Last evening, in an act of daring befitting a West Point graduate and veteran of Iraq, recently discharged New York National Guard Lieutenant Daniel Choi defied the orders of dozens of crowd control police and stepped into the 'no protest zone' street to ceremoniously salute his Commander in Chief, Barack Obama, who was out of site at a star-studded fundraiser at the posh Beverly Hilton hotel.
While the Lieutenant's respectful salute was extemporaneous, the effort that generated the Lieutenant's appearance at last night's pro-gay rights/pro-equality rally outside the Beverly Hilton hotel, was anything but impromptu. It was a meticulous plan spearheaded by
Rick Jacobs, one of the progressive movement's most effective organizers. Jacobs, Founder and Chair of the Courage Campaign, which boasts a membership of 700,000, is a co-founder of Brave New Films and a director of Liberty Hill Foundation. When I asked Jacobs what the tie-in was with Daniel Choi playing such a prominent role at last night's event, he offered the following:
The Courage campaign seeks to make California more progressive and more governable. The state cannot possibly be progressive if we can use the Constitution to take rights away from people. So nearly two weeks ago we saw Daniel Choi on Rachel Maddow, when he "came out." He's an Orange County California native... So we got in touch with him and said, 'Hey we'd like to run a campaign to help support you, to prevent the president from kicking you and others out of the military. So we put up a letter on line. It's very simple. It says:Later at the rally, Jacobs proudly holds up the letter being delivered to Obama:
Dear Mr. President,The time has come to end discrimination in our armed forces. We the undersigned ask you to stop the discharge of Dan Choi and any other soldier as a result of Don't Ask Don't Tell policy. We ask that you uphold your pledge and push Congress to quickly put a bill on your desk to repeal "Don't Ask, Don't Tell."
Sincerely, the undersigned 140,860 people.
And you can see this at Courage Campaign if you scroll down to "Don't Fire Dan." A friend of ours is going to present this letter to the President inside tonight and we also are here. We're hoping the President will send a representative outside to see what we have to say. We have four big boxes - that's a lot of people - 140,000 people in a week. So the tie-in is very simple, this is all about equal rights. It's all about equality. We can win our equal rights in California but they mean nothing if we don't get them federally, so when we look at a young man like Daniel Choi who is willing to sacrifice his life for the country and gets thrown out of the military for saying I love a man, there's a problem. We elected President Obama based on a spirit of hope, bringing the country together and we expect him to do that.
President Obama has been adamant about ending "don't ask, don't tell", but the longer he languishes, the more seasoned, talented specialists like Arabic speaker Lt. Choi will be victims of this discriminatory policy. It was this calculus that led Rick Jacobs and Equal Roots Coalition co-founder Matt Palazzolo, a co-organizer of last night's rally, to bring Lieutenant Choi close enough to the President to confront the issue directly, albeit not face to face.
Outside the hotel on Wilshire Boulevard across from the Beverly Hilton, Lieutenant Dan Choi was surrounded by several hundred gay rights/equal rights supporters who hung on his every word.
His message was one of power and resolve:
We can't wait for somebody else to give us rights. We have to stand up. If we want our rights. We gotta fight for them... Let me tell you a little bit about 'don't ask, don't tell.' It is a deadly poison. It is the most toxic. That's military talk. Civilians try to call it the closet but it's toxic poison. Do not force that toxic poison. Do not inject that toxic poison in them anymore. Let them out of the closet! [triumphant applause]It's not about my career. It's not about my pay grade. It's not about money. It's not about elections. It's about telling them [gay service members], you are not alone. So I gave a message to President Obama. Repeal 'don't ask, don't tell.' Stop forcing them to lie. Stop forcing our soldiers to lie. Stop forcing our soldiers to hide. Stop forcing our soldiers to be injected with the closet. And let them be free to serve! (more applause)
While Lieutenant Choi was still addressing the crowd, guests from the Obama event began exiting to their waiting cars from the front of the building. Many of the well dressed glitterati clearly supported the values of equality and civil rights held by the protesters who stood on the other side of Wilshire Blvd. Indeed, as documented in this video, one attendee charged across the street through traffic to join up with the rally:
(Video by Linda Milazzo)
Among the crowd on the rally side of the street was actor and human rights activist Hal Sparks, who made a lasting impact on the gay community as the character Michael in the five year Showtime series, Queer As Folk, a drama about the lives of a group of gay men.
