iPhone app iPad app Android phone app Android tablet app More

Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Meryl Davids Landau

GET UPDATES FROM Meryl Davids Landau
 

Does The James Arthur Ray Trial Mean There's No Law Of Attraction?

Posted: 06/12/11 01:37 PM ET

Now that the Arizona manslaughter trial against James Arthur Ray is gearing up for a verdict, one thing is certain: Ray -- who came to fame riding the coattails of the law of attraction in the movie, "The Secret" -- sure doesn't seem to be putting the law to work for him.

For anyone not familiar, the law of attraction is the "New Thought" teaching (actually more than a hundred years old) popularized by Ray and others in the movie. Oprah featured the cast, including Ray, on her show. The premise behind the law is that what you think about and what comes into your life is always a match, energy-wise. Think poverty and wealth won't flow to you, the theory goes; spend time envisioning a great career, and the job of your dreams will appear. It definitely sounds weird at first blush -- and is made even odder by the fact that its primary advocate is a woman who channels -- Esther Hicks. (Her Law of Attraction book is a New York Times bestseller.)

The fact that Ray would "attract" the deaths of three participants, allegedly from overheating, in his sweat lodge during a October 2009 "Spiritual Warrior" event, and, subsequently, the criminal trial where he potentially faces a dozen years behind bars, might seem to negate the prospect of the law's existence. Indeed, the Twitterati is ablaze with sneers that Ray's predicament means exactly that.

At one time I might have agreed. But I have seen the law work so perfectly in my own life that I've become an enthusiastic convert. Watching its incredible effects on myself and those around me has enticed me to research the teachings more closely. Here are some things I've discovered -- and why the James Ray situation doesn't change a thing.

1. The law responds to energy, not isolated wishes. There's a feel-good moment in "The Secret" when a young boy asks for a bicycle, and quickly receives one. Things aren't quite that simple in the real world. First, there's a time delay, so you rarely manifest your creations the moment you ponder them. Second, it isn't your words that matter. The law is misunderstood by many to be comparable to affirmations or positive thinking. But it isn't the upbeat words you say or think that brings things to you; it's your overall energetic "set-point" about a given topic. What the law does is draw similar energies together, like magnets. When you feel happy, for example, that happy vibration brings other joyful events and people into your sphere. Same with feeling prosperous or lucky -- or, by contrast, feeling victimized or angry.

2. Your expectation is most important. What really moves the energy needle are your core beliefs or expectations. Which brings us back to Ray. It's true he lectured and wrote about attracting good fortune and prosperity to himself. But he's the only one in position to know if he truly expected that. Don't think an upbeat spiritual teacher can actually feel like an under-confident fraud? You must have missed Oprah's televised February reunion with self-help guru Iyanla Vanzant. In her many TV appearances and her bestselling books, Vanzant had long emphasized that loving yourself is what most matters. Yet here she was, confessing that she'd needed Oprah's validation to feel whole. "I just wanted you to say you liked me and you never did," a teary Vanzant recounted. It's no surprise that the law of attraction piled onto Vanzant's sense of being unloved: Within a few years she lost her book deals, money and even her marriage.

3. Your feelings reveal your focus. Walk around boasting about how you're about to win the lottery and you may convince others of its possibility. But is that helping you manifest more money in your real life? The key is how you are feeling. When you buy objects, pay bills, or think about your money throughout the day, are you joyful and expectant, or fearful and sad? If the former, you're at the prosperity "set point" level needed for those lottery-winnings to flow to you; keep it up and it eventually will, even if your wallet is currently empty.

4. There's no blaming the victim involved. Some complain that this law seems to blame people for their bad predicaments. I have come to see that it can empower them, instead. Once you understand how the law operates, you can use it to shift unhappy circumstances rather than feel defeated and stuck. A friend of mine had one disappointing boyfriend after another. She could have bemoaned her horrible fate, but knowing the law, she realized it was her energetic expectation that the next one would be awful that kept shoveling these bad dates in. She changed her expectation, and a great guy (now husband) followed. In some cases there isn't so direct a correlation. It's not that someone expects to get cancer; it's that they spend much of their time feeling angry or disempowered about life, which attracts other, similarly low-vibration creations, including diseases.

5. Denying its existence doesn't stop it. Just because you didn't learn about the law of attraction in school doesn't mean you can ignore its effects. This law is powerful, so you might as well at least experiment with harnessing it. As Esther Hicks observes, if you didn't believe in gravity, you still wouldn't be able to leap up and fly away. Test the law by noticing that what comes to you is, at its core, an energetic match to what you are anticipating. Don't like what you see? Tweak what you expect and watch what follows.

