Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Meghan McCullough

GET UPDATES FROM Meghan McCullough
 

Not Even Horcruxes Will Make You Invincible

Posted: 01/17/12 09:25 AM ET

I'm sure that all of you, at some point or another, have heard adults utter the much overused and condescending phrase, "You teenagers think you are invincible." I'm also sure that you've always rebuffed the comment, saying things like, "I know I'm not invincible!" and "I know that I will probably die one day!" (at least, I know that's what I've always replied). But I'm not sure that we teenagers entirely believe those things when we say them. Are we able to fully grasp the concept that life is, in fact, temporary? Can we face the fact that, with each passing day, we are running out of time? Do we even want to? And, perhaps most importantly, are adults, as they scoff at our supposed invincibility, able to grasp that concept either?

Last night, I attended the New York City stop of young adult novelist John Green's book tour for his recently released novel, The Fault in Our Stars. The novel is about a 16-year-old girl's battle with cancer. After briefly reading from the book, Green went on to describe The Fault in Our Stars as a "little epic," complaining that too many novels rely on grand gestures of romantic sacrifice on the part of their characters to give worth to their characters' lives. What if, he pondered, as is the case with his protagonist, one does not have enough time to even contemplate accomplishing something out-of-this-world before they die? Green argued that it is better to come to terms with the fact that we don't have all the time in the world now, as well as realize that we don't have to rock the world in order to give meaning to what little time we have here. He went on to say that this is, in fact, the only problem he has with Harry Potter; that the concept of horcruxes (pieces of a person's soul stored in random objects that will live on if that person dies) fails to take into consideration the fact that our species will not survive forever, regardless of an individual life span. "I don't find this to be a depressing idea," he laughed in response to heckling he received from the crowd for coming off as such a Debbie downer.

Maybe that's the problem with the rest of us. Maybe it's time for us to officially own up to the fact that, no, we aren't invincible, but that doesn't mean that we won't leave our own marks, however small, on the world while we can. And I suppose if we fully embrace John Green's mentality, we will be forced to acknowledge that whatever mark we are able to leave on the world won't survive forever either. I'm not sure that I find this to be a very comforting idea, but I am on my way to adopting Green's view of not finding it depressing anymore. Instead, I find it inspiring that people all over the globe as well as throughout history still put in enormous efforts to spur change, to create, and to be passionate about what they love anyway. I think this speaks to the inherent drive that humans have to not only succeed, but also to help each other. It's time for us to start considering that an entire world teeming with people like that may be better than invincibility, after all.

 
 
 
  • Comments
  • 9
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Bloggers
Recency  | 
Popularity
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
JewishPhysician
fraternity, trust, discourse
09:00 PM on 01/17/2012
A horcrux is a cheap way to make youself a neat kid.
photo
intotheabyss
Imperialism is a form of insanity.
06:57 PM on 01/17/2012
Hi Meghan. You sound like a very mature young lady to me. As the old saying goes, "life is what you make it". I think in terms of teenagers believing they are invincible, it depends on your life experience up to this point as well as the culture you've been raised in. Some young people take bigger risks than others as do older people. Common sense plays a key role. You sound like you have that in your favor. Hope you enjoy being at Amherst. I live just down the road in Belchertown.
photo
dim
one in a can
01:56 PM on 01/17/2012
Forever (or infinity) is not a natural concept. It's a human construct. Being within this world we cannot achieve what's not part of it. The best we can hope for is to continue as a collective memory in others. Pythagoras is dead, yet somehow still here with us.

Probably die one day? Short of fanciful religious teachings, I think it's pretty well established that death is a certainty.

So yeah, nobody is invincible. Shouldn't stop you from acting like you are invincible, as most heroes have. I am not suggesting recklessness for the sake of it, but being too careful is dangerous as well. Kurt Gödel was so careful to avoid being poisoned, he only ate what his wife prepared. When the wife fell ill, he starved to death.
01:49 PM on 01/17/2012
MM. If you are lucky enough to feel invincible, good for you, I doubt you'll feel that way at 84 so treasure it. Take care.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
xenubarb
Nebulon V
01:11 PM on 01/17/2012
Wanna know something creepy? I'm 60, but don't feel any different than I did in high school. I've hurled myself into dangerous pursuits like motorcycling and hang gliding, and I'm still here.

We rode skateboards (a piece of 2x4 nailed to shoe skate parts) without helmets or pads in middle school, and none of us died. I rode horses bareback at top speed, didn't die. We rode bikes without helmets, some died.

What really nails your sense of mortality down is when your parents and friends start dying. When people die doing things they love, like flying, you can tell yourself they took the risk and understood it.

When they start dying of teh old, or disease, you realize you, too, have taken a number.

If South Park is correct, Heaven is full of Mormons making things out of popsicle sticks and toilet paper rolls. Meanwhile, Satan throws a hella Hukilau.

I kind of hope to step off into a maelstrom our bodies lack the sensors to detect, but it's probably just the same place you are before you are born. Nothingness is okay. It's not like you're there to complain about it.
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
rtgmath
There has got to be a better way!
12:41 PM on 01/17/2012
Meghan, I applaud you for such a well-thought out piece of writing. It is good philosophy. Do what you can now with what you have now.

Very few of us are going to rock the world. But I can make other peoples' lives better now. I can have a good attitude. I can be supportive of others. And I can do those things while preparing for a future in which, who knows?, maybe I will rock the world! But I do have to start now.

It is hard not to think of living forever. I am in my 50s, and have already had one heart attack. I never planned for it. But I think about the fact that the rest of my life is precious. I had better pay attention to the ones I love, do the work I love, and be a good example. Life is unpredictable.

But I do hope yours is long, satisfying, full of good works for others, and without regrets.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
CBasilJr
62 Retired Vet
02:59 PM on 01/17/2012
Based on my experience, you will live forever.
11:31 AM on 01/17/2012
Obviously this contributor has not heard or read about the Philosophy of the Singularity which was featured recently in a HuffPost piece. One of the weight bearing beams of the construct? That death does not define life, life defines life. The decisions we make aren't a response to the fact we are mortal with an unknown number of days, but we build on what came before us...
03:45 PM on 01/17/2012
Anyone roughly 20 years old today, has a pretty good chance of living several centuries. With the upcoming dramatic jumps in computing power, it won't be more than a few decades before the "problem" of aging is solved and we simply live as long as we want to.