One year ago today, blogger Ian Murphy of the Buffalo Beast pranked Wisconsin Gov. Scott Walker by posing as billionaire David Koch on a phone call. As the crowds at the Capitol protesting Walker's bill to end collective bargaining were increasing in size and volume, the fake Koch inquired how Walker's efforts to "crush that union" were going. Walker's fawning response helped rocket the Wisconsin protests into the national media limelight.
Now the real David Koch reveals that crushing unions is indeed at the top of his agenda. In an interview with the Palm Beach Post, Koch talks about Walker, unions and the historical importance of the Wisconsin recall fight.
"We have spent a lot of money in Wisconsin. We are going to spend more."
Koch didn't know that when he sat down with Palm Beach Post reporter Stacey Singer that he was talking to a native Wisconsinite and University of Wisconsin graduate, who follows state politics closely. Singer knows that residents filed over one million signatures to recall Walker (almost half of the people who voted in the last statewide election) and that a spring recall election is likely.
Although the interview was slated to be about Koch's charitable efforts to cure cancer, Singer got in a few questions about Wisconsin. Koch acknowledged working hard on behalf of Walker. "We're helping him, as we should. We've gotten pretty good at this over the years," he says. "We've spent a lot of money in Wisconsin. We're going to spend more."
Koch may be referring to the efforts of AFP, his Americans for Prosperity Foundation, a 501(c)(3) "charitable" organization, which is up on air with another $700,000 TV ad-buy in defense of Walker and his budget. While most Americans understand fighting cancer as a "charitable" activity, it is harder to see AFP's political ads as a charitable endeavor deserving of tax-exempt status.
But Koch may also be referring to expenditures we don't yet know about. "If Koch is willing to spend $700,000 on issue ads, there is no telling how much he will spend to directly aid Walker when the recall is scheduled," warns Wisconsin Common Cause Director Jay Heck.
"There Will Be No Stopping Union Power"
While Walker consistently described his efforts to extract concessions from public workers and make it harder for them to organize as a fiscal necessity, refreshingly, Koch abandons this spin. The fight in Wisconsin is about "stopping union power," says Koch.
"What Scott Walker is doing with the public unions in Wisconsin is critically important. He's an impressive guy and he's very courageous," Koch told the Palm Beach Post. "If the unions win the recall, there will be no stopping union power." The reporter adds: "As Koch speaks, he repeatedly uses the phrase 'union power' as though it's interchangeable with the word 'Bolshevik' -- a new red scare for a new century."
David appears to be channeling his dad Fred Koch, a founding member of the John Birch Society, who raved that the National Education Association was a communist group and that public-school books were filled with "communist propaganda." He even suspected President Eisenhower and spoke of the "pro-communist" Supreme Court.
In reality, a substantial portion of Wisconsin union members have had a tendency to vote Republican. Not anymore. "We are not going to let gays, guns and god divide us," said Joe Conway of the Madison Firefighter's Local 311 at a recent rally. Wisconsin police and fire stepped up in support of teachers, nurses and snowplow drivers, even though they were exempt from the Walker collective bargaining bill.
"It's Working!" Trumpets Koch-funded Ads as WI Jobs Numbers Tank
Walker's controversial budget gave $2.3 billion in tax breaks to corporations and the wealthy, while slashing $170 million from local governments and $1.6 billion from schools. Walker was elected on a promise to create 250,000 jobs in the state. Yet according to the most recent data, while the nation added 853,000 jobs over the last six months of 2011, Wisconsin lost 35,600 jobs. No other state lost that many jobs, and the downturn started in July, the month Walker's austerity budget kicked in.
Rather amusingly, the theme of AFP's latest ads is "It's Working!" The ads fail to mention the striking impact the budget has had on tanking state jobs numbers, nor do they mention teacher layoffs, increased class sizes, cutbacks in services or kids being kicked off their health care. Instead, AFP and the right-wing MacIver Institute have tried to convince voters that Walker ended collective bargaining "abuses" and saved the state money without any "mass layoffs."
Walker Cries Wolf
As Walker travels around the nation giving talks at Koch-funded institutions (the Texas Policy Foundation, Arizona's Goldwater Institute, Florida's James Madison Institute) followed by fundraisers, he complains ceaselessly about the "union ads" being run against him and the efforts of "out of state unions" to unseat him. He follows his speeches with high-dollar fundraisers that have netted $250,000 checks from out of state billionaires like Bob Perry of "swift boat" fame.
