More

Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Lincoln Mitchell

GET UPDATES FROM Lincoln Mitchell
 

Can Newt Stop Himself?

Posted: 12/13/11 12:02 PM ET

Newt Gingrich's emergence as the front-runner for the Republican nomination for president, at least according to the most recent polls, is quite extraordinary. The comeback narrative is a common one in presidential politics, but it usually applies to a leading candidate who stumbles badly, but regains his footing in time for the early primaries. John McCain in 2008 and Bill Clinton in 1992 represent the best examples of that phenomenon. Gingrich's comeback is something very different. His campaign seemed quixotic from the time it began. Since his political fall well over a decade ago, Gingrich had been more of a political gadfly and reminder of another era than a serious political force. Even during most of this campaign, Gingrich has not done much to suggest that he was capable of, or even interested in, playing more than a fringe role. However, with only about three weeks to go before the Iowa caucus, Gingrich has become a plausible candidate for his party's nomination for president.

The Gingrich ascendancy is at least as much about good timing, even luck, as about anything Gingrich has done, but timing and luck always play an important role in presidential politics. Gingrich is benefitting both from the predictable collapse of Herman Cain's campaign and of being the non-Romney flavor of the month at the right time. Gingrich's challenge is to hold on to that mantle until the voting starts. Significantly, others such as Cain, Rick Perry and Michele Bachmann have been unable to maintain that position as scrutiny has increased.

Gingrich is, for all the obvious reasons, an odd choice to be the favorite of the radical right wing of the Republican Party. His history of divorce and adultery, of having spent the last three decades as a congressman, lobbyist and consummate Washington insider as well as a penchant for innovative, if occasionally goofy or frightening, policy solutions, some of which diverge from current right wing orthodoxy, would seem to create problems between Gingrich and the anti-government, fundamentalist Christian base of his party. Thus far, they have not. This is partially a reflection of the dissatisfaction and rancor felt by many in the Republican base towards Romney. Moreover, Gingrich, for all his faults, is able to rile liberal voters and activists to a degree far greater than Romney can. Romney's failure to emerge as a target of liberal hatred and scorn has made him suspect among his party's base, while Gingrich has been hated by liberal Democrats since before most of the other Republican candidates were involved in politics. This too is part of the reason for Gingrich's current surge in the polls.

Gingrich's appeal, despite what the former Speaker of the House may have persuaded himself is not due to his shiny policy ideas or proven leadership, but rather simply that he is the non-Romney candidate at the moment the music is about to stop. The more clearly Gingrich understands that, the stronger his chances will be. Accordingly, the best strategy for Gingrich at this time is probably to present himself as a generic right wing candidate, stress his conservative credentials and stop trying to persuade everybody of how smart he is. This is also a strategy which will be uniquely difficult for Gingrich to pursue. Most candidates stumble when they try to be something other than who they are, or when they seek to conceal their true self. In this respect, Gingrich is an exception. His current popularity is occurring in spite of Gingrich's personal story and quirky ideas, not because of them.

For Gingrich, the days before the January 3rd Iowa caucus will feel like an eternity. If he can make it through the next three weeks without making one too many gaffes or policy proposals which irritate primary voters while avoiding any serious examination of his record or background, he will have a good chance of winning in Iowa and stopping what once seemed to be the inevitable nomination of Romney by the Republican Party. However, as Gingrich's already ample ego and confidence grows as he stays in first place in most polls, it will be increasingly difficult for him to avoid the mistakes of hubris and over-confidence that have plagued him throughout his political career. In the 1990s, Gingrich was a clever and formidable political force, but one that could be reliably depended upon to overplay his hand. It is far from clear that he has changed in that respect.

 
 
 

Follow Lincoln Mitchell on Twitter: www.twitter.com/LincolnMitchell

Newt Gingrich's emergence as the front-runner for the Republican nomination for president, at least according to the most recent polls, is quite extraordinary. The comeback narrative is a common one ...
Newt Gingrich's emergence as the front-runner for the Republican nomination for president, at least according to the most recent polls, is quite extraordinary. The comeback narrative is a common one ...
 
