More

Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Lisa Copen

GET UPDATES FROM Lisa Copen
 

Does "Housewife" Michaele Salahi's Confession of MS Help or Hinder Illness Awareness Issues?

Posted: 10/04/10 06:42 PM ET

If "Real Housewife" Michaele Salahi had an official brand name, it could be called Controversy and her recent announcement of multiple sclerosis has added in new debate. Is she faking it or isn't she? Most people first heard of Salahi when she and her husband allegedly crashed a White House state dinner. Lately she has gotten into a scuffle with The View's Whoopi Goldberg and she's explained that the reason the Redskins have no record of her as a cheerleader is because she lied about her age.

So, when Salahi announced that she had multiple sclerosis on September 15th, it came as no surprise that most people doubted her confession. Or, most people who do not have health issues, that is. In 2002 I began National Invisible Chronic Illness Awareness Week, held annually in September, and ironically the story of Salahi's MS broke during the middle of the week this year. Web sites around the internet buzzed with controversial remarks.

What was the controversy? Blog comments reflect that most people who are healthy believe it is just another one of Salahi's tricks to gain publicity with the release of a tell-all book, Cirque Du Salahi, by Diane Dimond. However, those who live with invisible illnesses personally understand how one day she could be stuck in bed and another hinting behind the scene with NBC's Today Show that she'd like to be on Dancing with the Stars.

So does Michaele Salahi's admission of living with MS help or hinder awareness about invisible illness or multiple sclerosis? I believe, despite her less than squeaky clean celebrity-hood there is the potential for benefit.

Why?

1. People with illness are angry enough to let their voice be heard.

Frankly, I am surprised that so many reporters chose to do a fast story about their skepticism of her claim of MS rather than doing even a smidgen of research on invisible illnesses. According to statistics, about 96% of illnesses are invisible and no assistive device is used. I have seen few articles that ask, "What if she is telling the truth?" that are not written by someone who does not have an illness.

Despite the ignorance of the reporters who jumped on the "liar, liar, pants on fire" bandwagon, controversy stirs talk. And people with invisible illness are commenting on articles and blogs more so than they ever will on an announcement of a new MS medication.

2. Illness associations have a hot news topic for the week.

I doubt the National Multiple Sclerosis Society (NMSS) would have chosen Salahi to be their next spokesperson, but it got their telephone ringing. NMSS spokesman Arney Rosenblat, in response to Salahi's weight, stated, "Weight loss is not a typical symptom [of MS]. However, if you are on medication or you have depression or fatigue, you could have appetite issues. If you know someone with MS, you know its hallmark in unpredictability." Unfortunately, most reporters quoted only his first sentence, making it sound as though even he had doubts about Salahi's illness.

3. It is an opportunity for patient advocates to create awareness about the variety of illness symptoms.

Reporters and those without illness were quick to chatter about Salahi's high heels and how she "looked so good." NAMS Rosenblat's comment "[MS] is often called the 'You look so good' disease because its symptoms are often unnoticeable to others" has been buried by the press, but patient advocates can grab it and remind people of this.

4. Celebrity gossip will always scoop health information to make good T.V.

When these stories happen patient advocates understand that the headlines will work far better for patient education than any PSA. On the Today Show September 24, Hoda Kotb tells Salahi, "I think now people come out with illnesses and. . . . no one looks down on someone," and Kathie Lee Gifford agrees, "There's no stigma to it."

But in my opinion, Salahi was right when she responded, "But there was a stigma. I remember being in a job where people got fired for less. . . .So I always had the fear. . . I thought, 'Oh, gosh, I'll be the next to go,' so I kept it a secret. No matter, if my hands, I couldn't feel them, or they went numb, I thought, 'No way am I letting this secret out.'"

Those who believe there is not a stigma have not lived with illness or they have likely been blessed with an unusual cocoon of support.

5. It reminds us of celebrities with illness and their causes.

Salahi told Kobt and Gifford she revealed her illness to scoop the media before they told the world. Many stars, including Michael J. Fox and Montel Williams have done the same thing. Like it or not, Salahi is now a part of the celebrity chronic illness club. The benefit is that it gets all celebrities who live with illness a boost in awareness of their causes.

And celebrities with illness increases awareness about the disease. The article, "Media Coverage and Public Reaction to a Celebrity Cancer Diagnosis," published in the Journal of Public Health last month, describes a studies results that showed a significant increase in public interest in disease prevention following celebrity diagnoses. Salahi's revelation may just spur some people to say "I wonder if I should see a doctor about this."

In conclusion, while those of us with invisible illness may grow weary of celebrities getting the media's attention about their diseases when we have suffered silently for years, we also recognize that it is the most likely way the challenges of coping with an invisible illness will get those prime time slots. Behind each celebrity there are millions of people living joyfully despite illness. Unlike Salahi, we may not have a doll that resembles us or a Bravo reality show, but we have passion for life reporters will be hard-pressed to find elsewhere. And we won't even crash your dinner.

