More

Max Bergmann

Max Bergmann

Posted: August 15, 2008 11:54 AM

As Things Fall Apart


No week has better illustrated the catastrophic failures of the Bush administration's foreign policy then this one.

Just look at the front page of the New York Times today. It has two big stories above the fold. The left column is about Musharraf's resignation. The right column is about the collapse of the Bush-Putin relationship.

Instead of two articles it should have had one headline: After 8 Years Bush's Pakistan And Russia Policies Shown To Be Complete Failures.

Nytimes

So this week at the same time the president was coming to the realization that his insights into Putin's soul may have been misguided, his failed policy toward Pakistan was also coming full circle. The resignation of Musharraf represents the total collapse of eight years of Bush administration policy. Toward both Russia and Pakistan, Bush pursued a personality driven policy -- to Russia we had a Putin Policy, to Pakistan we had a Musharraf Policy. And both leaders have used their personal relationships with the president to insulate themselves from broader criticism. In the end, we never had a real strategy for either country and eight years later we find ourselves increasingly powerless to do anything about it.

Perhaps the biggest foreign policy challenge for the next president is attempting to restore U.S. credibility and prestige around the world. McCain this week has shown exactly the wrong way to go about it. His recent over-the-top rhetoric about Georgia is exactly the wrong approach and reeks of the same neoconservative-inspired thinking that emanated from Bush's first term. Making hollow promises and defiant threats, when the Bush administration just showed that such rhetoric to be completely hollow, only makes the U.S. look less credible (Of course, if McCain were actually serious about following through on his reckless rhetoric and militarily confronting Russia then that would not only be insane but would further imperil our superpower status). McCain's mocking of Obama's trip abroad, only demonstrates how out of touch McCain actually is. The fact is that we need a leader who can convince the world once again to follow the lead of the United States. Obama's trip demonstrated that he has the power to do that. While on the other hand, all McCain has shown is a lot of reckless crazy talk that will only leave us isolated and weaker.



 

No week has better illustrated the catastrophic failures of the Bush administration's foreign policy then this one. Just look at the front page of the New York Times today. It has two big stories ab...
No week has better illustrated the catastrophic failures of the Bush administration's foreign policy then this one. Just look at the front page of the New York Times today. It has two big stories ab...
 
 
  • Comments
  • 53
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2  Next ›  Last »  (2 total)
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
nobillary1
01:52 PM on 08/16/2008
Watching the Last Days of the "Imperial Presidency"* of Geo W Bush is kind of like watching a sweater unravel. The saddest part is that he and Cheney get to just walk away from it all in January, leaving the next President to clean up the mess they leave behind.

The Bush legacy will be Politics 101 on how NOT to run a country, and hopefully it will be prerequisite reading for all who seek Political Office in the future! If I had my way, we would obliterate W from the History books altogether and emulate what they did in old Egypt after Akhenaten the Heretic King died. They erased every trace of him from their records and carvings.

Either way, I have a feeling history will not be kind to this Administration and they will certainly deserve it!
"Imperial Presidency" - Thank you Andrew J. Bacevich!
12:55 PM on 08/17/2008
I say let Dubya live in style after he leaves office.

Let him live in one of Saddam Hussein's palaces outside the Green Zone :)
09:47 AM on 08/16/2008
But, you don't understand....

It's just business as usual.

A phone call - a hand shake over a surf' 'n turf.
A back pat/massage, "whatever it takes"

"It's just business."
~Michael Corleone channeling the Bush Mafia
10:57 AM on 08/16/2008
Sonny to Michael: "Didn't wanna get mixed up in the family business, huh? Now you wanna gun down a police captain. Why? Because he slapped you around a little bit? Huh? What, you think this is the Army, where you shoot 'em a mile away? You gotta get up close like this and bada-BING! You blow their brains all over your nice Ivy League suit."
08:41 AM on 08/16/2008
What's with the sabor rattling and rhetoric from bush and mccain? What the hell does either think they can do. Critise Russia for invading a country? Hummmm glad we haven't done that in recent history. Just what army do they think they can throw at this? From what I can tell, we don't happen to have a spare army floating around.

mccain has to have his 15 minutes. But can't the bush handlers stick a sock in it, to prevent any more damage from the rootin' tootin' cowboy wanna be blustering? Keep him silent by any means!
08:15 AM on 08/16/2008
I understand tha Bush bashing is so popular nowdays, but could you be honest and remind us that isolation of Russia started with Clinton administratin.
Clinton did not comply with the agreement not to extend NATO eastward on Eastern European countries of the former Soviet block.
US keeps implimenting aggresive Imperialistic policies.
And corporate mass media is totally preoccupied with Putin, what he has to do wit Washington?
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
LeftRight
TANSTAAFL
03:50 PM on 08/16/2008
True, isolation of Russia did start with Clinton, however, it was REVERSED under bush!! Therefore to have bush come out and claim that Russia is wrong for following bush into invading a country....... Course, at least in Russia's case Georgia is right next door....
01:11 AM on 08/17/2008
WHO owns 'CORPORATE MASS MEDIA'??
Republican corporations. They got into MEDIA BUSINESS from advertising the products they sell.
That's a "secret"? ?

