iPhone app iPad app Android phone app Android tablet app More

Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Melanie Notkin

GET UPDATES FROM Melanie Notkin
 

When You're Not a Mother on Mother's Day

Posted: 05/09/2012 10:56 am

If you're like me, and always aspired and expected to be a mother, Mother's Day, and the days that precede it, can be a heavy time. With continuous Mother's Day promotions and news stories featuring moms of all ages, shapes and sizes ("It's the hardest job in the world!"), the day can make us feel left out and less-than. For some, Mother's Day is a harsh reminder that the dream of motherhood has not (yet) come true.

I recently asked the Savvy Auntie® Facebook community how Mother's Day makes them feel. Some of the honest and heartfelt responses included: feeling empty, incomplete, sad, lonely and left behind; unimportant, neglected, "anxious about my ticking clock," "not in the club that I assumed I would be in" and "like I'm sitting in a great cloud of sadness -- it's just the most awful day."

There's no doubt that mothers deserve their day to be celebrated and honored. I think of my own late mother on Mother's Day and how I am still grateful 23 years after she's gone to have had such an amazing mom. But for the nearly 50 percent of American women who are childless, especially those who desire motherhood, Mother's Day can feel like our contributions to the children in our lives -- and for some, even children around the world -- are overlooked and unacknowledged.

Being a mother and being maternal are not always the same thing. As one Savvy Auntie commented, "On one hand, I would have loved to have had kids, but on the other, I'm very blessed that the five kiddos who call me aunt are very much a part of my life." And we all know mothers who would rather not have had children (or should not have had children). Still, the former group aches with prideful love with the birth of a niece or nephew -- or any child born to a close friend or relative. They care for these children as they grow and develop with unconditional love and support. I even came up with a term for the value of the time a childless aunt spends with a child. I've dubbed it "QualAuntie Time" because the uninterrupted playtime during Auntie's visit has been proven to support the emotional, social and intellectual development of children.

Every moment an aunt by relation or aunt by choice spends with nieces and nephews is filled with her generosity of spirit and devotion. After all, unlike parenting, there is no legal obligation to "aunt." Every little boo boo she kisses, every little hand she holds, every word of advice she offers, is done with maternal love and is a gift.

In the spirit of Anna Jarvis, the childless aunt of many nieces and nephews, who founded Mother's Day in 1914 in honor of all mothers, living or dead, I hope all the maternal women in children's lives - all the aunts, great-aunts, godmothers and women in general who offer their love to children not-their-own -- are remembered this Mother's Day.

Babies are born from the womb. Maternity is born from the soul. There are many ways to mother.

As the founder of Savvy Auntie, the lifestyle brand for all the cool aunts, great-aunts, godmothers and all women who love kids, I founded Auntie's Day® in 2009 to honor and celebrate all that these women do for the children in their lives. Occurring annually on the fourth Sunday in July, the fourth annual Auntie's Day will take place on Sunday, July 22.

___

Melanie Notkin is the national best-selling author of Savvy Auntie: The Ultimate Guide for Cool Aunts, Great-Aunts, Godmothers and All Women Who Love Kids (Morrow/HarperCollins)

SavvyAuntie.com
Join the Auntourage on Facebook: Facebook.com/SavvyAuntie
Connect directly with Melanie on Twitter @SavvyAuntie

 
 
 

Follow Melanie Notkin on Twitter: www.twitter.com/savvyauntie

FOLLOW WOMEN
If you're like me, and always aspired and expected to be a mother, Mother's Day, and the days that precede it, can be a heavy time. With continuous Mother's Day promotions and news stories featuring m...
If you're like me, and always aspired and expected to be a mother, Mother's Day, and the days that precede it, can be a heavy time. With continuous Mother's Day promotions and news stories featuring m...
 
 
  • Comments
  • 25
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2  Next ›  Last »  (2 total)
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
ginas13
03:15 PM on 05/14/2012
Great articles. I too feel the sting around Mother's Day of not being a mother, especially for my parents who would be amazing Grandparents. But I am lucky to have so many wonderful children in my life through my friends. Many that do not have grandparents or the ones they have are lacking in warmth have adoted my parents as their grandparents. I am proud that they love me and consider me their aunt. I remember as a child always loving and looking up to their friends. I often thought of them as my friends. We never know what life throws us and we need to make the most of it. I love my "adopted" kiddies with all my heart and always will.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
DSevere
Deviant mind
12:49 PM on 05/12/2012
Wow. I had no idea people took Mother's Day this seriously. To me it's more remember-to-send-mother-in-law-a-nice-gift-and-e-card day.

