Stop Selling Child Abuse as Therapy: Call Congress Today to Support HR 5876

Finally, the end may be in sight for residential programs that sell child abuse as therapy for teens. The House of Representatives will vote next Friday on HR 5876, the Stop Child Abuse in Residential Programs for Teens Act of 2008, introduced by California Rep. George Miller.

For years, when I have described the inhumane treatment -- beatings, months of isolation, sexual humiliation, emotional battering, stress positions, denial of food and sleep, punitive use of restraint -- that is routinely inflicted on teens in "boot camps" and other tough love residential programs, people have asked me "Why isn't this illegal?"

How can it be that there are unregulated private jails for teenagers in which they can receive corporal punishment that is prohibited even for convicted murderers in 21st century America?

The answer I have always given is that there is no federal legislation that prevents it: it is not illegal to use corporal punishment in schools and these residential facilities have generally managed to avoid state regulations which bar such treatment in psychiatric hospitals, group homes and rehabs.

HR 5876 would begin to put an end to that situation -- banning such tactics, putting all programs under oversight and providing a federal hotline to which teens must have access in order to report abuse. Everyone who cares about children should call or email their representative to urge support for it today and throughout next week. No legislation is perfect, of course-- but this is an enormous step towards change.

This link provides an easy way to show your support.

It beggars belief that teenagers in America do not now have the right to be free of the kind of degrading and humiliating treatment banned by the Geneva Conventions.

Although I have never heard of waterboarding being used by these programs, the following scenarios have all been reported either directly to me by more than one witness to the incident or in court documents or Congressional testimony in these programs:

1) Boys hooded, with nooses around their necks, made to stand for hours in searing desert heat.

2) A girl forced to dress as a hooker, with "slut, 25 cents" smeared on her with lipstick, made to walk past catcalling boys. Then, she was forced to kneel in front of a middle-aged man who asked if she liked performing oral sex on older men. This occurred in front of around 100 people.

3) Teens were chained for days and spent nights in outdoor dog cages.

4) In subfreezing temperatures, boys were not provided toilet paper, just snow, to clean themselves.

5) Both boys and girls have had their limbs broken in brutal "restraints," inflicted for violations as minor as looking at a member of the opposite sex.

There are hundreds of other equally egregious examples. Please, call your Congressperson and help put an end to this now! [It should go without saying -- but there is no evidence that these tactics help or are therapeutic for any kind of teenage misbehavior or mental illness].

Comments

[livesimply]

If there were adequate services to help these troubled teens who otherwise may be living on the streets and putting themselves in life-threatening situations, parents wouldn't feel compelled to use drastic resources. The only help available for these situations is the criminal justice system which aint all that great either. Unless a teen gets caught in crime, there is little to no help for these kids . Most of these "boot camps" are not nearly so abusive as you describe. Instead of rallying against what is, what don't you talk about how we CAN provide these services for our kids.

[Eggbeth]

Doing one does not prohibit the other. These young people need the protection under the law that our Bill of Rights guarantees them. The recipe for creating a sociopath is to take a troubled teen and brutalize him/her. Don't choose to do nothing because you can't do it all.

[devadasi]

livesimply, I think you make a good point. There are no easy answers here. It's true that many of these boot camps are not nearly as abusive as the writer insinuates. Many of these kids are out of control monsters. Their parents have no control over them. Most people have no business having children to begin with. Lack of resources, lack of emotional intelligence on the part of parents contribute to deliquency. I work as a teacher in the NYC public school system and I can tell you that most of these kids are being raised by parents who are totally dysfunctional.

[Grijpstra]

Corporal punishment for profit. This reeks of the Evangelical notion of progressive social activism.

[larry278]

The tough love oxymoron, again?
larry lynch

[Lorifromky]

I am curious - are any of these "programs" run by religious organizations? They seem to have elements of sadism, humilation, etc., that are often attributed to religious-run schools of by-gone years. In any case, they are shameful and they must be stopped.

[MajorKong]

I think quite a few, if not most, are run by religious organizations.

[bmora]

I thought assualt and battery was always illegal...

[dexxjones]

never doubt the creativity and determination of child molesters to set up new amusement parks for themselves. thats the underlying story here.