iPhone app iPad app Android phone app Android tablet app More

Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Mickey Harpaz

GET UPDATES FROM Mickey Harpaz
 

Menopause Myths On Weight Gain And Age Dispelled

Posted: 02/07/2012 1:46 pm

There are 50 million menopausal women in America and yet, menopause is still considered a taboo topic. Many women know that it is an inevitable part of life -- a phase that they can't escape, no matter how hard they try -- but they do try to escape it or at best pretend it doesn't exist. After all, no one wants to admit they are getting older; young is in and everyone wants to stay young somehow, but that doesn't stop the clock. Time marches on. So why not find a way to deal with this elephant in the room? In this age of abundant knowledge at our fingertips and openness about many topics past generations just didn't talk about, we need to start talking about menopause. And not just when it happens, but before it happens. Many women experience changes in the years leading up to menopause, known as perimenopause.

One of the most distressing and common symptoms for the majority of women is weight gain due to changes in hormone balance: progesterone, testosterone and estrogen decrease and androgen increases. These changes affect a woman's body and how it burns and uses calories, in turn affecting its ability to lose fat. In fact, research shows that 95 percent of menopausal women who diet will regain as much as two-thirds of the weight they lose within one year of completing a diet program, and almost all of it within five years. And nine out of 10 American premenopausal and menopausal women will gain weight (as will 70 percent of all women worldwide, due to varied diets and other cultural influences), says Amos Pines, MD, former president of the International Menopause Society. They can expect to gain 10 to 20 pounds, which translates into needing clothing that's one or two sizes larger. Many menopausal women become frustrated, discouraged, annoyed, and angry as they gain the weight. I can't say I blame them.

After working with over 10,000 menopausal women in my practice over the past 23 years, I have seen some misconceptions and myths that women have believed that have hindered their success in navigating the dreaded "change." The good news is you don't have to believe those myths. There is a way to get your body back. Here are a few of the biggest myths I have come across in my work with premenopausal and menopausal women.

1. Myth: "If I starve myself, I won't gain weight during menopause."

Good news: dieting is out. With nine out of 10 women gaining weight during menopause, I've heard my share from desperate dieters. What women fail to realize is that their body chemistry completely changes, so that the old ways of staying slim simply won't work going forward. Eat like a bird or skip a meal and you risk gaining instead as metabolism slows to defend against what feels to your body like starvation. You've got to eat to get thin. But women need to know what and how to eat in order to increase metabolic rate and burn body fat. Small amounts of food at frequent intervals rather than three big meals a day will help regulate blood sugar, burn calories, melt fat and get you thinner.

2. Myth: "I can avoid the menopausal muffin top if I work my butt off doing high intensity exercise."

There may be nothing like an intense, sweaty workout to make you feel on top of your game, but it won't help you shed the pounds or the pouch. High-intensity exercises like Zumba, spinning or step -- though great for cardiovascular conditioning -- burn more sugars than fat, doing nothing for weight loss. To trim the fat, you need moderate cardiovascular activity, like a three mile walk or 45 minutes on a treadmill. Though walking is less grueling -- no huff, no puff -- you do need to do it every day.

3. Myth: "It's not fair; menopause is starting earlier and earlier these days."

We can't blame hormones in the food for this one. It's all your mother's fault! With 99 percent certainty, women go through menopause at exactly the same age their mothers did. And in much the same way. Night sweats? Hair loss? How irritable was she? Just ask her. And make it sooner than later; many moms can't remember, and when they do, there's often selective memory at work. When asked by one daughter what her menopause had been like, one mother responded, "Oh, just fine," to which her other younger daughter, the one who'd been living at home at the time, piped up, "Are you kidding, Mom? You were a wreck!" No need for women to feel they are entering a phase that will leave them out of control. With more communication and more women joining in the conversation they can find a way to take control of "the change."

4. Myth: "Menopause has done me in. I'll never get my body back."

There's nothing like menopause to wreak havoc on a perfectly good body. From extra pounds to muffin tops, hot flashes to hair loss, it's no wonder women get depressed. Through understanding how food, diet and exercise affect the menopausal woman, symptoms can be mitigated and the damage reversed. The trick: understanding metabolic mechanisms and then manipulating them. The right proportion of protein to carbs, the amount of fat intake and revving up fat-burning movement will all help to regulate blood sugar and burn calories. Armed with information specific to menopause weight control, women will no longer ask,"Why is it that the older I am, the more I exercise and the less I eat, the fatter I get?"

The bottom line is that menopause doesn't have to snatch your body and replace it with an unhealthier one; you can get your body back by understanding what is happening and applying common sense and do-able principles. For more see www.drharpaz.com and www.menopausereset.com.

