iPhone app iPad app Android phone app Android tablet app More

Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Lorenzo Candelaria

GET UPDATES FROM Lorenzo Candelaria
 

Mozart the Catholic: What Could Have Been

Posted: 04/03/11 11:08 PM ET

In April 1791, events were set in motion that would have changed the history of sacred music forever. Wolfgang Amadeus Mozart (whose mild notoriety as a Freemason tends to eclipse the fact that he was a Roman Catholic) had inquired about the possibility of becoming an unpaid assistant to Leopold Hofmann, the aging and increasingly indisposed chapelmaster of St. Stephen's Cathedral in Vienna. Mozart's petition was approved by month's end and it was virtually assured that the famous composer's magnanimous gesture would translate, in due time, into a handsomely paid appointment as chapelmaster at St. Stephen's, a premier venue for sacred music in the music capital of the late 18th century.

The idea of Mozart as chapelmaster at St. Stephen's Cathedral in Vienna fires the imagination in ways that few other composers can, particularly in light of the fact that he had become interested of late in composing not only large-scale sacred works but also more accessible church music in a "popular" style. We can only guess at what Mozart's "popular" music for Catholic liturgies at St. Stephen's would have sounded like. But it is nice to entertain the possibility that it would have pointed in the opposite direction of the path that Catholic church music would ultimately take. This is especially true with regard to misdirected attempts at a "popular" style in the waning decades of the 20th century. Anyone who experienced the "folk Masses" of the 1970s and 80s would surely agree.

Of course, Mozart's appointment as chapelmaster of St. Stephen's -- a position that would have required a regular output of new compositions for Catholic liturgies throughout the year -- never happened. By the end of 1791, Mozart was dead, his legacy capped off by two of his most enduring works -- "The Magic Flute," perpetually refashioned by authors de jour as the centerpiece of Masonic conspiracy theories, and his haunting "Requiem Mass."

Mozart's "Requiem Mass" occupies a special place in music history. It is a Catholic Mass for the dead written by one of the most celebrated composers in the Western world as he lay dying; a Mass he would leave unfinished at the time of his death in Vienna, Austria on Dec. 5, 1791. On the evening of Nov. 20, Mozart worked on the score of the "Requiem Mass" for the last time then took to bed with the illness that would kill him just over two weeks later (probably a streptococcal infection that led to kidney failure).

The story of Mozart's "Requiem Mass" tends to focus on the composer's tragic death at the age of 35. We romanticize the work as a requiem that the composer was writing for himself and, indeed, Mozart might have arrived at that notion as death approached in late 1791. But the origins of the "Requiem Mass" lie with another tragic death at a very tender age -- that of Anna Countess von Walsegg, who died at the age of 19 on Valentine's Day 1791. In the summer of that year, the widower Franz Count von Walsegg, a wealthy Austrian land owner and industrialist, sought to commemorate his wife's passing with a Mass for the dead which he anonymously commissioned from Mozart through an intermediary -- a figure remembered in the annals of history as "The Grey Messenger."

The secrecy of Walsegg's commission through "The Grey Messenger" has acquired a thick air of mystery around it. But there was a very practical aspect to it: Walsegg, an amateur composer, had intended to pass Mozart's "Requiem Mass" off as his own composition. Indeed, the count's personal copy of the "Requiem Mass" does not credit Mozart as the composer but instead gives his own name as the creator of the musical work. Wolfgang Amadeus Mozart did not live long enough to finish the secretive commission but Constanze Mozart -- suddenly widowed, with children, and in need of money -- made certain that her husband's commissioned work was completed.

In the early months of 1792, Franz Count von Walsegg received the full "Requiem Mass" that he had anonymously commissioned from Mozart. What Walsegg did not know at the time, however, was that only a fragment of the full work had actually been written by the famous composer. The rest was fleshed out by Franz Xaver Süssmayer, who had assisted Mozart in preparing "The Magic Flute" earlier that year, and two of Mozart's Viennese students, Franz Jacob Freystädtler and Joseph Eybler.

Mozart did not write much of the "Requiem Mass" that we continue to enshrine in churches and concert halls as his last great composition. We have known that for some time. If our stubborn hold on the "Requiem Mass" says anything about us, it might well reflect our desire to experience even a fragment of "what might have been" had Mozart lived just a little bit longer. One thing for certain: had the appointment at St. Stephen's Cathedral come through as expected, Mozart's celebrated operatic and concert works would have contended with one of the most glorious bodies of Catholic sacred music ever created. Much like Franz Count von Walsegg, the Catholic world would have been eager to claim that music as its own. Laus Deo.

 
 
 
In April 1791, events were set in motion that would have changed the history of sacred music forever. Wolfgang Amadeus Mozart (whose mild notoriety as a Freemason tends to eclipse the fact that he was...
In April 1791, events were set in motion that would have changed the history of sacred music forever. Wolfgang Amadeus Mozart (whose mild notoriety as a Freemason tends to eclipse the fact that he was...
 
