iPhone app iPad app Android phone app Android tablet app More

Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Mary Pritchard

GET UPDATES FROM Mary Pritchard
 

Are Today's Young Women Afraid To Lead?

Posted: 07/19/2012 8:46 am

A recent Forbes blog written by a 19-year-old college student raised an interesting issue: Women of the millennial generation are afraid to lead. Why? Because instead of hearing the "girl power" message that girls can do anything and be anything, this generation of women got the message that they had to do everything and be everything. And they had to do it perfectly... or not at all.

It's not surprising that so many women are choosing the latter option. Why even try to be a fearless leader if you're afraid of what people will be saying about you behind your back? Instead of empowering this generation of women, we've frightened them into inaction. This does not bode well for our society.

For generations, women like Susan B. Anthony, Margaret Sanger, and Gloria Steinem fought for women to have equal rights and hold positions of power. Yet fewer and fewer women are holding seats in Congress. Women comprise only 2 percent of Fortune 500 CEOs, 8 percent of top leadership positions, and 20 percent of college presidencies. If you were hoping the millennial generation was going to change that, think again.

But can you blame them? Look at the media's representation of today's women in power. Take the most recent presidential campaign. It seemed to me that the news media spent more time criticizing Sarah Palin's and Hillary Clinton's wardrobe choices than they did their political viewpoints. Did you hear moment-to-moment coverage of Barack Obama's suit selection? Of course not. But it seems that, for women, that kind of criticism is okay.

So is it any wonder that today's women are so afraid to be in positions of power? Not only do they have to be perfect, they have to look perfect. Men are simply not held to those dual standards. Caroline Heldman and her colleagues have argued that the media's focus on women's appearance may even be hindering women's abilities to obtain positions of power. Specifically addressing Elizabeth Dole's bid for the presidency in 1999, they criticized the media for treating Dole as if "she was a novelty in the race rather than a strong contender with a good chance of winning." Diana B. Carlin and Kelly L. Winfrey from the University of Kansas made a similar argument about the media's treatment of Clinton and Palin in the 2008 campaigns. "The analysis indicates that there was a considerable amount of negative coverage of both candidates and that such coverage has potential to cast doubt on a woman's suitability to be commander-in-chief or in the wings," they wrote.

What are we to do? How can we reassure future generations of women that they can and should hold positions of power, knowing that they will have to fight a media storm of sexism? By setting good examples. By doing things that scare us and letting our daughters watch us succeed. By being positive role models for tomorrow's women (and men). By owning up to our dreams and making them happen.

I encourage you to pick one area of your life that needs improvement -- something you've known needed to change, but that you have been too afraid to do anything about. Maybe you've always wanted to write a book. Or ask for a raise. Or lose 10 pounds. Or learn how to play the cello. It doesn't matter. Dream big and take small steps to make your dreams happen. Start today. Start now. After all, how can you honestly tell your kids that they can do anything or be anything they want to when you yourself have forgotten how to dream?

For more by Mary Pritchard, click here.

For more on becoming fearless, click here.

 

Follow Mary Pritchard on Twitter: www.twitter.com/Mary E Pritchar

FOLLOW HEALTHY LIVING
A recent Forbes blog written by a 19-year-old college student raised an interesting issue: Women of the millennial generation are afraid to lead. Why? Because instead of hearing the "girl power" messa...
A recent Forbes blog written by a 19-year-old college student raised an interesting issue: Women of the millennial generation are afraid to lead. Why? Because instead of hearing the "girl power" messa...
 
 
  • Comments
  • 138
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Bloggers
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2  Next ›  Last »  (2 total)
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
Mary Pritchard
10:05 AM on 07/30/2012
Thanks to everyone for their comments. I tried to respond to them in Part 2 of my blog on women and leadership: http://www.huffingtonpost.com/mary-pritchard/women-leadership_b_1699700.html
05:20 PM on 07/20/2012
Great piece! Goes along well with the Case Foundation's Be Fearless campaign. (www.CaseFoundation.org/befearless)
03:02 PM on 07/22/2012
Thanks, Jenna! Thanks for letting me know about the Case Foundation.
10:31 AM on 07/20/2012
Is it perhaps remotely possible that most American women simply don't pay two hoots to these third generation feminists crying 'the sky is falling' but, instead, have important work to do in their jobs, in their families, and their civic groups? Maybe they are more in touch with the thinking of Margaret Thatcher who, when asked about the importance of feminism to her success, replied "I am too busy to have time for that kind of nonsense theories."
08:39 AM on 07/20/2012
You need to start much younger. By the time women get to the workplace, many are too meek to even be considered for leadership roles.
03:05 PM on 07/22/2012
I agree wholeheartedly!
07:05 AM on 07/20/2012
From what I have witnessed woman in engineering quickly realize that moving forward down the career path is just a rigged game (for everyone). They realize that going into areas like project management or other areas is a far better career path. My point is that in the US today there is very little opportunity. And jobs like engineering are devalued inside large corporations. Instead we value people who actually produce nothing except meetings. So many woman move into project management. It has no responsibility but makes good money. Plenty of men make this jump too. But since there are fewer female engineers they thin out faster. That is what I see happening.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
MissTake1989
Equal means equal, hypocrites.
06:41 AM on 07/20/2012
Being a leader (theoretically) requires accountability.

