iPhone app iPad app Android phone app Android tablet app More

Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Meredith C. Carroll

GET UPDATES FROM Meredith C. Carroll
 

The Moment I Knew I Was A Woman, Not A Girl

Posted: 05/30/2012 9:48 am

I think I thought that getting married would have necessarily turned me into an adult if I weren't one before walking down the aisle. Maybe it's actually immature to think that dressing up like a virginal princess in an effort to demand all eyes on me for a day would make me more and not less mature. Regardless, buying a house and a car and giving birth to a couple of kids afterward should have been sound indicators that I am, in fact, a grown-up.

But as it turns out, I didn't actually realize that I'd fully crossed the threshold from girl to woman until Sunday night. While watching HBO's new series "Girls," perhaps for the first time ever it occurred to me that one of these things is not like the other. As in, I am not like these girls who are just a few years out of college. (Yes, the "Girls" girls are fictional, but there are undoubtedly plenty of real equivalents out there.)

Despite the fact that I've been out of college for well over a decade, I still feel like I've been inexplicably stalled on not a few emotional levels. Sure, I regularly do all sorts of adult things, like work for a living, attend 40th-birthday parties for friends, play mahjong, pick up my older daughter from preschool, nurse my baby daughter and shop for things like nonstick aluminum foil and dental toothpicks at places like Costco, but often I'm looking around to see if it seems like anyone else feels like they're playing the part of a grown-up, too.

Like, I wonder if other people are also kind of giggling to themselves at how they're fooling everyone into thinking they're as together as they appear. It's not in a bad way. I adore my life and family. But I'm just not sure when my doughy transition from lost college graduate rose and baked into my life as a responsible adult with a specific direction.

As my husband and I sat on the couch playing Scrabble over the weekend, I remarked for no fewer than the seventh time over the course of two days about how much better our backyard looks when the lawn is mowed (which might actually just make me boring if not necessarily an adult). I wouldn't have wanted to be anywhere else, with anyone else, doing anything else. Especially, say, at a crowded warehouse party in Brooklyn where people were accidentally smoking crack like in the most recent episode of "Girls" (partly because when I lived in Manhattan and made the occasional trip out to Brooklyn, I always made sure to tell someone where I was headed in case something sinister happened and I didn't return).

Part of the appeal of watching certain shows is imagining myself as one of the players. Like, I watch "Bethenny Ever After" and pretend it was, in fact, me who parlayed a watered-down margarita into a custom Tribeca loft. Or that I'm Liz Lemon of "30 Rock" except I command more respect from my staff and am in possession of fewer pairs of grey panties.

I never quite related to the "Sex and the City" ladies, HBO's "Girls" predecessors, because they always seemed so much sadder and older (or more sophisticated?). And now that I'm around the age they were when the show was first on the air (except for Samantha, who even all these years later is still older than I've ever been), I still can't picture myself in their uncomfortable stilettos.

Watching "Girls" makes me not imagine myself as one of them (although, believe me, there have been eerily familiar moments in each episode), but my daughters instead (even though I'm not nearly old enough to be one of their moms). I cringe and feel my heart break as I think of my daughters acting the parts of the "Girls" girls, barely holding down jobs and eking out rent money while their emotional lives are crazily in need of Krazy Glue.

That tells me something. Like, that I'm putting others before me, which must be a sign of maturity, or at least that I'm not a narcissist (although perhaps assuming that every fictional character has something to do with me means I've even more of an egomaniac than I ever realized. Either way).

It seems like adulthood happened somewhere between my mid-20s and now without me noticing, and I literally woke to find myself transformed into a full-grown woman (although it's probably more accurate to call me the tween version of a woman -- like, a twoman -- because I have yet to start carrying a purse).

Still, being a twoman is not a bad place to be if it means I can really appreciate the sight of a freshly mowed lawn. And as far as I can tell, it's certainly preferable to hanging out at a certain warehouse in Brooklyn.

What was the moment you knew you had become an adult woman? Tell us by submitting a video to our "Moment I Knew" series (instructions here).