 
  • Comments
  • 44
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2  Next ›  Last »  (2 total)
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Gadgetman
No sense of humor just isn't funny
06:52 PM on 12/14/2011
"Meanwhile, former House Speaker Newt Gingrich predicted that his recent rise in the polls is not a fluke: 'The American people want an adult, and no one has a stronger record of adultery than I do.' ~Andy Borowitz
photo
studioh!
just.words.
12:54 PM on 12/14/2011
"Gingrich had been more of a political gadfly and reminder of another era than a serious political force."

that's why the regressives like him - he's so retrograde.
photo
JudgeCCrater
From under a NJ boardwalk thanks to free Wi-Fi!
08:48 AM on 12/14/2011
This election will present two alternatives: (1) a common-sense candidate in charge of a weak economy (that he inherited it will be secondary to attention-limited Americans) or (2) an unlikeable lunatic. The election will go from being the GOP's to lose to being a loss for the GOP.
10:42 AM on 12/14/2011
How so? So if a candidate wants to run on a conservative platform that makes him Lunatic. Define lunatic for me and the rest of us, please.

I for one, as a democrat, see a government growing beyond its original boundaries. Spending $’s like a drunken sailor with programs that were valid and well intentioned initially and have become behemoths that the American people can no longer bear the cost of (ever expanding programs).

And if you ask which ones, I'll be happy to start with #1, the old widow and orphans program became the retirement program now called social security. It encompasses survivor benefits, disability (most legitimate, but abused also), and retirement benefits (predicated on an old formula of working to retired ratios that no longer holds true).
I have to ask, which of these candidates has actually passed a budget, controlled spending, and worked across the aisleway to do so?
You can say a lot about Newt, but he is not one to back down from a position, and he’s also not afraid to have the opposed conversation. It normally does not involve a lot of shouting and a barrage of name calling. So as a Democrat that is being driven out of the progressive party, I’m seriously looking at Gingrich as a presidential candidate myself.
photo
HUFFPOST PUNDIT
PatLow
A karate man bruises on the inside
03:25 PM on 12/14/2011
Take a look at what Newt did after the Contract with America. Look at spending increases under his watch as speaker of the house. How would Gingrich unite congress when he is one of the idividuals responsible for dividing it? You are no democrat, as no democrat I know would question one of the most successful government programs in US history.
photo
JudgeCCrater
From under a NJ boardwalk thanks to free Wi-Fi!
08:45 AM on 12/14/2011
Gingrich as POTUS is a scary thought. It's one thing to have wacky ideas; it's another to try to push half-baked schemes into existence as Gingrich was wont to do in the 90's. He doesn't appear to have changed, unfortunately.
07:05 AM on 12/14/2011
Romney's surrogates actually have the correct argument for once: Republicans want the election to be entirely about President Obama, and whether voters think he deserves reelection (they don't). If Newt Gingrich is the nominee, the election becomes, in large part, about Newt Gingrich and his ideas - both of which are very unpopular. Some will say that he's more disciplined as a candidate now, but if he is - why are people currently discussing whether grade school children should be put to work as janitors?
photo
Sorenson
Time for a Revolt of No Confidence
05:41 AM on 12/14/2011
The dude fits quite a few of the markers for sociopathy. inability to refrain from socially-awkward to socially-unacceptable behavior, inflated sense of self, lack of a sense of shame, impulsiveness, infidelity and/or promiscuity, extremily confrontational, and extremily hypocritical behavior just to name a few. Given any real political power, the man WILL be a danger to us and the rest of the world.
skykam
Sarcasm is a dish best served bitter.
04:43 AM on 12/14/2011
Interestingly, no one likes Newt. He's atop the pools because of who he isn't. He isn't Bachmann, Cain, Perry, Romney, etc... But when the inquisitors turn to look at who he actually is rather than who he isn't that popularity is certain to evaporate.
04:02 AM on 12/14/2011
I think it's odd that millions of conservatives all change their mind in unison. We have witnessed it happening five times in this campaign season. First they fell for Trump, then abandoned him en masse. Then Bachman, then Perry, then Cain. And now Gingrich. When millions of people all turn in the same direction at the same time like a school of fish, something is wrong with the democracy. I can't think of a better indicator that they are being led around by the nose by the propagandists at Fox News and talk radio. What a sorry state for the GOP and for our country. These folks should try exercising some of the democratic values they claim to believe in - values like independent mindedness and diversity of thought. To me, this is the real story of this election cycle.
12:42 PM on 12/14/2011
Why would you call people like Bachmann and Perry conservatives? They are not. Goldwater was a conservative and these R candidates would string him up to the nearest tree.

