EDITION: U.S.
 
CONNECT    

Michael Winship

Michael Winship

Posted: December 18, 2009 03:27 PM

Happy Holidays from America's Banks

What's Your Reaction:

Never mind Barack Obama's Audacity of Hope. It's the audacity of the banks that takes your breath away. Mean old Mr. Potter in "It's a Wonderful Life" seems like Father Christmas by comparison.

A recent report that Citigroup and Goldman Sachs may have received preferential treatment getting doses of the swine flu vaccine was enough to give Ebenezer Scrooge the yips. Then came news that in order for us to get back the taxpayer bailout money we loaned them, Citigroup is receiving billions of dollars in tax breaks from the IRS.

And there's a new study this week, "Rewarding Failure," from the public interest group Public Citizen, revealing that in the years leading up to the financial meltdown, the CEO's of the 10 Wall Street giants that either collapsed or got huge amounts of TARP money were paid an average of $28.9 million dollars a year.

In 2007, that amounted to 575 times the median income of an American family. Now, thanks in part to the banks' monumental malfeasance that led to our economic swan dive, food stamps are now being used to feed one in eight Americans, and a quarter of all the kids in this country. A new poll from the New York Times and CBS News reports that more than half of our unemployed have borrowed money from friends and relatives and have cut back on medical treatment.

The Times wrote that, "Joblessness has wreaked financial and emotional havoc on the lives of many of those out of work... causing major life changes, mental health issues and trouble maintaining even basic necessities."

Yet according to the non-profit Americans for Financial Reform the reported $150 billion that Wall Street is paying itself in compensation and bonuses this year would be enough to solve the budget crisis of every one of the fifty states or create millions of jobs or prevent all foreclosures for four years.

All of this wretched excess is occurring as more and more people can't afford a roof over their heads. Foreclosures were up another five percent in the third quarter -- 23 percent more than a year ago. Fewer Americans are willing to buy foreclosed properties, and the Obama administration's foreclosure prevention plan has been a bust so far - way too timid, critics say, and many of the banks won't play ball, refusing to negotiate in good faith with homeowners desperate to hold on.

We got a first hand look at the crisis this week, when thousands lined up at the Jacob Javits Convention Center just a few blocks from our Manhattan offices to attend a mortgage assistance event sponsored by the non-profit Neighborhood Assistance Corporation of America (NACA). So many showed up for this leg of the "Save the Dream Tour" that on many days, staff and volunteers stayed to help until one in the morning.

NACA has had success getting homeowners and banks together to work out a deal to prevent foreclosure. But the big banks' return to the government of the TARP bailout money with which we underwrote them over the last 14 months is a mixed blessing -- great to have the cash returned so quickly, terrible because any leverage Washington held over the banks because of the loans virtually vanishes with the payback. They're back in the saddle and not inclined to be of much assistance helping anyone else out, especially those in mortgage trouble.

As Andrew Ross Sorkin of the New York Times wrote in the wake of President Obama's Monday meeting with Wall Street's top guns (three of whom failed to show up because of airport delays), "Executive compensation, leverage limits and lending standards were all issues that Washington said it planned to change -- and when the taxpayers were the shareholders of these firms, it probably could have done so. But now the White House has been left in the position of extending invitations, rather than exercising its clout. And in the figurative and literal sense, it is getting stood up."

Afterwards, Obama said, "The problem is there's a big gap between what I'm hearing here in the White House and the activities of lobbyists on behalf of these institutions or associations of which they're a member up on Capitol Hill."

That's putting it mildly. This week, the American Bankers Association sent out an update and "call to action" memorandum crowing over its success watering down the bank reform bill that was approved by the House and urging its members to beat back similar legislation in the Senate. Self-righteously, it concludes, "As one of your New Year's resolutions, please vow to do everything in your power to show, and to have your colleagues in your bank show, your Senators the right path to true reform."

It helps when the right path is paved with silver and gold. As "Crossing Wall Street," a November report from the Center for Responsive Politics notes, "The finance, insurance and real estate sector has given $2.3 billion to candidates, leadership PACs and party committees since 1989, which eclipses every other sector...

"The financial sector has also been a voracious lobbying force, spending an unprecedented $3.8 billion since 1998, while sending an army of lobbyists to Capitol Hill to make its case. That's more money than any other sector has spent on influence peddling. Not even the health care sector, which spun up a lobbying frenzy this year over health reform, has spent more."

The banks are making a list and checking it twice. And lest we forget, during his run for the White House, the finance sector filled Barack Obama's stocking with $39.5 million dollars worth of campaign contributions, more than any other presidential candidate.

God bless us, every one!


Michael Winship is senior writer of the weekly public affairs program Bill Moyers Journal, which airs Friday night on PBS. Check local airtimes or comment at The Moyers Blog at www.pbs.org/moyers. Research support provided by producer William Brangham and associate producer Katia Maguire.

 
 
  • Comments
  • 19
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2  Next ›  Last »  (2 total)
iridium53
Semper Fi
11:51 AM on 12/21/2009
Obama will blame all the economic problems on Bush. Yet, he kept the facilitato­rs of the Great Recession on, Bernanke, and the then head of the NY Fed, Geithner.
Obama forgave $billions in taxes the banks owed. So that they could appear to be paying back their TARP payments and any remaining government control over them could be forgotten.

Now, as of the passing of the Healthcare "reform" bill, each and every American will be forced to pay more than 1% of their income to the profits and executives of healthcare companies. We will be forced to pay 8% of our incomes. 20% going to their overhead, compared to 5% to government plans. The remaining amount is their profit and excess salaries. That's 1.2% of your income that will be taken from you and given directly to healthcare executive compensati­on packages.

