In today's highly polarized political context, there is a great deal of political vitriol and frequent statements that are nothing short of appalling. Every now and then something is said that is far beyond the pale even by the standards of today's political discourse. Pastor Charles Worley's comments of May 13 are an example of this. Worley suggested, "Build a great big large fence 50 or 100 miles long. Put all the lesbians in there. Fly over and drop some food. Do the same thing with the queers and the homosexuals. Have that fence electrified so they can't get out. You know what, in a few years, they'll die out."
Comparisons to Hitler are too common in our political discussions as assertions that, for example, President Obama's health care policy is comparable to Nazism, are ridiculous. However, in this particular case comparisons are appropriate. Worley's ideas regarding gays and lesbians are not similar to Hitler's -- they are the same as Hitler's. The idea of putting gays and lesbians into concentration camps and killing them is not something out of Worley's distorted imagination, but is something that actually happened during World War II as gays and lesbians were rounded up along with Jews and others and sent to death camps.
It is possible that the practice of invoking words like Hitler, Stalin, Communism and Nazism to describe something that speaker passionately opposes, a practice which we have seen more frequently since President Obama took office, has made us less sensitive to these claims, and less aware of the meanings and historical events behind these terms. Raising taxes to what they were under Ronald Reagan is not Stalinism, but proposing rounding up gay people and killing them is, in fact, the same policy supported by Hitler. The problem with constant comparisons to Hitler and Nazis is that when somebody actually proposes a Nazi-style final solution, we, as a society, no longer have the words to describe it.
The origin of Worley's hatred is baffling, and suggestions that this is a response to President Obama's recent support for marriage equality are insulting and cannot fully explain Worley's radical, murderous proposition, with its strong echoes of Hitler's genocidal views. While there is disagreement about marriage equality, which will likely remain for years, Worley's views are well beyond anything that might be called reasonable disagreement or debate. There can be many possible explanations of Worley's extreme and hateful ideas. Fear of a changing world, a deep and profound misreading of the life and teaching of Jesus, and the opportunity to build a lucrative congregation of bigots are just some of them.
The reasons Worley made these remarks are not important, but the reactions to these remarks, support those comments received, and anger and hostility which they reflect are more significant. If there were no audience receptive to Worley's murderous rhetoric, he probably would have kept his mouth shut. Worley's views are also an insight into the depth of the hatred and bigotry which still exists in America, even at times when many of us are relieved and excited by the president's recent public statements about equality.
Worley's efforts to hide his bigotry behind his alleged Christianity are unfortunate and cowardly, but it also raise questions for Christians and Christian leaders across America. The protests that have occurred in North Carolina since Worley's comments are encouraging, but any American who claims to be a Christian, regardless of his views on gay people, marriage equality or anything else should be furious at Worley for using his faith to propose policies that are unambiguously murderous and which would constitute crimes against humanity.
Obviously to judge all Christians, or even all members of Worley's church or denomination by Worley's words and ideas, is unfair, and nobody is doing that. Moreover, Worley is not the first, and won't be the last, person to use religious views to justify outrageous and hateful opinions, but the extreme hatefulness in his words are particularly galling.
Nonetheless, this is not a case of people using different interpretations of Christianity to rationalize different political views. Rather is a case of Christianity being misused to justify indefensible positions. It should perhaps go without saying that real Christians, regardless of their political views, condemn Worley, but it would probably better if these things were actually said, clearly and forcefully, by every Christian leader in the land. Moreover, it is conservative Christians who should be condemning Worley the most since they are the ones who have the most to lose if statements like Worley's are viewed as representing anything more than the fringe of the fringe of Christian thought.
Follow Lincoln Mitchell on Twitter: www.twitter.com/LincolnMitchell
The sick part is that these sorts are absolutely fine with & promote violence.
"Make peace & love, not war!"
I believe you have chosen the same path as others in this instance. There are many of us who would judge all by the actions of a few for there are NONE standing up and complaining or taking issue with Worley's comments. Therefore, by complicity, they are accepting and, therefore, as guilty. The Germans stood by and allowed Hitler to do his dirty work...they started by burning the Reichstag and then Hitler motivated the youth...and by the time he was out of prison the youth were now his army.
I find the rationalization on our (LGBT) behalf horrible. The words have been spoken before..and a nation entered one of the greatest wars we ever saw and millions died in concentration camps..while priests, ministers, rabis and others stood by quietly.
I will not go quietly..believe me
We are 20,000,000+ strong in the U.S. and we are NOT going away and we will NOT be silenced by ignorance.
(continued next post)
I disagree. If this man does not represent all christians, then where are the christians speaking up against this vile piece of crap? If they choose to remain silent, they deserve to be painted with the same brush.
It seems that many of the thousands of different "Christian" churches and denominations in the US are very radical, narrow minded and hateful. In my eyes those are NOT christian communities, because God is love, he ceated us the way we are (also gay!) and he is the only one to judge us.
If you're Catholic, do you reject the church councils? The Fourth Lateran Council in 1215 force the Jews to wear the Yellow star to mark them as less than human; the council officially compared intermarriage with bestiality.
Nietzsche said that the last Christian died on the Cross. If you believe "real Christians" are the ones who never do evil, then you're proving him right.
Someone contradicts them and they are not a person who happens to think differently. They are an agent of Satan. This is extremist fundamentalism.
Very dangerous people. They whip up hate to keep their own faith alive.
The fact that Hitler got the idea for his concentration camps from our reservation system does not mean the two are precise equivalents,
We do need to call out our own (from our side of the political divide) when they make these types of outrageous comments. We sure aren't getting any where sniping back and forth at each other.