Liberals do. Even after eliminating church activities, Conservatives still volunteered for charitable work more frequently than Liberals. Conservatives are more likely than Liberals – 55 percent to 20 percent, almost triple – to say that they get happiness by putting another person’s happiness ahead of their own, and similar data were obtained in response to questions about caring for a seriously ill parent or spouse. In Who Really Cares?, Arthur C. Brooks calculated the annual giving gap between religious Conservatives and Liberals at $2,210 to $642.

According to the “National Generosity Index” in the Catalogue for Philanthropy, red states were ranked the highest. The blue states, such as Rhode Island, Massachusetts, New Jersey, Connecticut, and Wisconsin were on the bottom of the Index.

A Pew Survey (based primarily on the political party affiliation) found the following:

1. Conservatives are happier than Liberals.
2. Conservatives are more knowledgeable about politics and world affairs.
3. Conservatives are more generous.
4. Conservatives even give more blood.
09:28 AM on 12/28/2011
I see your statistic, but I know from personal experience that my liberals friends and family are more caring and giving than my conservative coworkers. I don't think much of donations to churches that try to drive their beliefs and lifestyles down my throat. There are also donations like Barbara Bush giving for Katrina, but the gift was buying software from her son's company. http://www.usatoday.com/news/nation/2006-03-24-bush-earmark_x.htm

So yeah it was a big gift, but how much did it help homeless people?
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
06:38 PM on 12/27/2011
When Gov. Mitch Daniels changed the laws in Indiana to stop mandatory union dues it decimated the unions. Unions saw their revenues cut by 90 percent. In 2005 16,408 people paid union dues, today it’s a mere 1490. Ouch!

What does this say about the cause of unions? It's over people.
05:23 PM on 12/28/2011
The cause or the need for unions isn't over. They've just been systematically murd**ed by forces who have always wanted to get rid of them - the same forces who want to dismantle Social Security and Medicare.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Mithrall
My inner child is a mean little S.O.B.
05:34 PM on 12/28/2011
No option to reply on other thread. Would I really have left an error in place instead of deleting and correcting it if I had meant it as a serious post?
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
06:15 PM on 12/28/2011
Yup like the Governor Daniel case above, the very members of the union are murderers of the people that dominate them.

I am glad to see Americans standing up for themselves in front of these thugs.

And yes, the Democrats have finally proven just how much damage to human life they have caused with their programs whose only purpose is to allow them to control others - it's greed in its most pure form. It's sickness beyond measure.

Let's hope and pray the conservatives can restore our government to the point where the government can actually follow through.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
stewartm0205
05:07 PM on 12/27/2011
Tax breaks for the rich damages the economy because it sucks money out of the productive economy and puts it into a savings account or worse puts it in the speculative economy where it causes boom and bust.
04:23 PM on 12/27/2011
Leo, the only problem with your thesis is that the democRATS have messed with the mortgage industry along with Fannie and Freddie, that you forget that it is the Republicans who are wanting the little town to remain like Bedford Falls.

