Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
HuffPost Social Reading
Lorenzo Candelaria

GET UPDATES FROM Lorenzo Candelaria
 

Praying Through Music: The History of Sacred Notation

Posted: 01/23/2011 10:13 pm

The musical arts of the Roman Catholic Church rank among its greatest contributions to contemporary culture. Music existed outside of the Church, of course. But it was the Catholic Church that first truly cultivated the art as we know it. In the service of praising God, it fostered a number of innovations -- such as musical notation -- that inform the ways we create and transmit music even today.

Take, for instance, the musical scale rendered in syllables as "do re mi fa sol la ti do." This arrangement of precise pitch relationships is the basis of a clever song in The Sound of Music ("Do -- a deer, a female deer. Re -- a drop of golden sun ... ") and, indeed, of virtually every piece of music that sounds "in tune" to the average ear in Western European and American cultures. These particular pitch relationships (and the idea of rendering them as syllables) were harnessed from all existing sound by a resourceful Benedictine monk named Guido of Arezzo in the early eleventh century. Guido's scale had only six notes (ut, re, mi, fa, sol, la) but with just a slight modification (changing "ut" to "do" in a later century) and the addition of "ti" (that brings us back to "do") the basic form remains unchanged nearly 1000 years later. So does its purpose. Then, as now, the scale served to help singers learn and recall a body of songs whose sheer quantity made them increasingly difficult to memorize and pass down.

Guido's scale had a "sacred origin" of sorts; at least in terms of the context from which it was derived. The monk drew his inspiration for the musical scale he devised from a hymn sung on the feast of St. John the Baptist (Ut queant laxis) that suggested to him the pattern of ascending notes (and the relative pitches that occur between them) that we still use today. The specifics of how Guido got from "point A" to "point B" need not detain us here. (Although it is an interesting story!) Suffice it to say that any song written down with the basic musical scale Guido first devised nearly a millenium ago -- whether it is sung by a Benedictine monk, Julie Andrews, or Lady Gaga -- reflects just one aspect of the Catholic Church's great legacy of cultivating music in the service of God -- the invention of a musical staff with precise pitch arrangements that help us to create, perform, and remember most of the melodies we enjoy today -- inside the Church and out.

It should not surprise us that music has been such a central concern for the Church. Indeed, praying through music allows us to express our highest calling -- to come together as a community to worship and praise God -- in a way that no other art can. Painting, sculpture, and architecture might spur us toward holiness, but none can unite us quite like music. This is particularly true of singing -- an art that invites group participation and can often arise spontaneously around a shared sentiment and a decent tune.

Singing is a natural response in times of joy or mourning, stress or relaxation -- even in times of sheer boredom. It is universally accessible in that -- all aesthetic judgements aside -- if you can talk, you can sing. In the most general sense, we might think of singing merely as heightened speech: an inflection here, a thoughtful pause there, a lilting cadence to accentuate related ideas. Plot those inflections, pauses and cadences onto a graph indicating relative time and pitch (that is essentially what sheet music does) and heightened speech is transformed into song.

St. Augustine was one of music's earliest eloquent proponents. (He is popularly credited with coining the phrase "He who sings, prays twice.") Today, Pope Benedict XVI, an accomplished pianist and brother of Msgr. Georg Ratzinger (former director of the Regensburg Cathedral Choir), has emerged as one of the most thoughtful commentators on sacred music since then. (I highly recommend his essay on music in The Spirit of the Liturgy, Ignatius Press, 2000.) In some recent remarks, Pope Benedict extended his advocacy of music beyond the realm of the sacred (strictly speaking), lauding it as a valuable tool in the educational process. Addressing the Fiesole Youth Orchestra after a concert in Vatican City last year, he praised the young musicians, noting their "constant practices carried out with patience; the exercise of listening to the other musicians; the commitment not to play 'in solitude'," but in a way that allowed the different orchestral colors to come together while maintaining their own characteristics. In fine, he praised their "common search for the best expression."

