More

Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Michelle Chen

GET UPDATES FROM Michelle Chen
 

Lowe's All-American Muslim Fiasco and the Politics of Normalcy

Posted: 12/25/11 04:08 PM ET

Cross-posted from CultureStrike, a new project that fuses arts with activism in the struggle for immigrants' rights.

Their slogan is "Never Stop Improving," but lately, "Never Stop Denying" seems more fitting. Lowe's has rebuffed a 200,000-signature petition to reinstate ads on the new reality television series All-American Muslim on The Learning Channel.

The retail giant stepped into a big political hubbub once word got out that the company decided abruptly to pull its advertising from the show, which depicts daily life in the Muslim American community, shortly after receiving some nasty backlash from a hardline evangelical group, the Florida Family Association. Apparently showing normal people on television who happen to be Muslim is a sin, and a threat to national security, and would make Jesus mad.

These arguments are nothing we haven't heard before of course, but activists were jarred when they heard that a big box behemoth like Lowe's would be cowed by the condemnation of a fringe group of anti-Muslim crusaders. Then again, the FFA did wage a rather virulent campaign to terrorize corporations who dared put their ads on the show. According to the group's website:

the show profiles only Muslims that appear to be ordinary folks while excluding many Islamic believers whose agenda poses a clear and present danger to liberties and traditional values that the majority of Americans cherish.

Aside from Lowe's, the campaign also targeted such household names as Hershey's and Campbell's Soup, urging supporters to call customer service to voice their rage.

Of course, wingnuts in Tampa aren't the only ones who wield social media to spread their gospel. The reaction to the reports of Lowe's pandering to anti-Muslim haters has proven to be much more of a political minefield than running a few commercials on show designed to be emphatically banal. The controversy has provided endless fodder for parodies about home-improvement jihadis, inspired a nationwide boycott, and prompted Russell Simmons to step up to replace the lost financing.

The interfaith Mecklenburg Ministries gathered 200,000 signatures to pressure Lowe's to reverse its decision, but to no avail. Even in the wake of accusations of "engaging in Jim Crow-style discrimination," the company's damage control unit continues to insist that the pulling of the ads was a marketing decision and not a cave to FFA.

Still, Lowe's spokespeople apparently have not settled on talking points about the influence of hate-mongering critics on their ad campaigns. While Lowe's VP of Marketing Tom Lamb sheepishly told the Charlotte Observer that "The decision was absolutely not, despite what's been reported in the media, influenced by any one group," another spokesperson, according to the Hollywood Reporter, claims that "decisions to pull commercial spots from shows that are considered controversial are made perhaps 8-10 times a year." As if outraged customers were supposed to find that reassuring.

But in the midst of the hooplah, you've got to wonder if the show is worth all the hype, positive or negative. Zaki Hasan had an alternative take on The Huffington Post, questioning the hyper-assimilationist mission of the show:

My "meh" reaction to the program comes, I think, from my general dislike of the omnipresent desire among many to turn religions into demographics, and compartmentalizing a far-ranging faith group that includes so much diversity into a single reality cast and labeling it "All-American" just seems counter-intuitive to me. I've long held that the best way to demonstrate how "All-American" Muslims are is to just do it without hanging a lampshade on it. Muslim lawyers on lawyer shows, and it's no big deal. Muslim cops on cop shows, and it's no big deal. Because, guess what? It's no big deal.

Now, fringe groups will always spout their bigotry, and probably no reality show will compel them to recognize their disconnect from the real world. What All-American Muslim ostensibly aims to do is to overcome stereotypes held by "average Americans" by showing them that the Lebanese neighbors next door aren't so scary after all. But the real question is: what does that say about our public discourse? Maybe what prime time television needs right now isn't a showcase of Muslims being as ultra-American as possible but a conscientious exploration of why our image of the "All American" is actually a complete fiction, why terms like "melting pot," "tolerance" and "diversity" have become tools for sugar-coating racial and ethnic difference, masking ugly tensions that block honest dialogue and reinforce hierarchy. Lowe's image problem will probably pass once the controversy subsides, All-American Muslim may or may not change public perspectives, and given the show's current ratings, it seems many might just shrug and change the channel.

In any case, the bigger picture won't get much airtime, because corporate television isn't quite ready to shift the lens away from "Look! they're just like us!" and toward an idea of "American" that isn't bound up in assumptions of middle-class normalcy. What would happen if we all just stepped back from our television screens and turned our gaze toward the real America outside our living rooms?