 

Follow Lisa Copen on Twitter: www.twitter.com/lisajcopen

 
 
  • Comments
  • 22
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Bloggers
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2  Next ›  Last »  (2 total)
05:38 PM on 10/17/2010
I will go ahead and choose to believe her but I can't blame the disbelievers because of her loose way of interpreting things. At one point I was told that I should be tested for MS because of some symptoms I was having fortunately it turned out I did not, but I think in a way this is why many have questioned whether Micheale has MS. She may have been a cheerleader because of some questionable records that she has interpreted. They went to the White House dinner because in their minds they interpreted certain communication as being invited. My thought is, like me she may have had a scare at one point and some feel she has interpreted it in her own way.
04:06 PM on 10/13/2010
Before reading this article, I judged Michelle Sahali but these opinions softened after reading the article and following comments.
Early on, it was easier to participate in social activities, the vision my social circle remembers and 21 years later, I am subject of criticism based on visual observations. Social functions may be enjoyable but crushing fatigue/pain follow for days and people do not see this side of Chronic Illness. Leaving social situations prematurely is necessary as symptoms change by minute, hour, day repeating weekly, monthly, yearly. There are no sure-fire preventative measures to stop symptoms. Such is the life people with Invisible Illness face.
Perhaps, Michelle went to that bar, had a drink to calm her nerves after the White House escapade before going home. Excitement IS a stress that causes the body to produce adrenaline, fight or flight hormone, which wreaks havoc on bodies with Chronic Illness. The adrenaline surge may be the reason for Michelle’s “flair”. This viewpoint, is speculation but brings to light an important point…How can we truly judge another person and determine what they should or should not do without knowing intimate details of the lives of people with Chronic Illness?
Invisible Illness week is a great time to bring MS to public attention. Doubtfully, she will profit from her “colorful” well-timed announcement but if we follow the example to be colorful, make noise and BE VISIBLE, perhaps “well” people will understand organizations need donations to help those with Invisible Illness.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Toddler
04:47 PM on 10/12/2010
New documentary available on Youtube that shines a light on the White House Party Crashers' attempt at 15 mintues of fame. As Brian Williams from NBC put it - State Dinner Balloon Boy and Girl. The Crash Heard Around the World - The Salahis is available for viewing now. Unfortunately YouTube only allows a max of 15 minutes so there are 6 parts.

Part 1 of 6: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uxiqXmbvvuA
Part 2 of 6: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Ml1s3_kFwCY
Part 3 of 6: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-smsV73x5fE
Part 4 of 6: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9bDbnVLJ2AU
Part 5 of 6: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lOmUVHpk2mI
Part 6 of 6: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JYLxxqYpRdY
03:53 PM on 10/12/2010
Great article Lisa. Brings up alot of discussions on how people are judge when they admit to having an illness.
08:02 PM on 10/11/2010
Great article Lisa. I don't whether this woman has MS or not. Is that ours to judge?
05:04 PM on 10/05/2010
Although it is interesting to see the comments about "does she or doesn't she" have MS... what you do you think about her bringing the topic of "invisible illness" to the press again. If she IS "making it up" does that even make a difference as far as it making people more aware of illness? curious about your thoughts.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
thinkingwomanmillstone
I'm nervous. My life is under a Micro-bioscope.
04:24 PM on 10/06/2010
My thoughts are that she does more harm than good. She is an attention seeker and her disclosure comes across as attention seeking...not for those who have illnesses but for herself. We are not our illness, even though it can dominate a lot of day to day activity. A person of good character remains a person of good character despite an illness. The same is true of a person of questionable character.
03:30 PM on 10/05/2010
MS or not, there are two important things to keep in mind:

1. According to Ms. Dimond's book, the Salahis had to leave the State Dinner before being seated because of a relapse of MS by Michaele. But what did they do? Walked across the street to the bar at the Hays Adams hotel where they cooled their heels drinking cocktails for two hours or so, only then to call the limo driver to pick them up outside of the White House, as if they just exited the dinner. If Michaele was sick from MS, I don't know, but I'm not sure sitting in a bar is the correct medical treatment.

