iPhone app iPad app Android phone app Android tablet app More

Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Margie Omero

Margie Omero

GET UPDATES FROM Margie Omero

Buyers' Remorse Over New GOP Governors

Posted: 05/26/11 02:27 PM ET

Voters across the country have buyers' remorse about the Republicans they elected to office. The big stands House Republicans have taken so far--defunding Planned Parenthood, keeping tax breaks for the wealthy, nearly shutting down the government, and ending Medicare as we know--have all been wildly unpopular. Even with Republicans. In upstate New York this week, Democrat Kathy Hochul won by running a campaign focused on the Republican Medicare plan. Seeing the writing on the wall, the next day five Senate Republicans defected and voted against it. And don't even get me started about the paucity of the GOP presidential field despite the 2010 "shellacking."

But it's not just candidates and insiders who are sensing voters' dismay with how things are going. Polls show voters in battleground states regret having voted for their new Republican Governors. Since February, Democratic firm PPP released surveys in eight states asking voters "if you could do last fall's election for Governor over again, how would you vote?" In seven of the eight, the Democrat now would win, with all seven showing double-digit improvements in their margin. (Only Rory Reid in Nevada still trails.) The chart below shows both the actual 2010 margin and the new margin, sorted by the shift.

2011-05-26-margieomero-image002.gif

Beneath the surface, these Republicans are losing ground with independents. Nationally in 2010, independents gave Republicans a +19 advantage. In the five states above for which we have exit poll data (FL, IA, OH, PA, WI), the Republican won among independents. Yet in six of these eight re-do polls, independents now say they would vote for the Democrat.

While there are no Senate re-do polls, there is likely some buyers' remorse in Wisconsin for the state's new Republican Governor and Senator. Not only do voters say they would now vote for Democrat Tom Barrett, just half (50%) support recalling Governor Scott Walker (47% oppose). Former Senator Feingold actually does better in a future matchup against Walker (+10) than does Barrett (+7), and Feingold now has a wide lead (+12) in a potential matchup against then-Congressman Mark Neumann, after besting him by three points in 1998.

No doubt Democrats will face some challenges next fall. But in just a few short months, Republicans have alienated the voters who just brought them sweeping victories. Once again, Republicans mistakenly believed they would be greeted with sweets and flowers. Instead of "yes we can" voters are saying "we did what?!"

UPDATE 5/27: This Maine survey by Critical Insights suggests some buyers' remorse of Governor Paul LePage. A quarter (24%) would change their vote if they "had the opportunity to vote again;" nearly half (45%) of those would vote for independent Eliot Cutler, along with 15% for Democrat Libby Mitchell. Only 4% of vote-changers would change their vote to the guy who actually won. Unfortunately, the publicly released data have the vote among those wouldn't change their minds, and calls to Critical Insights went unreturned. But since LePage's 2010 margin was just under 2 points, I think we can add Mainers to the remorseful list.

 

Follow Margie Omero on Twitter: www.twitter.com/MargieOmero

Voters across the country have buyers' remorse about the Republicans they elected to office. The big stands House Republicans have taken so far--defunding Planned Parenthood, keeping tax breaks for th...
Voters across the country have buyers' remorse about the Republicans they elected to office. The big stands House Republicans have taken so far--defunding Planned Parenthood, keeping tax breaks for th...
 
 
  • Comments
  • 29
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
11:33 PM on 07/20/2011
oh well, the country got snow balled by the repubs as usual...wake up...the repubs have always operated that way...lie, lie lie....oh well you got what you voted for. Good luck with that.
07:38 PM on 06/26/2011
I voted for Scott and am very happy with him so far. Drug test for people on assistance. YES
State workers sharing in the pension cost. YES
Drug test for state workers. YES
Friendlier business environment. YES
Drilling for oil. YES
What has he done wrong? Hopefully he makes our state grow and reduces taxes.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
04:06 AM on 07/16/2011
You voted for Scott? Congratulations on being part of the 27% that approves of this fraud. Drug testing welfare recipients and state workers is unconstitutional and will cost the state millions in lawyers fees. Giving tax breaks to corporations that are offset by the amount that public employees pay for into pensions equates to having those who can least afford less take home pay being shifted to those who don't need it and are using that money to oad their wallets, not hire.

What has he done wrong? The biggest thing so far is hire lawyers to fight the redistricting amendment that was overwhelmingingly approved by the voters. But the crook is doing a great job, all right--at helping Dems get a foothold in the Rep controlled state legislature and guaranteeing the state of Florida votes Dem in 2012. If you don't believe he is doing a great job, just wait for his robo call, or better yet, ask his mother!
foreverdemocrat
Change is inevitable...
05:47 PM on 06/12/2011
This is not AT ALL shocking. Republicans are masterful at the politics of 'fear', and then, once elected, commence to enacting their radical, overreaching agenda.

