iPhone app iPad app Android phone app Android tablet app More

Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Lincoln Mitchell

Lincoln Mitchell

Posted: October 15, 2010 01:14 PM

As the midterm election approaches, rarely a day goes by when a Republican candidate does not say something that progressives view as outrageous and which a generation ago many Republicans would have viewed similarly. In the last few weeks, a Republican congressional candidate in California called for the abolishment of public schools, another House candidate, this time from Ohio, offered an extremely half-hearted apology for being photographed wearing a Nazi uniform while seeming oblivious as to why this might be offensive to many Americans, and former Speaker of the House Newt Gingrich, a potential presidential candidate in 2012, has continued to refer to President Obama's "Kenyan, anti-colonial worldview."

To some extent, this reflects the nature of American politics today, where no claim or accusation is too bizarre, or requires any evidence whatsoever to be taken at least somewhat seriously by many in the media. Widespread voter anger has been channeled into a hostility, meanness and irrationality that has defined not just a few individual campaigns but almost the entire political climate of the country. Much of this has come from the group of anti-government, generally far- right extremists, which can be lumped together under the term Tea Party. This is a little misleading, because while too much ink, or its digital equivalent, has already been spilled trying to figure out what the Tea Party really means, its close financial and political ties to the Republican Party makes the answer to this question very clear.

These candidates, as well as others such as Christine O'Donnell and Sharron Angle, have come to define today's Republican Party. While many progressives are undoubtedly worried about what will happen if some or all of these people get elected, it is not impossible that some Republicans, if only for strategic reasons, share these concerns. Once elected, these candidates will likely be overmatched, unable to get anything done and prone to even more revelations about their past as well as wacky statements. None of that will be good for the Republican Party. Supporting any kind of extremist view point or statement that was critical of the president and generated enthusiasm for the Republican Party, or one of its factions, was a short term strategy that allowed the Republican Party to bounce back quickly from its resounding defeat in 2008, but it is unlikely to be a fruitful strategy in even the medium turn.

Exploiting voter anger and concern over a range of things, primarily the economy, and channeling it towards anti-Obama vitriol, often of a quite offensive kind, allowed the Republican Party to become relevant, with a real chance of winning control of one or both houses of congress, far quicker than many, even many within the Republican Party, would have thought in January of 2009. However, this approach has led to a Republican Party that is not only dominated by its most extreme wing, but where individuals with nothing in their backgrounds to suggest even a modicum of governing experience or ability are almost certain to get elected to high office.

The strange statements, beliefs, views and sheer ignorance of many Republican candidates may be in that grey area between damaging and amusing during the campaign, but once in office will lean much more towards damaging. Sarah Palin's ascendancy on the national political stage has led some candidates to believe that ignorance is a political asset and that knowledge itself is somehow suspect. This may work when seeking to appeal to an angry electorate, but is unlikely to be as popular once these people take office. Christine O'Donnell may be able to finesse her failure to think of a single recent Supreme Court Case with which she disagreed while she is a candidate, but preparation, hard work and knowledge is essential for anybody seeking to pass legislation of any kind in Washington. If candidates like O'Donnell are elected, they will likely continue to embarrass and begin to isolate the Republican Party through their strange and extremist views, and will also almost guarantee the failure of that party to accomplish anything.

Being the party of voter anger has proven to be a surprisingly effective short term political strategy, but it is a terrible governing strategy. What was left of the more thoughtful, if still conservative, leadership of the Republican Party after the Bush years has been completely defeated in the almost two years since Obama took office. The checks on the party's fringes are no longer there, so people who like to dress up as Nazis, advocate abolishing all public education, want to end Social Security and believe that any economic policy to the left of Ayn Rand is synonymous with Stalinism have emerged as the new face of the Republican Party.

 
 
 

Follow Lincoln Mitchell on Twitter: www.twitter.com/LincolnMitchell

 
 
  • Comments
  • 89
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2 3  Next ›  Last »  (3 total)
photo
jeffrey678
You don't happen to make it. You make it happen.
08:23 AM on 10/18/2010
The Main Street Media is pushing the Narrative that Republicans will work with President Obama after the Mid-terms. That will not happen.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
warriorwoman73
02:48 PM on 10/18/2010
I agree - that will not happen after the Mid-Terms. Frankly, I doubt it'll happen in my lifetime, if ever.