 
FOLLOW FIFTY
 
 
  • Comments
  • 15
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
photo
ginadeoliveira2008
Seen a shooting star tonight and I thought of you
06:56 PM on 03/07/2012
Wackette, some comments below this one, is right-- weight gain is the least of it! Your hair changes drastically, your skin stops shinning(mine used to), as your hormones play havoc your face seems to change, aging in a fast forward way. Of course I gained a lot of weight too, but I was able to lose it. As for the rest of the drama, had to get used to. And make the best of it.
04:12 PM on 02/14/2012
You don't have to think about menopause as only a downer and only about weight gain and hormone change. Visit http://menstruationresearch.org/blog/ to read about other ways to think about menopause!
09:46 AM on 02/10/2012
I doubt that men really know what women go through during menopause... weight gain is the least
of it!
12:35 PM on 02/09/2012
I read Menopause Reset and it was very educational and made sense and true. I was able to lose 13 lbs but had the help of Dr Seigal's Cookie Diet. I want to lose 10 more and will with the help of Dr Seigal and your book. Bottom line is that we eat too much food. I do light exercise every day but nothing that pounds these old joints. Golf, water aerobics and walking 2 miles a day. Thanks Mickey
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Anne Siperek
11:40 AM on 02/09/2012
Umm, hate to break it to the person shown in the picture, but that is way more then just a muffin top. Thats an entire cake made for a party of 25.
08:13 AM on 02/09/2012
Menopause and the lead-up period are not just different for every woman, the symptoms vary from day to day in my experience. Accepting the chemical change in one's body is a process, it doesn't happen overnight, and the exercise needed to manage weight is also tied to general body type and the condition one cultivated while hormones still infiltrated our systems.

What works for you may not work for me - I truly believe everyone finds their own way to cope and regain balance of their body and its chemistry.

One nerve the author did hit accurately is the fact that stigma surrounding menopause must end. As baby boomers age, the number of women in some stage of menopause will only increase each year, and with any luck we can establish a new perception of what a menopausal or post-menopausal woman looks, acts, and feels like. I for one feel just as "sexy," "young" and "attractive" as I ever did, and am on something of a personal crusade to explore spreading this revelation to others via an awareness ribbon, somewhat jokingly designed with a "flame" motif. If you'd be interested in participating and promoting this campaign. visit my blog http://menopauseawareness.org and let me know!

Hang in there ladies, it gets better.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
playflute2
flootz
09:58 PM on 02/08/2012
Sorry, but the person in the picture with the headline suffers from an inability to 'push away'. I fear too much is blamed on hormones, changing hormones, lack of hormones, etc. Oh, and what 'no exit' said. Menopause advice from a man--just a bit hard to get serious about.
06:37 PM on 02/08/2012
Women have it all wrong when they try to avoid weight gain. They starve themselves, do useless cardio classes, or gym machines, and avoid heavy weight lifting because they are afraid of getting "too big." I am knee deep in perimenopause, hot flashes, metabolic changes, etc. I speak from experience. The weight appeared around my middle, and I drastically changed my workout plan. Since martial arts is my exercise of choice, I switched from a more cardio one to a grappling art (Judo). Yes, grappling. Not saying that all women should do this... But my point is that if you want avoid the muffin-top, you will have to think outside of the (feminine) box. You will have to do strength-intensive, core-intensive workouts. You will have to build serious muscle. You cannot avoid the menopausal tire around the middle by running on a treadmill and eating salad.

Or...not. I know plenty of women who just accept it. Nothin wrong with that.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
02:38 AM on 02/08/2012
A bit difficult for me to take menopause advice from a man.
07:45 AM on 02/10/2012
Especially someone who sounds like he's barking orders at a boot camp! And if he thinks we need to start talking about menopause, he needs to do a search for the word and find thousands of sites dealing with it and some (like www.minniepauz.com) have been helping women explore menopause for nearly 18 years!
08:23 AM on 02/10/2012
I agree....I was offended by his attitude and that he acts like he's the first person to bring menopause out into the light. Minnie Pauz has been helping women get through menopause for nearly 18 years.
01:01 AM on 02/08/2012
Thanks for the tips - I think it is great that there is so much information and openness on menopause these days. I don't think that it has to be a horrible, negative experience as long as we have the proper information and manage the process in a healthy way.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
RhiannonRings
Childfree and loving it!
11:43 PM on 02/07/2012
I use tequila for my symptoms.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
jacquelinenh
HuffPo Addict
10:41 PM on 02/07/2012
Here are 10 more myths! http://www.womentowomen.com/menopause/menopausemyths.aspx
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
kirkland
08:23 PM on 02/07/2012
There are some great natural remedies/supplements for every issue which you mention. 7 keto, pregnenolone, algae/chlorella in the am and if you have a sweet tooth...a little bit of chromium piccolinate. JUST these things in conjunction with regular exercise , makes a HUGE difference.