The Holy Father was addressing a youth orchestra there, but his words resonate with the whole of humanity: Don't play alone. Come together. Listen to one another. Maintain your own characteristics in the common search for the best expression. Those are the basic rules for living in harmony -- an ideal for society that is rehearsed in our churches every Sunday, and never more so than when we come together as a community to pray through sacred song. Guido of Arezzo could not have foreseen the far-reaching consequences of the singing aids he devised in the eleventh century. But we can easily imagine that he would have been pleased. Laus Deo.

 
 
 
The musical arts of the Roman Catholic Church rank among its greatest contributions to contemporary culture. Music existed outside of the Church, of course. But it was the Catholic Church that first ...
The musical arts of the Roman Catholic Church rank among its greatest contributions to contemporary culture. Music existed outside of the Church, of course. But it was the Catholic Church that first ...
 
 
  • Comments
  • 73
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2  Next ›  Last »  (2 total)
09:51 AM on 01/28/2011
"Living on a prayer" isn't going to get you a "stairway to heaven" or a "highway to hell" because "all you need is love" in order to "come together"
photo
Big Richard
Stuck in the middle with you
04:46 PM on 01/30/2011
Nice of you to quote from the Third Testament of the Bible. But, you really should reference the prophets who wrote those lines.
03:47 AM on 01/31/2011
Amen!!! HTe 3rd Testament (The Newest Testament) is my Favorite.

Saint John Bon Jovi
Saint Jimmy Page
Saint Robert Plant
Saint Bon Scott
Saint Angus Young
Saint Paul McCartney
Saint John Lennon
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
PlayTOE
Morals evolved due to cooperative group living
03:58 AM on 01/27/2011
Apparently the world never had music till the Catholic church provided it in the early eleventh century. That is almost as big a whopper as the claim that the universe started in 4004 BCE.

There is a musical instrument 35,000-years-old, a 5 hole flute. It was found in the Ach Valley of southern Germany. It seems to have followed the rules of the pentatonic scale that still predominates in Asia, not the diatonic scale of middle ages Europe.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
hagagaga
My comments are funnier than yours.
01:04 PM on 01/28/2011
Where does the article say that?
photo
deepintheheartoftejas
Middle o/t Road = Yellow stripes & dead armadillos
07:07 PM on 01/28/2011
The article says nothing of the sort. It says written music that demonstrates actual pitch relationships is a western invention. That was an enormously influential step, and the credit is appropriately assigned to late medieval Latin scholars. The development of mensuration in the 13th century was another enormous leap. As a consequence, we know vastly more about how Latin church music at that time was performed, than about any other music in the history of the world prior.

Of course, liturgical music was just the tip of a vast iceberg of music that existed at the time, about which only tantalizing hints have been preserved.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
PlayTOE
Morals evolved due to cooperative group living
08:48 PM on 01/28/2011
Music using the pentatonic scale also demonstrat­es actual pitch relationsh­ips. The diatonic scale is simply a more complex scale.
Prediction - there will be additional scales discovered and used in music.

As to why liturgical music survived while the popular music was lost ... all preservation of knowledge was confined to the church, and they were selective.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Hysterian68
bureaucrat/historian/ranter
01:22 AM on 01/27/2011
That the Church has contribute­d to the arts is but a by-product of it's ability to accumulate wealth and power.
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Well at least at one time the RCChurch contributed to the arts. Today, the only thing it does is accumulate wealth and power, seduce teenage boys, and bribe the police to keep looking the other way.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
syntax facit saltum
We do not live in a 2 story universe
01:54 AM on 01/27/2011
Within the Eastern Orthodox church there were famous monastic singers and painters. (Wasn't that sometimes true for the Catholic church as well?) Like St. Romanos the Melodist: http://orthodoxwiki.org/Roman_the_Melodist (Here you can read some of his poetry); Here is a famous hymn of his. I've never heard it performed outside of its context of worship before as it is here: http://www.mygreek.fm/el/video-clip/4868/Simeron-kremate-epi-xilou

