EDITION: U.S.
 
CONNECT    

Marcia Reynolds

GET UPDATES FROM Marcia Reynolds
 

Alice in Wonderland: A New Look at Feminine Power

Posted: 3/17/10

I enjoyed Tim Burton's movie, Alice in Wonderland even though I realized from the first scene that the story line was manufactured for today's audience -- and to give Johnny Depp more air time of course!

What I found even more interesting than the 3D effects was the way the three female characters used their power. The Red Queen chopped the heads off of anyone who disagreed with her. The White Queen, due to her commitment to peace and the sanctity of life, could not defend herself. Alice had to learn how to claim her power, slay evil, be benevolent instead of brutish when the situation called for compassion and above all, take charge of her own life and destiny. The distinction in the uses of power is important to realize for all women, young and old.

The story line was similar to Monsters vs. Aliens where the lead character is a naïve girl who turns into a shrewd giant and realizes she doesn't have to kowtow to anyone, especially to her fiancé. It's clear that movie makers are depicting their female characters as smart and independent, at least in the cartoons. In Shrek, the ogre's wife Fiona and her friends, Snow White, Cinderella, and Sleeping Beauty, are no longer damsels in distress. They are smart, independent, and capable of drop-kicking the bad guys.

How is this shift playing out in society? According to the Bem Sex Role Inventory, an increasing number of college-age women demonstrate qualities that are traditionally used to define masculinity, such as being self-reliant, independent, able to defend one's beliefs, willing to take risks, and able to make decisions easily. However, these women also score high on traditionally feminine traits such as sociable, compassionate, understanding, and eager to work with others. The results demonstrate that women aren't becoming more like men. They are becoming stronger as women.

Kudos to the movie-makers for helping to facilitate this shift. So what's the bad news?

As if to make up for lost time, many girls are brought up not only to feel that they are strong and capable of achieving anything, but that they are exceptional and better than their peers. If they aren't the dragon slayer, something is wrong. Coloring books teach girls It's All About Me and We Are Special, making "special" the new ordinary. In school, to be worthy they have to find what they can master, whether it is academics, sports, the arts, or all three. Liz Funk describes the dilemma of today's schoolgirls in her book Supergirls Speak Out:Inside the Secret Crisis of Overachieving Girls. She says girls take on the challenge to be extraordinary with a vengeance, constantly pushing themselves to the breaking point. As they become adults, Supergirls take their crusade into the workplace, where they look to rise above the crowd quickly and consistently.

This shift has been going on for 50 years since the rise of the self-help era. We now have successful women in their 40's and 50's exhausted and asking, "Is this all there is?" One woman told me, "I've spent my life accomplishing one great thing after the other. Now I'm asking what I'm raising my hand for."

I believe it is good to help girls feel strong and independent. I coach women to fully step into their power and make life choices based on their passion and purpose. I love that Alice in Wonderland actually differentiates different types of feminine power so girls don't just see strong as physically tough or verbally demanding. However, we also need to help girls, and women, come to honor all aspects of themselves, even the parts that are not extraordinary. Isn't this authentic power?

In my upcoming book, Wander Woman, I define The Burden of Greatness that I see many women carry today. Fueled by a sense of power and freedom, they don't know when to stop. They go from achievement to achievement, looking for the Next Great Thing. Here are some of the symptoms:

• Taking on too many projects at once;
• Burning-out from taking on too much, or simply losing interest;
• Risking an addiction to work; making work the priority over family, friends and/or health;
• Restlessly searching for "something more," the work that will finally define their purpose.

The problem is that we have a hard time separating our work from our identity. When we equate our self with our accomplishments, we take ourselves too seriously. We have trouble asking for help and struggle with turning off our brains. In short, we are missing the beauty in our days and have trouble loving the imperfect parts of ourselves.

A friend once asked me, "Who is chasing you?" She saw me like a little hamster on a wheel with no end in sight.

With this awareness, I am taking steps to be softer with myself and to slow down to be more present in the glorious moments of my life. And obviously, I go to lots of movies! Do you have any suggestions to share? I would love for you to post what you do to cast off your burden of greatness.

 
 
 

Follow Marcia Reynolds on Twitter: www.twitter.com/MarciaReynolds

 
  • Comments
  • 14
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Recency  | 
Popularity
06:54 PM on 03/18/2010
Love the article!
03:48 PM on 03/18/2010
Liked this post, and the message of young women claiming their power. But there's another message too: when we're taught we can do anything and everything­, we can slay the dragon, and we can do it in our Jimmy Choos -- we end up falling down the rabbit hole of unlimited options and high expectatio­ns. Learning to navigate those is feminism's next chapter. More about this on today's post. http://und­ecidedtheb­ook.wordpr­ess.com/20­10/03/18/l­ife-accord­ing-to-ali­ce/
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Beka13
Obama 2012
02:28 PM on 03/18/2010
'Alice In Wonderland­' Stays No. 1, Crushes 'Green Zone'
Commented Mar 15, 2010 at 11:13:04 in Entertainm­ent
“Where is the Huffington Post article about Alice being the Anti-Disne­y Princess? I think this movie should be take your daughter to work required watching..­.It was wonderful.­”
__________­__________­__________­__________­__________­__________­_

Thank you for writing this article...­I think the message was just as important to men as women.
02:15 PM on 03/18/2010
Where it concerns achieving women I'll stay optimistic that the pendulum swing to the extreme is just temporary. Young women who've come into adulthood with a healthy balance of so-called traditiona­l male and female qualities but are in overdrive to succeed, need to be encouraged­, especially if they want to make their mark. Otherwise, we could see women regress and lose the gains they've claimed for themselves­.

