iPhone app iPad app Android phone app Android tablet app More

Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Maryam Zar

GET UPDATES FROM Maryam Zar
 

The Persian Conundrum

Posted: 12/27/2011 1:33 pm

With a Merry Christmas and a Happy Hanukkah to everyone who takes part in the Winter Holidays by virtue of a belief system that celebrates the season with joyful traditions of faith, family and friends, I must also make note of the Persian conundrum, in which I and my like-minded friends find ourselves. Each year at this time of gifts, merriment and lights, we find ourselves in the increasingly familiar predicament of assuaging our children's angst at not having a religion that takes part in the Holidays. You see, we are Persian (aka Iranian), and by virtue of not being either Jewish or Christian we are classified as "Muslim" -- though the classification could not be less fitting.

This year, while my family meanders our local Christmas tree farm for the perfect Fir or Spruce to adopt and adorn at home with a growing collection of ornaments that represent our family memories and history, they asked me once again why it is that we don't celebrate Christmas. Even though our home is decorated with holiday spirit each year, and we exchange gifts on Christmas morning following a family dinner that some member of our family will invariably host the night before, we do not mark the holiday with any religious undertone.

Similarly, on the first night of Hanukkah my children expect that I will conjure memories of childhood as a new immigrant, when my dearest friends would allow me to celebrate the Festival of Lights with their families. From that experience I have retained songs that move me to tears, to this day. I sing the songs for my children as though the tradition is my own, but alas, it is not. Even though my children know the story of the oil that burned for seven days and can sing the songs, they know they are not part of the religion that celebrates it. They are not Jewish. They are Muslim.

We are part of a growing community of Muslims from Iran that have embraced life outside of modern-day Iran in adopted countries where we lead unmistakably secular lives. Yet, we are labeled as Muslim, though we know little about the religion and celebrate no part of it. The most prominent celebration we mark as a community is Nowruz which marks the Persian new year and predates the introduction of Islam to the Persians. It is, not unlike Christmas and Hanukkah, a holiday that celebrates family, friends, forgiveness and the renewal of life. We similarly celebrate most other holidays that honor friendship, family, love and community in our adopted land. There is, however, no tradition in our lives that celebrates Islam. Yet we are labeled Muslim, simply by virtue of the fact that we are Persian and do not belong to one of the few minority religions that comprise the Iranian population.

Perhaps it is time to have a new minority classification: "the a-religious Persian," who takes pride in being Iranian and embraces all the achievements and accomplishments of our people in the vast Persian diaspora, which spans the globe in the aftermath of the Islamic revolution of 1979. We embrace the triumphs of Persian history including being one of the world's oldest continuous major civilizations, dating back to 4000 B.C., with historical settlements and urban centers that were some of the earliest civilizations on earth. We rejoice in the contributions of our ancestors to civilization and humanity, including algebra, human rights, the advent of paper, mail, wine, ice cream, tulips and the acoustic guitar, among others. But we do not embrace Islam as the cornerstone of our lives. Religious tradition does not permeate the fabric of our family, or guide our conduct. Instead, we choose to make our own traditions by embracing love and fairness, humanity and the ideals of doing onto others as you would have done to you.

There are many of us in the States and beyond. Our communities are well integrated into the fabric of our adopted homelands, and are made up of largely educated, accomplished, professionals engaged in the arts, sciences, medicine, academia, law, philanthropy, advocacy, policy, politics, journalism, literature, media and more. We are Muslim by classification, but not by tradition. Each winter holiday, we must defend our irregular practice to ourselves -- then gather the strength to elucidate it to our children and enlighten our friends who have the good-fortune of belonging to a faith in which they believe, with customs they can readily embrace and pass down to generations that come after them. In the end, we take incremental part in the mixture of rituals that comprise the Winter Holidays, and teach our children to respect all religions.

Happy Holidays to all faiths, and non-faiths.

