Huffpost Politics
THE BLOG

Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors

Majid Rafizadeh Headshot

Ayatollah Ali Khamenei: A Supreme Autocrat Not a Shia Messiah

Posted: Updated:

Although the media, policy analysts and politicians have been depicting Ayatollah Ali Khamenei as the man who has the final say in Iran, the man who wields ultimate power in the Islamic Republic, the Supreme Leader, a recent tactical shift in Ayatollah Khamenei's policies indicate that he has increasingly become less powerful or "Supreme" as the mainstream media reveals or as his title indicates. Ayatollah Khamenei totally distrusts any domestic institution, even the clergy. More specifically, he distrusts two categories: the Iranian population as well as foreign countries and powers including Arab and Western states.

In the last few months, Iran's Supreme Leader has been delivering speeches in contradiction, hypocrisy and double standards. In every other speech, he backs up one institution (executive branch, judiciary, Iran's Revolutionary Guards' Corps, Intelligence, Parliament or Majlis) and undermines others.

For example, when it comes to Iran's nuclear program, Ayatollah Khamenei points out that he supports President Hassan Rouhani's technocrat team to resolve Iran's nuclear problem by making temporary and short-time concessions. He famously called it "heroic flexibility" and insisted on a tactical shift stating, "A wrestler who sometimes shows flexibility because of technical reasons, should not forget his opponent nor about his main objective."

On the other hand, in his next speech he takes the side of the general of Revolutionary Guards, which reject any concessions and demand reaching nuclear breakaway capacity and ultimately obtaining access to nuclear weapons.

Velayate Faqih, The Supreme Leader's lifelong authority

The main question is, why are Khamenei's speeches filled with a multitude of inconsistencies and contradictions? Despite the fact that Ayatollah Khamenei attempts to depict a picture that he is a spiritual leader, a Shia messiah who represents a divine guide until Imam Mehdi returns, and an impartial figure in the political economy of the Islamic Republic, he has shown to be a shrewd, Machiavellian and autocratic politician.

After realizing that Western sanctions had hit Iran's economy hard, and endangered the survival of the Islamic Republic and his rule, Khamenei tactically and masterfully shifted his policies and reliance on some powerful institutions.

On the one hand, Ayatollah Khamenei is desperate to ensure the economic survival of the Islamic Republic and his grip on power. As a result, he began to support people such as former president Ali Akbar Hashemi Rafsanjani as well as the technocrat group of Rouhani, in order to obtain some sanction reliefs through temporary concessions.

Military Dictatorship and Authoritarianism

On the other hand, in order to appease the high generals and commanders of the IRGC, Khamenei backs their defiance in some speeches against any concessions and normalization of relations with the West, particularly the United States.

The fact is that Ayatollah Ali Khamenei is in need of the Revolutionary Guard in order to retain the consolidation of his power. The IRGC is crucial for cracking down on any domestic oppositions, pursuing Iran's hegemonic ambitions in the region by operating in countries such as Iraq and Syria and supporting proxies such as Hezbollah.

In other words, Khamenei is switching his support in every other speech from one institution to other, due to the fact that this necessitates his grip on power.

Modus Operandi of Ayatollah Ali Khamenei

Although Khamenei is transforming and watching how the Islamic Republic has rapidly turned into a military dictatorship by the evolution Iran's Revolutionary Guard Corps and intelligence -- the most powerful political and economic tools -- these institutions solely report to him and he regularly changes and handpicks the commanders.

He has masterfully used the tremendous oil revenues by saving billions of dollars in his assets such as Bonyad (which reportedly controls an estimated 33 percent - 40 percent of Iran's GDP), Setad (headquarters for executing the orders of the Imam, worth an estimate of 98 billion dollars and is considered as his economic empire), and spending the revenues on his jurisdiction, state-controlled religious institutions and foundations.

Khamenei has always tried to keep a low profile and hide behind the scenes by wielding power without holding himself accountable through the judiciary and executive branches, Iran's Revolutionary Guard Corps and Iran's parliament -- the Majlis.

Most of the commanders and members in the judiciary, intelligence and executive branches (as well as the IRGC, and Majlis), are either directly or indirectly handpicked by Khamenei, and remain loyal to him.

Although Ayatollah Khamenei is influenced by the aforementioned institutions, he mostly relies on the other recognized and unique bureaucratic group he created: the House, Bayt-e Rahbar, House of the Leader or Office of the Supreme Leader. Intriguingly, Khamenei avoids using clergy members as his advisors in the Bayt-e Rahbar, and depicts himself as the most knowledgeable figure in political, religious and economic affairs.

The moment that the Islamic Republic receives the required sanctions relief and when Khamenei can ensure that his rule and economic survival of his power are not in danger anymore, he will return to his traditional modus operandi -- relying on the House (office) of the Supreme Leader, ministry of intelligence, judiciary and Revolutionary Guard Corps.

Finally, it is crucial to point out that Khamenei's reliance on his handpicked commanders and members of Office of the Supreme Leader will create a resistance and gap between himself and the most powerful clergy members of Iran, particularly in city of Qum.

Majid Rafizadeh, an American scholar and political scientist, is president of the International American Council on the Middle East. He is originally from Islamic Republic of Iran and Syria.

This post first appeared on Al Arabiya.