Children's Librarian Says Picture Books Still Thrive

Piece cross-posted on Early Word.

The hum you heard over the weekend came from children's librarians infuriated by Friday's NYT article, "Picture Books No Longer a Staple for Children." According to the article, parents discourage young children from picture books, pushing them to more text-based "chapter books." As a result, the article states, publishers are releasing fewer picture books.

Parents who snatch picture books from tiny hands and force "chapter books" on children barely old enough to decode the words overlook what picture books can do for young minds.

Here's what my librarian colleagues from around the country say about picture books.

• Picture books give children practice in visual literacy. Jon Scieszka's perennial favorite The True Story of the Three Little Pigs by A. Wolf (Viking Childrens, 1989) makes use of a sophisticated unreliable narrator. Children learn critical thinking skills as they study the book's art, looking for contradicting evidence of the verbal story.

• The text of picture books is often written at a higher reading level. Children need to hear this higher vocabulary to acquire language before they can read it.

• On the other hand, while series chapter books are great for reading practice, their vocabulary and sentence structure are simplistic and their plots formulaic.

• Picture books provide self-recognition. In Mo Willems' Knuffle Bunny, kids relate to toddler Amy's frustrated attempt to make her father understand her bunny was left behind at the Laundromat. This story could not be told through the limited language of chapter books.

• Picture books for older children give a window into history, cultures and communities other than our own with sophisticated artistic representation. Consider, for instance Gregory Christie's Brothers in Hope: The Story of the Lost Boys of Sudan.

• Rhythm, rhyme, and repetition of early picture books support the learning of reading skills like phonemic awareness, phonics, comprehension and fluency.

The NYT piece is correct about one thing; fewer picture books are being published today, but the cause has less to do with parents turning away from them and more to do with the economic downturn as well as a decrease in library budgets. Parents, teachers and librarians need to understand the importance of picture books in children's education. If we don't continue to support the talented artists and writers who create them, there may come a time when the pickings are slim.

P.S. Check out this kid-tested list of fabulous picture books to read aloud, selected by Bank Street College of Education's School for Children 1st through 4th graders and almost 2,000 students from our cooperating schools

Piece cross-posted on Early Word.

 

Comments

[Leigh Barnes]

11:40 PM on 11/06/2010

Not sure which "librarian colleague" offered this comment, but the toddler's name in Knuffle Bunny is Trixie.

[Margaret H Mason]

09:21 AM on 10/22/2010

Great post! Some of your readers might be interested in joining a new Facebook group: One Million to Save Picture Books! -- created in response to the New York Times article.

It is an open group - everyone is invited to join and pass the word/add your friends (although some people don’t find it when they search, and have had to paste this link (without the apostrophes) into their browser to find the page):

‘http://www.facebook.com/home.php?#!/home.php?sk=group_159866324045455&ap=1’

The idea is – get a million people to join and then ask the NYT to take note… people ARE reading picture books!

Thanks!

Margaret

Margaret H. Mason
www.callingmrtoad.com

[Ruth Murray]

12:50 PM on 10/14/2010

Picture books are also used by teachers and librarians everywhere to teach, genre and writing traits. The illustrators play an important part in creating the message and the tone of the book. We need quality picture books to inspire readers young and older.

[Janice Rawlins]

10:35 AM on 10/14/2010

Children need picture books for learning and seeing pictures make children happy to see a dog, or cat or whatever the book reads about. I still love picture books and reading them to my kids are just as fun to see their faces when they see the pictures.

[Read AloudDad]

06:23 PM on 10/13/2010

Yes, there are a lot of fabulous picture and chapter books available for kids. Don't forget to start reading aloud to your kids at an early age!

A good selection of excellent books is available on my blog

Read Aloud ... Dad

http://readalouddad.blogspot.com

@readalouddad (on Twitter)

[Janice Rawlins]

10:35 AM on 10/14/2010

I agree with you 100%.