More

Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Mark Olmsted

Mark Olmsted

Posted: July 19, 2010 03:30 PM

The Evolution of Fascism -- Then and Now


2010-07-17-Evolution4.jpg

My late brother used to tell the story of asking in Sunday school whether we were descended from apes or Adam and Eve. The teacher (a nun) answered, "well, some people descended from Adam and Eve," and then, as she gestured to the only black kid in the class, "some people descended from apes." (Even at 9, my brother was shocked. So were my parents. No more Sunday school for him.)

I'm almost surprised I haven't heard this theory from creationists trying to fake a respect for science by acknowledging this as a possible explanation for the human fossil record. It would jibe with an ongoing strategy of selectively co-opting elements of the opposition, and in the course of so doing blatantly misappropriating and rewriting history. Glenn Beck tries to claim the mantle of Martin Luther King, as Rand Paul imagines that he would have marched on Selma. Opposite Day has been proclaimed across the land--even seemingly immutable mathematics are not safe, as Senators Kyl and McConnell insist that cutting taxes does not reduce revenue or increase the deficit.

Majority rule is a thing of the past: 41 senators hold the country hostage via a perpetual filibuster. Our mixed-race President is called a racist by the very people who hold posters depicting him as a witch doctor at all-white rallies. There are 5 job-seekers for every job opening, yet their unemployment benefits are somehow the cause of the deficit. BP offers 20 billion for the destruction of the gulf; and Obama is "shaking them down."

Up is down and down is up. On the right, the ability to accurately perceive reality has been compromised. Ideology has become pathology.

It's as if fear--of change, of dark skin, of foreign languages and poor people--has created a virus in the body politic. When an Alabama legislator with a confederate flag on his pick-up truck runs campaign commercials starring Abraham Lincoln, you know the virus rages unchecked.

A completely fictional narrative can take root as a functional reality. By 1939, a huge majority of Germans took as gospel truth a completely imagined Jewish conspiracy to control the world and persecute a totally invented "Aryan race." The mania took root in the last years of the Weimar Republic, nurtured by the upheaval of massive economic dislocation. Exhausted by the First World War, the rest of Europe offered no forceful counter-narrative. Even the moral indignation at German anti-Semitism led to a mere pittance in the number of Jewish emigrants accepted by attendees of the Evian conference of 1938. When talk is cheap, human life can be even cheaper.

The rise of the viral right here has fostered the same kind of fevered imaginings. The demonization of A.C.O.R.N. evokes the Protocols of the Elders of Zion. Fox's insistence that three--count 'em, three--"New Black Panthers" pose an imminent threat to white babies has the familiar ring of the accusation that Jews thirsted for the blood of Christian infants. Considering lists of the undocumented circulating in Utah cite the due dates of pregnant women, it would seem it's the brown babies who need to be afraid.

As the son of a woman who grew up under the occupation of France, I have always been fascinated by the Second World War. Volumes have been written asking how the German nation could have gone collectively mad--and there isn't an explanation that fully satisfies. All we really need to know is that mass hysteria can make for very nasty history.

I understand that our President prefers consensus to confrontation, but his fear of being cast as the "angry black man" is leaving a vacuum. Keith Olbermann does a mean Edward R. Murrow, but his ratings don't compete with those of Herrs Limbaugh or Beck. Only Obama, with his mastery of oratory and possession of the bully pulpit, can hope to give voice to a forceful narrative of uncompromising truth. He doesn't have to be hostile, just unrelenting.

Someone besides Joe Wilson needs to cry out: "You lie!" The time is now, before it's too little, too late.

 

Follow Mark Olmsted on Twitter: www.twitter.com/MarquisMarq

 
 
  • Comments
  • 55
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Bloggers
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2  Next ›  Last »  (2 total)
photo
Mover
Father, Husband, Ret 1SG
04:48 PM on 07/22/2010
Mark Olmsted at 05:11 PM on 7/20/2010 posted, "Neither you or the previous poster made any serious attempt to address or counter any of the contentions in the entry itself."

OK, I will oblige. Your writing is good, but the various areas to attempt to cover in it have little to do with each other and nothing to do with the title of the "entry".

For instance, the title, "The Evolution of Fascism, Then and Now", implies that you are going to reveal the differences, or the sameness, of then and now, but you do not. You list your knowledge of a few events, but do not connect them. Your Brother's Nun had exactly what to do with the rise of Nazism in the 1930's? Nothing? OK.

Then what did you intend to accomplish by implying that creationists are racists? And, I don't know that anyone has. "ongoing strategy of selectively co-opting elements of the opposition". More likely, people like Beck are selecting elements that the left have abandoned in favor of divisive rhetoric.

And no one is comparing Obama to a witch doctor at any rally, let alone your fictional "all white" rallies.
You are simply practicing more divisiveness in support of progressive ideas that have a long history of failure as a form of governance.