I'm not sure what political term would best describe them, but conservative surely is not it.
photo
grittyreboot
Book-Cover Critic
01:15 PM on 12/14/2011
I agree. These are not the conservative republicans of old. More like ultra-right religious radicals. Like the know-nothing party from the 1800s.
photo
studioh!
just.words.
12:58 PM on 12/14/2011
let's hope it's a short story
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
daniel o
01:08 AM on 12/14/2011
he will not be able to help himself. his arrogance is too great. he will crash and burn, as his opinion of his own intellect is unique among intelligent humans; he thinks he is one of them.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
Agathon
Wherever you go, there you are.
12:32 AM on 12/14/2011
When i finished viewing the last republican debate. i was struck cold by the feeling that one of these folks on stage has the potential to stumble in to the White House. The thought then crossed my mind about how many republicans might be dealing with the same eerie feeling..

Doesn't the fact that Newt is (still) on stage evoke suspicion?
12:27 AM on 12/14/2011
Mr. Mitchell, all those words and not one mention of Ron Paul's continued upward trending poll numbers. Newt and Ron Paul are in a statistical tie for first in Iowa as of the latest PPP poll today. I think that the winner in the Iowa caucus will be the candidate that has the best ground game and the the most dedicated supporters. I have a hint for you, that is not Newt Gingrich.
12:43 PM on 12/14/2011
I for one, sincerely hope that Ron Paul is nominated.
Jay Haney
My nuclear family imploded when I was 18. I've bee
10:05 PM on 12/13/2011
In regards to Newt, it is best to keep in mind a proverb from the Koran: "The lion's den is never empty of bones." In Newt's case, it is the bones of his own political careers.
07:49 PM on 12/13/2011
Newt will save us... from Newt
07:47 PM on 12/13/2011
If he holds it together for the next four to six months, that's all he'll need to secure the nomination. That's quite a while, but everything seems to be going his way and if Romney doesn't beat him nobody will.

He can self-destruct anytime after the summer starts!
06:38 PM on 12/13/2011
Newt will be stopped - no doubt about that. Everyone has gone a little insane on the Republican side (redundant?) to even put that guy as the front runner for a day much less a couple of weeks. Here's a great piece saying exactly how messed up this is and that 'there should never be a President named Newt'...

http://mankabros.com/blogs/chairman/2011/12/13/newt-gingrich-america-is-seriously-f-cked/
09:25 AM on 12/14/2011
Wow you based your opinion on that article. I'm all for being open minded, but when I see someone telling their daughter thats some "f_cked up s_it" and broadcasting this to you, me and the public at large. I have to doubt their credibility. Is that the new standard to tell your kids reguardless of age, and go spread it around?

It does define this gentleman and others in the progressive party, as obnoxious parents, and we wonder why the discourse in our country is so rude and outrageous. If we can see that displayed in public and in our homes, I'm guessing it's ok in schools, government, etc, etc.

And we wonder where all that behavior comes from.
10:45 AM on 12/14/2011
Oops typo regardless.