iPhone app iPad app Android phone app Android tablet app More

Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Mia Redrick

GET UPDATES FROM Mia Redrick
 

Are You a Hovering Parent?

Posted: 03/ 1/2012 12:36 pm

We've all heard the term "helicopter mom" to describe moms that are over-protective and overly involved in their children's daily activities. For those of you who have encountered a hovering mother, it is probably apparent that she is the last to realize that her need to stay informed, be involved, or to move things along is a tad over-board. These moms frequently over-stay their welcome and hyper-manage everything.

I've witnessed this behavior in friends, clients and parents at school. Most of the time, I've said very little so as to respect the parent's perspective and to avoid passing judgment -- although secretly, I was thinking something quite different. Personally, I have been called over-protective because, for example, I haven't wanted the children to see R-rated movies or because I feel that Facebook isn't a birthright just because you are a pre-teen.

I was recently at one of my children's extra-curricular activities and I witnessed a mom completing her child's homework. I could see that this mom's motivation was rooted in love and wanting her child to do well, but it crosses the line when mommy decides to submit her academic ability instead of the child's. What is behind this behavior?

In the book The Go-To Mom's Parents' Guide to Emotion Coaching Young Children, Kimberly Blaine says: "Parents who have a strong need to hyper-parent, to hover, or to control their child's environment, usually have some un-met need that makes them feel helpless and out of control. A parent's tendency to over-protect and shield a child from the world may be a way of regaining control that one lost in his past."

Or, as many of us have speculated, these parents are filling some inner need by living vicariously through their children and want everything to go well because it didn't go well for them as a child.

What I find equally as interesting is that while it is often thought that hovering only happens with mothers of young children (or at least children still in the home), many mothers continue to want the same access and influence over their adult children's lives -- a particularly disturbing phenomenon.

If you are wondering if you're a "helicopter mom," here are some warning signs:

  • You are frequently suspicious of the people that care for your child. This might be a teacher, babysitter, girlfriend or even a spouse.
  • You feel that no one can meet the needs of your child as well as you.
  • You feel validated most as a mother when you rescue your child from harm.
  • You impose your ideas on your children frequently.
  • You might help complete your child's homework without being asked, volunteer to help your child with something although they don't need your help, or force your child to accept your help.
  • In your free time, you consistently reflect on the terrible things that could be happening to or with your child because you're not there to supervise.
  • You experience boundaries like scheduled visits with teachers and planned visit requests with family members as rude and intrusive.

This is indeed a touchy subject but we all know that when you have experienced a parent, relative or mother in-law that hovers, you wish that they would just realize how distrustful and overbearing it makes them seem. If you see yourself in some of these areas, I would encourage you to ask yourself: How can I experience another perspective? Also, please consider the long-term affects of hovering.

Blaine says: "Hyper-parenting can have some pretty serious repercussions. When children are shielded from every benign aspect of life they never learn to be responsible for themselves - they become overly reliant on others and have a hard time trusting their own instincts. They may see the world as an unsafe place to live. When we hover, the message our children receive is, "You're not capable." Children are very capable and deserve the right to live securely in this world."

To learn more about Kimberly Blaine, go to:

www.TheGoToMom.com
or
www.EmotionCoachingYoungChildren.com

 
 
 

Follow Mia Redrick on Twitter: www.twitter.com/Mia_Redrick

 
 
  • Comments
  • 20
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
10:58 AM on 03/03/2012
SuperCopter,

is also hovering around. Passengers are welcomed aboard for a nice pleasant trip.