Hal has been an activist for gay rights and the fight against AIDS since the early days of AIDS Project Los Angeles - one of the pioneering organizations to assist AIDS victims soon after the epidemic first hit Los Angeles. Hal spoke openly with me last night about his many passions, including why Lt. Choi's appearance at the rally was so critical in the struggle for human rights:
I'm here because I believe it's a civil rights issue. We cannot argue that this country is the freest country in the world and then limit the freedoms of people we don't agree with and are not like us or make us uncomfortable. That seems absurd to me... I think there's some work that needs to be done and you can't argue with that fact.Regarding Dan Choi, Hal goes on to say:
First of all, how many great soldiers, translators, officers have we lost simply because people are uncomfortable with the idea of gay. How un-macho does that seem that I don't want gays around me 'cause it's icky. Here's the ironic part. One of the reasons that they used to make being gay in the service and in the DOD [Department of Defense] and the government illegal was because it was so shunned in the public circles that you could be blackmailed easily. The cure to that is not to make it more illegal or more shunned. The cure is to open it up. Nobody can blackmail a state official for being gay if nobody cares. That seems to be the logical thing. We'd take their weapon away. But we've been too afraid to do that up until now. Obviously the repeal of "don't ask, don't tell" is a necessary moment and I do believe Obama's moving toward that.
One contrast worth noting last night was the obvious separation between those who rallied earlier in the day against the wars and occupations in Iraq and Afghanistan, and those who rallied later in the day on the issues of gay rights and equality. The organizers of the gay rights and equality rally scheduled their event for 6PM, so as not to conflate issues with the peace activists and keep each group's messages separate and distinct.
The rationale for clarity of message is understandable. Certainly all groups want their message understood. And sadly, both groups, the peace movement and the pro-gay marriage/anti-Prop 8 movement, have at times fallen short in their messaging.
As for the failure to stop Prop 8 in 2008, Matt Palazzolo of Equal Roots Coalition, frames it this way:
I think what propelled Prop 8 to be supported and to pass were two things. The first was a series of some lies and then just some heavily shrouded information from the YES on 8 side. And you know every side of a campaign has propaganda but they got really dirty and played tricks. And the other part is the blame on the NO on 8 campaign that they did a very poor job in the community... with people of color and the center of the state and because of that we failed to move enough of these people.
Why Proposition 8 passed in 2008 will be the subject of much discussion as the 2010 and 2012 elections approach - just as the question of why the wars in Iraq and Afghanistan have not yet ended will similarly be hotly discussed. Still there is strength in numbers.
One can be certain that amongst the thousands who marched Tuesday night through California and across the nation in opposition to the Supreme Court ruling to uphold Proposition 8, that there were many who've been active in the anti-war movement. After all the suppression of the weak by the strong, sorrow and injustice are hallmarks of LGBT inequality, and of war. Perhaps as the LGBT struggle for humanity and civil rights moves forward, and the common struggle for humanity and civil rights to end war also moves forward, a greater harmony will develop between these two groups - with clarified goals and a universal message that unity wields more power than division.
if he really wanted serve his country just do it
and keep your mouth shut..
All of the above are grounds for dismissal from the military if a gay person does them. Don't Ask needs to be repealed.
Until then, why don't you shut your mouth?
I applaud Lt. Choi. Equality is not given--it must be grabbed. And confronted on many fronts--from the quick letter, to the news-making protest--all need to be done.
Lt. Dan Choi is a star. He is charasmatic and an incredible speaker.
He will be a major leader in the struggle for gay equality.
Social justice rarely operates under a politically convenient timetable. He won't be able to ignore gay issues for 4 years, because there is a court deadline looming. President Obama will need to decide to defend DOMA in court by June 29th. He will have to make a decision that will determine if he will keep his campaign promise to us or not. If he chooses to defend DOMA, that would be a major betrayal of our community.
Coincidentally, June is also the 40th Anniversary of the Stonewall Uprising, an important event in gay history and American civil rights history. It would be a wonderful gesture if the President traveled to Stonewall to commemorate the occasion and announce he would stop-loss all gay soldiers being discharged under don't ask, don't tell and that his administration would not defend DOMA in court as per his campaign promise, and then call on Congress to repeal both DADT and DOMA and institute federally recognized civil unions.
