iPhone app iPad app Android phone app Android tablet app More

Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Michael J.W. Stickings

Michael J.W. Stickings

Posted: October 22, 2010 12:12 PM

Calgary Elects Muslim Mayor

What's Your Reaction:

Calgary, a deeply conservative city in the heart of the most conservative province in Canada, the city that pretty much drives Canadian conservatism, has elected ... a Muslim mayor?

Many of you may not appreciate the significance of this. For the rest of you, feel free to let out another gasp.

Voting was heavy, about 53 percent, for Monday's mayoral election in Calgary, one of many municipal elections held throughout Alberta. Naheed Nenshi has never held elected office before, but, riding a wave of change in a city of oil and rodeos, he triumphed over his conservative rivals, winning a 40 percent plurality of the vote. Upon taking office, he will be the first Muslim mayor of a major Canadian city. The Globe and Mail explains what Nenshi represents:

In many ways, Naheed Nenshi's come-from-behind win in Calgary's mayoral race is a traditional story.


Mr. Nenshi is qualified, charismatic and well-spoken. His career path has set him up well, perhaps purposefully, for a political career. He earned key endorsements and had all the momentum going into election day.

But, of course, his victory is unique, both for reasons the 38-year-old is inclined to discuss - such as his impressive grassroots "Purple Army" shoestring campaign - and those that he is not. He represents a changing Calgary, with its 230,000 visible-minority residents (nearly a quarter of the population), as the city's first non-white mayor.

In a province so often dominated by its conservatives, who supported opponents Barb Higgins and Ric McIver, Mr. Nenshi was a rallying point for progressive Alberta - young and old, white and non-white, eager to debunk their city's conservative Cowtown image.

Of course, Nenshi only won a plurality, not a majority, and, taken together, his two conservative rivals outperformed him, receiving 58 percent of the vote, suggesting that Calgary is not nearly as progressive as his victory might suggest.

Still, this is a hugely significant win for the forces of progressivism, even if Nenshi's views are generally quite moderate (and certainly not radical), in a province that for the most part is staunchly conservative, suggesting that even Calgary, even this bastion of right-wing obstinacy, is opening up and liberalizing somewhat, prepared, at least to a point, to join the rest of Canada in a brighter future.

Now it's just up to Nenshi to do the job well, and to expand on what he has built, so that he can effectively guide the city forward.

(As for me, I'm just waiting for American conservatives like Sarah Palin and Newt Gingrich to complain that this suspicious-looking Muslim was elected mayor way too close to Ground Zero. How dare Calgarians spit all over the memory of 9/11! Perhaps if he were to move further away, say, up to the Yukon? No, that's too close to Alaska. Maybe to Nunavut? No, it doesn't matter where, the problem is really that these good-for-nothing Canadians elected a Muslim in the first place. No wonder Sharron Angle thinks we're to blame! Calgary, thy name is Park51!)

(Cross-posted from The Reaction.)

 

Follow Michael J.W. Stickings on Twitter: www.twitter.com/mjwstickings

 
 
  • Comments
  • 11
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
12:38 PM on 10/25/2010
I think a lot of the support for conservatives in the West has more to do with geography than values. Some liberals have demanded moratorium on a single industry (oil sands). Alberta has actually been the first province to have a carbon tax, and it also has many firsts including first online submission system for resource development, first to implement an orphan well program, and first to implement a biodiversity index, and first commercial wind farm in Canada. Calgary has also been rated as the world's top ecocity by Mercer, and elected a mayor who wants to increase density instead of sprawling footprint, and the highest ridership per capital light rail system in North America. Calgarians aren't adverse to environmental protection, in fact many people who care about the environment move to Calgary because of it's close proximity to hiking in the mountains. It's important that governments realize that there are certain elements of extremism with some environmental organizations like Greenpeace who want a moratorium on oil sands development and will not even consider carbon, capture and storage as an alternative. It also needs to be recognized that oil sands is a cost-effective energy supply, and our quality of life is hugely dependent on having access to a relatively cheap energy supply. Fear of a Liberal National Energy Policy, and fear of the long arm of government shutting down an industry that Albertans are in majority in favour keeps Alberta primarily conservative.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
oxjr
10:23 PM on 10/22/2010
Albertains confuse me - the ones I have meet are some of the smartest and most worldly Canadians - BUT Alberta is the powerhouse behind the conservitive movement. I tell ya - they must have some wicked arguments in their Tim Hourton's
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
06:50 PM on 10/24/2010
Albertans are more libertarian than true conservative. They believe in individual freedom and limited government, including low taxes and spending, but are not socially conservative compared to most of Canada. In fact they are one of the least religious provinces.

To confuse Alberta with the U.S. bible belt is a mistake.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
oxjr
08:18 PM on 10/24/2010
That makes sense - but it seems the US style politicians are the ones who enter the national scene.