6. Action gets you to your destination. The law of attraction does not mean you can sit on your couch all day waiting for the universe to drop goodies from the ceiling. Life doesn't work that way. When you're an energetic match to your desired creation, you are inspired to act in a way that brings desired results. It's similar to the "liquid luck" potion that Harry Potter drinks in book six. Although Harry needs to seek out Professor Slughorn for crucial information, after drinking the potion he decides the right thing is to head for the gamekeeper Hagrid's hut. By following his inspiration, he runs into Slughorn and learns everything he needs to know. When you're feeling good and get a strong impulse to call someone or head someplace, that's the law of attraction at play. You'd be wise to follow the trail.

Ultimately, then, the James Ray trial doesn't say anything about the truth of the law of attraction. It only says something about Ray: That if he does sincerely believe in the power of this universal principle, he somehow didn't put it into practice as well as he might have.

Edited to add: On June 22, Ray was convicted of negligent homicide for the deaths of three of his sweat-lodge participants.

 
 
 

Follow Meryl Davids Landau on Twitter: www.twitter.com/MerylDL

Now that the Arizona manslaughter trial against James Arthur Ray is gearing up for a verdict, one thing is certain: Ray -- who came to fame riding the coattails of the law of attraction in the movie, ...
Now that the Arizona manslaughter trial against James Arthur Ray is gearing up for a verdict, one thing is certain: Ray -- who came to fame riding the coattails of the law of attraction in the movie, ...
 
 
  • Comments
  • 45
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Bloggers
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2  Next ›  Last »  (2 total)
09:50 AM on 07/12/2011
I was very happy to come across this article - it expresses my feelings exactly. The one thing I want to add is that I went to two James Ray workshops - not the mind blowing - sit in the desert & meditate ones - just the weekend 'pump you up' run of the mill ones. In his presentation he tells you of two fateful events in his life where he has once nearly killed himself in a motorcycle accident and second lost everything he owned and his relationship; two powerful life changing events. Then he goes through the process of rebuilding himself mentally-physically and spiritually. So it seems to me that this third event is history repeating itself again with James. There is some lesson he fails to see so he keeps attracting disaster in various forms to himself. Sadly he involved the lives of others this time and it's rather hearbreaking. Or maybe not - I think the universe is far more complicated than we realize - these people who died also had some part to play in this lesson. Maybe it was simply their time to go and they fulfilled their life here on Earth by leaving him with another powerful lesson to sort through on their way out.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
DeniseDuffieldThomas
Coach and Author of Lucky B*tch
06:59 PM on 06/26/2011
This is a great article, I really liked the way you explained it. I'm a life coach and I teach a lot about the Law of Attraction with my clients purely because I've seen some unbelievable things happen in my life.
Some thoughts:
The healthier I am, the easier it is to manifest, especially when I'm doing yoga regularly.
When I take time out (especially away from my computer), life flows better and I can attract more easily.
When you ask for help or ideas for the next step, they always come if you're willing to listen.
03:05 PM on 06/23/2011
What twaddle. Newsflash: magic doesn't exist, even if you call it a "Law".
12:14 AM on 06/23/2011
For those who have read the original books on the subject of the law of attraction from the early 1900s, there is a clear warning NOT to misuse it to control others. James Ray obviously didn't read those books or ignored them.

And everything Abraham Hicks says they "channeled" they actually just adapted from old out of print books as well. So give the credit where it is truly owed. Atkinson, Wattles, Collier, Hill, etc.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
02:52 PM on 06/20/2011
So little has been put on Huffpo about this startling story, i appreciate you trying to tackle it.
You do not really mention the TRUE victims in explaining why this tragedy is not a judgment on the*Law of Attraction* - and i find this detachment just a little creepy- sort of why people are questioning this in the first place.
I mean none of this argument is germane without these well intentioned people having perished in persuit of THEIR dreams, their "Manifesting".
If the *Law of Attraction* does not inherently blame the victim, then what exactly happened to the ACTUAL victims of James Rays manifestations for wealth?
Surely they made some mis-calculation about their own desires and what they wanted?
These people were obviously highly motivated, and if not "adepts", they were not the slackers who you describe as "sitting on your couch all day waiting for the universe to drop goodies from the ceiling."
No, these earnest people, according to the Law of Attraction, were doing everything they had been told to do, payed all the money, fasted, prayed, etc. and aside from dying, what DID they do wrong? .
I have my own opinion about what they did wrong, give me yours, please.
Thanks,
GAB
photo
awesmpwrca
That which is like unto itself is drawn...
02:52 PM on 07/07/2011
GetAbike,

The term 'victim' fails to see individual responsibility. We are each RESPONSIBLE for our own experiences. The seemingly difficult reality is that each of us, including the three from AZ, make choices. This is not to say Ray did not have a responsibility in the process, but the reality is, those that died made choices, to attend the event, to go into the sweat lodge, etc. Responsibility and outcome of those choices always rests on the individual...period.