At least that's what a "fierce advocate" for the gay community would do.
I think the President is showing that he is an advocate for gay rights. He believes in civil unions. Further, the President has committed to repealing DADT and has stated this himself and through the Press Secretary multiple times. The President has recent ensured that gay diplomats receive benefits for their families. The President has the DOD studying the impact repealing DADT will have on the military. When the Pentagon rep said otherwise, the Pentagon rep either lied or mispoke. The Secretary of Defense had him clarify and he now admits that the President has been in ongoing discussions with the Pentagon to repeal DADT.
In all of 4 months, the President is showing his support. It is unfortunate that you demand so much more and fail to recognize the progress that has been made.
--------------------
Please provide a link. I have not seen this AT ALL
You do not get to decide what makes someone a "fierce advocate" for our civil rights is either.
I do not dictate what is sufficient progress for your civil rights, so do not lecture to us about the civil rights of the gay community.
By June 29th, we will know for sure what the President's intentions are with regards to his promises to the gay community. He will either decline to defend DOMA or stab us in the bank. There is no triangulation on this one.
The 40th Annniversary of Stonewall is upon us and we will give it everything we've got to push for equality.
How about instead of this odd way the LGBT community seems to have lobbying people by attacking them, the LGBT community changes tacts. They work to bolster President Obama's popularity, bolster his capital instead of screaming and protesting every single week since his election. First it was that 8 passed and it was the fault of blacks and Obama. Then it was rick warren, then it was 8 again and that Obama hadn't come out and supported the law suit, then it was rick warren and how people were going to wear sheets to the inauguration to teach obama a lesson, then it was LGBT in the cabinet, then it was lgbt in the sub cabinet,. then it was DADT then it was DOMA, then it was Rick Warren again, then it was keep your word, and then there was the inauguration. Are you starting to get the picture. All of that before he was even sworn in. I have to tell you, if I were running Obama's white house I would never take another LGBT call. Not one single call.
We have yet to see any actions that indicate he intends to keep ANY of his promises to our community?
We've learned the hard way. Silence = Death.
I wont' repeat here the progress the Prez has made on DADT, I just ask you to become more informed.
But in taking those calls, the President would say to the LGBT community what he has said to all critics. I hear you. Now hear me: He would remind the LGBT community of the following:
1. President has committed to repeaing DADT and had stated this himself and through the Press Secretary multiple times.
2. The President has recent ensured that gay diplomats receive benefits for their families.
3. The President has the DOD studying the impact repealing DADT will have on the military. When the Pentagon rep said otherwise, the Pentagon rep either lied or mispoke. The Secretary of Defense had him clarify and he now admits that the President has been in ongoing discussions with the Pentagon to repeal DADT.
And, the President would note that all of 4 months have passed. He would ask for patience.
Is he truly about getting DADT repealed or is this about childish defiance? Is he truly interested in getting DADT repealed or is this about childish impatience?
Choi dared the President to uphold the law and he lost.
DADT will be repealed but not because of the histrionics of people like Choi.
Presumably we all want equal rights and the repeal of DADT.
Further, the President has committed to repeal DADT and had stated this himself and through the Press Secretary multiple times. The President has recent ensured that gay diplomats receive benefits for their families. The President has the DOD studying the impact repealing DADT will have on the military. When the Pentagon rep said otherwise, the Pentagon rep either lied or mispoke. The Secretary of Defense had him clarify and he now admits that the President has been in ongoing discussions with the Pentagon to repeal DADT.
How do they expect one man to fix everything in 4 months?
Give it a break already.
Have some empathy.
It will happen.
Give him a chance for pity's sake.
"To my LGBT citizens and allies, I am here to reaffirm my commitment to press Congress to repeal DADT and DOMA. Please, be patient. These issues are complicated, and will take some time to negotiate through the complexities of such an emotional issue. But, we are working on it, and I promise, again, to stand by your side in the fight for all American citizens to have your right to equal protection under the law, as guaranteed by the constitution"
The president has commited to repealing DADT. He is following the law that is currently the law. Choi broke the law, regardless of what he says his motives were.