Mr. Breitbart has offered $100K to anyone who can provide video of racist slurs hurled at congressman as they went to vote on HCR. He still has his money.
01:12 AM on 07/22/2010
One further note - with the Bob Schieffer incident in the past week, and one or two other things, the Anti-American Fascist propaganda media are now openly asserting that they are the only legitimate sources of information, in a way I do not recall their having done before. We have just passed another very dangerous milestone.
01:03 AM on 07/22/2010
Thank you very much for this post, Mr. Olmsted. There are people who know what it is going on and we are calling it what it is - just in the past week or two I have seen a noticeable uptick in the proper name being put to what is around us. Thank you again for making your contribution.

One minor point I just noticed - I was reminded elsewhere that "monopoly of violence" is one of the primary factors defining a state. The current assertion by Anti-American Fascism that the Second Amendment includes a supposed "right to overthrow the government" - negating one of the foundations of our state - strikes at the very existence of the United States of America.

I had the misfortune of spending several months following Yahoo news, where the typical thread resembles what one imagines a KKK meeting is like. They are many people who intend the end of our nation, and they do appear to largely overlap with the baggers.

I am very grateful our President had the wisdom to keep the Patriot Act. I imagine he may have been able to anticipate what was coming.
08:37 PM on 07/21/2010
Thank you for your well-thought out, articulate posting.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
pecosdog
this sht writes itself
07:26 AM on 07/21/2010
Fox news is blatantly practicing bigotry and then whines when called on it and the Shirley Sherrod video is a prime example of their willful assault. They were trying to tar the NAACP in attendance of her speech and her as the prop by maliciously editing a video of her and leaving out the context of epiphany. They, through seannity and breitbart, said that the members in attendance did not know the context but where chuckling at the seemingly bigoted comments she was making, but they lied there as well, The video was not just chopped at the end, the beginning was chopped as well. Before she went into her "callous black woman dealing with whitey" speel, she prefaced it with a comment that left no room for doubt that this talk was about her epiphany on the the subject of race and how she had once harbored ill-thoughts on a person because of his skin color. Fox purposefully left that out. Just as they did with the hispanic ACORN worker who seemed to be going along with breitbarts crew, but was really just getting more information from the two clowns as he was about to call a relative who was a detective to blow the lid on their scheme. Fox news consistently lies in attempts to tarnish minorities and needs to be called on loudly now for it.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Ishmael1
A Man Born To Hang Ain't Gonna Die Of Drowning
07:16 AM on 07/21/2010
Didn't you know? It's A New Germany.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8E9X_AcpHbA

To quote the program,

"Most people think the Nazis a little absurd here, too obsessive there. But, perhaps, the time for thinking is over."
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
mark331blue
Left leaning independent
01:47 AM on 07/21/2010
"He doesn't have to be hostile, just unrelenting." And exactly when will this happen? He's long overdue and the November elections loom. Meanwhile, the small minded, self-defined by everything they hate and fear, infest the airwaves like vermin. Yes, it's time for the great conciliator to come out of his shell and start making waves.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
truthglow
12:03 AM on 07/21/2010
Obama no longer has "it" in him, I fear. It seems as if he is being blackmailed, or something. I wonder?
11:53 PM on 07/20/2010
This is a great piece of writing from Mark Olmsted.It captures perfectly, the feeling of falling down the rabbit hole that is American politics today.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
mark331blue
Left leaning independent
01:34 AM on 07/21/2010
Fanned.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
11:06 PM on 07/20/2010
Well, there is always this favored trick, as detailed by a well respected progressive who served with Carter and Clinton:
"Tainting the tea party movement with the charge of racism is proving to be an effective strategy for Democrats. There is no evidence that tea party adherents are any more racist than other Republicans, and indeed many other Americans. But getting them to spend their time purging their ranks and having candidates distance themselves should help Democrats win in November. Having one’s opponent rebut charges of racism is far better than discussing joblessness."
You are adding to the problem by calling the "viral right" Germans and racists.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
SimianNation
Progressive NOT Regressive
08:26 PM on 07/20/2010
Yes, yes, yes, and a loud yes! Can it be made any clearer?
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
mark331blue
Left leaning independent
01:35 AM on 07/21/2010
Not by anyone other than Obama.
02:03 PM on 07/20/2010
If it means we can carry on a reasonable debate, I'm willing to concede that rich people do not have the interests of poor people in mind. (Often they do, but that is beside the point). Every time a writer who is obviously much smarter than me (just ask him) paints large groups of people as rich, hateful racists, I wonder if he takes into account two things. First, there are plenty of poor people who would rather die than go on unemployment because they think it is embarassing and insulting that a working person needs a handout. Second, those same people don't want to pay for other people to get a free lunch. It is possible that opposition to some Marxist oasis is not race-based, but rather rooted in pride and can-do attitude. Your're a dime-a-dozen, Olmstead. What is a blogger, anyway? Go work in a tobacco patch for a day and then call somebody a racist.
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
Mark Olmsted
essayist, blogger, activist
04:56 PM on 07/20/2010
So someone who works their ass off for years, pays in thousands of dollars into their unemployment insurance, then draws on it because they are laid off is "getting a free lunch?" That's her money she's collecting. I supposed you'd rather she keep her pride and not feed her kids?.
On the other hand, some corporate CEO whose Daddy sent him to business school, who loses billions of dollars on market speculation, still gets paid 80 times what said laid-off worker was making. And you think he's the admirable, productive citizen?
He's the parasite, not the working stiff who applies for every single job she can. As for being a racist, I did not accuse rich people of that. I accuse the pundits at Fox News, frothing at the mouth, convincing working people that they are each other's enemy based on language and skin color when they are on the same side. If that makes me a Marxist, fine. (At least I've read him. Something we smarty-pants bloggers do. READ.)
What working in a tobacco patch has to do with the authority to determine racism is beyond me, but don't you worry. I've been to prison. I saw way up close all the hate we were supposed to feel toward each other. I didn't drink that kool-aid, but most did. And the most virulent brand of it always came from the other whites.
photo
TheCommons
I didn't quit. You just bored me.
07:34 PM on 07/20/2010
I don't know if the taxes for unemployment compensation are uniform by federal law or are otherwise levied the same in every state, but in my state to the best of my recollection those taxes have been paid by the employer exclusively. None of the money came from the employee's pay. While I can agree with you on some points and disagree with the other poster on some of his points, I think you may be in error with first paragraph. To be clear however, I do support taking these benefits when a person needs them and is eligible. And if I am wrong in my recollection, someone please correct me.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
mark331blue
Left leaning independent
01:36 AM on 07/21/2010
Fanned.
12:18 AM on 07/21/2010
Reasonably speaking, those people you note who "would rather die than go on unemployment," are just ignorant of what unemployment insurance really is. Would they refuse to collect a legitimate claim from their car insurance provider? Of course not. It’s the same emotionally charged, ideologically blinded thinking that leads many people to forget that Medicare IS government healthcare, or that Social Security has helped support virtually every grandma and grandpa born in the US in the preceeding 80 years. Hey everybody, Oma and Opa are communists!
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
mark331blue
Left leaning independent
01:37 AM on 07/21/2010
Fanned.
11:34 AM on 07/20/2010
^5!
photo
Mover
Father, Husband, Ret 1SG
08:41 PM on 07/19/2010
"Majority rule is a thing of the past: 41 senators hold the country hostage via a perpetual filibuster.