Accountability is like sunlight to a vampire for many, many women.

Modern feminism has bred this in them.

But...leadership also requires self assurance...and well, leadership....

On a thread the other day about pornography...I saw a woman ask "my bf watches porn and I don't know if I SHOULD be jealous..."

SHOULD?

She wasn't wondering if she was or was not jealous...what she actually felt was irrelevant to her...she wanted to know what she SHOULD feel...
09:23 AM on 07/20/2012
Interesting comment... I was actively disagreeing with you until the second half about the woman asking what she "should" feel. I've often thought that women, myself included, tend to question every feeling we have. Healthy men are introspective up to a point, but they don't dwell on whether they have a right to feel or think in a particular way. I'd bet that the woman's bf in your example has no problem telling her that he enjoys pornography and that it's perfectly fine for him to do so.

Now, the real question is whether women's self doubt is a cultural phenomena or a biological one.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
MissTake1989
Equal means equal, hypocrites.
10:54 AM on 07/20/2012
I believe most things are culture rationalizing biology.

Insecurity holds back many very talented women.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
honky1234
Sweep the leg? But I'll be disqualified!
02:31 AM on 07/20/2012
"Not only do they have to be perfect, they have to look perfect. Men are simply not held to those dual standards."

Oh really? What about all the studies showing that tall men have significant advantages in life? Career advantages, relationship advantages. Men are judged on looks too, especially on physical characteristics that aren't easily changeable, such as height.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Yellowcab
100 % Cotton
02:21 AM on 07/20/2012
A leader is someone who leads even in the face of fear.

Facing certain death, facing bullets, facing crucifixion, facing execution, facing starvation, freezing to death, beatings and torture is what leaders have done through out the centuries.

Worrying about someone making fun of them or saying their butt is too big or their hair do is unflattering?

Are. You. Kidding. Me?

Sorry, there's no quotas, affirmative action or Title XYZ for leadership.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Walrus Man
09:57 PM on 07/19/2012
Yes.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Nic the wonder puppy
When life throws lemons, throw them back
06:12 PM on 07/19/2012
Remember, it's the leader who leads the pack
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
lisac3333
Farm Lady
05:41 PM on 07/19/2012
I would love to see more women in power as leaders. I think we let a lot of women down when we, as women do not support them when they attain positions of power. I was all set to vote for Hilary Clinton when she ran for president. What happened? Suddenly she was asked to step down for a man and did Obama even consider her for Vice President? No! Some man we knew little about was placed as Vice President. Hilary would have been excellent as president and I do believe she would have focused on the economy of this country first! We missed out on a good leader.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
MissTake1989
Equal means equal, hypocrites.
06:34 AM on 07/20/2012
If you knew little about Biden, it's because of your gyno-centric vision.

The man was a senator for 30 years.
12:09 PM on 07/20/2012
Funny that she considers Biden someone we knew little about. Compared to Sarah Palin...
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
rlj13
Torn between liberal and libertarian
05:10 PM on 07/19/2012
I totally agree. I also think the millenials (of which I am one) have had the rug pulled out from under us. We went into college 'knowing' that we could find alright jobs when we came out, even if we were not exceptional. This was not the case, and I don't think only women have been affected by this change in how the world regards us as young, smart, but average people. I have no ambition whatsoever. My boyfriend has only slightly more. We both used to, but at the same time we recognize that we can never compete.
09:33 PM on 07/19/2012
It's a tough world out there, for sure. I'm Gen X. I've been paddling upstream for what seems like forever now...and not getting that far. Don't think I can rack up more credentials, experiences, accolades, etc. So, I don't really blame you millenials for your attitude. We've been sold up the river for sure. Guess my only advice to those younger than me, like you, is truly focus on doing something you enjoy even if it pays jack squat. What have you got to lose, eh. Might as well enjoy.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
rlj13
Torn between liberal and libertarian
07:05 PM on 07/20/2012
To that end, I'm focused on enjoying my life and ignoring my job :)
09:28 AM on 07/20/2012
My husband and I are technically millenials (27 years old). If we hadn't had a child that we now must support, I would probably be right where you are. We've begun the slow process of succeeding in a horrible economy with huge student loans. At our low point, we were living in a junky apartment with no furniture, a new baby, and my husband was working on a factory line making greeting cards. I worked from home writing articles for dating sites. He has degrees in mathematics and chemistry. I have degrees in English and French with a minor in microbiology. Not exactly how we pictured things turning out...