 
 
 

Follow Michelle Chen on Twitter: www.twitter.com/meeshellchen

 
 
  • Comments
  • 85
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2  Next ›  Last »  (2 total)
01:20 PM on 02/06/2012
The actual pulled commerical was in poor taste, despite the two main characters who are of indian descent, and who used to act on the now cancelled show, Outsourced, this commercial wasnt even funny. Its even more in poor taste that this commercial be reserved for a time slot inbetween All American Muslims, im suprised the outrage isnt coming from the muslim community. Im not even religous and im glad that commercial was pulled, seeing as how the implication is still a very real epidemic worldwide. Not funny.
06:13 PM on 01/02/2012
I watched the show for the first time last night and found it most entertaining. It seems TLC has gone out of its way to find the most ‘progressive’ representatives of Dearbornistan. Not once in the broadcast did I see any veils.
The religion police of Saudi Arabia would have arrested three of the wives simply for their provocative style of dress. The Taliban’s Ministry for the Promotion of Virtue and the Prevention of Vice would have stoned the one with the makeup, body piercings, tattoos, and pink hair.
They may be typical Americans, but they are NOT typical Muslims.
For real truth visit: Remember the Islamo website.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
irishinohio
skating on a razor blade
08:59 AM on 12/27/2011
I suppose The FFA would be happier if the show was called "American Muslim Jihadists"...or All American Terrorists"....oh! ...wait!....that would include some Christians...wouldn't it?
08:07 AM on 12/27/2011
This must be a Protestant problem with accepting people, my religion is global, Christian and has 1 billion members worldwide of all nationalities and colors.
Eric4969
Type Today Post Tomorrow
04:47 PM on 12/27/2011
To Bad its ALL MAN MADE Sorry FACTS are FACTS :)
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
stuoverit
"What year did Jesus think it was?"-GC
10:32 PM on 12/27/2011
What's especially awesome is seeing how well things have turned out in the world with so many Christian influences. In the words of Tim and Eric: Great Job!
05:43 AM on 12/29/2011
I believe it has nothing to do with Christianity and more likely due to testosterone the aggressive/violent hormone in men.
Norm
Read think read analyze read comment
07:37 AM on 12/27/2011
I agree with Zaki Hazan. Shows like this tend to project a homogenity on American culture that does not exist. Programs like this seem to be because a particular group needs a defense. They don't, and showing them incorporated into the work life of this country works better for everyone - not that I see Muslims incorporated into mainstream television. Can anyone really make a series work on the basis of the characters having a different religion? The premise is just all kinds of wrong for a society that proclaims religious freedome and diversity.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Rita R
Always asking why
02:44 AM on 12/27/2011
""All-American" just seems counter-intuitive to me" and to me also. I grew up in a melting pot city. School buddies always seemed to have a grandma or grandpa at home who was from the Old Country -- or, more correctly, Countries. Those were European countries: Poland, France, Holland, Germany, Ireland, Italy, Greece, Austria, Sweden, Finland, etc. The grandmas always cooked food from the Old Countries, and that's one of the ways we got to know other cultures. It's really difficult to feel suspicious and hostile over great food. My own kids grew up in a melting pot of Asian, African, Central and South American, and Middle Eastern cultures: India, Pakistan, Palestine, Lebanon, Algeria, Liberia, Niger, South Africa, Japan, Taiwan, South Korea, Bolivia, Costa Rica, etc. An invitation to dine with these families at home was great thing because it was, yet again, a cultural immersion. "All American" teams of these ethnically diverse kids played park district soccer and Little League and attended Scout troops together.
It seems to me, looking back, that the politicos and Christian church preachers have done their utmost to create an ethnic Jim Crow era. How very sad. We can decide not to vote for such nor attend their sermons, just as we can boycott corporations that coat-tail on their absurd and divisive ideologies.
12:29 AM on 12/27/2011
Another example of how capitalism fuels & sustains ignorance. I've only caught 2 episodes of "All American Muslim", but the show does expose the reality that there ARE Muslim Americans who live assimilated lives, as if that is a total shocker. I don't know who's worse: (1) LOEWS for pulling the ads after the pressure from the closeted racists in office/Christian Church, OR (2) the American PUBLIC--for even giving in to such ignorance. "All American Jew" wouldn't be a show--I watched those 2 episodes & realized that I know better...
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
logicalchoice
logic is as logic does
11:37 PM on 12/26/2011
One day all religions that hate and restrict and destroy will be gone and we will all love each other and the great creator as one.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
stuoverit
"What year did Jesus think it was?"-GC
10:34 PM on 12/27/2011
Considering that there are humans who, in the same moment, possess the capacity to build a nuclear weapon while thinking they'll be rewarded in the afterlife, methinks you're mistaken.
11:12 PM on 12/26/2011