 
  • Comments
  • 42
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
American Air
01:19 PM on 04/05/2011
Mozart loathed the Churh. He was a diehard Free Mason and deist. To call him a Catholic is fraud, IMO
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Pat Pepe
02:05 PM on 04/05/2011
Freemasons do not loathe the church or any other religion, I am a catholic and Freemason, I do not kneel to false gods or idols, I believe in Jesus Christ my saviour, Mary the mother of god on earth and all her worldly love given through prayer. The church (many of them) are fore runners of the conspiracy theories. I have been a Freemason 32 years, never heard of plots, prayers to false gods. brotherhood, charity, and Faith in the religion of their choice, To deny that is to exlude yourself from the societies of the world.No my friend it is the conspirators, and theorists, and the DUUHS of the world who are the frauds. When my life is ended and I stand before Jesus and almighty God, and all that is seen in my book of life FREEMASON, I will trust in the will of god and be accepted.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
American Air
11:49 AM on 04/06/2011
The Vatican has a Fatwa against Free Masons!

LOL :)
photo
Readbetweentheelevens
You can't turn the wind so turn the sail.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Pat Pepe
02:14 PM on 04/05/2011
Read the above, and learn. I have no reason to be evasive some of the finest men including the religious I have met in the Craft are the finest of men.Ask and inquire visit a Masonic Lodge especially on open nights see for your self and be included in the circle of knowledge. Believe and you will not be shattered, your faith will still be intact you will witness Brotherhood of all ethnic, races, and religious faiths in harmony
photo
Readbetweentheelevens
You can't turn the wind so turn the sail.
04:38 PM on 04/05/2011
Do you read the link I posted, and did you learn? Nothing in your post changes the position of the Roman Catholic church. The same or similar position existed at the time of Mozart's life. According to the Roman Catholic church, you can't be both.

BTW, did you like the "folk Masses" of the 1970s?
photo
flamflurm
The name's Flurm. Flam Flurm.
10:30 AM on 04/04/2011
The greatest Catholic Mass was written by a Lutheran, J. S. Bach.
photo
HUFFPOST COMMUNITY MODERATOR
Pyfagorus
I'm here, I'm Dear... get used to it!!
02:37 AM on 04/05/2011
Can't argue with that... but the B minor is awfully long for a mass. Of course, Bach's music is always so glorious, sitting through it is time well spent.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
ManuOB1
A voice crying in the wilderness
07:22 AM on 04/04/2011
What makes Catholicism catholic is diversity in ethnicities and cultures. A folk Mass is fine at summer camp. Mozart's Mass, not so much.

What makes Catholicism parochial is the "circle the wagons" approach to criticism of its failures or excesses.

What makes Catholicism archaic is its foisting of vestiges of the Roman empire on the modern world.

What makes Catholicism fascinating, infuriating and fun: all of the above.
10:15 PM on 04/04/2011
What makes Catholicism great and a distance from being archaic is that it is the original Church of Jesus Christ: it is spiritual; it is home. The Church as provided western civilization as well as other faiths with such "fun" things as universities and hospitals, not to mention music, art, literature and even theater a la Shakespeare and Pope John Paul II. For sure it has lasted for over 2000 years with its enemies being inside as well as outside the Church. The church does not provide matinees for entertainment or "fun". It reveals the presence of GOD. Jesus cleared out the money changers of the day this past decade with cleaning house of sexual deviants and church liberals who held our Church hostage in the USA and around the world. Look around you, people! The world is falling apart because GOD has been kicked out of the home.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
ManuOB1
A voice crying in the wilderness
10:35 PM on 04/04/2011
Jesus never uttered the word "Catholic"; much less pope, cardinal etc. Held against the Gospel, the current structure of the Church betrays Jesus' teaching at every turn. He called his apostles to be servants and explicitly told them NOT to lord it over others. The sexual deviants are not half as scandalous as the complicity of bishops who time and again sacrificed children on the high altar of bureaucracy. Jesus weeps over Rome as he wept over Jerusalem.
photo
HUFFPOST COMMUNITY MODERATOR
Pyfagorus
I'm here, I'm Dear... get used to it!!
02:29 AM on 04/05/2011
The world is falling apart because of the 2nd Law of Thermodynamics. If you think conditions in the world have ever been better than they are now, it's because you're making a very selective reading of history, both ancient and recent.
photo
me again
I'm not wrong....
06:56 AM on 04/04/2011
Mozart wrote his church music by commission. He ran afoul of the Prince Arch-Bishop in Salzburg and everywhere else he went. There is reason for the play-up of his Free Masonry and that is that even though he was born a Roman Catholic, it does not appear he was a religious man. His opera from Nozze di Figaro to Zauberflote reflect the more of the time and or Free Masonry, not religious themes as many of his contemporaries drew upon. Wrapping up, Mozarts relatioship with the Church throughout his life was strained and a means to an end financially and like his contemporary Beethoven, there is not much to go on to describe his as devout.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
TheWM
aka The Wrong Monkey
12:22 PM on 04/04/2011
There is not much go on to say that he was not a devout Catholic, either. There's not a lot of evidence either way. The private letters of the Mozart family seem to show pretty clearly that Wolfgang's father Leopold was quite devout. And a lot of the popular stories of Leopold being a tyrant, and father and son hating each other, seems to be pure legend. (Beethoven's father -- now THERE was a bad father!)

