iPhone app iPad app Android phone app Android tablet app More

Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Michael Shaw

GET UPDATES FROM Michael Shaw
 

Reading the Pictures: About Those 'Lottery Winner' Dinners With the Presidential Candidates

Posted: 08/24/2012 11:28 am

2012-08-24-MIntwoodPlacecampaignwinners2.jpg

On top of running a fundraising lottery for dinners with the President (I'm sure you've been getting Michelle and Barack's emails), the White House has been prominently using the ensuing sit downs for photo-ops. The latest event took place a few days ago at the Mintwood Place restaurant in D.C.'s Adams Morgan neighborhood. Whereas, on the surface, it's heartening to see the Obamas hanging with wildfire smoke jumpers and assistant high school principals, as if one of those chairs might be filled (for $25 or so) by you or me, I'm wondering about the larger symbolism.

Isn't what we're seeing here, in fact, mostly the product of brilliant marketing, the president (or Romney) engineering the perception of populism and participation? More seriously, by having people pay for the opportunity, isn't the campaign also emulating and forcing the public to (literally) buy into the plutocratic game where citizens (those with the real wealth) are expected to pony up to get (the real) attention of elected leaders? Looking at the photo again, how much is the scene a democratic act, a lighthearted strategy for engagement, a concept to say that the little guy helped build the bank, one more reinforcement of the lottery society, and/or a vehicle to model for the American electorate the concept of "pay to play"?

2012-08-24-ObamasLotteryDin.png


And then, I happened to also notice this single photo from the evening the White House happened to publish on Instagram. In contrast to the wire photos presumably taken of the Obamas and the lottery winners before the dinner started, everyone sitting there with a glass of water in front of them, the Instagram shot shows the Obamas in isolation enjoying their meal in what otherwise (there's no caption) looks like an intimate dinner.

Not to make too big a deal out of it, I also wonder what kind of message this snapshot is supposed to communicate given the whole point of the event involves the Obamas breaking bread with Joan and Jane Q. Public.

(Photo 1: Pete Marovich-Pool/Getty Images caption: President Barack Obama and first lady Michelle Obama have dinner with three winners of "Dinner with Barack and Michelle" fundraising contest on August 20, 2012 at Mintwood Place in Washington, DC. Voters will go to the polls on November 6 to decided if Obama will be re-elected for another four years.)(Photo 2: @barackobama / Instagram.)

 

Follow Michael Shaw on Twitter: www.twitter.com/bagnewsnotes

FOLLOW POLITICS
On top of running a fundraising lottery for dinners with the President (I'm sure you've been getting Michelle and Barack's emails), the White House has been prominently using the ensuing sit downs f...
On top of running a fundraising lottery for dinners with the President (I'm sure you've been getting Michelle and Barack's emails), the White House has been prominently using the ensuing sit downs f...
 
 
  • Comments
  • 47
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2  Next ›  Last »  (2 total)
03:33 PM on 08/25/2012
FWIW, I just entered without having to make a contribution via the banner ad at the top of the page;however, I realize the number of entries make my selection unlikely, not the absence of contribution.
photo
HUFFPOST COMMUNITY MODERATOR
Stephen Stafford
Be the answer to somebody's prayer!
09:50 AM on 08/25/2012
This article is an absolute inspiration to me. Since they published this, I might as well submit my ideas.It will be better than this (and you better not send me a word saying it was not.)

We did a bucket list thing at church. I was amazed that meeting the Obamas was at the top of just about everyone's list. This fundraising idea makes such a thing possible for some lucky somebodies. I am thrilled for them.

A friend's mom worked on the '08 campaign in her city. She was invited to the White House for lunch. She had the best time ever. She got there and looked for all the other invitees.It was just her little group. She was shocked.

Then they asked her what she wanted to eat. She said whatever you are serving. They said, no, really, what do you want to eat. She said crab cakes. They said large or small, and how many? Needless to say, this was the best and most memorable lunch of her lifetime, and she thoroughly enjoyed this time with our President.

President Obama genuinely engages with folks. I have never seen people used as props. I do not appreciate that kind of aspersion in this story. These fundraising appeals offer the chance to more regular folks like my friend's mom, and that is a great thing. I say if you get that chance and don't want it, HOLLA! I will take your place anytime, anywhere.
photo
HUFFPOST COMMUNITY MODERATOR
MIMom
Your ad here.
09:44 AM on 08/25/2012
One, I get e-mails asking for either $3 or $5, or WHATEVER YOU CAN CONTRIBUTE.