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2yW39rHxW2c

And this is very beautiful in my opinion.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Hysterian68
bureaucrat/historian/ranter
12:46 AM on 01/27/2011
Yet it takes the Anglicans to do the Catholic liturgy and perform great choral pieces better than the Catholics themselves. Great church music may have started and was continued down through the centuries to moder times, but you sure the hell wouldn't think so today---with very few exceptions. The average Catholic can't or won't sing and most choir directors don't know what they're doing in the first place.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
02:17 PM on 01/25/2011
Where and to whom dose one complain to with respect to the deletion practices of your nameless and faceless "moderator(s)"?
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
01:19 PM on 01/25/2011
“In general, the best way to determine whether a comment is appropriate is simple. Ask first whether it's inappropriate. Ask whether it violates any of the guidelines outlined here. If it does, then it should be flagged or deleted. If it doesn't, the comment should be published or left alone.â€

Just ask, right! Taint neccessarily so! Whom do you ask and where do direct your query to? I got a better suggestion: Every moderator should include his or her argument(s) for deleting any comment(s) and every such deletion(s) should include the name and title (if any) of every such moderator.

Cowardice comes in many forms and anonymity is one of them. kaman kapu
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
10:14 AM on 01/26/2011
Fully agree, KK.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
08:32 PM on 01/27/2011
X2
photo
ArtJunky
Belief is mandatory
01:04 PM on 01/25/2011
I would wager that Ancient Greece had this whole music thing figured out way before the Christian Industrial Complex came along.

One only has to look at the sophistication of the Arts to realize just how advanced they really were.

Music would have been included in this ancient Renaissance.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
syntax facit saltum
We do not live in a 2 story universe
10:04 PM on 01/26/2011
Byzantine music was a very different kind of Christian music that was obviously influenced by the traditions of Greece. (for an example) http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cd5U9qqt-c4

Also, Byzantine iconography is to me far surpassing in beauty Western religious art. http://www.goarch.org/resources/clipart
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Hysterian68
bureaucrat/historian/ranter
12:50 AM on 01/27/2011
Byzantine music is rooted in Syria and Palestine synagogues. I agree with your second sentence to a point. Byzantine is not a purely eastern art form. Far from it.

Yet, the purely naturalistic Western religious art starts to deteriorate into pious kitsch, mere ornamentation--gingerbread and plaster of paris pastiche after the 13th century.
photo
deepintheheartoftejas
Middle o/t Road = Yellow stripes & dead armadillos
07:15 PM on 01/28/2011
Sure, there are many references to Greek music in the works that survive... but if they ever developed a system of notating the performance of it, it hasn't survived.

It's rather interesting that the term "Renaissance" applied to the European period from the trecento to roughly 1600 replied to a rebirth of learning from the classical world--however, classical music theory played almost no role in the era of Renaissance music...

But, it did influence the early baroque! In the period around 1570-1620, long past the era named the "Renaissance" in art and cultural history, a number of musician-scholars tried to recreate the music of the Greeks. Of course, it was no such thing in reality, but their virtuosic monody led directly to Monteverdi's innovations. One of the most important music theorists at the time was Vincenzo Galilei, the father of Galileo.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
12:16 PM on 01/25/2011
Can music be a prayer ?
When Blind Willie Johnson, plays'Dark was the night,cold was the ground' on the guitar, I think it is.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
theburb
12:15 PM on 01/25/2011
The point of this article is notation as a means to play or sing together, It took someone, "Guido d'Arezzo, to figure out a SYSTEM of notating, back in the Gregorian chant days and prior. Some might say the greatest contribution to music was this new ability to play and sing together, no longer just "call and response", etc. In those days and on into the medievil, renaissance, baroque, even classical, the center of Western music development was in the churches.
I like the words of Benedict to the youth orchestra members, and I think they can be applied in on the world scene as well.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Hillbilly49
Don't tell me you are a Christian; let me guess.
10:09 AM on 01/25/2011
The only good thing ever to come out of religion was the music.