WATCH: The Moment I Knew I Was A Woman, Not A Girl

 

Follow Meredith C. Carroll on Twitter: www.twitter.com/MCCarroll

FOLLOW WOMEN
 
 
  • Comments
  • 33
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
12:47 AM on 06/04/2012
my mom just realized she was a "woman" how? she was yelling at me (something about me not cleaning my room) and suddenly she lit up like a christmas tree. i ask her "mom? u okay?" and she yelled out yes!!!!! I was a little muddled and didnt bother any longer. dinner time came and she said
"I became a woman today. I yelled at my daughter, and saw me, someone who also didnt want to clean her room and saw myself as how far I came." and then we just ate.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
mmmmikkimac
03:56 AM on 06/03/2012
You know you are a woman when you can support yourself, buy a house, a car all on your own, have your own credit cards, plan and take your own vacations, plan and save for your future and be happy. It is only then that a woman who is happy and decides to marry to enhance what she already has. No woman should be dependent on a man for her survival or to prove she is a woman. As women, mothers, sisters, wives, we need to empower are children and embrace them to do teh best they can in whatever their chosen endeavers.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Katie Wray
12:01 PM on 06/04/2012
we also shouldn't demean the choice some women make to be supported by their husband and raise a family. priorities are subjective.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
mmmmikkimac
05:44 PM on 06/04/2012
Yes. I find that 'older' women who had a husband with a very good job and who was able to stay at home and didn't have to work somehow look down on single women who do have to work and support their children.
Rubberfish
Who needs a stinkin' micro-bio
12:32 AM on 06/03/2012
I'm 38, working, widowed, a mother of 4, and still wondering if there is something you should feel in order to be a woman. I mean, I'm doing all the "adult" things like working, paying bills and raising kids, but I really don't feel much different inside than I did when I was younger and didn't have those kind of responsibilities. Oh well, I guess 40 years from now I'll wonder about what I should feel like in order to feel old. ;-)
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
mmmmikkimac
03:58 AM on 06/03/2012
You are only going thru the motions of what others expect you to be as a woman. See my post I made after yours. It is my own opinion and I don't expect or care if anyone agrees or not, but I think my late Mother would be proud of what I have accomplished on my own and I hope my children and grandchildren are as well.
Rubberfish
Who needs a stinkin' micro-bio
05:17 PM on 06/03/2012
Ok, I read your post, but none of the things you've mentioned -which I've done- make me feel like a woman. I don't know if there is a special "womanly" feeling one should have at some point in life; I just feel like myself, and I'm just fine with that.
10:44 AM on 06/04/2012
yup
photo
LogicMeetsHumor
Don't touch my food!!!
11:50 PM on 06/02/2012
The lack of substance between your legs should have been the first sign...
05:26 AM on 06/03/2012
or the PRESENCE of it.
11:48 PM on 06/01/2012
i loved this article! although it does kind of make me feel silly, because i'm trying to figure out when i became an adult but i'm only 21. idk why, but this awkward limbo between being a teenager and a grown up is getting to me.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Jessica Weber
12:48 AM on 06/06/2012
It's because your not. But that's ok. I'm 30 and just realized I'm not either. Embrace it and live forever. Being an adult, in the traditional sense, is boring.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
hubertandsusan
10:31 PM on 06/01/2012
As long as women my own age refer to me as Sweetie, honey, sweetheart, and Toots, and mistake my husband ( 4 years older ) for my father, I will never feel that I have crossed over to that woman threshold. When I see other women teetering on skinny high heels, smelling like perfume, and having perfect french manicures, and nicely kept purses with credit cards all in their own slots, and no crumbs rolling around in the bottom of a purse full of lipstick without caps on them, I feel more unwomanly. I think feeling like a grown up woman has to do with personality, people's perception of you, and not a numeric threshold.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
mmmmikkimac
04:00 AM on 06/03/2012
take charge of your life and some comparing urself to others or what you think others think a woman should be.
photo
ccselkie
GERONIMO!
03:57 PM on 05/31/2012
This women didn't figure out she was a women until she watched the show "Girls"? Here's a suggestion, stop watching dumb T.V. shows and join the real world.
01:47 PM on 05/31/2012
After I bought my first home (at 25) I felt like I was playing grown-up. For a long time. When I had my first child (33) I became a mother. When my mom died (44) I became an adult. Different stages along the way, yes. But I became a "woman" when I had my first period. I knew that childhood had flown out the window & nothing about me, my body, my life, would ever be the same. Innocence was gone. That was the moment I became a WOMAN. and it sucked.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
mmmmikkimac
04:04 AM on 06/03/2012
Being a woman should make you proud. You become a woman based on 'things' or events in your life. My idea of a woman is when I was no longer dependent on my parents or a man. I raised 5 kids on my own after their father died in an auto accident. I stumbled and fell, and made mistakes, but I bought all of my furniture, all my vehicles, my house, paid for my trip to Gt. Britain, and had my own credit cards and it did it all on my own. I think that is when a 'girl' becomes a 'woman' not when she menstrates or marries or has sex the first time. It is when she is independent of others and happy with her choices in life and when others come into her life, it only enhances it and makes it better.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Katie Wray
12:03 PM on 06/04/2012
so, had circumstances not forced your independence, would you never have become a woman? single motherhood = woman?
01:08 PM on 05/31/2012
I remember thinking on my wedding day how young I was to be getting married, that I really wasn't old enough to be doing this huge thing, but knowing how badly I wanted to be independent (yes, you can be independent and married!). I was 22-years-old at the time. So young, but not, say, Teen Mom young.