 

Follow Maryam Zar on Twitter: www.twitter.com/womenfound

 
 
  • Comments
  • 15
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
01:23 PM on 12/28/2011
Labeled by whom? As far as I know, there's no document in the USA that requires you to identify with any religion.
01:15 PM on 12/28/2011
The survival of your self-identification as Persian is sufficient, and could be a source of pride for you. Whatever strategies you have adopted are valid and to be cherished. May you and your family continue and prosper.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
sandalwood
songs of the shamans...
10:33 AM on 12/28/2011
Hopefully, the Persian civilization will rise again, like the Indian and Chinese civilizations are doing right now.
photo
Jelle NL
Unity in Diversity
06:13 AM on 12/28/2011
The Persian Conundrum is the uncomfortable feeling that causes Iranian expats to call themselves "Persian". It is another word for shame.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
03:07 AM on 12/28/2011
Become a Unitarian. They welcome everyone.
02:35 AM on 12/28/2011
totally agree with Sand dude and SouthStJo. In my opinion this article doesn't make sense. If you don't like Islam well why don't you change your religion? or even you can become an atheist. It's your choice. But i don't think it is such a big deal.
photo
Jelle NL
Unity in Diversity
01:30 AM on 12/28/2011
Maryam-djan, Naw Ruz is "our" festival. Isn't that enough tradition? We have grown into pluralistic world citizens. And there is no reason to be sad about that.
01:26 AM on 12/28/2011
Maryam- Why don't you take a look at all religions and see they are similar and then consider yourself "spiritual" rather than religious.
08:55 PM on 12/27/2011
If its such a crucial issue, as I've seen that it is to many Persians whose families are of Muslim descent, and you choose not to identify with Islam in any way, why don't you propose to your community that you either convert to other faiths or philosophies, or choose to be atheists. Like it or not, the problem is that you continue to attach yourselves, albeit marginally, to Islam. Thus, people classify you as Muslims. If you choose not to be identified as such, then divorce yourselves from Islam. I've known many a Persians who come from a similar background as you, and very few have been able to move on. I happen to be Muslim, and a very proud one. I once met a Persian guy who told me that he plans on converting to Judaism because he does not like Islam nor does he like being identified as a Muslim solely for being Persian. I actually had a great amount of respect for him. My point is, before you ask others to identify you in a certain way and go out of their way to understand your murky identity as you present it, you need to know who you are yourselves. If you're not Muslim, then don't be. Move on!
06:51 PM on 12/27/2011
Meh, what classification?
This is America, and unlike Malaysia or Iran or where ever there isnt a religion stamped on your ID card or some official classification....You're technically not classified as anything and can do what ever you want. If someone mistakenly assumes you are something you arent just correct them.
ThinkCreeps
Seriously, it's time.
05:43 PM on 12/27/2011
Good for you.

Now if the educational level of the nation around you can only rise to match your community's, we'll all be much better off.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Abdul-Halim Vazquez
05:03 PM on 12/27/2011
I'm not sure why this is a "conundrum". Religion and ethnicity are two different concepts. Some misinformed people will tend to make assumptions about one based on the other. Such is the way of the world. If you don't want people to think you are Muslim then you can explain to them that you are deist, agnostic, atheist, "spiritual but not religious" or whatever. If it really bothers you, you could even get a button or a bumper sticker.
05:02 PM on 12/27/2011
With popularity of Internet and social media, the real-time global exchange of ideas and the universality of moral values, people have now a better understanding of religion, especially of Islam, and the nonsensical claims often force-fed to naĂŻve believers under its name by clerics. Islam has reacted to the new challenges by fomenting extremism and breeding a new generation of fervor devotees who are younger, often educated, well conditioned, and are ready to take any drastic actions, including killing themselves and slaughtering others, and by raising the bar. By doing so, Islam has lost the masses of marginally-attached followers who now think that the opportunity cost of compliance with its strict requirements is too high. It is now controlled by a small hard-core noisy followers who control the life of the majority who do not agree with their gloomy version of Islam, a powerless army of pretentious followers - siahi lashgar as we say is Farsi. We are the by-default Muslims have no choice but to pretend that we are faithful to prevent persecution.
A very good article indeed.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Dr Idris
polymathy is not understanding
05:02 PM on 12/27/2011
Welcome to U.S>-the only intentionally Secular Republic created by Enlightement Phiosophes, where many many people wrongly think it is a specifically religious foundation. ( I know Secular Iranis here, who wish that Persia had remained Zoroastrian!)
04:21 PM on 12/27/2011
I'm in the same position, expect I'm Bosnian and i absolutely don't know anything about Islam and don't practice any facets of that faith(neither does anyone in my immediate or extended family) but I'm labeled a Muslim because of my name. You seem to be really offended and embarrassed by that label, I on the other hand don't really care.