It's as if the caged wild bird has just been let free -- it flies away fast and furiously at first, then settles down to its balanced routine.
12:28 PM on 03/18/2010
Thanks for the thought-pr­ovoking article. Perhaps the never ending search ends when we embrace the idea of our greatness right now in this moment - not at some point in the future when we have accomplish­ed something. It's shifting to the idea of loving that we are spirtual beings inhabiting a human form - and that in and of itself defines our greatness. How you choose to express that greatness takes on a whole new feel from this vantage point.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
FloridaLAW
This Day, This Moment, Right Now!
05:12 AM on 03/18/2010
and maybe it was just a movie. good grief!
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
Marcia Reynolds
Executive coach
01:41 PM on 03/18/2010
There a many classic psychology books written about the impact that fairy tales and stories we tell our children have on their lives as adults. Add the visuals of a movie and I believe the impact deepens. I have met Disney writers who take this phenomenon very seriously. Since the story of Alice was fabricated for the movie, making her much stronger than in the original books, I believe Burton was quite aware of the impact as well.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
FloridaLAW
This Day, This Moment, Right Now!
02:55 PM on 03/18/2010
You have a good point. Since you have a relationsh­ip with Disney I would be interested to know what your views are regarding the fact that it took Disney over 77 years to portray a black princess. Not to mention the fact that the black princess in the Princess and the Frog spent 95% of the movie as a FROG. What impact has that had on little black girls?
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Christine Maingard
Author of Think Less Be More
01:26 AM on 03/18/2010
Love your article Marcia.

Maybe in order to cast off the burden of greatness we should find a way to transform the burden into a privilege or an honour. We should and can show the world that greatness is not measured by who we are nor by forever doing and achieving more; it should be measured simply by BEING more. A new social movement, perhaps, led by wander women whose greatness will be defined one day by having had the courage to slow down and to simplify their lives in order to show the rest of the world that much of what is needed for a life of greatness can be found within.

Says Alice in Wonderland­: "I wonder if I've been changed in the night? Let me think. Was I the same when I woke up this morning? I almost think I can remember feeling a little different. But if I'm not the same, the next question is 'Who in the world am I?' Ah, that's the great puzzle!"

Dr Christine Maingard, Author of Think Less, Be More - http://www­.thinkless­bemore.com
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
Marcia Reynolds
Executive coach
01:37 PM on 03/18/2010
Sounds like you have the making of a new fairy tale to share. Even as adults, we love learning by stories as the best-selli­ng leadership tales demonstrat­e. Think about it Christine, that should be your next book!
06:40 PM on 03/17/2010
Hi Marcia,

great article. Know the feeling well. That hamster running on the wheel. Always someplace to get to whether it is developing the inside, or taking action in the outside world.

Learning to stop and appreciate the "enoughnes­s" of me now is such a challenge. (Not the "specialne­ss" in a narcissist­ic sense because that is such a trap of entitlemen­t as well as setting the stage for never being enough)

Keep up the great writing,

Christine
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
Marcia Reynolds
Executive coach
09:52 PM on 03/17/2010
I love the word "enoughnes­s." That's a sense I can aspire too. It's nice to know that the craziness we experience in life is useful informatio­n for someone else!
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
robbcoffee
05:33 PM on 03/17/2010
I think there's another element to that downside. Similarly to how the self-right­eous believe nothing they do is wrong, the girls raised on too superficia­l and consumeris­t a form of "girl power" believe nothing they do is subservien­t.
Taking a look at a lot of pop culture now... we're surrounded by sexual exploitati­on of women- nothing new.
Is what's different that they are doing it voluntaril­y? No. Not really.
It's the widespread belief that being a sex toy is another form of having power. They fail to see that "sex power" is a dependency on attractive­ness and youth to get what one wants from men... Instead they see it as power, and much of today's media hammer that message home (because for Corporate America, it is power).
Just look at the sudden mainstream­ness of stripper poles. Strippers and models, people who are essentiall­y career sex objects, are portrayed as images of freedom and power.
06:54 PM on 03/18/2010
That was a Great Comment.

And we young women who are trying to assert our independen­ce and power by NOT being sex objects and conforming to that particular sexy "ideal" are seen as less than. Or prudish.

Question: Women who are "essential­ly career sex objects" (as you say), while portrayed to have this image of freedom or power....a­re they TRULY respected by men? or by women?

I do think you can be a powerful and free BEAUTIFUL woman. We don't have to or need to downplay our looks. Even that aura of freedom and power can BE sexy. But using that sexiness to get what you want (additiona­l power and freedom)..­..by becoming a sex object....­Why do we women feel we have to do that? We don't.....­you don't want the WRONG kind of attention. There is SUCH a sense of power when someone treats you with respect and respects your opinions..­.and doesn't just lust at you. And there is SUCH a sense of freedom when someone looks at you impressed by your very being...th­e whole you...and not just by your looks

Respect (self and from others) leads to power....p­ower leads to freedom. And sex doesn't have to be involved in any of it.