More

Michael Shaw

Michael Shaw

Posted: November 12, 2007 03:18 PM

Reading The Pictures: You Lost Your Face And Your Legs, But I'm Here Now


2007-11-12-SmileySanAntonio.jpg

Oops, sorry for the blasphemy! ...Here's the real version.

I'm sure most of you, by now, have seen the pictures from George Bush's photo-op last Thursday at the Brooke Army Hospital in San Antonio. (If you're a regular HuffPost reader, the images were on the home page all weekend, garnering almost 900 comments as of this morning.)

So, why the smiley face?

Well, with the sophisticated PR manipulation practiced by the White House, it seems almost necessary, as the "visual opposition," to employ as many counterinsurgent techniques as possible to illuminate the kind of visual tactics being deployed here.

What smiley is designed to bring out, in this image of Bush posed with Army Sgt. James Kevin Downs, is the cultural propaganda strategy that this Administration applies to catastrophe -- no matter whether nature caused it or they did.

A week or so ago, I did a post about Bush's California firestorm photo op. In that piece, I cited the work of widely-respected NYU Media, Culture, and Communications Professor Marita Sturken. You can read and see it here (and, don't miss the video), but in brief, Sturken's thesis is that post 9/11 America (led by the Consoler-In-Chief) has morphed into what she calls a "comfort culture." Bottom line (and playing up the wounds and the insult we suffered at the hands of al-Qaeda), the function of this executive branch is not to make things better, but just to make people feel better.

It's a tactic that goes a long, long way. For example:

..It is this mentality that obscures how George Bush can walk into a high tech rehab center in San Antonio which, although situated on a U.S. military base, is completely funded by private donations, and rant about the state of the government's support of injured veterans.

...It is this mentality that overshadows the fact that Bush's visit (the cost of which was offset by the taxpayer) was sandwiched in between two fat cat Republican fundraisers.

It is this mentality that allows George Bush the ability to actually seek out a photo op with soldiers whose faces have been mutilated or their legs blown off in his elective war, and perceptually neutralize his culpability (and even, the visual horror) because he is there to comfort and console.

It is this mentality that allows Bush to chuckle and gaze into the eyes and, I assume, the soul, of Marine Lance Cpl. Isaac Gallegos while accepting an Iraqi Freedom t-shirt with (unbelievably enough) the picture of a wolfman on it.

In this Rovian-guided, mind-messing, pictorial era we're living in, however, you wouldn't expect that "Bush love" alone would be the only strategically applied to smooth the rough edges off these rough pictures, would you? Another way the American viewer is being comforted, as well as bought off here, is through the mojo of technology.

Take Bush-navigated Marine Lance Cpl. Matthew Bradford, for example, who lost both legs and one eye (and was blinded in the other) by an IED. The demonstration Bush witnesses shows Bradford scaling a two-story climbing wall as if, through super-rehab, he's been turned into Spiderman.

Or take Army PFC Nicholas Clark, who figured prominently in the day's picture show. Posing in this laboratory-like setting "wearing retro-reflective markers to measure his body movements under infra-red cameras" (as AP authoritatively informs us), how much easier is it to lend one's heart (as the President lovingly lends his jacket) to a bionic man who will likely be re-engineered even better than new.

Photographer Nina Berman -- recognized earlier this year with a World Press Photo award for her incredibly disturbing (and not at all comforting) portrait, Marine Wedding -- addressing this photo of PFC Clark, as well as the one I first linked to, writes:

Look at those great computer legs. Look at the great battlefield medicine. See what we can do to patch up bodies. Meet the great doctors and staff who tend to our boys. They can house skulls in torsos and make toes into fingers. These images smooth everything over. People get excited and upbeat by the gadgets (just like the video simulator) and never look at the reason for the gadgets.

So, my apologies again for sticking a smiley face atop the President of the United States, especially while he's providing comfort to our worst maimed troops. But then, if these images now look a little harder to you (meaning, a little more unspun and real), then at least I feel a little better.

Original Reuters slide show.

For more of the visual -- including two more angles on San Antonio -- visit BAGnewsNotes.com.

(image: Gerald Herbert/AP. San Antonio. Thursday, Nov. 8, 2007)

Follow Michael Shaw on Twitter: www.twitter.com/bagnewsnotes

 
 
  • Comments
  • 66
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2  Next ›  Last »  (2 total)
02:59 PM on 11/14/2007
Great job, Mr. Shaw.
Now if only we could get the mainstream media to pay these folks the attention and respect they deserve, and stop allowing Bush & Co. to co-opt the press as their personal propaganda machine.
08:01 PM on 11/13/2007
These images are both brilliant and obscene. Brilliant because the subtext and insane emotional contrast is so very clear and obscene because they are unbelieveable and betray emotional decency. The fact that these images are taken at a private re-hab facility
( rather than the mold blackened bowels of the inadequate Gov. facilities which are the best that the Gov. (( and us by ommission of our active complaint and urgent remedy)) can do for our wounded)
is ironic in spades. Hideous. I blame the Dems for the continued agony at this point. Every day they could have brought the WAR to the voting table- MADE IT THE ISSUE dejour. This was there charge by the public that elected them. They have failed. Miserably.
07:14 PM on 11/13/2007
Great piece. George Bush and his minions do not know the meaning of shame. Whether that makes them clinically sociopaths, I don't know. But a leader who is incapable of feeling shame has escaped the bounds of democratic discourse. And if a leader, or the country as a whole, is incapable of feeling shame, then changing policies through civil disobediance becomes almost impossible.