Fanned and faved.
05:12 PM on 10/17/2010
The Republicans will not do a damn thing. They will cry about Obama when their own plans go south and even if their plans get inacted AND things turn worse....they will somehow claim that it is others fault

The Republicans do not care about facts....they could be 100% at fault but they will never admit their stupidity
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
warriorwoman73
02:48 PM on 10/18/2010
Exactly. Fanned and faved.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
phylsboutique
09:47 AM on 10/17/2010
"If candidates like O'Donnell are elected, they will likely continue to embarrass and begin to isolate the Republican Party through their extremist views and will also almost guarantee the failure of that party to accomplish anything"............................................................HELL, they've embarrassed themselves WITHOUT the help of O'Donnell and Angle!
08:04 AM on 10/17/2010
It does not matter what the Repubs do or don't do. Even if they get all of their craziest nominees into congress it won't matter until the Dems stand for something. Right now we have the Repubs looking to privatize or eliminate Social Security and Medicare. The Dems have set up a catfood (deficit) committee to privatize or eliminate Social Security and Medicare, only slower and nicer than the Repubs. We did a health care bill that rewards Insurance companies, big Pharma and the hospitals. We did nothing on cost control or insurance costs. We institutionalized the insurance industry rather than creating an alternative option. Unless the Dems can start showing that they stand for anything and are willing to actually fight for something , even the Sharon Angles will have a chance.
photo
OMEGA MAN
A wise man learns from the mistakes of others.
HUFFPOST PUNDIT
hrpmap
Retired man still active..
02:16 AM on 10/17/2010
So your saying they will be just like the democrats?
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
notverySuttle
Ignatius J. Reilly, we need you.
03:47 PM on 10/17/2010
"your"
photo
Tristman
Green is good
07:45 PM on 10/16/2010
Come on Link...this seems more like your Christmas wish list.....
photo
PaganKMcK
Dems are from Earth; GOP are from Ferenginar
06:54 PM on 10/16/2010
While I think this column's main point is valid, it is unlikely Christine O'Donnell will win her election. Sharron Angle on the other hand may just have a shot at winning her election.

Still Democrats have to do more than just be Republican Lite. I worry they will take the wrong message away from this loss and shift to the right.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Saxton
03:57 PM on 10/17/2010
I think the shift began a long time ago. In order to get elected the Blue Dog Democrats spoke like they were true Democrats but once elected they changed parties and acted like Republicans. The Republican platform is pretty small and simple - God, war, anti-environment, big business, and the elimination of social programs that benefit the majority of Americans. The Democrats need to do a major overhaul if we stand a chance to truly resurrect this country and move it forward. It is imperative to have major campaign and lobbying reform, and term limits.
03:13 PM on 10/16/2010
this sounds like a likely scenario - even if the GOP leadership manages to corral these guys, they will not be able to control them. Once they start up their subpoenas on the Obama administration, someone ought to mention the COST of their investigation plans. I just don't think the GOP will be able to control them like they have in the past - since they have no intention of either mediating or cooperating. They are there to throw word bombs and we'll see that the Congress is only as good as its members - and maybe the Dems will be saying 'no' and give the GOP some of their own medicine.

so when they want to close down all but 4 departments, their states will be none to happy to lose thousands of jobs - which of course, none have thought of the natural consequences of their actions. They haven't a clue.
photo
ywcachieve
President Barack H. Obama supporter.
04:30 PM on 10/16/2010
They won't take the Congress.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
phylsboutique
09:48 AM on 10/17/2010
I'm praying they won't!
01:35 PM on 10/16/2010
What I expect is more likely to happen, is if any of these strange ones get in, they will be pulled aside and told 'what the facts are'. The repubs are very effective in controlling their people to follow lockstep with the party leaders, to say only what they are told to say, and do as they're told. As many of the candidates are inexperienced, I suspect that they will be easy fodder for the 'good 'ol boys' that run the repubs. This is happened in '94 when a group of freshmen repubs with reform on their minds were sent to WA.
iridium53
Semper Fi
01:58 PM on 10/16/2010
Delusional.
03:08 PM on 10/16/2010
And at this juncture, I expect that the fur will fly and the congress will function basically as if there were three poltical parties instead of two. And, perhaps I should say 4 parties since the independents deserve to be acknowledged. We are progressing to a more European form of government where alliances will be more important than the actual totals afforded to each party. I hope, personally, that fact-based opinions will be more important than simple opinion and delusion which has reared a really ugly head in recent debates.

