More

Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Luis Heredia

Luis Heredia

Posted: April 27, 2010 08:32 PM

Arizona's New Immigration Law Is a Sham, and That's Just Fine by Republicans

What's Your Reaction:

Greetings from Arizona, where we have a brand new immigration law. It's been called many things, a few of them even printable. But here's what I call that law: a sham.

It's a sham because the Republicans who drafted the bill, SB1070, know it does nothing to protect Arizona. They know it doesn't help secure the border. And they know it makes law enforcement's job even harder. Local police who are busy solving crimes and catching criminals will now have to enforce federal immigration laws. But Republicans passed the bill anyway - it's an election year, after all -- and Republican Gov. Jan Brewer signed it into law on Friday.

Brewer says she did "the right thing" for Arizona. I say she did it for the right-wing in Arizona. After all, the governor is locked in a race to the right with a handful of GOP primary challengers.

Arizona is a border state -- it's no secret we have a serious crime problem at our border. Over the decades, the federal government has neither secured the border nor passed comprehensive immigration reform to protect our families and our economy.

But let's be clear: SB1070 is a sham. The real public-safety threats to Arizona are border violence, drug cartels and human smuggling. This new law does nothing -- I repeat -- nothing to secure our border, make us safer, or put a dent in the cartels' operations. Instead, it diverts law enforcement's attention from more serious crimes. It forces police to defend frivolous lawsuits. It creates fear among Hispanic communities. And it puts a black mark on Arizona nationally at a time when our state needs to attract businesses and tourism.

Despite all their chest-thumping about being tough on immigration, the Republicans could take a lesson from a Democrat -- Attorney General Terry Goddard -- who takes on the drug and human smuggling rings every day in his job. His work keeps Arizona safer, unlike the empty GOP grandstanding. Our state party is working hard to help elect Democrats up and down the ticket in November, starting with Terry Goddard at the top. He called on Brewer to veto SB1070, but she caved in to the right wing.

We love Arizona, and we're angry about what's happening here. We know people across the country are angry too. So what happens after the protesters and the TV trucks go home? We register voters. We boost community outreach. We raise money. We spread our message in every way, across every form of media. In other words, we use all of our resources to elect strong, common-sense Democrats. It's the only way to get Arizona back on track. If you're angry too, we invite you to join us.

Unless we win this fight, Arizona is stuck with this sham of a law - and sham of leadership.

 
 
 
  • Comments
  • 33
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
HUFFPOST COMMUNITY MODERATOR
SMAckley
12:13 PM on 05/01/2010
Unfortunately, the AZ Democratic Party has shown itself to be completely incompetent. During the last election cycle, when Obama was energizing new voters and Democrats were riding his coat tails into office, the AZ Democratic Party raised more campaign funds than at any previous time.

They used this money to hire their cronies as campaign advisors. These consultants were arrogant, knew little about the districts and the voters and refused to listen to the rank and file precinct workers and volunteers.

The AZ Democratic Party actually LOST SEATS in the last election because of their incompetence and their choice to funnel all the money raised to their friends instead of to candidate support.

The AZ Democratic Party has been raising very little since then, as most of us realized the money was wasted. There was some hope of new leadership, but the newly elected Party Chair was convinced to resign by the powers that be so that the former, completely ineffective leader, could be returned to the post.

That's one reason that AZ is SO screwed: the Republicans saw this show of incompetence and were emboldened to execute their extremist policies in immigration, education, health care and other key areas.

The AZ Democratic Party is NOT the answer under current leadership. Too bad for the state.
11:12 AM on 04/29/2010
This is a very good point and is definitely an accurate description of AZ SB 1070
12:33 AM on 04/29/2010
Do Arizonans really want law enforcement stopping everyone with a brown face and Spanish surname? There will be less time to monitor serious crime and will turn law abiding citizens into second class citizens with fewer rights. What an embarrassing abomination this law is to all Americans!!
07:06 AM on 04/28/2010
Terry Goddard vowed that he would not enforce SB 1070 if Brewer voted for it. Is the Democratic party endorsing AGs that can decide which laws to enforce?
09:46 AM on 04/28/2010
Actually, Goddard only said that if the law is challenged in court, he would have to recuse himself from defending it due to his public stance against the law. This not uncommon in the AG realm, and a legal surrogate is appointed to to defend the case. See today's NY Times: http://www.nytimes.com/2010/04/28/us/28legal.html
01:43 PM on 04/29/2010
I'll concede that what he said. Here is a quote from the AG website:
http://www.azag.gov/meet_the_ag.html