Christians are the worst probly most hipacritical there are I wasn't defending Christians I was just saying there base shopper is that. It's all marketing they will lose more money supporting that show.
08:08 AM on 12/27/2011
Not all Christians are Evangelical Protestant types.
10:48 PM on 12/26/2011
If lowes base buyer is American Chirstians why would they piss them off and shame on the learning channel for putting them in that spot? We have tons of Americans born here that need help. So most Americans don't are about there plight. We have are own.when I'm done making sure my kids eat and I can make all my payments I'll worry bat something and it will be something less important then a TV show that's helping people"no matter who they are" that want to be on TV when real people "the homeless" could use the money. Sorry ur roof leaks but ask the guy who doesn't have a roof.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
temmaleah
10:42 PM on 12/26/2011
the christian religion is the one thru HISTORY that has shown no regard for anybody else's religion and has exacted ANY MEANS to eradicate it. roman catholics despise any outgrowth of the religion and do not consider any of the others christians.. as for genocide of a people's because of their not being christians .as for the fact that religion is SUPPOSED to be seperate from gov the tea partiers and the evangelicals have ignored THAT aspect of the constitution; but considering they forced the republicans to
'swear" to a do nothing congress they are exerting a religious doctrine which not ALL americans believe in. the wonder of america is that we ARE TOLERANT of others beliefs,(note i said tolerate),and some of us accept it by knowing THE PERSON not the group,and soon the group becomes accepted. intolerance IS NOT what this country was based on. it was first colonized by people running away from religious persecution.then after it was economical but now we're back to persecuting religious differences? or is it about money? if so, wouldn't that town of dearborn,a whole town ;spend more money than that religious group that "blackmailed" lowe's? i wonder
08:53 PM on 12/26/2011
I've stopped shopping at Lowe's. They are far too easily swayed by Racist's and Bigot's and have shown they are capable of targeting ANY religion or group. The left wing of the Tea Bag Rabble want to make this country into a Fundamentalist country run by religious zelots that would destroy the constitutional law that saparates Church and State. In that respect they are no better than the Taliban that want Sharia Law to prevail where ever they have power. Are we so stupid to believe the Tea Bags are promoting Religious Fundamentalism just for fun ? They want it to become the 'National Religion' by forcing candidates for congress and the presidency to sign onto their 'litness test' for the promotion of this cultlike religion. They mouth off their belief in the constitution while at the same time fighting for our government to be ruled by the religious beliefs of this madcap group. Being a racist and bigot comes easy for some Americans, especially the less educated red necks in the southern states. (example: South Carolina) Shopping at Lowes in my opinion PROMOTES racism and bigotary, and perhaps this example has provided us with an opportunity see the REAL Lowe's 'mission statement' to be exposed as their corporate policy. The are the closest major home improvement store to me, but I'm DONE with Lowe's.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
tamihunter45
Two half nothin's is a whole nothin'!
01:04 AM on 12/30/2011
Ooooooh!! I bet they are scared to death!! Now, just because YOU won't shop there, they are going to have to close their doors! LOL! Now, tell me this, what do you think of THIS: MADISON HEIGHTS, Mich. (WXYZ) - Five gas station owners in Madison Heights plead in a price-fixing scheme.
Four station owners pleaded guilty, while one owner pleaded no contest in a scheme where the gas prices at the five stations were set within a few cents of each other.
Attorney General Bill Shuette says the gas station owners lined their pockets **at the customers expense**
Not to mention all the price gouging that went on when the towers were hit, when the Eastern coast had the black out AND even when Hurricane Katrina hit.
I guess THAT'S somehow "different", eh? Well, don't shop at Lowes. WHO CARES?
02:09 PM on 12/26/2011
Thank you for all this great publicity for Lowe's. They are raking it in big time.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
tamihunter45
Two half nothin's is a whole nothin'!
01:06 AM on 12/30/2011
I'll keep shopping there. I LOVE Lowes! If they don't want to back that program, that's their right and I don't mind as long as they are open when I need something.
01:56 PM on 12/26/2011
Advertisers do want to reach as many people as possible and for myself I tried to watch but it just seemed like following arround some Americans that are just as boring as me and the highlite was a woman deciding to wear a scarf on her hair or not just did not do it for me.
10:26 PM on 12/26/2011
why then r the kardashians so interesting
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
stuoverit
"What year did Jesus think it was?"-GC
10:34 PM on 12/27/2011
Because America is full of idiots.
11:56 AM on 12/26/2011
Could articles stop referring to the Florida Family Association as a group or an organization? It has ONE EMPLOYEE!. JUST ONE, who is on record as making approximately $50,000 a year. He is the president, vice president, secretary AND treasurer.

Just because he bought some stationary that has the word "Association" on it, doesn't actually make him a group.