I cannot help but wonder if the Texas textbook fiasco has poisoned the voting pool thru its emphasis on hate and ignorance of actual history.
DUSAA-1775
never moon a werewolf
01:01 PM on 10/16/2010
...' If candidates like O'Donnell are elected...'
after reading that brilliant political scenario, I did not find any reason to read anything this sage has to say about anything....
photo
Cactusman
Persons of Cactus, Unite!
03:56 PM on 10/16/2010
That's a tad dismissive. If you would read the entire article, you might find that Lincoln Mitchell's commentary is fairly incisive.

Besides, the comment is "IF candidates LIKE O'Donnell are elected", not "when O"Donnell is elected". He's using a rhetorical device of comparison to make his point, which is that extreme candidates like O'Donnell are having some influence in the political sphere these days, and that some of them will be elected, if not O'Donnell herself. I don't think he's wrong, much as I dislike it. I doubt that Mitchell is saying that O'Donnell actually will win. He can read polls just as well as you or I.

But SOME baggers like her will win.... and I don't think that this Teabagger thing is going to prove useful for Republicans for very long. It will eventually force them to really start governing and solving serious problems with realistic solutions (that run contrary to their electoral rhetoric) rather than cheaply inciting hate and fear in white people. When their new snake-oil remedies prove to be the same old snake-oil remedies they've had for 40 years or more, they will lose big in 2012. This will probably be only a short-term blip of a gain for Republicans. That was Mitchell's point.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
drray23
physicist, liberal and woodworker
12:04 PM on 10/16/2010
I hope this analysis is correct. However, I am still concerned that a few of these loons if elected could wreck this country. It does not take more than one crasy senator to paralyze everything because of the peculiar rules of this body such as the "secret" hold...

I would not bet on the people realizing they voted somebody who is against their own interest.

The voters who are supporting the tea party lunatic have an habit of doing so. They have voted against their own interest forever and will keep doing so. No amount of
facts or reality will change that.

In short, I would rather not to have to find out. Better be safe and make sure we elect democrats.
photo
Epiphany2b
Always waiting for the light to dawn
12:02 PM on 10/16/2010
While these candidates might not have the intelligence and experience to be able to write and present legislation to accomplish what they want to do, their one true value to the party is to be a rubber-stamp vote to destroy all that has been accomplished so far.
jjtx
living between the trees
09:54 AM on 10/16/2010
The short run is all these Republicans are concerned about.

Despite their talk of bankrupting the future, what they really care about is putting the greatest amount of money into the fewest hands as fast as they can. They will keep doing that and feeding off mis-placed voter anger until there is no wealth left to transfer to themselves and their friends.

Two things I will never forget about George W. Bush.
1. While governor, he laughed about the prospect of executing an inmate (something I'm sure God will take up with him)
2. Being happy to be around "his type of people". Here I thought, as President, that all American citizens should be his type of people instead of a rich few.

These two things should speak volumes to everyone especially when taken together. This is the true face of the Republican Party and what it stands for.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
botan
ConnectTheLeft
10:57 AM on 10/16/2010
GHood comment, fanned!
photo
ywcachieve
President Barack H. Obama supporter.
04:23 PM on 10/16/2010
I read that a soldier who was wounded in Iraq, who was being treated at Walter Reed Hospital, told then-Pres Bush, when he visited Walter Reed Hospital, that the troops in Iraq were not getting enough water to drink, and he asked Bush what could be done about it. The soldier said, Bush said, '''I am so happy we are fighting them on their land, and not our land.''' Bush totally ignored the soldier's question.
12:13 PM on 10/17/2010
Bush always wanted his own war and to be like Margaret Thatcher. He mentioned it in his book, "A Charge To Keep".
08:43 AM on 10/16/2010
It is still possible to rally the moderate intelligent citizens of this country ( which has happened in the past) and push back against this ignorance and hatred. I knocked on doors for Obama for days to help with his election and have to say I am deeply disappointed in what he has settled for, however, he still has a quality and higher level of sensitivity that MCCAIN. So, are we going to let the Kochs, Limbaughs, Becks, Palin, Angle, O'Donnell, all the-take-advantage-of-the-situation, screw-the-country people take even more control of the quality of life for so many? Get to work, it is not too late.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
wikwox
So there I was, playing the piano....
07:38 AM on 10/16/2010
True, and the Republican leadership knows it. If Moderates are not fleeing the party in droves at some point they will, the same for Independents. It's why the Republican Leadership really does not want to embrace the Tea Party, they know what is happening and they know the end result will be unelectable candidates and a party no one wnats to belong to.
photo
Brian Gilmer
Good citizens make good citizens.
08:16 PM on 10/16/2010
Moderates have already left the Republican Party.