2. The Salahis and Ms. Dimond maintain this was some deep, dark personal 17 year secret, never shared with even their closest friends, and only exposed on national television last month on the cusp of releasing their so-called "book".
FALSE. The fact of the matter is that Michaele's purported "diagnosis" with MS was publicly known and traded upon by the Salahis' now-defunct "charity", Journey for the Cure Foundation [currently under investigation by the Commonwealth of Virginia, if not the IRS as well]. MS? I don't know. Some deep dark "secret"? Hardly.
05:08 PM on 10/05/2010
In response to #1... yes, one can want to leave a big dinner, with lots of people, noise, etc. and go somewhere OTHER than to bed. People with illness are still people. There is not "must," "always," or "never" when it comes to how people act/respond. People with invisible illness are often trying to defend their actions because they may not behave how people EXPECT them to behave. And having flare ups from illness are quite different then "being sick." Illness is a life-long condition; being "sick" is a state where you huddle down and wait to "get well." If people with chronic illness never left their home until they were ill, they would have no opportunity to "live." Our actions often seem odd to others, but we are doing the best we can to choose to "live."
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
thinkingwomanmillstone
I'm nervous. My life is under a Micro-bioscope.
08:51 PM on 10/05/2010
I don't know. As someone who suffers from an invisible illness, I have my doubts about her behavior. (I am not commenting on her diagnosis) If I am trying to garner my resources to go to some "special occasion" and I have to leave due to a flare, you won't find me sitting at a bar for a couple of hours...If I am not strong enough to get through one, I wouldn't be able to do the other. Everyone is different, but, I find her behavior suspicious...not impossible...but suspicious. I suspect she left the dinner for reasons other than a flare.
05:48 PM on 11/27/2010
I'm sorry my daughter has MS so yes I took offense of her saying she has MS and especially one of the side effects is her weight. It's quite the opposite. If she would have had a relapse it would affect her physically. Speech, motor coordination, balance or even vision. To go have drinks during (notice I didn't say after) a relapse is highly improvable. Your body needs to recover from a relapse it does happen within an hour.
06:54 PM on 10/05/2010
I could not agree with you more, Tractor Man.
People Magazine and D. Dimond's Circus book have pointed out the Salamis left the India State Dinner b/c Michaele was having a MS flare up and they needed to head back home to rest. The Salamis did indeed go straight to the bar across the street ....and then true to form...stiffed the bartender. http://voices.washingtonpost.com/reliable-source/2009/12/salahis_stiffed_hay_adams_bart.html?hpid=moreheadlines
What a mess. Sadly, with events like this....it is their integrity, a life long condition, that also needs to 'get well'.
ThinkCreeps
Seriously, it's time.
07:30 AM on 10/05/2010
The MS gods do get the occasional direct hit.
02:28 AM on 10/05/2010
I don't care for the Salahis and think that they tend to be really dishonest, but as you stated so well, Lisa, she could very well have MS and have not told many people all this time, not have outward signs that so many people would expect to see, etc. I hope that all of this controversy actually helps educate the public about invisible illness in general and MS in particular. Thanks for a great article!
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
10:24 PM on 10/04/2010
First, I'd need to see a note from her doctor.

Second, there is no excuse for the Attention Seeking of "MS" and her husband, so no change in my opinion of the woman.

Third, I also have an "invisible" disability and I know how judgmental people can be.
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
Diane Dimond
Journalist/Author/Columnist- DianeDimond.com
08:13 PM on 10/04/2010
I am the author of the book Cirque Du Salahi and I'd like to offer a couple corrections to your otherwise very thoughtful commentary. Arney Rosenblat, National Multiple Sclerosis Society (NMSS) spokesperson is a WOMAN, not a man. And, no one ever said that Michaele Salahi was thin because she has suffered from MS for 17 years. She's thin, like her brother Howard is thin, because that is what runs in her family. In addition, according to the research I did for the book keeping a lean body mass is the absolute smartest thing an MS patient can do to manage the disease, according to the latest scientific study.
Thank you for seeing past the knee-jerk "we hate the Salahi" news coverage to see that there is a living breathing and fallible person (just like the rest of us) behind this sensational news story.
Sincerely,
Diane Dimond
www.DianeDimond.com
08:40 PM on 10/04/2010
Diane, thank you so much for your comments... I did my research online to verify Arney was a man and tried contacting her; my apologies for the mix up. I thought Michaele's explanations and comments about her illness on the Today show last week were well done. In today's day, I am still surprised to hear people say, "There is no stigma [of illness]." I am not sure what world they are referring to, but Michaele's explanation made complete sense to me and was the closest she could come to being able to show that it was real. In responses to the "thinness" question, unfortunately, it has become one more instance on the internet for people to be able to say, "Well, she's too thin to have MS." The statements surrounding Rosenblat's response I believe were her response to a sort of theory that "thin... (or heavier people...?) get MS." Anyone can have an invisible illness and just looking thin or healthy does not mean the illness does not exist. Thank you for your time and give Michaele my best!
07:30 PM on 10/04/2010
Well written article! If Michaele has MS, I wish her well in her medical journey. If Michaele and D. Dimond are in fact fibbing for sympathy votes and book sales, I hope sweet karma is served. The Salahi's are narcassistic sociopaths, pathological liars, and con artist bottom-feeders. May justice prevail. http://jezebel.com/5655184/salahi-101-a-guide-to-the-lawsuits--lies?skyline=true&s=i
07:23 PM on 10/04/2010
Great article Lisa! Thank you for these reminders about "silent illnesses".
07:00 PM on 10/04/2010
Beautifully written. Most people with MS suffer with this disease for years before the damage is physically seen. Whether Salahi has MS or not she has brought awareness to MS and that’s a wonderful thing. There are many invisible illnesses in the world. The more people becoming aware of these diseases brings us one step closer to cures and gives us hope. Great article!
06:46 PM on 10/04/2010
There isn't all that much that the Salahis should be proud about, but Diane Dimond interviewed numerous sources--doctors, nurses and family members--all confirming that Michaele Salahi does in fact have MS.