It's true that nothing more than economics is necessary to explain Mozart's work for the Church. The great majority of job opportunities for musicians and composers in Mozart's time were bestowed by patronage, and the Catholic Church was by far the biggest patron. Composing works for the Church doesn't mean Mozart was a devout Catholic.

On the other hand, his being a Mason and coming into conflict don't mean he wasn't devout. Many Masons at that time were also devout Catholics. And many devout Catholics before and since have come into frequent conflict with Church authorities.
05:37 PM on 04/06/2011
No devout Catholic would join Freemasonry knowing that it is forbidden, which Mozart probably did. I suppose you could say he had subscribed to a kind of heterodox Catholicism, though.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Pat Pepe
02:22 PM on 04/05/2011
I don't know if the word devout is standard in todays world I have attended Catholic Masses and seen some receivers of the host move to a side line to ignore receiving the host from a Black Catholic Priest in favor of the White Priest also serving in communion. Jesus sees all and will eventually question all.
02:49 PM on 04/07/2011
That sounds just terrible. Maybe they were just moving to the next open spot? We have 4 people administering the Eucharist, 2 at the altar & 2 on the sides & to make the line flow, you go to who's open instead of holding up the line so you get the priest and not one of the lay ministers.
photo
HUFFPOST COMMUNITY MODERATOR
Pyfagorus
I'm here, I'm Dear... get used to it!!
05:55 AM on 04/04/2011
I'll settle for the great sacred music Mozart did write. There are close to 20 masses and the K.427 Great C minor alone is one of the most magnificent choral works ever written.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
naschkatze
A free man creates himself.
02:21 PM on 04/04/2011
x2
photo
TheSojourner
My blog is up and running.
05:52 AM on 04/04/2011
It seems a bit egocentric of the Catholic Church, to want to confine this genius to religious music, rather than Mozart being able to expand what was already a very remarkable portfolio of compositions in other directions. I would like to have heard more development of his abilities as he traveled through his life chronologically. Who can say how he might have expanded his craft even more?
photo
HUFFPOST COMMUNITY MODERATOR
Pyfagorus
I'm here, I'm Dear... get used to it!!
06:25 AM on 04/04/2011
The mind boggles. I often wonder the same about Schubert, who also died so young. What sort of amazing music would he have produced if he'd lived into the mid-19th century? And would we now think of him more as a full-on Romanticist like Schumann and Mendelssohn, rather than as a "transitional" composer like Beethoven?
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
2lib4oh
05:08 AM on 04/04/2011
The music is there, and if it fits a Catholic heart, then why can't Catholics claim it as their own?
photo
flamflurm
The name's Flurm. Flam Flurm.
10:31 AM on 04/04/2011
I do!
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
American Air
01:20 PM on 04/05/2011
The Church has stolen so many things, so why not this as well
02:43 AM on 04/04/2011
Of all the words of tongue or pen, the saddest are these: It might have been!

Don't remember who first said that, but whoever it was missed the riches provided by history's might-have-beens -- they can be turned into fiction. This article cries aloud for an alternate-history fantasy in which Mozart composed for the Catholic Church! :)

(Adding notes to my unending Story Ideas file...)

Fascinating food for thought, and a bit of Mozartian history I hadn't known. MANY thanks!!!
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Hysterian68
bureaucrat/historian/ranter
01:31 AM on 04/04/2011
If it were not for the fact that Pope Benedict is a great admirer of Mozart and plays Mozart on his piano almost every night, the pompous philistines in purple and scarlet who surround this pontiff would have undoubtedly done the same to Mozart that happened to him at St. Stephen's cathedral in the 18th century. To this day these tasteless boors have permitted the continuing ruination of music in the liturgy for 40 years. They would not recognize a musical genius and patronize his work unless some apparition occurred and a voice from Heaven were to give that artist high praise and demand that his work be used in church.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Jeannette Lacey
12:13 AM on 04/04/2011
Unfortunately, even if Mozart had lived to write more liturgical music, I doubt that it would have helped us avoid those horrible folk masses anyway.
12:50 AM on 04/04/2011
If He had writtine liturgical music I would love to hear little 10 yr old JAckie Evancho sing them.
Here she is performing 2 different versions of Ave Maria
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=D0FAbYepMic
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GzBvpTfNulI
And Pie Jesu
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IbjWz_WIhSE
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
04:28 AM on 04/04/2011
pretty amazing....anything without the electronic's helping so much ?
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
PrairieGayCompanion
To improve is to change
11:12 PM on 04/03/2011
I don't know. Ave Verum Corpus was like a dirge, but Exultate Jubilate, especially the Allelujia, indicated some playfulness in liturgical music. Would the Church have had more power over his works? Perhaps.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
mrkurtzhedead
I'll be back, when it's dark!
12:04 AM on 04/04/2011
If he had lived I would have way preferred more of what he was doing: building on the late symphonies and piano concertos.