At 37 I still don't feel like a woman. I don't even know the definition of woman. When I think of woman I think of my mom, who is a fabulous and high spirited 65 years old. I think of her as a woman not because of her length of life but because of all the things she's accomplished in her life. As a newlywed she put my father on a plane headed for Vietnam. At 27 she had me. She is a life-long military wife. She's moved us from the US to Europe and back again. She provided the emotional and physical support for our small family. For teaching me about feminism and having courage in myself.

Now that she's no longer tugging a surly teenager around I have enjoyed watching her blossom into this amazing new woman. From mom to woman. From picking me up from dance practice to going through her collection of watercolor paintings (she deems them unfit to be seen but I think they're beautiful!).
Randybostonterrier
Calling Republicans down on their BS
08:12 PM on 05/31/2012
Some women don't define their accomplishments as getting married and reproducing. I say when you live by yourself and pay your own bills without any help from parents or a man, you have to become an adult.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
mmmmikkimac
04:06 AM on 06/03/2012
AMEN! Totally agree 1,000% and then some.
07:12 AM on 05/31/2012
I am fascinated by the process by which a girl becomes a woman.

Gone are the days when a girl was handed by father to husband, leaving her childhood home for her married one, to start her life as a woman. For young women nowadays there are so many more ways of making that transition from girlhood to womanhood.

Every teenage girl longs for affirmation that she is on her way towards becoming a woman. Teenager girls often don the clothes, make-up, and mannerisms of a women mistakenly believing that this makes her so. Appearance is such a small part of what it means to be a women, but who is there to teach our daughters this?

We can be. We can spend time with our girls, in the company of other women, doing things that we enjoy together. We can talk about what it was like for us, growing up through our teenage years. We can tell them our stories. We can remember aloud important events that for us marked our progress towards adulthood. We can allow them to overhear and join our conversations, woman to woman. http://ritesforgirls.com/when-does-a-girl-become-a-woman/

You ask about the moment when I knew I was an adult woman - for me I would say it was when I held my dead baby in my arms and knew that I would survive.
06:29 PM on 05/30/2012
Ok time for a guy question. When do you realized that you are not a mature woman and just an old broad? Or is it other individuals that notice it before a woman does.
photo
pixiepotpie
If you can buy an election, you can pay more taxes
11:53 PM on 05/30/2012
What's the difference?
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
signgrrl
design & production
09:02 AM on 05/31/2012
women are pretty self-critical, so i imagine they notice it themselves first.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Jeanette Gabaldon
Accountability Enthusiast
02:52 PM on 05/30/2012
Isn't it amazing how looking on the outside makes a woman realize how much she has grown on the inside? The conversations are no longer one-sided and different views on one subject are discussed and respected. It is a good feeling to grow up but still be a girl at heart. Good for you :) best wishes!
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
signgrrl
design & production
01:56 PM on 05/30/2012
WAIT. i was supposed to be paying attention to that ? sorry, missed the whole thing.
photo
ccselkie
GERONIMO!
03:58 PM on 05/31/2012
You didn't miss anything...
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
signgrrl
design & production
05:05 PM on 05/31/2012
OK, good to know . . . .