WHY PRETEND there's somebody else other than REPUBLICAN CORPORATIONS WHO OWN MEDIA?

Their media is preoccupied with Putin and other stuff because their BOSSES WANT DIVERSIONS
and CAMO SCREENS away from what they are really up to. Including BIG OIL's rape of
countries for oil profits.

BUSH-CHENEY'S mission accomplished? TO ENRICH BIG OIL. they are oil men.
BIG OIL'S BOTTOM LINE GOT RICHEST in 8 yrs.
06:50 PM on 08/15/2008
You left out his disasters managing the economy and US energy policy.

Bush should write a book: How to Completely Destroy a Superpower in Just 8 Years

Assuming he can write.
09:57 PM on 08/15/2008
He can't speak, why should expect him to be able to write?
12:33 AM on 08/16/2008
and let us not forget:

Katrina
Iraq
Iran
Torture
Osama Bin Laden
Eavesdropping on Citizens
Civil Rights
Justice Dept
Karl Rove
Dick Cheney

Skindoggy
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
horhay
Res ipsa loquitur
09:47 PM on 08/16/2008
Let's not forget these as well:

Criminal negligence leading to, or actual complicity in 9/11/2001.
Donald Rumsfeld
John Ashcroft
Alberto Gonzales
Condeleeza Rice
Jeff Gannon/Guckert
UAE ports deal

Hell-the list goes on ad infinitum
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
davesideas
06:41 PM on 08/15/2008
Particularly galling is the failure in the region that represented Rice's specialty; Russia. Again, this administration was caught flat-footed.
12:57 AM on 08/16/2008
Yup, cowboy Georgie has moved us from world superpower to world STUPORPOWER.

Heck of a job Georgie.
photo
HUFFPOST COMMUNITY MODERATOR
girlwild
Corporations aren't people until Texas executes 1
05:43 PM on 08/15/2008
Maybe it's because Bush's "personality driven diplomacy" means that the people running other countries really don't want to hang out with "someone they can drink beer with" and instead seek to have diplomatic relationships with those who have the intellectual and educational capacity to understand what's really going on.
04:31 PM on 08/15/2008
Can you imagine Barack trying to negotiate with Putin when he can't even handle Clinton who steamrolled him over the convention....He should have told her - "get lost loser...." Instead he plays "can't we all get along" and gets mugged......

And now Russia is threatening Poland with nukes? And we want Obama in the middle of that? No thanks......Rather have Grandpa Mccain on the porch with his rifle....
05:36 PM on 08/15/2008
Let's see, Russia decides to install anti-missile weaponry in Cuba as a defense against a possible U.S. attack and the U.S. is going to sit by and say it's OK? Poland is in Europe, thousands of miles from the U.S., unless you haven't checked your map. The so called anti-missile systems we've been spending billions on DON'T WORK. We are de facto threatening Russia that isn't threatening the U.S. with anything except their mafia who've invaded some of our cities.
ReadyNow, did you ever go to school? Read a book or learn something about history, military strategy and politics? Doubt it.
05:41 PM on 08/15/2008
"And now Russia is threatening Poland with nukes? And we want Obama in the middle of that? No thanks......Rather have Grandpa Mccain on the porch with his rifle...." ReadyNow
Do you live in the hills where idiots need to defend themselves against another idiot invading their property or stealing their can of Coke? Obviously, you have no knowledge of history, military strategy, anti-missile failures of this country, Poland, or anything else for that matter. It makes no difference because in the scheme of things, the USofA is slowly going down the drain. There's no excuse for stupidity.
04:26 PM on 08/15/2008
Bush was elected while his failures in Military, Business, higher education and so on were just ignored by the conservatives and big business. Why? They needed Santa Claus with lots of gifts and business with no regulation. Meanwhile the US behaved like we were in the middle of the cold war with a palm reader as President. The whole country is for sale. If you have to wear a Canadian flag in order to not get killed abroad or pretend your Hispanic, the State of the Union is poor. The Cold war has been over for fifteen plus years but the administration is building jets for an enemy that disappeared, we are about to get another Cold Warrior as President because the American People have a hard time to let go from old glory days, that were not so glorious. In the meantime the majority will pay the prize for the looting of the treasury and America. While the rich will toast to each other, $1000 bottle of Champagne in their million dollar luxury villas in Dubai, the working stiffs will pay for it with a bankrupt country. In the event of real revolution, I would like to have a front seat when they hang those rich bastards. But it will not happen, because the moralists will argue that we poor people destroyed the country.
03:06 PM on 08/15/2008
America is becoming to resemble Russian after the collapse of The Soviet Union. LeftRight, in the post below, is correct. Inertia is carrying America along at the moment. We may have those shiny SUV's and you may drive your BMW's, but you are paid in the dollar that is a joke around the world right now.