obama promised hope and change, and the American people fell for the pitch. It's A Wonderful Life stars obama as old man Potter wanting to cheat George Bailey (the American people) out of their hard earned money.
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
Shan Wells
Sciencey sun venerator + political cartoonist
04:56 PM on 12/27/2011
Actually, the mortgage-backed security product came first, a creation of Wall Street. The default rate of F&F mortgages is twice as good as those issued by private corporations, indicating that the twin lenders actually did a much better job of capitalizing their loans.
photo
HUFFPOST COMMUNITY MODERATOR
swengnikaerb
'ello Duckies :)
10:17 PM on 12/27/2011
Who forced banks to create fraudulent lending practices beginning in 2000? Why did they lower their lending standards?? No one did. Greed. Plain and simple. Nice attempt. Have a bone and a belly rub.
08:30 AM on 12/28/2011
CRA - Community Reinvestment Act, for starters caused this problem. CRA offered mortgages to people who could NEVER in their wildest dreams pay back the loan. But the democRAT party forced the banks into bad lending practices. And you buddy obama was up to his eyeballs in the mix, forcing banks to make bad loans.
http://www.mediacircus.com/2008/10/obama-sued-citibank-under-cra-to-force-it-to-make-bad-loans/
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
lgillooly
03:58 PM on 12/27/2011
The sad part of this whole thing is average Republican voters believe the vitriol and lies from talk radio, Fox and other corporate backed rightwing media outlets.
Over the last 3 decades they have saturated the AM airwaves 24/7 and reach 20 million every day.Until there is accountablilty for lies of ommission, baseless attacks and Orwellian propaganda they will continue to succeed. Most Republican voters are good people that buy into this fake patriotism, pro life (until your born) welfare for corporations GOP. Sadly, they vote against their own interest and pit Americans against each other. When will they finally see that trickle down has ONLY trickled up and supply side economics is only half the equation?
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
TaurusRose
Seek the Unique
04:58 PM on 12/27/2011
And it has gone sooooooo beyond that.
12:05 AM on 12/28/2011
Actually, we've been trickled ON! To paraphrase Judge Judy, the robber barons have been peeing on our legs and telling us "it's raining!"
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
rextrek
50yr old, Moderate-liberal in S.NJ/Phila
02:53 PM on 12/27/2011
Greed will be the downfall of this country..if not now - someday in the near future...Hopefully I'll be long gone when that happens......Greed RUNS America....it runs ALL our holidays....almost every aspect of our lives. Its up to the Individual to make sense of it all - and prioritize life, and life's ups and downs. ]
The GOP talks about Deregulation, I guess they don't need Clean Air, water, Ground or safe products? The Higher ups and ther MSM have people, up against one another - distraction from the REAL Important Matters,Issues and news has become a Past-time......pitting neighbor against neighbor........pitting Union against non-union...when its the 1 and 2% we NEED to PAY Attention Too!
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
offred
A biocitizen is 3/5 of a corporate citizen
02:39 PM on 12/27/2011
"It's a Wonderful Life" will be banned under the next Republican administration.
01:56 PM on 12/27/2011
The GOP will fail because one day, hopefully before November 2012, they will wake up and realize that America is not USA, INC. It's not a business. It's a country and a nation that was built from the bottom up, not up down. Mitt Romney wants to run the country as a CEO.

CEO's rightfully, have one and only one thing on their mind, maximize profit. When it comes to profit or the moral thing to do, they will always go for the money. Period. This country didn't become great because presidents like TR, FDR, Lincoln, Ike, choice profit over doing the right thing.

So don't fall for this GOP BS about free markets and free enterprise solutions as the only answer.
I believe in capitalism too, but, when you are a leader of a nation as great as ours, it can't be always about the profit. If it was, we wouldn't have had SS, Medicare, the GI Bill, the interstate highway system, etc.....Think of what lesser of a country we would have been and listened to the GOP back then when they were fighting against these programs.
Genders
Love, Tolerance, Enlightenment
02:28 PM on 12/27/2011
well said! FF
photo
GUITFIDDEL
If you PICK on me, you better know the CHORDS
02:35 PM on 12/27/2011
Tell em' like it truly is "jdo1958"!! AND, when you're done tell em' again and WHAT FOR!! #68
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
otalp
Vermont dem
01:04 PM on 12/27/2011
I've always wondered how a computer model would describe our country/society if the Republicans had their way in all things and then the Democrats, This movie kinda does that.
photo
triplettam
Mind Bender
11:32 AM on 12/27/2011
Pottersville? Try Mordor.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
muck-raker
give me liberty or give me death
11:17 AM on 12/27/2011
Yes today we still have the movers and shakers, aka bought legislators, bribing contractors, making laws that only that the ultra rich can benefit...but then the PEOPLE still have the......

Mr Smith, aka Bernie Sanders that will come to Washington and FILIBUSTER the miscreants causing them to cower in the corner and scream for mercy. And all is well in Washington once again.