More

Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Marian Wright Edelman

GET UPDATES FROM Marian Wright Edelman
 

When Working Hard Is Still Working Poor

Posted: 10/18/11 05:53 PM ET

Recently Federal Reserve Chairman, Ben Bernanke, stated what most of us know, long-term unemployment is a national crisis. Our slowly recovering economy is not producing enough jobs and the number of poor children and families continues to grow. Many poor families have at least one working parent but can’t keep their heads above water and their children above poverty.

The Children’s Defense Fund asked reporter Julia Cass to visit families across the country like the Harper family of Columbus, Ohio, to see how children were being affected by economic downturn. Sixteen-year-old Haleigh said her biggest concern over the last few months has been “not knowing what the next day is going to bring. It’s not knowing like whether we’re going to have …” her sister Lindsey, 14, finished the sentence: “Food in the house”. The girls’ mother lost her job, and although their father is still working hard, he’s making less than he used to, and his hours have just been cut back. The family’s home is in foreclosure, and recently they were accepted for food stamps. The Harpers have just joined the growing numbers of America’s working poor.

New faces of poverty in Columbus, Ohio–Haleigh Harper, 16, and her sister Lindsey Harper, 14, have more than grades and boys to worry about. Haleigh said her biggest concern is, “Not knowing what the next day is going to bring. It’s not knowing like whether we’re going to have…” Lindsey finished the sentence: “Food in the house. With money being tight, there were times we didn’t have a lot of food in the house but we always found some way to get it like borrow money from family. But now we have food stamps; we recently got accepted for food stamps.” Their mother lost her job, their father is making less than he used to, and their home is in foreclosure.

According to Cass, “For almost two decades, their parents, Sandy and Walter Harper, have inched towards middle class – although at a pace of two steps forward and one or two steps back, because their best positions more often than not ended when the companies they worked for went out of business or sold out to other companies. The Harpers’ hard work has not enabled them to consistently provide their daughters with safety or security. After nearly 20 years of labor, they’ve had to call on the safety net to put food on the table and to get medical insurance for Haleigh and Lindsey. ‘I am terrified for my girls’ future,’ Walter said. ‘Something seriously has to be done because people can’t survive anymore.’”

Walter and Sandy both had good jobs in 2009.“In a very brief period Sandy calls ‘the golden age,’ they bought a home – the first they’d ever owned. ‘It was something we’d always dreamed about and planned on,’ Walter said. They looked at foreclosed homes that didn’t need too much work and selected a small three-bedroom in a lower middle class neighborhood.” But as both parents’ companies went through restructurings, closings, and layoffs, within a year they fell behind in their mortgage payments. Sandy’s last job was working at the catalogue call center of a small woman’s sports clothing company that was bought by Gap. But last February, “Sandy stopped working when she broke her hand. She needed surgery and received short-term disability payments. She was supposed to call into Gap regularly but didn’t receive the notice specifying that requirement until too late and was fired as a ‘no call, no show’ . . . Now Sandy has ‘the job of looking for a job,’ as she put it.”

Walter had been earning $1,000 a week installing movie rental kiosks until his company went out of business. His old employer gave him a job installing marble and granite countertops—at $13 an hour, no benefits. But then in September, Walter’s hours were cut back, and the family fell below the official poverty guideline of $22,350 for a family of four - the latest setback in a year of setbacks. Walter’s still on the lookout for better paying work. “‘I was offered a job at $15 an hour, but it was seven days a week. I said I needed Sundays for church and family.’ The Harpers are very active in their church. Sandy runs the youth group, which includes Haleigh and Lindsey. Walter helps feed the homeless on Friday nights. All four volunteer at a soup kitchen. Occasionally, they’ve taken in homeless teenagers. ‘We’re the kind of family that helps others,’ Haleigh said.”

Where is the help for them? Cass notes the family is currently trying to save their home through a federal program called Hardest Hit, created by the Obama Administration to help families dealing with a loss of income avoid foreclosure. They’re stuck in a loop of paperwork requirements. They’ve been able to get Medicaid for Haleigh and Lindsey, though Walter and Sandy still have no health insurance. Now the same cycle that’s taken away the girls’ security for today is starting to eat at their hopes for tomorrow. Cass says, “The girls have not given up on the future, but their outlook has been tempered by the uncertainties they’ve experienced. This fall, Haleigh attends her regular high school for a half day and a career-oriented school the other half day to study surgical tech. She wants to become a surgeon. She’s heard that Ohio State has a good medical school but that it’s expensive. ‘One of my goals in life is to be able to help my parents – if they need money, to be like, “Hey, I got some.” But I don’t know. You’ve got to be realistic.’” The Harpers have become one more American family faced with vanishing dreams.

