I have one fast food weakness -- an eight-pack of chicken nuggets in a white and red box. I could go years and never crave a fast food burger, but I'll admit I have a deep kinship with Chick-fil-A's version of fast food. As a kid growing up (Christian) in the south, Chick-fil-A has always been part of the good food I loved. They donated free sandwich coupons to our church fundraisers, and as a teenager I attended community prayer breakfasts that met at our local Chick-fil-A. True story: I've even dressed as a cow to get free food.
But today, we're parting ways. For the past few months, I have been following the news that Chick-fil-A donates money to groups such as Marriage & Family Foundation, Exodus International and the Family Research Council. These groups and others have contributed extensively to the religious hate speech that marginalizes lesbian, gay, bisexual and transgender (LGBT) people. They have spoken out against civil rights for LGBT individuals and have even discouraged anti-bullying campaigns that seek to prevent LGBT teens from taking their own lives.
I'm not one to rush to a boycott. I recognize that many of the places I eat have unjust practices. Even when I cook in my own kitchen, I have little knowledge of whether or not those who grew, harvested and packed our food were paid a fair wage for their work. Beyond buying a label that says "organic," I have little information about whether the process of growing my food hurt or healed the earth.
But we are what we eat -- isn't that what they say? And as it turns out, I can't eat hate. Over our breakfast of fair-trade coffee and organic fruit this morning, my husband and I read Dan Cathy's latest anti-gay comments in The Huffington Post. In talking about the article, we both admitted we'd felt guilty every time we popped into Chick-fil-A for nuggets or that delicious cookies and cream shake. But we knew what we needed to do. As people who grew up in the churches that fueled this dehumanizing anti-gay rhetoric, we've stomached enough hate for a lifetime.
As I read where Dan Cathy talked about the "the biblical definition of the family unit," I couldn't help but think of the teenage girl in Louisville, Ky., who was beaten by a group of adults who shouted anti-gay slurs as they broke her jaw the day after his comments. Unfortunately, the "biblical definition of the family unit" that Cathy speaks of would not seek justice for this girl. After all, those who were considered an "abomination" could be stoned for their lack of conformity to the patriarchal norm. Did I mention that the place where this teenage girl was beaten was in front of two churches? Words have consequences, and the words that some churches have been speaking are still creating an atmosphere where violence can be justified. The consequences of our words are coming back to our doorsteps to call us to account.
As cited in HuffPost, when Dan Cathy was asked by Baptist Press about his company's support of the "traditional family," he replied, "Guilty as charged." Like Cathy, churches that speak hate through exclusion are "guilty as charged" for the violence we incite. By promoting (or simply ignoring) speech that marginalizes people -- any people -- we deny that we are all made in the image of God, deserving of human dignity and human rights -- no matter who we are (or aren't) having sex with.
As a kid, I not only loved Chick-fil-A's nuggets, but I also loved that Christian values shaped their business. I loved that they hung out a sign to say they were closed on Sundays. I still believe that, as people of faith, we are called to live out our faith in whatever work we are called to do. But hate is not a Christian value. Jesus, who never married, did not come to marginalize people but to proclaim justice. Perhaps Dan and his family will understand. I'm hanging out my sign. I won't eat at Chick-fil-A on any day of the week because I can no longer be part of these contributions that fund hate. Words have consequences. I don't want to be "guilty as charged."
I have a 1-year-old daughter who also loves her chicken nuggets. Unfortunately, if Chick-fil-A continues to donate money to groups who speak violence against LGBT individuals and their families, then she will not grow up with same love for this food that my husband and I had as children. A small sacrifice, I guess. I just hope she grows into a world where hate crimes become uncommon, where people are not beaten in a church's front yard for being different, for being queer.
Throughout the Christian church's history, food has always been a sacred space of sharing. The common religious ritual that forms both liberal and conservative churches is communion -- the act of taking part in the table of Christ. Willingness to participate in the life of Christ -- willingness to drink the cup and taste the bread -- has always been the signifier of our faith, not our sexuality. I teach ethics, and during a recent class the subject of homosexuality came up. When some students began to cite the biblical reasons against homosexuality, another student felt marginalized by the discussion. She said, "I'm glad to hear everyone's voice, I'm glad that as a church we can come to the table, but I can't come to the table if people are throwing food at me." The violence is not only at our doorsteps, but at our altars as well.