Why the common man continues to VOTE AGAINST HER/HER OWN INTERESTS completely, and I mean, toally, shocks me.

"Hey, I hate Obama, so I'll take a chance at having my Medicare eradicated! Please, and thank you, very much, GOP!"
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Norcal2
Rimmon Diplomacy
07:42 PM on 06/14/2011
It's the social issues...if you can rally a whole mob against those "others", you can pretty much get them to do anything.

The "others" use to be communists, now they are gays and lesbians.

The only problem is that gays and lesbians are outsmarting them.
01:17 AM on 06/05/2011
we realy need to address the unconstitutional retirement funds paid to politicians and their private insurance accounts. look at all the money we could put toward the deficit if they were on the ssi and medical we are forced to be on. these people should all be voted out Repub or dems .and go back to our constitution that congres will pass no laws that they are exempt from. Term limits for the pres. and govenors. why not congress and senate.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Danilo Gurovich
Software Technologist and Motorcycle Blogger
12:28 AM on 06/01/2011
No refunds on damaged goods.
photo
talkmedown
End the insanity - PoliticalFinanceReform.org
08:21 PM on 05/30/2011
It's not nice to implement un-campaigned on policy. Anyone voting Repub gets what they deserve, like FL.!
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
10:25 AM on 06/17/2011
They do, but there are also a lot of people who didn't vote for him that live in Florida.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
brokerallen
The Middle Class Needs To Take Back America
12:15 AM on 05/29/2011
The GOP's mandate, as they call it, wasn't from the people who voted for them. The average middle class Republican who voted for them didn't want to have their retirement age raised by 5 to 10 years with less benefit. They surely didn't want to have a cheap voucher system replace medicare. They weren't thinking about the additional tax cuts for the rich which adversely effects almost everything else that makes America great. The heck with public safety and education and infrastructure. Phooey!
I think they campaigned on jobs. I think they must have forgotten.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
truly moderate
Paleo-conservative and Anti-tea party
05:41 AM on 06/04/2011
ill bet traditional republican voters (as a whole) will think twice before pulling the voting booth lever next time.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
shoshannadailey
08:42 PM on 05/27/2011
If you want to help the recall effort in Michigan, please go to the Facebook page: "Recall Governor Rick Snyder". Over 19 thousand "likes" so far.

If you live in Michigan and are looking for a signing event in your area, go to the "discussions" page on the left hand side, look for the counties list and click on to your county. best/S
02:50 AM on 05/27/2011
Most of these states have experienced deep budget cuts due to the slow economy and the public is upset about this. It's just wishful thinking on the public's part to think things would've been different if they voted for the dems.
rogergoldkin
If you think education is expensive, try ignorance
08:12 AM on 05/27/2011
I disagree! I don't Strickland would have proposed anything like SB5 or the sale of public assets.
11:29 AM on 05/27/2011
Strickland was a nice guy, but most Ohioans have quickly forgotten that he never attempted to do much about the high unemployment rate. SB5 will help in getting the budget under control and will make Ohio a more business friendly state which is sorely needed.
photo
HUFFPOST PUNDIT
TheRevV
My micro-bio is microbial.
12:06 PM on 05/27/2011
You're not from Michigan are you/ You know, the state whose governor overthrew local democracy itself. No, that's not exaggeration.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
ladywing
I get on my knees and pray I dont get fooled again
07:13 PM on 05/30/2011
the Governor of Michigan is an out law
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
10:32 PM on 05/26/2011
This is just want PPP wants you to believe. They are simply shifting the poll demos towards an election year from a mid-term demo and saying its buyers remorse. I'm sure these GOP govs lost some support, but I doubt its anywhere near the amount PPP says it is.
09:22 AM on 05/27/2011
I'm playing you a sad song on the world's smallest violin Field

lol

The polls show that their unpopularity will help the Dems in 2012
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Myriah007
Say whaaaaaaat!?
06:56 PM on 05/26/2011
They wanted him there in the first place, and voted him in so I don't know why they're so mad/upset now...ohhhh I see----Things just didn't work out as planned, or should I say as PROMISSED
photo
K August
Research Alec Exposed
09:20 PM on 05/26/2011
If the Republican Gov's had been honest in stating their agenda (slash everything their people need and give the rich more tax breaks) I doubt they'd have been elected.
They were dishonest. That's why the polls are showing that the voters are NOT happy with their secret agendas.
10:33 PM on 05/28/2011
would obama have been elected if he would have campaigned on the truth? keep Gitmo open, expand the war in afghanistan, continue with the bush policy in Iraq, start a new war in Libya, keep the bush tax cuts in place etc....