My province(NB) is conflicted as well. Not ashamed of big government because central Canada stole most of our industry way back in confederation - and continues to steal our best people to this day. So we don't get upset about huge government projects paid for by central Canada - we feel we are owed it. Social issues - well that is were we get into a bit of a kerfuffle. Fights about bilingualism (despite being the only province that does it well and officially) Fights over women's reproductive rights, friendly to tourists - but suspicious of immigrants. so on so on.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Richard Pearce banned
Never let them tell you it can't be done.
05:32 PM on 10/22/2010
If the Palins and the Gingritches term something with a couple of thousand of square feet a 'megaMosque', I wonder they'd call the Baitun Nur Mosque here in Calgary?

And if that didn't get their blood pressure up enough to make their heads explode, maybe a mention that the Prime Minister, and the head of the second largest political party in Canada both felt it was necessary to attend the opening will.
11:38 PM on 10/22/2010
Richard, as a fellow Canadian, those paragraphs (and the associated visuals) get you Refanned. 8)
04:41 PM on 10/22/2010
The other thing to point out is that the other runners were tremendously well known. Barb Higgins was a news anchor the CTV news network. Ric McIver was a three term alderman. Nenshi had not run in the previous election, but built his campaign based on ideas, early polls showed him at near 0% compared to Ric McIver's 40%. Nenshi came from behind to win. Nenshi won because he had the best vision for Calgary's growth, and he mobilized the youth vote through social network like his ingenious iPhone application, tweeting, and campaign policy videos. Nenshi in fact was able to win more votes than ALL candidates in the previous election combined. If candidates engage in adult discussions, they will win. This election was about who had the most creative ideas to build infrastructure and services and less about splitting the vote based on political lines or religion.
03:57 PM on 10/22/2010
Barb Higgins attended events from gay pride (including dancing at after party), to IndiaFest to Sudanese Community and Scottish Highland games. She also lives in the downtown Beltline, and supported the city administration's urban policy. In the last weeks of the election, she was supported by Bob Hawkesworth, previous alderman and New Democratic Party MP. I know she flew under the banner of conservative, but one has to rethink whether she was social conservative or a libertarian conservative. A tremendous amount of people came out to vote this election (53%), because all candidates engaged in adult debate. One also has to understand that municipal politics is very different. In Edmonton, there is also a Jewish mayor. So, Albertans can respectfully engage with a variety of politicians that may or may not have different backgrounds if they have good ideas on transportation, budgeting and urban issues. It is much harder for Albertans to vote for left leaning politicians, because of past history with the Trudeau government and implementation of the National Energy Program which crippled the economy, as well as NDP which wants a moratorium on oil sands which is generally supported by Albertans. Calgarians have some of the highest postsecondary educated people in Canada, we are open to many ideas, but not to environmental bigotry. A government that understands the energy challenges, works with us to implement better environmental policies and engages us in adult conversations is a must have for a party.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Richard Pearce banned
Never let them tell you it can't be done.
02:50 PM on 10/22/2010
One of the effects of the long boom here in Cowtown was the high price the prejudiced and racists faced if they wanted to try and continue their ways.

When you're trying to hire 10 workers, and only get 8 applications, you can't afford to toss a couple in the trash because they're from 'the wrong sort of people', you hire them, and, because you know they can quit at noon, and be hired and working someplace else the next day, you get to know them as people, so that they are less likely to decide to do that, and so does everyone they work with.

When you're looking for somewhere to live, and know that the asking price is getting bumped up almost daily, you can't afford to look at the neighborhood, see the 'wrong sort of people' living there, and decide to keep looking because of that.

And seeing as getting to know 'the wrong sort' and living amongst 'the wrong sort' is the most effective treatment for prejudice and racism there is, the number of them dropped.

And without that constituency to play to, that Nenshi was Msulim just never became a big deal.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
07:05 PM on 10/24/2010
Racism has always been bad for business, which is why black scientists were being hired in the commercial sector long before they were hired as professors in universities.

At any rate, the petroleum industry is a global one, and anyone who harbors strong racist sentiments would find it very tough sledding.
12:24 PM on 10/22/2010
>Of course, Nenshi only won a plurality, not a majority, and, taken together, his two conservative rivals outperformed him, receiving 58 percent of the vote, suggesting that Calgary is not nearly as progressive as his victory might suggest.

Religion wasn't even mentioned during the election and it didn't really have anything to do with progressivism, just a look at which of the three major candidates had the best plan, and Nenshi's was the best and most detailed. It was only after the election was over and the national media began paying attention that suddenly the big story was the "Muslim mayor". Also, Calgary's last mayor ran for the federal Liberals and the one before (who began in 1989) was soft-spoken, married to a Chinese woman and speaks some Chinese himself so Calgary really hasn't had anything close to a redneck for as long as I can remember.