As the State’s chief legal officer, the Attorney General has many duties,
but at the heart of my mission is an unwavering commitment to:

* promote justice
* protect all Arizonans by aggressively enforcing the law
* safeguard Arizona’s economy, environment and heritage for our children

So Goddard can spew euphemisms about supporting or enfocement -- but he said he won't enforce it. Brewer should fire him immediately unless he kisses her boots with an apology.

If a conservative christian fundamentalist was the AG and he said that about a popular liberal law you guys would be saying off with his head.

Do you think a liberal democrat is always going to be there?
HUFFPOST COMMUNITY MODERATOR
SMAckley
12:15 PM on 05/01/2010
He did NOT say that. You need to check your facts.
07:04 AM on 04/28/2010
I'm not sure what you mean by "frivolous lawsuits". What it will allow is for victims of crimes to hold cities accountable for sanctuary policies. As an example, 16 year old Kelly Tracy who was killed by a drunk illegal. Manuel Contreras-Galdean had been convicted of several serious felonies but was allowed to walk because of Gilbert's sanctuary policy. The family has tried to sue the city but unfortunately they didn't have SB 1070. Hopefully once the law passes so they can appeal.

The Bologna family in San Francisco won't be that lucky. Edwin Ramos, 21, an illegal immigrant from El Salvador, gunned down the family when they were returning from church. He was a known member of MS-13 but SF let him roam free. So far they haven't been able to sue because of that city's sanctuary policy.

I think the Democratic party leaders like yourself should explain your lack of compassion for these Americans, and should explain why you believe cities should get away with this lack of regard for its citizens. Your irresponsible behavior and attitudes puzzle me.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Appleblossom
11:27 AM on 04/28/2010
The guy got 14 years and had not been convicted previously of any serious felonies. He had two drunk driving convictions, one in 2007. And considering the amount of DOSL-Bs clogging the courts, apparently even white people have trouble obeying the laws on not driving after a conviction for DUI.
01:55 PM on 04/29/2010
I understand most liberals don't consider illegal immigration a crime, but that's not the case here. Ramos was arrested for assult twice (one of the a pregnant woman and her mother) and he was convicted of a robbery felony.He should have been detected merely for having MS-13 tatoos but the police let him ride every time. I don't understand why Democrats want to leave these low life scums free to roam the U.S. so they can choose victims. Don't you fee the least little bit of guilt for what happened, or perhaps compassion for the mother and daughter.

Of course you don't fee compassion even though the family is first generation American. For some reason liberals have a mind block that prevents them for feeling compassion especially if the victim is a whitey.
04:51 AM on 04/28/2010
Commonsense points, no hyperbole - thanks Luis
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Buzzm1
01:30 AM on 04/28/2010
Lawmaker wants to bring Arizona immigration law to Utah http://bit.ly/bJedfG

Nathan Deal, in the Georgia race for governor, says he’d implement Arizona-style immigration laws http://bit.ly/c6R7p1
01:20 AM on 04/28/2010
Outrageous... Luis hits the target. This bill is a sham, and shameful. While we do have a heady illegal immigration problem, that has long been sanctioned by our governments and big business, it does nothing to try to secure our borders. It overburdens an already overtaxed police force, and could potentially pit neighb...or to neighbor. What about the Hispanic armed forces veterans, who have shown their heroism? Are they to be stopped and detained? There are culprits in the sad state of our financial system, but it is not the illegal immigrants who should bear and wear, that mantle of shame.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Christopher Daley
11:36 PM on 04/27/2010
I just love that we are going to have a police state in the USA. Maybe we should start filming old spy movies there. I think we could hide the dessert, a little Blue Screen should do the trick.