~George Carlin

photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Hysterian68
bureaucrat/historian/ranter
12:52 AM on 01/27/2011
Art, architecture, poetry, and music are religions in themselves. The only TRUE religions.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
methodman
07:25 PM on 01/24/2011
Classical Music is really formulated out of Pre-Algebra Relationships. I Kinow you church people want to dicredit every trace of rationality that is woven into time. An turn it into this Gawd Bullshit. But muscial procedures are based on mathematical methods. Today Algorihmic composition has fallen down to one remaining program left called Band in a Box. At one time there were quite a lot The Atari St had the most midi music program with Dr T's KCS Level ii probably being the most complicated. The funny part of it is that none of the softare matched the academic focus and worse the magazines. Eletronic Musician and Keyboard didn't either. Instead what happened is Jim Aiken who wrote the manual together with Craig Anderton seemed to represent music in terms of physics processes. It took me years to translate between every body Walter Piston, Miguel Francoli, Dr. T of course, Tim Courderoy's atari midi archives, and the designers of Reaktor. The only way to appreciate it is to turn your computer into an Atari ST for Music or Amiga for everything else. Those programs in some ways emphesized a side of the coin that has dropped out of the music programs on the XP and Mac side of things. Fitting words to syllables works only when you have developed enough words to state material and the surrounding areas. I am appaled by the lack of words that are being used on recordings.
06:18 AM on 01/25/2011
Recorded history began when people began reading and writing. And while most people didn't read or write, who were the writers of history? The RigVeda mystics, the priests at Karnak, the jewish scribes, the NT authors. The printing press was invented for religious reasons, as was music notation. Mathematics was a way to count and predict celestial events, and astrology and astronomy were religious matters. Science has as much to do with religion as it does with politics, with war and technology, building and mercantry. And we know all this because people wrote.
photo
ArtJunky
Belief is mandatory
01:12 PM on 01/25/2011
Follow the money and the power and you QUICKLY learn why these Scientific and Artistic Institutions were embedded in Religion.

Making claim on that basis is like the sort of authority that Saddam Hussein claimed in his rigged elections. It was stacked in his favor just as the Christian Narrative is so self-serving.
05:47 PM on 01/24/2011
beautiful inspiration ; on epoin tbeing that modern music is nothing new but is a profitable business

another point : a study in Virginia showed that children listening to traditional music from the appalachians developed higher IQ

in music it is also true what is said about true art " all art comes from the peasants " this is especially true of happy [ [but authentic , emotional intelligence] ]music

the most ancient music is maharishi gandharva veda music

[ maharishichannel.in carries a replay of a German radio interview with maharishi about the origin of gandharva ]

this most basically is 1. simply chanting aaaaaaaaaaaaahhh in Drupad singing [ precise rythms plus improv] the origin of the origin

2. Sarasvati's Vina [ veena] and rythms expressed by Mridingam or tabla

the pentatonic scale is from the 5 mahabhutas

our 8 note octave is from all 8 prakritis [ 8 svaras of the [ uncreated , nitya apaurusheya] devanagri alphabet ]
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
mommadona
I paint. I blog. Therefore, I am.
04:36 PM on 01/24/2011
Now, that's interesting... I posted a simple Disney cartoon about Mathematics that explained the origin of a musical scale and that post was (?) (lets try this again, shall we?) http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ACtjN4CSN50
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
wbthacker
Can YOU pass the Turing Test?
03:22 PM on 01/24/2011
"The musical arts of the Roman Catholic Church rank among its greatest contributions to contemporary culture. "

Let me rephrase that: "The RCC collected tithes, by blackmail and force, from all of Europe, then used some of this money to pay the world's best artists. Some of the greatest masterpieces of music, painting, and sculpture resulted."

