Forgetting Our Biggest Special Interest: The American People
If you listened to CNN self-promote the YouTube debate on Wednesday night, it was going to be another "monumental" or "historic" moment where the voice of the people would be heard loud and clear on the campaign trail. Anderson Cooper and his team would push the candidates to answer tough questions from thousands of regular Americans that sent in videos on the issues that mattered most to them.
They claimed they wouldn't let special interests push questions. Apparently that doesn't include allowing questions from Grover Norquist's anti-tax group, and even Hillary Clinton's campaign. Just like at the Democratic debate in July, CNN again struck out by failing to listen to the most important special interest in our democracy--the American people.
The Wall Street Journal analyzed the first 3,000 questions submitted, and found that education was the most submitted topic. There were more questions submitted on education than those about health care, Iraq, foreign policy, and personal character. Americans understand that we have a crisis in education.
The media simply ignored the voices of the American people. The only quasi-education question concerned college tuition breaks for military members or illegal immigrants. How about addressing the fact that nationally one third of college students (civilian, military, ALL students) need to take remedial courses just so they can learn things they should have mastered in high school, and less than third of them will ever earn a degree?
Cooper chose a question asking if candidates really believe every word of the Bible. Fine, but a more fundamental concern is that kids won't even know how to read the Bible, given that about 70% of U.S. 8th graders are below the proficient level in reading. Yesterday's Washington Post reports more test results showing that American students are in a reading skills free-fall compared with other countries.
We can discuss crime and how to punish criminals, but CNN again missed the point. To reduce crime we've got to address the root cause. More than two-thirds of inmates in the nation's state and federal prisons and local jails are high school dropouts, and dropouts are more than eight times as likely to be in jail or prison as a high school graduate and nearly twenty times as likely as a college graduate.
Trying to address crime without improving education first is like fixing a leaky roof by putting a bucket on the floor to collect the water: it does nothing to stop it from dripping.
I have no problem with discussions of the economy, taxes, and federal spending. But our dropouts costs us $192 billion every year, and we could grow our economy [pdf] an additional $1.5 trillion over 30 years if we could raise our students' skill levels just to the level of average Europeans. It's ridiculous to talk about our economic future without mentioning education.
There was no shortage of quality, important questions on education, like the one submitted by Jonathan Mitchell, training director of a New Hampshire electrical union. He is pleading with the next president to improve our school system to produce students who have the skills necessary to take on high-wage, skilled jobs.
Momentum has been building on education in this election. More candidates have released substantive education plans, and the YouTube submissions indicate Americans want to hear from the rest of them. Before Wednesday night, we heard six education questions in just the three previous debates.
The media refusing to question Republican's on education in the most watched debate plays into the kind of patronizing, partisan stereotyping that hurts the political process by disregarding the will of the American people. The media often holds itself up as the guardians of truth and defenders of liberty, but if it wants to embrace such a high and mighty position, it cannot allow the next president to be timid on education.
Loading comments…
Want to reply to a comment? Hint: Click "Reply" at the bottom of the comment; after being approved your comment will appear directly underneath the comment you replied to
Marc, you were too polite to say it, so I'll say it for you: CNN's efforts to date on the so-called debates is patently and completely fraudulent.
As you point out, rather than pursue substantive questions, CNN has consistently attempted to push their usual, tired narrative of bare-knuckled slugfests and hot-button smackdowns.
Based on their performance, I'd be in favor of a Constitutional Amendment prohibiting CNN from covering any political issue ever again. Might as well include all the other MSM dimwits as well.
Another thought to add: I don't want politicians
to promise me money. I want them to uphold their
oath and take an honest effort to the table
to do things like clean up the national debt
and take on energy independence and stuff.
Cut the welfare crap, and let's really do
something here, so we're not a third-world
country that can't do anything at all in
the future.
I think a common problem today is that 'the government' is supposed to fix all these problems and stuff, if something's wrong,
you either call or blame 'the government'.
Well, got some news: If you're a US citizen,
either current or aspiring, you ARE 'the
government', at least part of it. You can't
just try to vote yourself money. Mark Twain
wrote about that. The People ARE 'the
government'.
That's why the voting process is so damn
important, and can't just be the means by
which career criminals and their hangers-on
seek public office to enrich themselves
(that's an extreme circumstance, but you
can see what I'm driving at). They gotta
keep the turnover high, that way nobody
gets all cushy and comfortable in there,
clears the air, and stuff. That's why we
have term limits, that's why we have
elections. But, when people start trying
to screw with our elections, specifically
people in OTHER COUNTRIES with LOTS OF
MONEY, then you see all sorts of interesting
stuff to happen.
Moral of the story? If you're going to call
yourself an american, first, pick a country,
then, stand up and be a citizen OF that
country. Don't just be a hapless puppet for
some sharpie sitting on a boat or on a sand
dune or whatever that feels like having a little
fun with the american political system.
There's one such rich dude in Mexico. They
don't get that way by accident..
really smart, and stuff. And, since the US
has the world's largest Con Me, you can bet
your last dollar that they ARE trying to play
poltix HERE, via proxy or via donation or
any means possible. Reform, the New Broom,
can sweep the problems OUT of our Congresser.
It doesn't have to hurt, but we do have to
start...an
standing there with their hands out etc.
More schools, more local manufacturing,
better representation, less excuses etc.
We 'can do'.
The whole goal of the process is to kill the voice of the American public.
Most campaign funding comes from the special interests to guarentee their influence.
Republicans and Democrats work for corporate America, as they are funded by them.
Our corrupt mass media is part of this web, and they constantly lie to the people to further their own causes.
If we had three or four parties in this country, our votes would get us a few chips to sit at the table. Now we have none. Our rigged fake two party system needs a third party to shake things up.
You must be logged in to comment. Log in or connect with
