More

Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Mike Elk

Mike Elk

Posted: October 22, 2010 03:15 AM

The locked-out workers of USW Local 7-699 in Metropolis, Ill., are claiming that their company, defense contractor Honeywell, is spending more money to keep its workers locked out than what it would cost to give the workers what they are demanding. Honeywell wants to cut retiree healthcare and pensions entirely for new hires and increase their healthcare contributions to $8,500 a year (see more about the Honeywell lockout here).

USW spokesman John Smith claims that, according to calculations done by the union, it would cost Honeywell a total of $20 million over the three-year life of the contract for workers to keep their health and retiree benefits at current levels. Union officials say that Honeywell has already spent or lost at least $48.8 million to keep the workers locked out of the facility.

This figure includes the costs of contracting at scab labor estimated to be $20 million, an estimated $5 million to house, feed, transport, and provide additional security for the 300 scab labor working inside the plant, and $2.5 million for overtime pay for management working extra hours. This figure does not include legal costs for Honeywell, which has sued the union for their picketing activities.

Additionally, the plant has lost at least $22 million in production in the 11 weeks the plant was shut down.  Honeywell plant manager Larry Smith confirmed that the plant lost $2 million each week for the 11 weeks the plant shut down -- a total loss of $22 million for the company.

Union officials claim it's outrageous for Honeywell to claim they do not have $20 million to maintain their current health and retiree benefits over a three year period when the company is willing to lose $22 million alone through lost production.

So why is Honeywell willing to spend more money to lockout its workers for six months (they were locked out in late June) than to just give the workers want they want?

The company employs several thousand workers scattered among a number of different unions at Honeywell facilities throughout the country.  By showing that Honeywell is willing to hit its workers hard at the Metropolis facility, it's sending a signal to its workers throughout the country: Either give into the company demands or endure the months of financial hardships and missed mortgage payments like the workers at Honeywell's Metropolis facility are enduring.  

For decades, Honeywell didn't engage in hardball union tactics with its employees. Likewise, it did not use political contributions to lobby for its special interests. Honeywell had refused to get involved in political giving under former CEO Lawrence Bossidy, who left in 2002. Now under new CEO David Cote, the Honeywell Corporation, having given $3 million in PAC contributions, is the number one political donor in the country, according to a report released yesterday by the Center for Responsive Politics.

Honeywell has used this political clout to win $13 billion worth of federal contracts, mainly in defense spending, during the last ten years, leading to record profits. The company is on the verge of expanding massively, in large part because it has received several contracts under the stimulus to make hybrid batteries.

Now Honeywell is seeking to prevent defense-spending cuts by using its political clout to prevent it. It has increased its political giving by almost 400 percent since Obama, who has flirted with defense cuts and contractor reform, came to power in 2008.

But that's just the beginning. Honeywell has used its political clout to get Cote on the Obama's deficit commission in order to prevent defense cuts. Cote so far has pushed back against calls by Senator Tom Coburn (R-OK) to cut waste in the military by suggesting instead that the military cut the pay of its troops overseas (many of whom are already relying on food stamps) and make them pay for their own healthcare. Cote has also supported cuts to Social Security.

Honeywell has also faced accusations that it's used political clout to get the Nuclear Regulatory Commission (NRC) to approve allowing undertrained scabs to work with enriched uranium at the Metropolis facility. In the 60-plus years the union has represented the Metropolis uranium facility, the commission has never allowed scabs to be hired during a lockout.

Given that the Metropolis plant is the only conversion facility of its kind in the United States, familiarity with the plant, and not just generic experience in the field, is key to ensuring the plant's safety. This time around, the company worked with the NRC for more than a year to draw up acceptable contingency plans for hiring temporary labor -- and was ultimately granted permission to do so.

So, to recap: Honeywell under CEO David Cote is willing to do whatever it takes to provide Wall Street investors with ever-expanding profits, including (paradoxically) losing massive sums of money to bust its union.

The question of the hour is: Are the labor and progressive movements willing to stop Cote from his drive for unlimited corporate profits at the expense of workers? The answer in Metropolis is "Yes," as union members pledge to remain out on the picket line for as long as it takes to win a contract to their liking.

 

Follow Mike Elk on Twitter: www.twitter.com/MikeElk

 
 
  • Comments
  • 48
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2  Next ›  Last »  (2 total)
05:18 PM on 11/11/2010
maybe if the unions would quit spending all the members money on elections, and would spend it on the members themselves, they wouldn't need more
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
marijam
Independent
12:25 PM on 10/25/2010
The will spend anything that it takes, today, in order to break the back of the unions so that they won't have to pay out the money tomorrow. It's all about the race to the bottom.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Lance Manling
10:00 AM on 10/26/2010
An alternate version could be that the company does not agree to the Union's position, therefore the workers represented by the union are "locked out". Both parties are to blame for the impasse.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
edejan
02:55 AM on 10/25/2010
Another ant-America company willing to go as far as needed to break the employees' morale....before moving their jobs overseas.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Lance Manling
09:58 AM on 10/26/2010
An anti-American company that has plants in the US?
09:24 PM on 10/24/2010
With (Obama's) friends like these, who needs Republicans?
photo
LunaPark
Don't believe it until it's officially denied
12:43 PM on 10/24/2010
Honeywell should just move to South Carolina or Texas. Those states will appreciate the jobs you create.
02:08 AM on 10/25/2010
Honeywell has at least 4 facilities in South Carolina and at least 5 in Texas. Those employees are getting screwed too and they can't do anything about it. By the way, thanks for leading the corporation cheering squad. Let me guess, without unions Honeywell wouldn't be stuck at a dismal 74 on the Fortune 500. With a record like that I ought to pay them to employ me.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Lance Manling
08:00 PM on 10/25/2010
Why are the employees getting "screwed"? If I don't like the company that I work for, I can always leave.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
OSCPJ
Want it? Work 4 it. No 1 has ever drown in sweat.
05:47 PM on 10/23/2010
"USW spokesman John Smith claims that, according to calculations done by the union, it would cost Honeywell a total of $20 million over the three-year life of the contract for workers to keep their health and retiree benefits at current levels. Union officials say that Honeywell has already spent or lost at least $48.8 million to keep the workers locked out of the facility.