On my daily commute to work, the only Chick-fil-A in the city is 10 feet away from my subway stop. To leave the train and walk the one block to my office means I will pass Chick-fil-A each day. But now, instead of stopping in for a chicken biscuit and coffee, I'll keep walking and say a prayer for peace. I'll pray that love will conquer hate, that justice will roll down like waters and that I'll have the strength to keep on walking.
Follow Melissa Browning on Twitter: www.twitter.com/imaginejustice
Jacques Berlinerblau: Chick-fil-A, Secular Values and Religious Freedom
Note to self, don't ever encourage my philosophy students to attend graduate school at Loyola University's Institute of Pastoral Studies. If the reasoning skills in this article are representative of the faculty there, the students are better off somewhere else (and this article was written by the Graduate Program Director no less!). Melissa, do yourself and your students a favour--go to your local community college and take a basic class in logic (or critical thinking if you can't handle that).
Is it reasonable for us to expect our creator to change what he deems right and wrong to satisfy the desires of his creation?
Do we as parents change the rules in our household because our children tell us what they think is right? Of course not.
It seems very logical to me... but it might not seem logical to someone that is living in opposition to God's requirements. I can see how the arrogance of that person may feel that they know more than God.
By "Biblical definition" ALL Christians are called to defend others, to seek justice, and to love all people... even if the people are Christian or not, straight or gay, male or female, and to forgive those who aren't worthy of forgiveness (which is basically all of us). Any Christian who did not rush to the defense of this girl has no idea what it means to be a Christian. What ever happened to the directive to love your enemies and do good to those who hate you? Hard words to grasp, even harder to live.
The only anger Jesus ever exhibited was toward the religious hypocrites of his day. Are not all these who insult and injure homosexuals guilty of the same hypocrisy? Why are Christians not outraged when those who claim the name of Christ act in the very ways that Christ came to change?
What I do know is that, as a Christian minister and Bible-is-the-Truth believer, we are COMMANDED to hold fast to the Scripture and speak "Truth" to everyone with correction and rebuke with compassion (2 Timothy 4:2). As for Dan Cathy's statements, they may have been "without compassion" towards anyone who is in a situation other than the "Scriptural" view of marriage, but he WAS right in "speaking the Truth" about what the Bible says about what marriage and family SHOULD be. The fact is, we should boldly proclaim that a sin "IS A SIN", but also say that we AND GOD love them just as they are (LOVE the sinner, HATE the sin). That is how God views it, READ THE BIBLE. He is constantly HATING sin and LOVING the sinners (ALL of us).
For us to boycott Chick-Fil-A means we'd have to start going there in the first place, then stop.
To me, all of this is a distraction from Romney not releasing his TAX RETURNS!!!
I want a successful businessman in office, not a community organizer who is a crooked Chicago politician.
Obama cannot even come close to what he promised in his campaign. He is not transparent, he is not a healing force for our nation, he DOES NOT UNITE....HE DIVIDES. It is so obvious too....He does not evoke hope and change........It's deception and more of the same dirty politics.
To Romney....."do NOT release your returns. Please don't. The liberal leftie media will just play political hot potato with them so they can DISTRACT the masses from what really matters....the economy."
And for this Chik-Fil_A stuff.......Free Speech is for EVERYONE not just politically correct ones....
PLEASE EDUCATE ME.
But this is the type of "journalism" one comes to expect on the internet; one attempting to push agenda with specious association, i.e. "Oh, you're family's half German? You must be a Nazi!!"
At the core of the issue is that people supporting the very "hateful" idea of marriage as a union of one man and one woman are the ones speaking truth in love. Others are simply pushing a distortion of reality.
I think you have a lot to learn about Christian love and compassion.
The whole, if you're not for me you're against me, RDICULOUS mentality.
Ironically, you're showing Chik0fil-a/Dan Cathy the hate and discrimitination for HIS beliefs that you say he is giving to the homosexual community.
The picture of hypocrisy.
But I will go try it now. Not because I am against gay people but as an American, I will go there in support of FREE SPEECH.
Don't ya just love when free speech is only for those that are politically correct!
Whose truth? This writer is spot on for those of you that use and abuse your beliefs for your agenda.