Marian Wright Edelman is President of the Children's Defense Fund and its Action Council whose Leave No Child Behind® mission is to ensure every child a Healthy Start, a Head Start, a Fair Start, a Safe Start and a Moral Start in life and successful passage to adulthood with the help of caring families and communities. For more information go to www.childrensdefense.org.

 

Follow Marian Wright Edelman on Twitter: www.twitter.com/ChildDefender

 
 
  • Comments
  • 337
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Highlights
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2 3 4 5  Next ›  Last »  (5 total)
02:40 PM on 10/20/2011
Have the social darwinists chimed in yet to say that children are poor because they want to be poor?
05:17 PM on 10/19/2011
My dad making $7000/yr working for a low paying insurance company in the 60's and 70's raised a family, built a house, took a vacation, had a boat, a snowmobile, and sent us to school on one salary.
Rather than gaining twice the wealth, ever since both parents have entered the workforce due to more women getting higher education and wanting to rightly have their own careers, standard of living has dropped, prices have doubled and tripled on goods. The average house that once cost double the average annual salary of a single middle class person, now has quadrupled or more.

The result is that no average family today can survive on one person working. What happened? Business figured out they could charge double or more for everything since two people were now working and reap the profits.
09:46 PM on 10/19/2011
great one
02:52 PM on 10/19/2011
I went to m0nster and there are over 1,000 job listings within a 30 mile radius of Columbus.

Obviously there are a bunch of jobs requiring many years of specific experience, but look at the requirements listed here, and tell me how many people YOU know who would qualify (just about everybody over 25 without a criminal record):

Good oral and written communication skills, and strong interpersonal and conflict resolution skills
Basic business math and accounting skills, and strong analytical/decision-making skills
Basic personal computer literacy
High School diploma (College or university Degree a plus!)
1+ years supervisory experience in a complex food service or retail environment, including Profit & Loss responsibility
01:59 PM on 10/19/2011
Honestly,
You have to wonder if divorce wasn't a planned, government inspired scheme to get Americans to buy two of everything. If people are divorced, they need two households,two or more cars, two dishwashers, two refrigerators, two or more television sets, two dogs, two cats etc.and so on ad nauseum. Consumerism is king and what better way to sell more than by promoting divorce. It's brilliant!
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
cj7874
The truth will be drowned in a sea of irrevelance
03:25 PM on 10/19/2011
Interesting.
12:57 PM on 10/19/2011
While I like others here agree that he had no business turning down the $15 an hour job, the need to work seven days a week brings us closer and closer to many less developed countries. Go to South America. There are the few wealthy enjoying life, maybe a small middle class around major city centers but mostly the working poor. The working poor basically work everyday of their life to just get by and forget about benefits.

The American Dream of a M-F job has sadly turned into the American Nightmare of a seven day workweek that just barely allows you to survive.
photo
Angrykitteh
You're on double secret probation....
02:28 PM on 10/19/2011
I recently interviewed for a job that had a "required" 60 hr work week. They did not allow personal calls of any kind and PTO was frowned upon. Not a biggie for me. My kids are grown and I'm single.

However, I thought about people with kids. How would they check to see if their child got home from school OK? Make doctor appointments? Go to doctor appointments? Etc, etc.

I never got the job and was actually relieved as I would of had to make myself take it if te jjob was offered.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
cj7874
The truth will be drowned in a sea of irrevelance
03:26 PM on 10/19/2011
It also doesn't make sense that he has to work 7 days when he doesnt want to but there are other unemployed out there that cant find other work.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Rwin Hopkins
12:36 PM on 10/19/2011
who turns down 15 bucks an hour especially in ohio that's degree rate here. obviously they weren't going to work 7 days a week 365 who can afford that overtime. and even is they did give me that i'll take it can i get a hook up? i have plenty of construction experience and an associate degree that's good money.
09:49 PM on 10/19/2011
very well said
12:21 PM on 10/19/2011
Can you email this article to Herman Cain?
photo
HUFFPOST COMMUNITY MODERATOR
WasteNJ
All Out Of Bubble Gum.
12:14 PM on 10/19/2011
The ranks of the poor are increasing worldwide, thanks to the systematic destruction of the middle class, but when I read a story like this, I find myself asking what the story is. This had been my reality throughout childhood and had always been a fact of life, something just around the corner if you weren't careful.

