More

Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
GET UPDATES FROM Matthew Long

Is Ecotourism Sustainable?

Posted: 07/22/10 01:36 PM ET

2010-07-21-GiantTortoisesHuff.jpg

Last year I actually won a sweepstakes (one of those that no one ever wins) for a trip to the Galapagos Islands. Beyond Darwin, I knew nothing of the archipelago and went only because it was free. However, my week touring this eco-wonder changed my life and perception of ecotourism forever.

The staff and crew of the Lindblad/National Geographic ship Endeavour quickly stepped in to fill the massive knowledge deficiencies I had regarding the Galapagos. Before arriving the only thing I knew was to expect very large turtles and to never, ever touch anything lest it become extinct and bring about the end of the world. Almost immediately though, the biologists onboard began an immersion course into all things Galapagian and we even took a nature hike that first afternoon.

Over the course of several days, my ability to be completely overwhelmed by nature was surpassed by every new experience. Everyone knows that the wildlife on the islands have no fear of humans, but to experience this unique phenomenon in person is quite another thing. To be able to stand inches away from blue-footed booby hatchlings and listen to them cry for their parents etched a sensory memory that can never be erased. This endemic trait does have its drawbacks, more than once an angry pelican tried to take a nip and seeing spitting iguanas crossing the path ahead is certainly an eye opening experience.

2010-07-21-Sealionandshiphuff.jpg
At the end of the week, we said our teary eyed goodbyes and took with us memories and experiences to last a lifetime. As I watched the group of islands disappear from the airplane window, I began to think about our responsibility to preserve such natural wonders.

The ability to keep areas such as the Galapagos pristine is a delicate balance between much-needed tourist dollars and limited access. I began to wonder if our presence there is really a benefit or not. Fifty years ago, the Galapagos was an all but forgotten island chain with just a handful of inhabitants. Today more than 20,000 people call this tiny place home and many more visit each year. Following in the wake is the expected pollution and general ecological maelstrom in one of the last untouched biospheres on the planet.

However the presence of these scientists and visitors has also accomplished the impossible. The Charles Darwin Foundation and other notable organizations have brought back several species from the brink of extinction, including the giant tortoise, ensuring their presence for centuries to come. Their research has also allowed biologists to better understand these endemic creatures, which in turn adds to our collective scientific knowledge and abilities.

Ecotourism and sustainable travel are oft used and very trendy travel buzz words, but most of the experiences do little to protect the designated areas. As with all things, there are both good and bad actors. I have encountered organizations, companies and properties that truly "get it" and do offer a sustainable experience. However, I fear that there are many more bad actors who are ruining the utility of the terms for everyone else. These terms are being used everywhere as a way to describe travel to important and delicate natural areas. Unfortunately though these are areas which, because of that very tourism, may very well cease to exist past another generation or two.


What do you think? Does ecotourism really preserve the habitat, or are many of the operators destroying that which they profess to protect?

 

Follow Matthew Long on Twitter: www.twitter.com/landlopers

 
 
  • Comments
  • 4
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Bloggers
Recency  | 
Popularity
06:08 PM on 07/27/2010
Great article! We are happy to see someone thinking critically about the terms "ecotourism" and "sustainability." Creating amazing experiences for travelers while preserving the environment and culture of a destination can be a delicate balance, but it is something we believe in strongly at Global Basecamps. http://www.globalbasecamps.com/sustainable-tourism-ecotourism
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
Linda Buzzell
03:27 PM on 07/23/2010
Thanks for reminding us that we need to consider all the impacts of travel, not only the benefits to us personally. The fossil-fueled flights and car rides, the environmental, social, financial and even political impacts of tourism all have to be weighed against the inspiring experiences and education we receive when we travel. REAL eco-tourism is in its infancy and we have to be aware that some are using the "eco" word as a form of greenwashing, making travel sound much more benign than it may really be. Let's support those who are genuinely trying to lessen the destruction caused by unthinking travellers.
01:09 PM on 07/23/2010
I love that you went on your trip not knowing what to expect and came back with a passion and thoughtfulness for such an important issue - and one that is ignored, green washed and capitalized on. Your experience is proof that by bringing visitors to pristine places we want to preserve, we can instill in them the respect for a place that will inspire them to preserve the earth as well. There are two kinds of people that can develop any of the remaining, pristine places left in the world - people who will take care of the place to preserve it, and people who will not. It is important as tourists and visitors that we encourage, support and put our money into projects that sustain the earth and do things the right way. I am lucky enough to have found and work for a company who is creating a small, sustainable community on a beautiful pristine island in Panama called Isla Palenque. Working on this project, and understand that beautiful places like Isla Palenque still exist, and I hope that when other people visit, they will gain the same understanding as you did on your trip to Galapagos. For more about the sustainability efforts we are implementing on Isla Palenque, visit http://www.islapalenque.com/island/sustainability
12:59 AM on 07/23/2010
About sustainability in Bonito - MS - Brazil - Rio da Prata e estancia Mimosa

To provide visitors with a unique experience of intense interaction with nature through ecotourism tours focused on innovation, environmental conservation and regional, sustainable development in a setting of stunning natural beauty.

Our Guidelines for sustainability:

Creation of a RPPN - Private Reserve of Natural Heritage, to protect relevant areas and biodiversity (RPPN Estância Mimosa in process of creation);

Adoption of minimal-impact practices during tourism activities, as well as established practices of safety in adventure tourism;

Responsible use of natural resources and constant efforts to minimize the possible negative environmental and social impacts arising from tourism activities;

Monitoring of the environmental quality of areas of tourist activities;
Using ecotourism as a tool for environmental education;

Priority in hiring local workmanship;

Sale of handcraft produced by regional artists to encourage local culture;

Supporting scientific research projects and technical visits;

Private production of part of the food offered to visitors, such as artisanal sweets, cheeses, organic vegetables, breads, milk and eggs;

Worm farms used for composting manure and improving the quality of the natural soil;

Ecological management of rural production;

Maintaining a native tree nursery;

Hunting, fishing, lumber exploration and the raising of domestic and wild animals are forbidden;

Adequate disposal of solid waste and wastewater;

Staff training;

Support for NGOs, regional social projects and class associations;

Authenticity in commercial relations and institutional growth. www.bonitoweb.com.br