We didn't give up and now we make over 100k/year. Quitting should only be an option when you're dead or too old to care. Good luck!
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
rlj13
Torn between liberal and libertarian
06:57 PM on 07/20/2012
Good job! You rule.
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
Mary Pritchard
05:40 PM on 07/22/2012
Good for you! Way to take life's lemons and make them into lemonade. :)
03:55 PM on 07/19/2012
"And they had to do it perfectly... or not at all." Boys and girls of my generation both got this message loud and clear, believe me. I do think it hit girls the hardest, since the powerful women in the public eye are so often subject to loud and unapologetically misogynistic attacks.

Boys at least had counterexamples to look up to. "So you don't get straight As. That's OK, Bill Gates dropped out of college!" And so on. 30 years ago, men who made mistakes or had flaws still had a chance to succeed. Women, not so much. Sadly, it hasn't changed as much as we like to think.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Yellowcab
100 % Cotton
01:16 AM on 07/20/2012
Being a leader means taking responsibility and accepting blame - not blaming others for your lack of leadership and responsibility.

Why step up and take the slings and arrows of leadership, when you can pull the strings behind the scenes and get what you want without the hassle of responsibility?

When things are wrong, we blame men. We blame men for war while enjoying the profit but not the duty. We blame men when we don't get paid more than they do, or don't get ahead like they do - while ignoring they put in over time to get ahead.

We recognize another woman is NOT going to give up her seat on a lifeboat to save ours, while a man will certainly force another man to do just that.

It's a nice, comfortable arrangement. Blame, complain and demand.

It's working out quite nicely.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
angry mom
03:52 PM on 07/19/2012
I keep reading articles about how young women today are overtaking men in almost all areas of college and business. I don't think most women think they have "to do everything and be everything. And they had to do it perfectly... or not at all." I think women have realized that they can't be everything to everybody, so they are going to decide what they want to be. It's the young men that seem to be slacking off. So many of them aren't even looking for work or going to college because its "too hard."
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Yellowcab
100 % Cotton
01:22 AM on 07/20/2012
It's "too hard" to compete with gender quotas, affirmative action and Title XYZs that favor others over you or suspend your constitutional due process rights.

It's "too hard" to accept that YOU are to blame for every thing that's wrong in life, and that you are responsible for things you have no control over.

It's "too hard" to be told you are slacking off and not even looking for work or going to college because of some magical thinking that your are "priviledged" when in fact, it's quite the opposite.
01:24 PM on 07/23/2012
It isn't slacking off. It's wising up.

Young men realize that the deck is stacked against them, so instead of killing themselves for the privilege of subsidizing their first wife's affair or dealing with rejection, they're just getting smart. They're not pushing for marriage and family any more, so there's no incentive for achievement (and since you do achieve, you're despised for it because, after all, "you're a man" ...).

Well, that's not quite true. A lot of dudes are looking overseas for sensible women without a lot of feminist dogma in their purses. Why go be some American woman's excuse for a divorce when there are millions of third world women with more traditional values who find green cards really sexy?

But American women? That's a high-risk assignment. Better to play videogames and watch porn than inflict that on yourself.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
03:51 PM on 07/19/2012
If "Girl Power" is going to help save this country, young ladies need to seek positions of integrity before seeking public office & power; otherwise, they will become just as corrupt as the men. For the most part, men are irresponsible, which is why they can't handle power. Even the Pope failed the integrity test in handling its child abuse scandal, even though he had the power to fix it.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Yellowcab
100 % Cotton
01:26 AM on 07/20/2012
Blaming men for everything that's wrong, while not accepting responsibility or blame for your own wrong doing isn't going to solve the problem, either.

"Even the Pope" had help from the Nuns who participated in covering up church scandals, or participating in scandals themselves.

If "girl power" is going to help save this country, young ladies need to learn to accept blame for their own short comings instead of always blaming men.

Women always have been as corrupt as men - more so if you figure they are the ones behind the scenes pulling the strings while men are out there doing their dirty work.
11:27 AM on 07/20/2012
Bravo! Quit playing the victim card, take ownership of your own life.