iPhone app iPad app Android phone app Android tablet app More

Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Meryl Ain, Ed.D.

GET UPDATES FROM Meryl Ain, Ed.D.
 

Is Public Education Really Free?

Posted: 08/09/2012 2:04 pm

As we look forward to a brand new school year, parents are busily getting their children ready for the first day of school. And that means spending money. The average parent will spend $688 this year equipping children with back to school clothing and supplies. Most schools prepare lists of essential school supplies that parents are required to furnish. Depending on the level of the student, these range from notebooks to laptops.

In our difficult economic environment, this can be a burden to struggling families. According to figures released by the US Census Bureau earlier this year, the median household income is dropping and more Americans are living in poverty -- about 15% of the population.

With more families living below the poverty line since the 1990s, income dropping and rampant unemployment, parents are increasingly concerned about expenses. In the 2012-2013 school budget vote, many districts scaled back programs and cut staff to keep tax increases low. But is public education really free? Just because parents pay taxes doesn't mean that they do not have to contribute to their children's education. In addition to school supplies, here are some of the extras parents are typically paying for:

  • Tissues -- To save district funds, many elementary schools ask parents to send in boxes of tissues and other supplies for use by the entire class.
  • School Spirit wear, such as tee shirts, sweatshirts, sweatpants, etc., are popular items at all levels. Students may be asked to wear these for special events at school.
  • Musical instruments, purchase or rental
  • Sports equipment and uniforms
  • Field Trips
  • Fundraising -- School, PTA, Special Interest, e.g. sports, music, theater.
  • Celebrations, such as birthdays, holidays, special events

What Can Parents Do?

  • For back to school, PTAs can contract to provide boxed set of school supplies by grade at a cost less than shopping for supplies on your own. The school will supply a list of school supplies by grade. For example, Staples does this through http://www.schoolkidz.com. Ask your PTA to investigate this money saving option.
  • Parents can lobby the principal or superintendent of schools and request that fundraising activities be reduced and consolidated. Parents may prefer to write one check for a set amount instead of being compelled into participating in a perpetual round of sales and fundraisers.
  • If parents believe that the cost and incidence of field trips are excessive, parents have the right to question school's field trip practices and ask that guidelines be established to limit frequency, distance, and cost per field trip, e.g., two per grade at a limit of $25. Also, parents should request that they are informed at the beginning of the school year what their expenses will be for field trips.
  • Request that your school limit expectations for children's birthdays at school.
  • Lobby to scale back spirit wear and unnecessary sports paraphernalia, such as sweatshirts and sweat pants. It's hard to say no when everyone else is buying it and your child wants it too.
  • Volunteer with your presence and skills at school and at special events and fundraisers instead of with your pocketbook.
  • Parents should know that all schools provide help to families who cannot afford school-associated expenses. Don't be afraid to ask your principal if you need financial assistance.
 

Follow Meryl Ain, Ed.D. on Twitter: www.twitter.com/DrMerylAin

FOLLOW EDUCATION
As we look forward to a brand new school year, parents are busily getting their children ready for the first day of school. And that means spending money. The average parent will spend $688 this year ...
As we look forward to a brand new school year, parents are busily getting their children ready for the first day of school. And that means spending money. The average parent will spend $688 this year ...
 