Ahhhh, It must be nice to have such a short memory. It was just 4 short years ago the the Democrat minority in the US Senate had a stranglehold on any meaningful legislation. I've read where at least 4 times, Democrats stopped any changes to Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac. And as we all know now, these two Democrat babies were the pillars that the financial markets revolved around. Many investment firms and average Americans retirement accounts were all dependent on Fannie and Freddie. When they failed, the entire house of cards that Democrats built and Republicans were too wishywashy to stop, came tumbling down into the recession we have today.

Thank you Democrats and cowardly Republicans. We are now paying for your stupid self-serving and short-sighted money grabs.
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
Mark Olmsted
essayist, blogger, activist
09:42 PM on 07/19/2010
"Meaningful legislation?" Like Bush ever proposed anything beside war and tax cuts (oh sorry, Medicare Part D. Unpaid for and far more "socialist" than Obamacare.) The Republicans have used the filibuster well over twice as much as the most severe use of it when Democrats ran Congress. There is zero comparing in the degree of obstructionism. Bush didn't even have to use the veto for years because he could always depend on some Democratic votes.
The idea that there was any impetus for any financial reform under Bush is ludicrous. Trillions were shifted to the rich with his tax cuts while deficits ballooned with two unpaid wars. Fannie and Freddie Mae may have been part of the problem, but its the deregulation-mad casino capitalism that was clearly the source of the meltdown.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
RarianRakista
02:27 AM on 07/20/2010
That is what you get when you think the rapture is right around the corner, spend and no tax.
photo
HUFFPOST PUNDIT
InfernoTIE
I am a leaf on the wind...
04:28 PM on 07/20/2010
Fortunately (or,perhaps, unfortunately for you) there is a vast repository of C-SPAN videos that prove you wrong. Maxine Water's loving portrayal of Franklin Raines comes to mind, as does Barney Frank spouting (spewing) that Fannie and Freddie are rock solid (less than a year before they collapsed). Dang those video tapes. How can I make people believe stuff that ain't true now?
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
TS
I prefer to think of my micro-bio as half full
07:15 PM on 07/20/2010
Check the number of times this tactic has been used and compare the democratic congressional use of this tactic under Bush to the current use of it by the GOP. It's use has more than doubled in a very short time period. Trying to make the financial meltdown which was caused primarily by investment in worthless derivatives where no real value was created that benefited the few over the short term and screwed the rest of us into something centered around Fannie and Freddie is a joke.

I don't think much of either major party, or the libertarians either for that matter, but you seem to be rewriting history in claiming the financial markets revolved around Fannie and Freddie.I also don't think you are wholly accurate in suggesting the democrats would allow no change to Fannie and Freddie. You're also ignoring what those changes were, which is more than a little piece of the issue.
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
Mark Olmsted
essayist, blogger, activist
08:00 PM on 07/19/2010
I disagree. Fox won't cover it but his Saturday calling out of the Republicans got plenty of MSM play, and he can call a news conference anytime. I feel like most of the time, he pulls his punches. Which would be fine if his forbearance had gotten him any traction with the opposition, but it hasn't.