Hey Buddy, it seemed you've written your own flight manual.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Kate Perez
10:38 PM on 03/02/2012
At the school I teach in, we call that "smother mother". Not trying to be mean, but you HAVE to put your children's needs first and a sense of independence a competence is a need as children get older.
02:50 PM on 03/02/2012
Great article Mia! I see the hover in the attention to snacks provided to kids in after school groups, too. The Hover Mom is the one organizing the list of people who will be responsible to bring snacks for the kids. I'm not against snacks for kids, mind you, I just think the kids should decide that they might need one because they got hungry not because their mom has always made sure there was one available. And if they find that they need a snack, then it's great to just include one for your child at his or her request. I love the way a little pinch (or hunger pain) helps a kid learn how to arrive in life prepared.
01:16 PM on 03/02/2012
didnt some collage kid call his parents cuz he smelled smoke in his dorm building? not the cops or the fire department... his parents?

couldnt that be a side effect of Hovering Parent's, i've seen it in both parents not just mom. that your kid has been so micro managed that they dont even know to call the cops/fire department if they smell smoke or think something bad is gonna happen?

just my thoughts.
11:02 AM on 03/02/2012
•You feel that no one can meet the needs of your child as well as you.

Because as a parent, esp a mother, no one can!
photo
360Dunk
Feeder of slot machines
11:01 AM on 03/02/2012
So the message I'm getting here is that mothers should not hover over their children during their romantic honeymoon. Good info to file away.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
dancerctry
I love Gardening and Decorating
09:56 AM on 03/02/2012
"•You impose your ideas on your children frequently."

While I agree the others can harm a child's development I must not understand what she means by this? Maybe it's the word "impose". It's called raising a kid to TEACH them your ideas and how you concluded them. Ex. how did you decide eating your veggies are a good idea? But if the author means "always telling them what they SHOULD BE DOING then I understand why it's included. It's one thing to take a kid who isn't eating and say "you should eat something" it's another to be saying "you should be taking piano lessons as well as art classes and playing basketball".

It's important to let them explore the world and form their own ideas of it but, especially when they are little, they need guidance. Playing in your toy box, good playing in the garbage, bad. A kid won't know not to play in garbage unless you tell them not to and why not to. This bullet has a gray area and needs to either be reworded, or better explained.
09:32 AM on 03/02/2012
I am soooo a helicopter mom to the T. Not proud of it and did alot of damage. Kids are too dependant, personalities are too similar to mine, they question their actions, afraid to grow up, still dependant and they are over 20. So if you are a helicopter mom stop now. Its not doing them any good.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
victorzeller
07:54 AM on 03/02/2012
Learn how to be a parent first. Teach your kids respect, discipline and manners.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
MrTaban9
07:29 AM on 03/02/2012
We've all heard the term "helicopter mom"

We have? I haven't!, although I have often heard of the term "Helicopter Mechanic" that would be "Me!" fixed them up in VietNam so as our wounded & dead soliders could be quickly airlifted to med hospitals in the field/base camps.
photo
Shira Adler
aka Diva Mama www.Diva-Mama.com/Aromatherapy
02:23 PM on 03/01/2012
Love this article & Kimberly Blaine. I have leanings of being a helicopter mom but try to refrain from overdoing it. For example, I shared in my blog this week what my own initial emotional response was regarding Angelina Jolie's right leg and how that image would affect my tween daughter. I'd love your comments Mia and Kimberly (or any other constructive or open hearted person who wishes to share): www.Diva-Mama.com
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
EmCeePee
09:38 AM on 03/02/2012
Jolie is much older than your tween-aged daughter, so she probably isn't a role model for her. Jolie also probably isn't a family friend, so there's no personal connection with you or your daughter.

Thus, I ask: Why would any image of Jolie's right leg (or anyone's right leg) affect your tween daughter? My question is meant to be constructive by being thought-provoking.

Are these questions helpful?

-- Why are you blogging about Jolie's leg?
-- Why should your daughter be affected?
-- Why are you concerned about how your daughter might react to an image of stranger's leg?
-- What might this be about besides your daughter?

Think about the effort, concern, and time you have invested in this non-important topic about someone you don't know and somehow linking it to your child.

Best of luck. Parenting is the most important thing any of us do. And none of us is perfect. Bit by bit. Day by day. Task by task. Hug by hug.