 
  • Comments
  • 16
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
05:02 PM on 08/13/2012
No one has mentioned transportation fees or bus passes. I know people spending over three hundred dollars per year, per kid for school bus access. That is not for field trips or away games. That's is for bus transportation to and from public school. How this does not constitute tuition is beyond me.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
11:40 AM on 08/13/2012
Public education is not free as it cost around $15k per student. This is one of the reason why school vouchers are needed.
04:55 AM on 08/11/2012
What a silly question. Let me show you the breakdown of my Michigan property tax bill......
01:50 AM on 08/11/2012
How do I get to your school? Teachers at my school buy their own tissue, wipes, hand sanitizer, copy paper, and lots of other supplies. For field trips, we donate items for fundraiser, and chip in to pay the difference out of our own pocket. Classroom teachers have prizes that include books and school supplies they can use to do homework. Our PTA does fundraisers all year and contacts local charities and businesses to provide backpacks, shoes, clothes, coats, and food. Please send us some of those parents!
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Konnie
Really South Carolina??
07:38 PM on 08/10/2012
don't forget your competitive teachers who coerce students into constant competitions with other schools. a band parent can log hundreds of miles and shell out hundreds of dollars in gas and food for these required weekly away trips and the constant back and forth of all year practices on top of the private lessons required to participate.. same for track, pom poms, dance teams, choir, tennis, table tennis, soccer, rugby etc. the days of taking an extraciricular class to learn something or utilize a talent are long gone.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
see-ellen2001
10:30 AM on 08/10/2012
The Ontario, Canada, school board I work for states to parents that the provided list of supplies is not mandatory. The school provides supplies as needed. The school I work in does sometimes have a small fee for field trips, but buses are covered out of the budget. Any activity that the family can't afford they can approach the principal privately and it is covered. I don't know what kind of school puts laptops on their supply list!
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Konnie
Really South Carolina??
07:47 PM on 08/10/2012
another reason Canada is superior..............here in the lower less evolved "merka" we think that educating all the students for the betterment of the country is just silly. the ruling class thinks everything should be private and only the wealthy should have access to general knowledge, everyone else is on their own. and like an vending machine should have to insert their coins for everything from entrance to the bathroom, access to toilet paper, the soap to wash their hands if they choose, to pass thru the library for a charge, and be charged again for the priviledge of having a table and chair. there is money in them there chillin' and they intend to wring out every penny.
07:54 PM on 08/20/2012
True, but we always manage to run out of Kleenex by about February...I wish parents would donate some!
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
JustinP213
I dislike all political parties.
09:22 AM on 08/10/2012
Public education, of course, isn't free. NJ, where I live, has the highest property taxes in the country. Yes, the schools are usually good, but around 60-70 percent of the property bill is for schools.
09:06 AM on 08/10/2012
I just bought 150 folders, 1000 pencils, 30 big erasers, 600 small erasers, 30 boxes of crayons, 30 boxes of colored pencils, index cards and post its, still looking to get pencil sharpeners and pencil boxes, all on my own dime as a teacher. In previous years I've already bought scissors, rulers, glue sticks, highlighters, and paper. I don't think that it's too much to ask that the students bring in their own notebook and pencil...

You know why field trips are so expensive? It's the buses. Even on a field trip within town we have to get a bus which costs $198 each.
09:40 PM on 08/09/2012
So only field trips you feel are affordable are okay?
Hmm, some kids cannot afford snacks so no snacks should be allowed. Some kids are from homes with no car so no car drop-offs allowed. Oh, shoot! We just learned some kids cannot afford lunch and their parents didn't get them signed up for free lunch. Gosh, I hope the other kids aren't hungry.
Oh, by the way, you cannot "require" parents to even supply a single pencil. Our schools (FL) request pencils, pens, filler parer, two reams of copy paper, tissues, hand sanitizer, colored pencils, crayons, and on and on. You cannot even ASK in class. This does save me from buying ALL the supplies myself, as a few parents actually send the supplies in.
Oh, and if I may, shall I mention those fundraisers pay for the students who cannot afford field trips to go. Every cent goes to aid students specifically BECAUSE many could not afford extras, field trips, backpacks, uniforms, school spirit shirts, etc.
PS: Nothing is free and there is no Santa. Well, the PTA often steps in for Santa- but I'm not sure how if parents follow your advice.
07:07 PM on 08/09/2012
My school does not legally "require" anything. I end up paying for everything as a teacher. Just dropped over $100 on pencils, paper, binders, and yes, tissues. I sympathize with families as I serve a low-income community, but nothing I'm asking for is anywhere near $688. I don't think it's crazy to get your kid to school with some pencils. And when you don't, I'll take care of it. But think of that next time you're on the news blaming teachers for all of the world's ills.
10:22 PM on 08/09/2012
I'm all with you. It's my opinion that parents who can't afford it should not be allowed to have a second child. I know this one couple who keeps popping out kids (4 as of now) despite not being able to feed them or even buy them school supplies. I know teachers buy all these things just in case for this situation...but it should not happen.
Allthosewhowander
My micro-bio is a microclimate
03:10 PM on 08/09/2012
Many of the most basic resources are being paid for by teachers and parents as districts do not supply them anymore. Paper, pencils, etc. The superintendent of my district has a car that he uses and all expenses are paid for by the district. He also has a healthy 6 figure salary.
04:58 AM on 08/11/2012
Schools NEVER provided supplies for me...but hey, I am only 56 years old, so maybe you're talking about "the good old days."
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
08:49 PM on 08/12/2012
I remember the school having rolls of colored paper for bulletein boards and SCA posters in high school, and crayons, glue,newsheets etc when I was in elementary school. I still had to get my own personal supplies ( notebook paper, pencils, notebooks etc), but there were office supplies in the classroom as well. I dunno, maybe the teacher bought them, or the PTA, but I do think there was a budget, albeit a small one.