Two, if you read the fine print, there's usually a way to enter without making a donation. That's what I did for a trip to the DNC convention.

Three, you're really grasping at straws, aren't you? $25 donations (as cited in your article) certainly compares to a Sheldon Adelson or Koch brother donation. Futhermore, all your expenses are paid for the trip, which pales in comparison to a lowly $25 donation. Give me a break.
12:54 PM on 08/25/2012
a fund raising scam tied to a lottery that uses the fund raising scam prcoeeds to pay the expenses of the lottery winner. brilliant! another way to use OPM (other people's money!)
09:44 AM on 08/25/2012
The promotion is a little cheesy, but it does give a few people a chance to talk to the president. It would never even occur to Romney in the first place. Dine with the little people? Ewwww.
photo
mrelmo
improvise, adapt, overcome...
09:26 AM on 08/25/2012
I don't find anything wrong with this type of campaign fundraising. Romney was recently here in Little Rock, and the tickets were $25,000 a couple for a dinner. I think the $5 blue-plate special with Obama is a more reasonable offer...
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
thinkagain2
08:59 AM on 08/25/2012
The emails I get ask for 3 dollars. That's hardly high rolling campaign financing.
photo
ILoveFiction
That's unbelievable!
08:38 AM on 08/25/2012
And then, I happened to notice you can enter one of these lotteries for free.

And then, I happened to notice there are only a very few restaurants that have a seating capacity of 300,000.

And then, I happened to notice the President otherwise lives in a bubble and really doesn't get too many chances to talk to regular people.

See, I'm very observant!
07:55 AM on 08/25/2012
Nonconstructive criticism from the left at this point does more to help plutocrats than anything.

In any case, Romney would be insulting the baked goods after showing up late, and then blame somebody else for it. He'd then tip 13 percent but only for his own meals value, while claiming the whole dinner as a tax deduction.
06:23 AM on 08/25/2012
You're reaching. As far as campaign fundraising goes, it's a meaningful difference, not a cynical one. All the wrongs that need righting in this world and you're using your energy and voice on THIS?
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Brooke Doris
12:07 AM on 08/25/2012
I think the photos are lovely, and so are the Obamas.
11:22 PM on 08/24/2012
I have entered these contests paying 3 bucks. I wanted to help and I don't feel I have been involved in "pay to play". I bet Obama will not insult my baking.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
lolita
Oh, for the love of...
10:40 PM on 08/24/2012
Seems like a bit of a reach and maybe tinged with sour grapes... I mean really, the whole meme of "is this the man you would sit down to a beer with?" was started by the W campaign. As a marketer, I think this campaign is a winner. If you have dedicated your fundraising (as a campaign) to maximizing participation from a large number of small donors as opposed to a few large donors, you need to create excitement about giving. It IS a lottery ticket. The closest someone who is not a bundler is going to get is to either become a national hero or win this contest. Stop pissing on something that is an effective fundraiser that is focused on small dollar donors - or would you prefer our POTUS sell it all out to the 1%?
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
CSNC
Living on the edge -- not taking too much space
10:29 PM on 08/24/2012
"Reading the Pictures: About Those 'Lottery Winner' Dinners With the Presidential Candidates"

I did not get selected... but if I had, I already have my questions memorized and also written down -- the first one being: 1) Why are such a wimp? The second: 2) Why no one responsible for the economic crash is being prosecuted?

There are more... many more.

M
photo
HUFFPOST COMMUNITY MODERATOR
Stephen Stafford
Be the answer to somebody's prayer!
09:54 AM on 08/25/2012
1. You would get the most wonderful, gentle rebuke while being educated otherwise.

2. The other diners would be so annoyed they would snatch you up, drag you to the bathroom, and "clean you up". You might gather yourself enough to join the party by desert, if you dare.

There won't be any more whatsoever guaranteed.
12:50 PM on 08/25/2012
really? violence is your answer?
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
CSNC
Living on the edge -- not taking too much space
02:18 PM on 08/25/2012
Stephen Stafford, I am not easily intimidated, like you seem to be. T
photo
SamEllison
I feel so clean!
08:25 PM on 08/24/2012
Pass the arugula, please.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
ziggywasastar
07:53 PM on 08/24/2012
This is only my opinion, but here it is.

Many Americans are throwing away the chance to be VERY proud of the President of the United States. He is intelligent, funny, and knows what he is doing. Sad that some people will never see it.