(I do hope we all try to be open-hearted (?) persons -- and not just on our best days.)
photo
Shira Adler
aka Diva Mama www.Diva-Mama.com/Aromatherapy
12:20 PM on 03/02/2012
Thank you so much for taking the time to respond. Of course, I always appreciate thoughtful comments. I am wondering were you able to actually read the linked blog that I wrote? I think all of your answers will be found therein. If/when you do, please feel free to leave another comment on my site directly under the blog. You can find my aforementioned blog (entitled Zaftig, the new Sexy) at http://diva-mama.com/

Also, on a related note, another mom blogger (one of my favorites, Liz Gumbinner) http://www.mom-101.com/ had her daughters serve as guest bloggers for an altogether different kind of piece from mine. However the young girls most definitely shared THEIR take on the Oscar fashions so I dare say it is more than expected that our daughters are exposed, and have visceral responses to the body images as portrayed in all forms of media and entertainment.

Wishing you a wonderful day.
10:14 AM on 03/02/2012
Being a former teacher, I would do one of two things: either wait for your daughter to bring it up and have an open dialogue with her about it and what she thinks it means, or you can approach it and say something like "she sure looks cold in that dress, what do you think?" Tweens are more likely to discuss when they feel that their ideas are valid and being looked for rather than just a "don't ever do that" type of thing. But it is also based on your daughter and how willing she is to share on a regular basis. While we do have to guide them and make sure that they are safe and secure, tweens and teens often listen to us and our guidance more than they would ever admit to publicly. Talking openly and honestly is always best and I'm sure your daughter appreciates having a mom that wants to let her be her own person with her own ideas. :)
01:46 PM on 03/01/2012
Great post. I think you did a really good job explaining why parents might be inclined to hover and what dangers that hovering poses. I'm not sure why our generation of parents has such trouble letting go. I
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
EmCeePee
09:49 AM on 03/02/2012
Your question is so important -- "why our generation of parents has such trouble letting go." I'm sure it is not a majority of parents, but it does seem much more the case than 20-30 years ago.

Are we simply bring to be better parents than we had?
Does the modern and near-future world require us to do more and better parenting?
Are we simply more aware of or smarter about the dangers that have always been present?
Have we covertly manipulated by some forces (media, peer group, religion, politicians)?
Are we compensating for our fears of inadequacy as a parent--our potential failure to all that we can?
Has the role of parent changed from a rather passive and benevolent model to a more aggressive and demanding model? Parent as coach or boss? Parent as a "tiger?"

Or is this just a problem for some parents, of some children, some of the time?
11:21 AM on 03/02/2012
We probably feel guilty. Many of our moms were home and were full-time moms. We have jobs and lives of our own - so, when we do take time out to parent we have to parent to the max. Just a thought.

Also, I noticed that cultural differences come into play with parenting style. I am Italian-American and we Italian-Americans are much more directly involved. Many of the kids my son attends school with are Irish-American. I notice many of these parents pretty much cut their kids loose as soon as they are in pre-school. I am not judgeing mind you, I am just making an observation. So, what in one culture seems normal and nurturing may seem hovery to another culture. I must say though, completing a child's homework is over the top for anyone. In fact, I would call it heat seeking missile parenting instead of helicopter parenting. LOL
03:08 PM on 03/02/2012
I don't know about the guilt. I don't hear that from most of my working mom friends and I don't think I feel guilty, but I do have trouble letting go. My challenge isn't so much the hovering as it is making sure that I give my children the emotional distance they need so that they can learn to make their own choices and succeed or fail based on those choices. I'm sure that cultural differences comen into play as well!
01:37 PM on 03/01/2012
Great article, Mia. I think I have been on both ends of the spectrum here. I think a balance is much better for the children and MOM!
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
seattleite4
Don't believe everything you think.
10:29 AM on 03/02/2012
Ha, me too! But I have also been on both ends as a teacher and mother. Sometimes it is hard to know just how much help one needs. I see this with parents of students too and it is very hard to tell a parent that they need to allow their child to struggle a little. There are lessons to be learned through the struggle and they come out knowing they can do it rather than thinking a "rescue" is in order.