iPhone app iPad app Android phone app Android tablet app More

Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Matt Kane

Matt Kane

Posted: March 8, 2011 12:33 PM

The Implications of the Inhumane Treatment of Bradley Manning


Barack Obama's transition website -- created when he was president-elect following the 2008 elections -- says:

Often the best source of information about waste, fraud, and abuse in government is an existing government employee committed to public integrity and willing to speak out. Such acts of courage and patriotism, which can sometimes save lives and often save taxpayer dollars, should be encouraged rather than stifled. We need to empower federal employees as watchdogs of wrongdoing and partners in performance.

This statement is in stark contrast to the treatment of one of the most famous whistleblowers of our time, Pfc. Bradley Manning, who leaked thousands of military documents to the website WikiLeaks. Manning has been held in solitary at a Quantico Brig in Virginia for over seven months, allowed to leave his 6' X 12' cell for only one hour per day. In addition to this, Manning has now been deemed a threat to himself and must now sleep naked and report to attention in the morning nude. All of this despite the fact that Manning is not on suicide watch.

There is no argument that Manning's treatment is inhumane; he has not even been convicted of any crime. The silence of the American people is one thing, but the silence of our president is deafening. As terror trials and indefinite detention are the policy again at Gitmo, Obama is running out of people upon whom to blame these miscarriages of justice. Obama cannot blame Republicans for blocking the closing of the Quantico Brig and cannot blame Republicans for Bradley Manning's treatment. This one is on him and him alone.

For all of the talk of protecting whistleblowers -- which, if the chat logs portraying Manning's alleged intent are to be believed, he certainly is -- Obama is doing an about-face. Manning's detention is scary not only because of the violations regarding humane treatment, but also because of the implications of his situation. While Guantanamo was justified as a place for very bad people who were different from us -- Muslims from war-torn regions of the world -- Manning is an American citizen from the heartland. Take into account Jose Padilla's detention and it is clear that the American government has no qualms about defying Constitutional protections in order to break down those it deems enemies of the state. As Manning's captivity proves, the definition of "enemy of the state" is quite malleable.

While many like to point to Obama's successes -- repeal of DADT, the health care bill -- and assert that the man cannot solve all of the world's problems, in reality this is beside the point. Obama explicitly promised protection for federal whistleblowers yet he locks Manning up for exposing the wrongdoings of the armed forces. As Commander in Chief, Obama has the ability to stop the inhumane treatment of a U.S. citizen who is still awaiting trial. The question now is, will he?

 

Follow Matt Kane on Twitter: www.twitter.com/RealMattKane

 
 
  • Comments
  • 9
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
03:17 AM on 04/08/2011
Bradley Manning has disobeyed orders. We have seen in Cinema just what that means in the American army. He has not just leaked a few documents here and there, he went much further than that. It is understandable that he is held in custody. A country which opposes neither the death penalty or torture must not be suddenly shocked. In Europe we have been watching you electrocute and inject people to death, before an audience for years and no matter how shocked we are about this, as are some good people in America, it still happens. There is torture in the sewers of world governments, much of it is carried out without our knowledge. I daresay Manning will be luckier than most as everyone knows where he is and his situation is being monitored. How many other innocent and unknowns face torture and brutal death in countries where these issues mean nothing? I am sure Manning will be alright in the end and will probably finish his days imprisoned for life for espionage. Meantime, let us help the NGO's which expose despots and torturers so that they cannot act so liberally and make them accountable for their actions.
photo
BrassOnes
Hasa Diga Eebowai
07:28 PM on 03/19/2011
All those that think Manning is singled out for this treatment should read todays aljazeera article.

http://english.aljazeera.net/indepth/features/2011/03/201137125936219469.html
10:24 PM on 03/10/2011
The modern day Hessians who torture Manning will experience blowback on Monday, when Anonymous exposes them to the world.
11:04 AM on 03/10/2011
Maybe he should have thought twice before leaking those documents.
photo
Counterglow
Werner Heisenberg may have been right.
09:54 AM on 03/10/2011
Bradley Manning has not been convicted of a crime. He is an innocent man. Why is he being imprisoned under conditions that amount to abuse, and why is President Obama turning a blind eye?
09:45 AM on 03/10/2011
it's not about name or party... it's about the behavior itself...

from political beginnings that used underhand tactics...
taking opponents off the ballot before that election...
to present day deeds which contradict previous promises...
it's not hard to see that leadership lacks decent actions!...

for the spirit of america based on real truth and decency principles... there's a "rally for brad"... pfc bradley manning... on sunday march 20th at quantico virginia...

the best of wishes'n'ways'n'todays for fair'n'square and the truth and caring!... :)
04:57 AM on 03/10/2011
Bradley Manning is a political prisoner.
04:50 AM on 03/10/2011
The article documents the lies of Obama pretty well. Asking will he now intervene and stop the torture of Mr Manning is asinine: No. He is not going to stop it. He is no friend to basic human rights, freedom of speech (And that includes his good friend Hillary Clinton), the Constitution, or international laws governing war crimes. He got in bed with the GOP (And likes it) along with Wall Street,
Big Pharma, Monsanto, banking and likes what all these sociopaths stand for. Women's rights are under atttack--AGAIN by the GOP and he is silent AGAIN. He is eager for military intervention in Libya but can't deal with issues here destroying this country and 99% of Americans way of life. Get used to it. He is not one of us (A liberal or progressive) and never was.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Edward Standley
opinionated jerk
04:24 AM on 03/10/2011
The honor and integrity of our country and of our armed forces require us to treat prisoners as we would want our own soldiers treated if they were held prisoner. Only a petty little bug would rejoice in the mistreatment of a person, whether before they've been convicted of a crime, or while they are serving a punishment for a crime they've been convicted of. The U.S. should aspire to better than this.