Oh, and China, with a trillion dollars in foreign reserves, has more influence in Washington than American voters. Besides, the dollar would become toilet paper if China released $400 million of those dollars onto the world market. The only save we have right now is that China is dependent on America for economic growth. And that dependency is slowly coming to an end. Once gone, China will economically destroy America. Sure, China will take a hit, America will be sunk.

And not only is China capable of doing so. Those countries with dollar reserves are increasingly diversifying their holdings. Most Americans afford America on debt. You will not be able to afford America, or even Zimbabwe, if the dollar collapses.
02:54 PM on 08/15/2008
__________________________Why we Blog_________________
A Rapid Examination of 21st Century Expressions of Mass Dissent

Hard working, tax paying, family focused, and well-intentioned people, from sea to shining sea, are channeling Marvin Gaye when they ask, “What’s going on?”

War, rumors of war, post war examinations revealing pre-war contamination of the presented truth, yet, average plugged-in Americans did not need much proof prior to invasion that Bush was hell bent on Iraqi enslavement. The rise of the neocolonialist who occupies nations, and wraps it up in pretty pictures and words like

Shock and Awe
Mission Accomplished
Axis of Evil
Surge

All over, people come to economic realizations that ends may never meet and corruption and greed have set up shop on Wall Street. Credit scores and media whores, they rhyme but have more in common than that. The new system is one of tight control through information; measured and filtered dissemination of facts, to achieve ends of design not ends that free but ones that bind. Oh what a mountain of lies and illusion the average citizen is forced to climb -- just to make it, it is a wonder how any of us continue to take it.

So we vent, we set up tent in the public square. We come hard with our view of America; we bring our opinion to bear. Words alone do not solve a thing. Blunder -- is what action without consideration, usually brings, we blog because we think before we act on these things.
02:51 PM on 08/15/2008
I cannot resist taking another swipe at religion in politics. Bush was "elected" on a pro-right wing conservative Christian platform. A narrow platform concerned with the issues of Guns, God, and Gays. As if that is all that existed in the world of Christian voters. For eight years, this is what has driven Bush. For thirty years, these issues are what have driven conservative Christians to consistently vote Republican.

During this time, America has come to accept torture. The military is in disarray, the moral authority that America stands for is in tatters and Jesus Himself would seem to have endorsed deregulation of commerce. Deregulation that has destroyed America's economic future and led to the steady impoverishment of most Americans. Science, the area that gave America the knowledge to lead in technological innovation is under assault by religious extremists. Never mind the lack of effective education that exists in the schools. And health care? No money? Just die already.

Not that the Democrats have done much better. Remember Bill Clinton and NAFTA? Or the tech bubble that began under his reign only to burst in Bush's presidential appointment by nine voters on The Supreme Court.

Now get the hell out of politics before you further destroy America.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
02:42 PM on 08/15/2008
"... at the same time Bush was coming to the realization that his insights ..."

Perhaps not.
02:05 PM on 08/15/2008
Our idiot president has not had a good idea in 8 years let alone listened to any sane foreign policy advisers. We have Condi Rice who is scared of Cheney, We have big oil that sets this administration's agenda and policies, Wonder what the FOIA will reveal about Cheney's famous energy policy meeting that is a deep administration secret. Its simply a botched administration that trampled the constutitioin and will continue to do what they want till they leave in January. They got theirs and don't give a damn about anyting else, let alone anyone that is not an "American." Thanks God for Jaunuary.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
LeftRight
TANSTAAFL
03:07 PM on 08/15/2008
One thing's wrong in your comment. Condi isn't scared of Cheney. Condi's doing EXACTLY what she was hired to do: Be a yes woman!
10:29 PM on 08/16/2008
Don't thank God for January too much yet. If McCain gets in, it will be just like the Bush administration and then some. The details of that energy policy meeting would almost surely be kept secret.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Spiritgirl2
02:05 PM on 08/15/2008
Who us a Superpower? Only those with unbridled hubris still tend to think we are a Superpower. All of the neocon policies have failed to deliver for the average American. Allies, we have none, and even the ones that were bribed into this war ended up coming to their senses and have been bringing their troops home! As for tough talk aimed at Russia, the Russians are probably laughing their heads off saying "go ahead, we dare ya".

Superpower, pluuleaze!