I understand the depth of your questioning and to explain in detail all the workings that lead to the outcome of this event, would be numerous. I ask you to simply be open to seeing that each of us, no matter what the outcome, makes choices, and we must take personal responsibility for those choices...no blame, no victim.

You state "according to the LOA, were doing everything they had been told to do..." "what DID they do wrong?" They did nothing 'wrong', yet they did make choices. And doing everything they had been told to do has nothing to do with LOA. If someone tells you to 'jump off a cliff'...do you do it? No matter if you do or don't, you make a personal 'choice' prior to your action. We must understand ultimately our outcomes are based on our personal choices. LOA aligns with our vibration (thoughts, feelings) and creates a perfect match...no exceptions.
07:29 AM on 06/20/2011
Thanks, Meryl, for a great article. This should be required reading for anyone wanting to apply the Law of Attraction to their lives.

I have a question: can (should?) a Christian apply the Law of Attraction (and the other supporting universal laws) to their life? Any opinions?

(Please, this is not a request to attack Christianity or its followers).

Jesse Rowe
http://twitter.com/loafc
www.theuniversallawsforchristians.blogspot.com
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
Meryl Davids Landau
author of Downward Dog, Upward Fog
12:25 PM on 06/20/2011
Hi Jesse:

Glad you like the article. I don't see why people of any religion can't apply the law of attraction. My spiritual women's novel, Downward Dog, Upward Fog, which features law of attraction, along with spiritual principles (like mindfulness and acceptance), and yoga, is not religious, but I've heard from some religious women that they really enjoyed the book.

If you believe (as I do) that the law of attraction is always operating in your life, then you really have only two choices in terms of what comes to you: Creating by intention or creating by default. And creating by intention is so much more satisfying, whatever your religious beliefs.
photo
awesmpwrca
That which is like unto itself is drawn...
03:18 PM on 07/07/2011
If you believe or you don't believe in LOA, truth is it already is operating through you, no exceptions. If you're Christian or Atheist, Buddhist or Muslim, the LOA already operates within you, no choice to 'apply' available....just as there is no choice to 'apply' gravity when needed or not. It is a choice however, to use LOA as you say Meryl, with intention /consciously or default / unconsciously.

And yes, I also give great thanks to Meryl for writing the article!!! The experience of James Ray has nothing to do with the validity of LOA...and has everything to do with the demonstration of the LOA. Bravo Meryl, Bravo!

And only the very best to James Ray and each of us as we navigate the experiences of our lives. And to the those who transitioned from Sedona, thank you for gracing our physical world with your brief yet most important existence.
photo
Ytrus
''it's a map''
03:39 PM on 06/20/2011
Please don't. I don't want Jesus to return and destroy civilization just because a Christian really wants it to happen.

In fact, maybe if I use the Law of Attraction, everyone will magically become an atheist.
03:19 PM on 06/18/2011
The main reason this happened to Mr Ray is because those in power who wanted to keep The Secret a 'secret' were angry that the principles were finally openly revealed to the public. They OWN the media. They OWN the voting computers. They OWN all the money you spend. They OWN America and they wanted revenge because the principles contained in The Secret were NOT supposed to be openly revealed to the public. Go to YouTube and watch the first 20 minutes of The Secret. Those scenes about the super-rich being determined to keep the principles of The Secret from the public were no joke! There is a great body of evidence that the political arena you see in the media is a sham to fool the ignorant. The big banking families own America and they OWN the political computers. THEY determine who gets elected, not the public. The reason Obama was put into office was to try to throw the general public off the 'scent' created by people like Alex Jones.

There is a great body of evidence that THEY have been using the basic principles of The Secret combined with blood-drinking black magic rituals in order to enslave the minds of the ignorant peasant world.

July is soon upon us and they should be performing another magical 'cremation of care' ritual in Bohemian Grove so that for the rest of the year THEY DON'T CARE how much the ignorant peons suffer because of their greedy decisions!
08:21 AM on 06/18/2011
I’m shocked and amazed by what I saw in Mr Li’s closing arguments. The prosecution convicted and sent Mr Ray to jail without thoroughly examining the full medical record examination evaluations from the doctors who did the ‘hands on’ work upon everyone who was injured or died from the sweat lodge event! They just decided those three died of heatstroke and ignored all evidence to the contrary!

THIS IS INDEED A CRIME COMMITTED BY THE REPRESENTATIVE OF THE STATE OF ARIZONA!

THEY SHOULD GO TO JAIL FOR THIS CRIME!