You're thanking the wrong people. You should be grateful to the serfs and peasants of medieval Europe who had precious little to spare, yet were taxed (in money, goods, and work) to pay for this art. Not that many of them ever saw those paintings or heard that music, of course. But I'm sure just knowing it existed was enough to make them forget about their hunger and poverty.

Thanking the church for this music is about as goofy as thanking Bernie Madoff for the fantastic apartment he created in NYC. He turned a pile of money into something beautiful... what difference does it make how he got it?
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
CMB1969
raging moderate
12:11 AM on 01/25/2011
The exact same analysis can be made about any "civilized" society the world has seen between the rise of the earliest city states in Sumeria circa 4,000 BC and the start of the industrial revolution circa 1800 AD. Every society in that broad stroke of history was founded on a small nobility (priestly and/or warrior, in some rare cases merchantile) governing a much larger peasant class. The musical accomplishments of the medieval Church were probably more productive (and cheaper, overall) than some Roman senator's orgies....
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
03:38 PM on 01/26/2011
Agreed. In fact, the same can be said about any civilized society with a tax system used to finance anything. Perhaps a better way to think about this, or at least to complement the analysis, would be to examine how music (or art, or sculpture, or architecture) would have developed in the absence of support from the church.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Hysterian68
bureaucrat/historian/ranter
12:58 AM on 01/27/2011
Just as serfs in America today are the foundation to the great wealth of Wall Street. So, what?

Serfs and peasants were born to be taxed. Always have been and always will be. Thank goodness the robber barons of the middles ages spent the loot they took from them on great works of art.
What are the looters and highwaymen of corporate America spending it on today? THEMSELVES and only THEMSELVES.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
wbthacker
Can YOU pass the Turing Test?
05:22 PM on 01/28/2011
I can't distinguish your sarcasm from your actual point. I'm sure you don't really believe that it's right and proper to preserve a peasant class and tax them for luxuries for the rich.

But I think what you're saying is that it's OK that "peasants" end up paying for luxuries they can't appreciate, and indeed, that's their purpose. This suggests I shouldn't have any guilt at all about buying diamonds. Normally I would be afraid that I might be putting money into the "blood diamond" trade that causes so much suffering in Africa. But from what you are saying it seems that suffering is insignificant compared to the lasting beauty of a well-cut diamond. Those African "peasants" should feel lucky, I guess. In a few hundred years their descendants.... well, *someone's* descendants, since many of them won't live long enough to produce children ... will be able to go into a museum and see the pretty stones they donated at gunpoint.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
DiogenesOfAlaska
Mitt Romney for president - of the Cayman islands!
02:40 PM on 01/24/2011
How true. Just take a simple statement, such as, for example

'All we are saying is give peace a chance'

and you will automatically chant it. It really is that simple.

:-)

Thank God the Vatican recently managed to admit that the Beatles need not go to hell for their claim that they're more popular than Jesus by now.

But maybe that's just because after the Beatles, one of the popes managed to be more popular than the Beatles. Who knows.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Hysterian68
bureaucrat/historian/ranter
01:03 AM on 01/27/2011
Thank God the Vatican recently managed to admit that the Beatles need not go to hell for their claim that they're more popular than Jesus by now.
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
How very generous of the pope. Did he lift the Church's excommunication from them too? Did Holy Joe Ratzinger also tell his priests and cardinals they need not go to hell as well for dropping their pants around little boys, fondling them, and then lying to the police and the courts? Committing repeated acts of obstruction of justice and perjuring themselves?
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
DiogenesOfAlaska
Mitt Romney for president - of the Cayman islands!
05:00 AM on 01/27/2011
Well, if these offenders were protestants or existentialist philosophers, they would already be in hell. I'm not sure that catholics are much better off.