I grew up in a working poor household, never lived in a house, drank powdered milk and ate government cheese and MRE's as meals. It was the late 70's/80's, both parents worked, Pops had two jobs and still we just scraped by.

I don't see how one can be in this position and somehow not work hard, if you don't you're out on the streets.
Riven
Honi soit qui mal y pense.
11:49 AM on 10/19/2011
I get angry when I hear people say the 1% are wealthy because they worked hard. The vast majority of the other 99% are extremely hard--and smart--workers, too (teachers, for example). Hard work is not equally rewarded in the U.S., and workers who contribute the most are not necessarily workers who are paid the most.
12:39 PM on 10/19/2011
I'm not sure there is any valid way to study it, but I have the sneaking suspicion that, in more than half of all instances of wealth, the accumulator of that wealth did so by lying, cheating, or outright stealing, at least at just the right moment to gain their advantage, thus allowing the accumulation of their fortune. I'm not talking about constant criminal behavior, I'm talking about an enabing dishonest or unethical act or series of acts.

Just as an example, I grew up across the road from a guy who farmed. He and his brother also owned a huge tobacco warehouse in our hometown.

The story was that, when the tobacco alotments were established in the depths of the Depression to smooth the flow of tobacco into the market (yes, a government-run tobacco cartel, in effect), he and his brother gamed the system. They planted all the tobacco they could, got busted for growing way over the limit, paid the fine, and made out like....well...bandits.

Then they used the proceeds to build their warehouse empire.

I have a sneaking suspicion that a majority of fortunes could be traced back to enabing, unethical behavior, if it were possible to see the truth about what really happened.

It is so pervasive and so obvious in so much business behavior, that I don't really have much respect for people (or corporations) with big wads of money; I always wonder whom they cheated to get it.
02:22 PM on 10/19/2011
My money says that they cheated us the consumers, followed closely by their investors.
Riven
Honi soit qui mal y pense.
11:32 AM on 10/20/2011
@huff reader: I have a sneaking suspicion that your sneaking suspicion may be right. Judging from the replies your comment generated, I am not alone.

One case I am familiar with concerns chicken farmers in Louisiana, where everything is under water, under suspicion, or under indictment. Many years ago, most, if not all, of these farmers made huge fortunes by selling diseased birds for slaughter and bribing the inspectors to look the other way. You can imagine the problems the first honest inspector encountered when he tried to get the farmers to clean up their act. At length, he was successful, but he was afraid for himself and his family throughout the ordeal. I know this story because the man at the center of it later became a veterinarian for whom I worked.


Follow the big money long enough, and you're almost certain to find unethical behavior--from Fan #450.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
cj7874
The truth will be drowned in a sea of irrevelance
03:28 PM on 10/19/2011
So trued. Fanned.
Riven
Honi soit qui mal y pense.
01:44 AM on 10/20/2011
Many thanks--and back at you!
texasprogressive
A voice crying in the wilderness.
11:36 AM on 10/19/2011
We've got companies paying executives 300 to 400 times the lowest paid workers, then they have the nerve to blame "overregulation and excessive taxes" as the reason why they can't hire more workers. In the 1970s, the average executive made only 30 to 40 times the lowest paid worker and there was very little outsourcing then. It's corporate greed that's killing this country, not regulations and taxes.
04:10 PM on 10/19/2011
I'm curious if he republican congressmen in Ohio were among those to veto the legislation for bringing the jobs back to the this country and if they are supporting the jobs act...yes, these stories are heart wrenching, and every state has Americans with stories to tell. Are they going to continue to support republican congressmen who haven't done anything for middle class????
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
dewh
Driving Miss Crazy
10:43 AM on 10/20/2011
Great question
11:35 AM on 10/19/2011
Our economy has been on a slow but steady decline for the middle class for the past 40 years. Like the preverbial frog in boiling water, we just didn't notice on a day to day basis that we were being cooked for dinner.