But judging from the heartfelt and sad responses here, it's really meaningful to a lot of people. Thanks, I am thus enlightened....
03:45 PM on 05/10/2012
As a VERY old first time Mom, quickly a Single Mom and a favorite Aunt of 2 now grown boys/ men - I hear you, feel you and appreciate the 'aunts' everywhere. For many years I was the Aunt who loved to get the photo mug of my nephews on Mother's Day... I love where you say "Babies are born from the womb. Maternity is born from the soul. There are many ways to mother." Yes, I get to celebrate Mother's Day now as a Mom (of a now 10 year old) and nothing brings me more joy. (And now I long for more children but am too old for any more coming from this body!) Know that there is one Mom here that is living proof that you just never know what, when, how or why it might happen that your soul will be fulfilled. I had my son at 43 and got married at 52 - backwards I know but it happened!
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
01:35 PM on 05/10/2012
Just call it "woman's day" and get on with it. This hemming and hawing is particularly uncomfortable to witness. Or better yet just place your "aunt's" day on the third sunday of June so that everyone is aware of society's current disdain for everything "paternal". Us fathers, uncles and mentors will get over it, most likely.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
ginas13
03:18 PM on 05/14/2012
If this bothers you so much, why did you even read the article in the first place? You just like to post negative things to feel superior.
09:09 AM on 05/10/2012
Melanie- this post is reason #905 why I think you are just brilliant and such a powerful voice-- your words resonate with so many of us on a primal level!
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
rbelmonte
always grateful
07:46 AM on 05/10/2012
No one is really left out on mothers day, woman without their "own" children have mothers. Celebrate your mother, whether she is with you or not; whether you know her or not. And if you have differences with her, try to be kind and forgiving, remember it is "the hardest job in the world". We all have a mother. Happy Mother's Day :)
09:09 PM on 05/09/2012
Thank you so much, Melanie. For years I have swallowed my tears and put on a happy face for all of my friends and family with children and/or moms, all the while mourning not only the loss of my mother 14 years ago, but the loss of my dream of being a mother. But something clicked this year. My husband and I made a committment to not hide on these holidays. We made reservations and we are going out to a wonderful jazz brunch. We will count our many blessings and we will celebrate the fact that through it all, we have each other. (We also have amazing nieces and nephews who think we are the cool aunt and uncle -- which definitly helps lessen the sting!) And we will think of you and this wonderful piece you have written and know that we are not alone!
09:00 PM on 05/09/2012
I have two wonderful sons, yet ever since I lost my mother almost 10 years ago, I do not look forward to Mother's Day. To me, being motherless on Mother's Day, is extremely difficult as I always looked at the holiday more through the eyes of a daughter than a mother.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
pslcitizen
I intend to live forever. So far, so good.
06:22 PM on 05/09/2012
Why let other people expectations or assumptions define who you are? Everyone of us, parent or not, can be a good example to children...to mentor, to encourage or just to offer a smile. I had lots of great ladies come through my life to make me the person I am today & they didn't need to be a mother.
04:55 PM on 05/09/2012
I prefer the term "childfree". Defining a woman as "less" because her home does not contain children sounds too negative.
06:19 PM on 05/09/2012
I agree... childless is someone who it trying to have children... childfree is someone who chooses to have no children. Childess has a engative appraoch to it.
photo
Badger33
I'm trying real hard to be the shepherd.
12:32 AM on 05/10/2012
Faved for good use of language. I'm religion-free.
03:27 PM on 05/09/2012
Don't forget about the "almost" mothers. I had a miscarriage in 2007 and it still affects me to this day. Where I work it is required for everyone to be there on Mother's Day. You are fired if you do not show up for your shift. It is so hard to see all of these mothers yelling at their children while I wait on their tables. This is a day to value your children and what they have touched in your life.
02:42 PM on 05/09/2012
What do single people feel about Valentines or Sweetest Day? Who has enough time on their hands to split atoms over Wall Street and Fifth Avenue holidays?
02:18 PM on 05/09/2012
I too wanted to be a mom. But after 3 miscarriages and a 5 month D&E at 40 years old felt like I was only killing babies and couldn't do it any more. I can only hope that people will begin to realize that not all childless women chose not to have children and will temper their questions and judgements that I don't have any with the possibility that our bodies would not allow us to share one of the greatest joys of womanhood. Luckily I have 8 nieces and nephews that I could not love any less and they allow me to "mother" them through their kindness. To all who read this, please know that not ALL women have made the choice not to be mothers. I would have given my life for a child. PS My husband at that time also changed his mind about adoption. We are now divorced.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
sadiemae1214
Life is a Cabaret old Chum!
05:56 PM on 05/09/2012
Nobody ever speaks about the mothers that have lost children. My only sister lost her only child many years ago. My 7 year old niece was walking home from school when she was hit by a car. My sister had 7 years to love her and then she was gone. For reasons only she will know, she chose not to have more. I can't pretend to know how she feels on Mothers Day but my heart goes out to all mothers that have gone thru this.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
gumbygirl
That's Princess Smarty-Pants to you, buster!
08:04 PM on 05/10/2012
Thank you. My only child died two years ago, at the age of 26. My own mom died in 2005. Mother's Day is just a painful reminder to me of what I have lost.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
pslcitizen
I intend to live forever. So far, so good.
06:26 PM on 05/09/2012
Even the best laid plans don't always materialize. Just because you can't give birth doesn't mean you don't have a LOT of love to give. Trust me every life you touch will be better for it. Your nieces & nephews are very lucky to have an aunt who can be there for them.
12:38 PM on 05/09/2012
Babies are born from the womb. Maternity is born from the soul. There are many ways to mother.

Beautifully stated.

I received a Mother's Day card from my niece and nephew this week. Though I have children of my own, I was particularly touched that they thought of me.
11:45 AM on 05/09/2012
This is awesome. Thank you. I am the proud Aunt to lovely 15 month old, Allyson. I love her like my own and I am thankful I can do the fun stuff with her and give her to my sister when she starts getting cranky.