http://www.csdaley.com/2010/04/papers-please.html
11:11 PM on 04/27/2010
Wow! Even on the Huff post, people r fed up w/illegal immigration, and the federal gov't's refusal to fulfill its constitutional obligation to secure our borders and enforce our immigration laws! 2 bad it had 2 come 2 this, but we've been more than patient!
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Buzzm1
10:39 PM on 04/27/2010
Tucson Border Patrol Sector Monthly Apprehensions Of Illegals---Length 262 miles
----------OCT---NOV---DEC---JAN----FEB---MAR---APR---MAY---JUN----JUL---AUG---SEP
FY2010-23211-16999-10922-16096-21223-31203
FY2009-18814-12845--9862-18649-20943-31433-28072-24084-20822-20144-20805-15178
FY2008-21725-18232-11722-26348-34297-45222-45436-32851-24290-21074-18404-18044
FY2007-25135-21323-16136-29459-34148-52692-49044-41789-34103-30373-24388-19649
FY2006-27316-24270-16447-33229-43153-63583-51588-40190-25049-21187-23256-22806
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Buzzm1
10:37 PM on 04/27/2010
8,300,000 - the number of illegals, using invalid SS numbers, illegally working at known places of employment.

In the meantime, there are 15,000,000 unemployed American workers

8,000,000 illegals earning $10 an hour, equals $20,800 a year, that's 8,000,000 X $20,800 equals $166,400,000,000; that's $166.4 billion that American workers aren't taking home for their wives, and children.

Remember all of those jobs that used to be available for teenagers.

But wait there's more; let's suppose 1/2 of those unemployed American workers, are drawing unemployment, at a very modest $300 a week, $15,600 a year times 7 million American workers; that's another $109.2 billion dollars out of taxpayer pockets. (Most of the state unemployment funds are broke).

So those 8 million illegally employed illegals are costing us $275.6 billion;...but wait there's more, they send $65 billion dollars home every year, so that money isn't even spent in our United States to support businesses.
09:49 PM on 04/27/2010
So many of us in AZ hate this law, but it takes a LOT of work to get the right people elected. I'm glad the writer made a call to action -- let's turn our anger into registering voters or fundraising for good candidates or the Dem party. AZ has elected Dems before, but it takes a TON of resources to turn out the vote -- we're outnumbered by GOP and independents!! People across the U.S., if you're pissed like we are, lend a hand!
10:32 PM on 04/27/2010
No, we will lend a hand to those Arizonians that are fighting for our freedom from the invasion of illegal aliens. The only people that want the illegals to stay here are people that hope their numbers will add to the numbers of Democrats to the point everyone can be a ward of the state that doesn't want to work for a living. We tax payers and patriotic Americans are tired of being run over by the politically correct and we are doing something about it for a change. Thank you Governor Brewer and the people of Arizona for the courage you have shown. We will support you and your state as much as possible.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
01:57 AM on 04/28/2010
You are so misinformed you're not worth arguing with.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Appleblossom
11:30 AM on 04/28/2010
Then how come you are not willing to stand up to businesses by electing someone who will?

How come it is just the people being offered the jobs that are being hit and not the owners?
09:47 PM on 04/27/2010
God bless Arizona for taking this on. The Arizona law is totally based on a federal law that Holder and Nepolitano are not enforcing. Both are breaking their oath of office by not enforcing the laws of this land. I think both should be arrested for lying to a federal official under oath when they were sworn into office. As a member of the board of directors of a large organization I will recommend that we do as much business with companies in the state of Arizona as possible to support their efforts to remove illegal aliens from this country. My wife is of Latin heritage and she and her family detest the illegal invasion of this country by mostly Mexicans and Central Americans. Her ancestors came to the USA in 1840 legally. They do not want the USA to turn into Mexico Norte'. Too many of any one ethnic group will destroy the character of this country. We have 15,000,000 real Americans unemployed and Holder and Obama are supporting foreigners over American citizens. Many illegals are working in skilled construction jobs such as carpenter, brick mason, and plumber. Those jobs belong to Americans. As far as the work in the farm fields go, if politicians like Obama didn't pass out free cell phones with 300 minutes per month, food stamps, housing allowances, and $1,500 per child to keep people on welfare, they would be out picking lettuce or do without. We need NO immigration reform.