If you are old enough to remember the 60's and 70's, a high school educated employee could make enough money to support a family, buy a house and car and maybe a vacation home and boat. To achieve that same standard of living today requires two earners per family with a college education or technical trade.

We need labor laws and tax policies that focus on re-building the middle class. Alas, all we get are arguments about who caused the horrible mess we are in. It was not one side or the other it was all of us; and, it will take all of us to right the ship. The first step to fixing any bad situation is to acknowledge there is a problem and to generate interest/enthusiasm to make the changes needed.

Either we are a nation that believes in and supports the middle class; or, we are just a casino where a few lucky ones get rich and the rest get to suffer.
04:20 PM on 10/19/2011
True...until people start voting in their best interest, I'm guessing there will be more of these stories. I'm guessing they are down on their luck and will continue to support republicans who certainly don't support unions, haven't created any legislation for creating jobs, continue to tank the economy...after all the republicans don't give a flip for you, unless you're the top 2%!!!
09:50 PM on 10/19/2011
well said
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
charleyvldm9
He thinks outside the box.
10:42 AM on 10/19/2011
Its not about howmuch you make,but howmuch you keep.American culture is based on consumerism, people just buy,buy, then shop until they drop,then use credit to spend more.They save nothing. Then wonder why am I so poor,Govt.pse help me.
10:25 AM on 10/19/2011
My heart goes out to this family and the others like them. I was surprised however that the $15/hour job was turned down due to "church and family obligations". Assuming a 40 hour work week, that's $600/week before taxes, even if you figure taxes and take home is $500 a week, that's $2,000 a month. I go to church myself but am sure God would understand if I had to work to feed my family.
photo
HUFFPOST COMMUNITY MODERATOR
WasteNJ
All Out Of Bubble Gum.
12:20 PM on 10/19/2011
"I was offered a job at $15 an hour, but it was seven days a week. I said I needed Sundays for church and family."

What a ridiculous decision, but no problem, the employer will hire somebody that really needs the job. If they are desperate and supporting kids, I don't know how somebody can be so irresponsible to turn down work, it's even more than the husband is making. Nothing wrong with being spiritual, but if you're making 22 grand a year with a family, choosing church over food is asinine and selfish.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
dewh
Driving Miss Crazy
10:45 AM on 10/20/2011
I don't really feel it's irresponsible because the man IS working, he's doing his best to provide for his family. Now, if he was unemployed and he turned it down...well that would just be silly, wouldn't it?
12:37 PM on 10/19/2011
Me too. I hate to hear his daughter saying that she needed to be realistic in the pursuit of her dream of being a doctor, and I hate that his has happened to them. But I too wondered why he made that decision. If you're having trouble feeding your family and keeping a roof over their heads, you do whatever you need to do to change that. God will forgive you for working on Sundays.
10:24 AM on 10/19/2011
I can work hard by washing dishes and scrubbing toilets my whole life and still be living in poverty. Therefore, it's not only about how hard you work...it's about working SMART.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
skylark
Tangled up in blue..
10:45 AM on 10/19/2011
However, low income workers can not pay for training/education that might qualify them for a better job. Taking out a loan brings on huge debt, and the Repugs want to end all grants and training for laid off workers. Class warfare?
04:22 PM on 10/19/2011
What you say is true...but why on earth would anyone vote for a republican????
09:52 PM on 10/19/2011
no most rail road have very high paying job and thry will train you for free
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
Social Construct
Go left, young man.
09:53 AM on 10/19/2011
The US has a strange division of folks. I wonder how many other nations, where a person working at least 40 hours a week but not earning a wage high enough to provide for an average family, calls them slackers?
12:51 PM on 10/19/2011
It is a fundamental breach of the so-called 'social contract'.

If you are not willing to pay people enough to live, then they have no reason to support the system (from which you accumulate your wealth).

This is simply unsustainable.

Sooner or later they will conclude that they have nothing to lose, then you will witness something more like the French Revolution than Occupy Wall Street.

"Let them eat USED cake!"

Yeah, that'll work. Just try it, and see what happens.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
Social Construct
Go left, young man.
06:35 PM on 10/19/2011
I agree. Further, I'd say that some of the greatest thinkers on the subject would agree, as well.
04:27 PM on 10/19/2011
Until people wake up and start voting for representation that supports middle class and jobs, these stories are commonplace...when they are in that voting booth are they pulling the lever for the same republican who created this mess...my guess is yes!