Think about the civil rights movement, and the images of dogs and firehoses trained on nonviolent marchers. Is there any question that on seeing those images, more Americans than not felt ashamed of what our fellow countrypeople were doing in Alabama? And that shame in the hearts of those in power is a powerful motivator for change in the face of civil disobediance?
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
02:04 PM on 11/13/2007
I would be mad as hell if my face and limbs were lost on account of President Bozo's egomaniacal War On Iraq. They both must be on some powerful meds!
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
LoriAnn
loving my new blue state existence !!
01:30 PM on 11/13/2007
Personnally I wouldve recognised him sooner if you had put a horses ass (no offense to our equine friends) where the smiley face went, but I get the theme here. The inane hypocracy just keeps flowing, it may use different venues and employ the usual actors but the bottom is just never reached!! This time I wanted to puke!!!!
01:08 PM on 11/13/2007
"Compassionate conservatism" = "Hey, I really feel bad for you. Can't do anything about it, but believe me--I really am sorry about your situation."
12:37 PM on 11/13/2007
Having lost a Brother in Viet Nam, then going through an Alice in Wonderland journey into the meaning of war and politics, eventually lead me to realize that the history I knew was grossly revised and inaccurate. The transition from suspecting the sources of history to suspecting the sources of journalistic integrity was a short step. My Brother believed in what he was doing and wrote a compelling letter to the hometown newspaper in support of the war in Viet Nam. He died in 1966. Since then, I am forever attached to all of those in uniform who have made incredible and sometimes the ultimate sacrifice. So how is it that I can believe in them, pray for their welfare and safety, but not in the political machinations that put them there and keep them there? The answer came in a gradual progression of revisiting history and realizing that people’s lives can be broken by the acceptance of duty without question regardless of what that duty is. That the trial of battle is ancient and sacred, deserving nothing less than respect and tribute for those who went into it. For those who came out with less than they went in with, and those who never came out. There must be truth in the accounting, whole, complete, and unmasked truth. When a cause is predicated on death and dismemberment of those pledged to serve, and inflicting the same on others does not rise to balance that cost. Whether it does or not will not diminish the spirit or valor of the warrior. But if a cause does not balance the warrior’s sacrifices in truth, the deficient decision behind veiled motives is all the more damnable.
12:17 PM on 11/13/2007
How can that smug sack of crap even stand to be in the same room with those brave soldiers? Oh wait--judging by the photos, he can't. Feels more like "let me do my act and get out of here," and "I'm gonna whup whoever set up this here photo op!" And if you think those poor SOBs look tough now, imagine what they looked like on the battle field, and the emotional scars of the guys who carried them off, and worked on them to save them. Lots of psychic carnage and mayhem for all concerned...save the guy who started it all.
12:14 PM on 11/13/2007
That callous bastard Bush spent about 15 minutes at the Center for the Intrepid so he could justify using Air Force One for a fund raising trip.
Yes, in less than half an hour, Bush's motorcade left the Army post and dashed off the the mansion of attorney John Steen, where he met with a bunch of Republican ass kissers to raise $1 million for Sen. John Cornyn's next Senate race.
Steen was named (by either Gov. Bush or Gov. Perry) Chairman of the Texas Alcoholic Beverage Commission, a Mafia-like position where he decides who does and doesn't get permits to sell alcoholic beverages in Texas.
Cornyn was once Texas Attorney General, where he gave the nod to record-breaking death row executions.
Bush failed to mention that the Center for the Intrepid's $50 million pricetag was paid for by a bunch of Hollywood liberals like Rosie O'Donnell and Michelle Pfeiffer.
In his brief remarks, Bush admitted that facilities to care for severely wounded returning Iraqi war vets were in short supply. But of course he failed to mention that his crooked government did not pay for this one.
The trip to San Antonio probably cost us taxpayers $2 million, just so Bush could help raise $1 million for that crook Cornyn.
Sickening, isn't it?
12:04 PM on 11/13/2007
The smile is just to cover the SMIRK!
11:38 AM on 11/13/2007
How does one calculate the immensity of the price paid by US soldiers and their families? Haven't we had enough of these wars? Bush's and Cheney's friends and family are drawing profits beyond the dreams of avarice, and America is nearly bankrupt. Of course we should have expected this, as Bush has run every company he's ever had into the ground.
10:54 AM on 11/13/2007
There is no amount of "photo op spin" that will reduce the ultimate guilt that the WAR CRIMES and CRIMES AGAINST HUMANITY have left as the TRUE LEGACY of the BUSH/CHENEY/LIEBERMAN/SCOTUS/CONGRESSIONAL Cabal in their pursuit of their illegal and immoral WAR OF CONQUEST AND OCCUPATION OF IRAQ!
So has it already been written. So shall it remain as long as man survives on this poor and dieing planet.
10:33 AM on 11/13/2007
Well of course President Bush would go to see mamed and mutilated soldiers. It's just like blowing up a frog with firecrackers (his favorite past time as a developing young socio/psychopath). You have to see the pain and suffering you have caused to really get your jollies.
photo
ibsteve2u
Someone who cares - to his unending regret
09:59 AM on 11/13/2007
Those pictures of Bush gave me the exact same crawling feeling in the pit of my stomach as I got when I first saw this picture:

http://www.clownz.com/pa_jwg1.html
09:33 AM on 11/13/2007
The reason Bush can console bereaved families, look into the eyes of mutilated Iraq/Afghanistan war veterans and then go home, eat a hearty meal and get a good night's sleep is that he knows, perhaps only, "subliminably", that Cheney and the other PNAC neocons are the ones who are truly culpable. He's just a legacy; someone acceptable to the American electorate, unlike themselves, who will allow them to implement their plan.