In reality, there are no union ads on TV in Wisconsin or any other ads critical of Walker, only pro-Walker ads from AFP and the Walker campaign. Walker has successfully raised $12 million with this gambit and has spent some $7 million on television already, but unions and independent expenditures groups have yet to spend a nickel on television. Given that six Walker aides and associates have been indicted in a wide-ranging being run out of the Milwaukee District Attorney's office, the lack of ads is surprising.
Federal Reserve Forecasts More Job Loss in Wisconsin
While the rest of the nation is on the uptick, Wisconsin's job loss is forecast to continue.
These predictions arise not from the Bolsheviks or the unions, but from the staid Philadelphia Federal Reserve. Economists there say "there is little prospect that such trends will reverse. Given the Contractionary policies implemented in the budget, this is no surprise."
In his conversation with the fake David Koch over a year ago, Walker said Wisconsin is "ground zero, no doubt about it." For once, Walker was right. Given the impact of his policies, to many observers Walker's recall election will be a bellwether on whether or not Americans will allow policymakers to force them to bear the blame and the brunt of the Wall Street financial crisis or if another view of Wisconsin's future will prevail.
Obviously the media is going to want to focus in on who’s spending the most in these recalls (and we’re sure to see a lot from BOTH sides if the previous state senate recalls are any indications), but the real story is where does Wisconsin, and America in general stand in regard to public unions. In a global economic market if we’re hamstrung by unreasonable contracts and collective bargaining, we’re all going to suffer. With states like Rhode Island on precipice of insolvency due to a lack of foresight regarding union compensation (http://nyti.ms/wn7HlE), how long does the country allow these problems to persist?
At the end of the day it’s not about who spends more, the Kochs or unions, but rather how sustainable an economy Wisconsin wants now, and into the future.
You do realize David Koch is one man, right? With his brother Charles, they are only TWO men. They are not citizens of Wisconsin.
However, Wisconsin's labor unions are comprised of thousands and thousands of Wisconsin citizens. These are the people who live, work, vote and pay taxes in Wisconsin. If you think they should butt out of our government's business, then you do not understand what it means to be an American. Because it is 100% American to be interested and involved in what our government is doing. It is our right and it is our responsibility.
David Koch should meddle in the politics of whatever state he lives in AND he should STOP meddling here. What he is doing with his money is unwanted and unacceptable. No single man should have that much sway.
Ultimately, the point I was trying to make was that we’re going to see a lot of money being spent on this election on both sides, and that a lot of it will come from out of state sources. It’s nothing new.
It’s one thing for unions to be involved in government, but it’s another to have a stranglehold over politicians. There’s a reason why Wisconsin’s pension system was a mess (http://bit.ly/oVovMT), and a reason why unions in the state were contributing next to nothing into pensions and health care. There was a systematic problem in the way compensation was created in the state, and ultimately it’s a problem that reaches far wider than just Wisconsin.
There has not been a Million people sign the petitions. There has been a million signatures, many are fraudulent, multiple signs and fictional. I have neighbors also, and they are mostly pro-Walker. Of course they are self made, functional people that do not have to rely on a union or the goverment dole to survive.
I will say this about the forces aligned against Walker in Wisconsin: they are people. They are more than the million people who signed a petition to recall Walker. They are my neighbors.
David Koch may spend his millions to protect Walker. Well, he can try to protect Walker from the million people who signed the recall petition. Because no matter how much Koch spends, he cannot change the minds of those who signed the petition. They cannot be bought.
And if his Americans for Prosperity PAC wants to waste its money at this time, I say go right ahead. In the end, it will be the usual grass roots ground game of ordinary non-billionaire citizens who"ll win the day. A union of us, the progressive people of Wisconsin, is strong enough to counter Koch's "charity" cash. I feel certain of that.
I believe Wisconsin will show America how to beat the billionaires. We've led the nation before, and we will again. We will go FORWARD from this.
In any case, labor unions REPRESENT people aka Wisconsin citizens. Whereas, David Koch represents only HIMSELF.
If you want to root for Goliath, go right ahead. Me, I stand with David aka the citizens of Wisconsin (aka my neighbors). Our state is not for sale. It is ours.