The honorable keep their written promises even if corrupt lawyers and judges give them the option to break those promises. The dishonorable do not deserve to be protected from the promises they may make in writing, period!
01:48 AM on 06/18/2011
i was pondering, the people who died in the "tipi" did they not have a door to walk out from? this trial doesnt say anything about Ray, it says everything about the noobs who decided to stay.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
03:09 PM on 06/20/2011
Wow. Harsh.
If you had been following the trial even peripherally, you would know that the issues that makes this trial ALL ABOUT James Ray, is the control he has over his followers, his instructions to them at this event, and his lack of action and preparation for the "noobs"- the people otherwise known as the victims.
sheesh.
08:32 AM on 06/17/2011
I try to teach my students that their beliefs can hold them back as strongly as anything else in life. I remind them to expect the best, even when things look the worst. If they make it a habit, they stand a chance of having a better future. Read: http://spiritualteaching.wordpress.com/2009/11/09/just-a-reminder/
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
KellyRyan
A micro-bio for one who has none.
09:28 PM on 06/15/2011
Rather than discuss new age non-sense, let's discuss the law. Whether civil or criminal, James Arthur Ray had a, "duty of care."

He defaulted on both.
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
Meryl Davids Landau
author of Downward Dog, Upward Fog
10:27 AM on 06/16/2011
I don't see why we can't discuss both: the metaphysical aspects and the legal ones. Just because Ray energetically called this situation to himself doesn't mean he won't, or shouldn't, bear the social consequences of his actions. The jury will determine--as early as tomorrow, from what I see of the trial--whether he indeed defaulted on that duty, and Ray will continue to pay the price for both his negative energy and his seemingly irresponsible actions. All is as it should be.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
HowardFalco
Spiritual Teacher & Author of 'I AM'
06:00 PM on 06/15/2011
The whole idea of the law of attraction is to show you how life is always working for you. That is YOU the reader of these words. You cannot escape this law and it doesn't need to be verified because it just is. To know why James Ray attracted this into his life you would have to know every one of his thoughts, experiences, fears and beliefs. More interesting and relevant is that you attracted this blog and these words to yourself, why? Most likely your curiosity about how you can understand this a bit more and use it to create what fulfills you at the deepest level. You have asked questions and for this moment this is how your reality has responded with a critical piece of the information.

The amazing thing about life is that it doesn't matter what you have attracted or created in your life up until this moment (this goes for James ray as well). All that ever matters is who you decide to be right now and what steps you are willing to take to demonstrate this state of "being" to the universe. It is the only thing the universe responds to. This requires a faith in the way life unfolds and an understanding that things don't happen "to" you they happen "for" You. When you come to this level of trust with the universe that has given you and everything else life, the journey gets a bit more magical.
photo
Ytrus
''it's a map''
01:57 PM on 06/15/2011
Is there any evidence that suggests that the Law of Attraction works better than chance? Like, actual scientific evidence, that's reproducible and verifiable in some way?

The answer is no, right? You can't provide evidence for it, can you? What a shock.
06:31 PM on 06/18/2011
Better than chance? when you understand what it is - you understand the 2 can't coexist -- there is no such thing as chance. "Chance" "luck" and "random" are words scientists and other people use when they don't understand HOW something happened.

Some religious people might say: "god did it" and scientists say: "it's random chance"

point in fact: law of attraction
Just look in your own life. Next time something big happens good or bad - the moment it happens try to remember to look over what your predominant thoughts and feelings were in the days leading up to it -- my girlfriend and i do it all the time - and now when one of us gets on a complaining streak and then something happens like we spill our coffee or lose something - we just laugh because it ALWAYS makes sense.

the only reason - i think - people can still believe in chance is because the media and movie makers distort reality. When someone is murdered they just get the sensational sob story with the neighbors: oh he was a great guy -- but no one does any investigating into the background of the person in the days and weeks leading up to that event -- you'd see that there isn't any CHANCE that someone can just randomly pick you and get you.

Is there evidence? yeah - it's all around. Look in your life.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
03:15 PM on 06/20/2011
Well, when i buy a powerball ticket, i may want Law of Attraction to work for me (dear god: oh please! oh please!) just like everyone else, but in the end, winning will be determined by chance.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
FreedToChoose
...lest my wife says I'm not.
09:07 PM on 06/14/2011
"Does the James Arthur Ray Trial Mean There's No Law of Attraction?" No.
For a law to be valid it must be tested by experiment, not by anecdote.. The problem with squishy-wishy pronouncements is that they encourage people to trade personal responsibility for the dictates of others... and if you buy my position, you may be at risk. Think for thyself.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
aprilinheaven
Be the change you wish to see in the world.
01:55 PM on 06/14/2011
The truth is that none of us commenting here have any idea what all of these souls are up to. I went to one of James' paid events. I felt it was trans formative, dynamic, and shockingly, refreshingly honest - a combination of things I needed. James was an effective teacher to me and as I've watched this unfold, I've tried to remember that I have no idea what James' soul, or Kirby Brown, James Shore, or Liz Neuman's souls were doing in that tent. I've tried to merely observe, take responsibility for my own thoughts, pray for all involved, and know it's unfolding exactly as it should. How else can it.