Obama and the Democrats are intent on creating a government that takes advantage of government­al corruption to extend the personal wealth and political power of government officials and the ruling class (executive­s of big companies)­, via the taking of state funds at the expense of the wider population­, without even the pretense of honest service. Kleptocrac­y literally means "rule by thieves".
photo
Soulsurfer
Solar Electrician,Longtime Surfin'Fool
08:48 AM on 12/21/2009
More dysfunctio­nal and delusional thinking on Wall St. Cut jobs and your company's stock goes up. More joblessnes­s means prosperity­!
08:44 PM on 12/20/2009
The "soft money" from lobbyists is one part of the collusive corruption in this failing republic. Like a fire triangle (oxygen, flame, and heat), it takes all three to make a fire. Take one away and the fire goes out. The level of corruption within the corridors of Washington DC is stunning. What is more stunning is the masses of this country apathetica­lly allowing it to continue. Hoping for an epiphany from our elected officials is a waste of time. Psychopath­s have no conscience and therefore will not willfully do what is right without being forced to do so. I thought Sheriff Obama was the man to tackle that task after he expressed those thoughts to the American people when he was seeking our votes. He got my vote and what have I received? I have received the reality that examples set forth by those of supposed virtue are nothing more than the poorest example of rhetoric, ethics, and patriotism­. I'm surprised anyone pays taxes or their mortgage after watching those that produce nothing get rewarded for one of the biggest heists in history.
schatsie
Wealth Taxes work in Germany and Switzerland
12:26 PM on 12/20/2009
TAKE THE CAPS off the PAYROLL TAX.....Pu­t a Cap of 100,000 on capitals gains tax rate, eliminate deductions for people with over 1 million dollars in income....
photo
Soulsurfer
Solar Electrician,Longtime Surfin'Fool
08:50 AM on 12/21/2009
Double the capital gains rate. It's UNEARNED INCOME, made off the sweat of other people's productivi­ty.
schatsie
Wealth Taxes work in Germany and Switzerland
12:17 PM on 12/21/2009
Doubling the rate from 15% to 30% still makes it less than the income tax rate of 35%....
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Carl Caroli
Give peace a chance
09:06 AM on 12/20/2009
We have to change campaign finance laws to prohibit corporate campaign contributi­ons and eliminate lobbying by requiring ALL lobbyist correspond­ence to be in writing and available to the public. The problem is the current, bought and paid for, crowd wont do it.
schatsie
Wealth Taxes work in Germany and Switzerland
12:27 PM on 12/20/2009
Lobbying should not be tax deductible­...at all...Who do you think pays for the lobbying in the first place, us working class slobs who pay our taxes....
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
DebtNavigation
Attorney and Author
08:54 AM on 12/20/2009
Americans need to form a Barzonian type of grassroots organizati­on.

http://en.­wikipedia.­org/wiki/E­l_Barz%C3%B3n
08:36 AM on 12/20/2009
great article. Very discouragi­ng. The banks walk from their obligation­s, screw everybody in their path, pocket the profits and laugh all the way to their illegal investment paradises. I am sickened..
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
edejan
02:49 PM on 12/19/2009
Good article. Thanks! But I see no hope of any change. We voted in Pres. Obama to CHANGE these very problems and he seems to have missed every opportunit­y. We are truly one of the most corrupt countries in the world.
02:29 PM on 12/19/2009
IS THERE SUCH A THING AS A CORRUPT DEMOCRACY?

American democracy? A huge joke! A paradise for lobbyists? Yes.
One of the most corrupt countries on earth.
The American lobbying system should be mentioned along with Afghanista­n, Nigeria or Mexico as another paradigm of institutio­nalized corruption­.

Bringing democracy through the sword to Irak or Afghanista­n?

Perhaps. A corrupt democracy "like ours".
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
11:29 AM on 12/19/2009
Merry Christmas to you greedy Wall Street buggers.

You're having a great year. You are foreclosin­g on homes, killing companies and sucking money from the Treasury and the economy at a vampiric rate. Nobody will stop you. In a few years, you can sell the whole package to China, who will already have whatever of our money you might have missed with your bloodsucki­ng siphons, and the Middle Class will become a great failed experiment­, murdered by the financiers who will be living on tropical islands ringed by armed guards. May all your children bear the curse you have brought on your houses.

Oh, and Happy New Year! Stop by the shelter later for some generic fruit punch and a day-old muffin.
photo
guveqzero
Inventor and Innovator
10:31 AM on 12/19/2009
Revolution is not far off, now that the people have lost faith in our financial system. Why should anyone be in perpetual debt? This is known as slavery.
schatsie
Wealth Taxes work in Germany and Switzerland
08:58 AM on 12/19/2009
And this is EXACTLY why we WANT SINGLE PAYER.....

We are bailing out Wall Street and going bankrupt and loosing homes at RATES THAT ARE HISTORICAL­LY UNPRECEDEN­TED.....

To stabilize this mess calls for TAX REFORM AND HEALTHCARE RENOVATION­...there is no freaking reason that with the money that this country spends on heatlhcare per person $6 grand for every man woman and child that we should not have the BEST OUTCOMES in the world...bu­t the FREE MARKET has totally corrupted this system and EVERYONE KNOWS IT!!!
11:34 PM on 12/18/2009
Forty million to buy a President seems low to me... even if you double it with reelection­.

Even ego stroking at that rate isn't so hot when you break it down hourly... and it's really just a loan to buy their commercial­s right... not going in his pocket...y­et.

Hate to say that leaves ideology, blackmail, and stupidity as motivation for tolerating criminalit­y.
photo
drbob601
Soylent Green is People
09:46 PM on 12/18/2009
Good article.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Jannsmoor
07:45 PM on 12/18/2009
Our children may not be better off than we are, but corporate CEO's children will have a bright economic future.