BS Flag up here. HP, why can't you do any research and figure out what the cost are? You don't think the union would have anything to gain by using Their numbers?

Apparently Honeywell has no problems with the math.
12:01 AM on 10/24/2010
Company sources reported several weeks ago that their costs and losses had already exceeded $50 million. The Union simply identified areas where the losses came from. Would you expect Honeywell to report this information?
schatsie
banks are more dangerous than standing armies
10:24 PM on 10/24/2010
Where are the numbers on the CEOs bonuses and stock options and pension and the pensions of management,,,,million dollar a year pensions for the top 20 just like American Airlines....but god forbid the production workers get anything....
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Lance Manling
08:04 PM on 10/25/2010
Workers dictate their own worth to a company, not the union.
04:34 PM on 11/11/2010
I tries to post those.
10:54 AM on 10/23/2010
Republican Businessmen are Heartless !
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
07:16 AM on 10/23/2010
Honeywell boasted of profits of $2.153 billion in 2009 even with the economic downturn.

David Cotes is one of the top 10 paid CEO's in america...$28.7 million for 2009

Wake up america.....Big Business won't be happy till the middle class is gone.

15 million hungry unemployed americans fighting over what few jobs are available......a corporate dream come true.
schatsie
banks are more dangerous than standing armies
10:25 PM on 10/24/2010
28.7 million, that does not put him in the top 400.....who averaged 250 million a year....poor baby...
06:11 PM on 10/22/2010
Does Honeywell still produce those particularly devastating "flechettes" that they sold to the U.S. military for use on Vietnamese women & children?

Flechettes are little arrows, made of plastic, encased in bombs. When they are dropped on people and explode with tremendous force, they penetrate the body as they tear through flesh, but were rendered invisible on X-ray, so removing them from the injured was next to impossible.

Just another way the U.S. spreads its brand of democracy around the globe.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
OSCPJ
Want it? Work 4 it. No 1 has ever drown in sweat.
05:49 PM on 10/23/2010
I've never seen plastic ones, but have seen the metal ones.

BTW, they were never sold to be used against Vietnamese women and children.
11:02 PM on 10/23/2010
We're always told bombs are used against "insurgents," these days. During the Vietnam War, if they were killed in the official body count, or injured, they were always VC.

Unfortunately, those least likely to be able to run & hide were then as now, women & children.
04:30 PM on 10/22/2010
Dear Friends,

They pay millions on lobbyist fees, they can do as they please with the Unions, as in Washington it is all about money all the time, and as long as you pay money to the party in power, it does not matter what party is power you can get what you want.

Honeywell moved tons of work overseas, and will continue to do so, and they will increase their donations to what ever party is in power.

One thing people need to understand is both the democrats and the republicans are owed by the donors, and our only chance is to vote everybody out of government after one term, as it is very hard to be completely corrupt in one term.

But if you are truely smart and from Chicago, it is a lot less hard.
10:35 PM on 10/27/2010
I guess the Unions don't lobby or contribute to candidates as a way of gaining influence?
imayes
Mongo like candy!
04:02 PM on 10/22/2010
Sounds like someone forgot to do a cost-benefit analysis before letting the strike happen. That's just bad business.
06:11 AM on 10/28/2010
Not a strike, a lockout. There is a very important distinction. The union offered to continue to work under the benefits of the newly expired contract while negotiations continued toward a new fair contract. Honeywell decided that instead of maintaining production that they would rather completely shut down and lock the union members out of the plant.
imayes
Mongo like candy!
08:14 AM on 10/28/2010
That's even worse! So basically the company incurred unnecessary losses just for spite.

Thanks for clarification.
03:51 PM on 10/22/2010
I can't dispute any of the facts presented in this article. However, not only union employees are getting squeezed. White-collar employees took a 10% pay cut in 2009 and were furloughed for a week this year. The company 401K match was cut in half, with no promise from Dave Cote of a return in the future. Health care plan costs continue to spiral out of control, and retiree benefits were eliminated. This is where Globalism has led us, to a severely weakened middle class. Honeywell is the poster-company for outsourcing jobs, and Dave Cote is on the short list of possible replacements for Larry Sommers, Obama's top economic advisor. The message needs to be delivered to politicians on both sides of the aisle that this rampant cronyism is destroying our country.
schatsie
banks are more dangerous than standing armies
10:28 PM on 10/24/2010
Health care in this country is an abscess on the working class.. there is no job security any more. so we no longer have a vibrant and creative middle class....sad, so sad....
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
marijam
Independent
12:29 PM on 10/25/2010
Which is one of the reasons why we have a mortgage problem. Who truly qualifies with "stable income"?
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
mountainweb
Conservative Commonsense
03:39 PM on 10/22/2010
Bottom line, they have been screwing their employees for so long that they do not want to set a bad precedent by doing something FOR them even though it costs them far more money.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Anthony C Wilson
02:49 PM on 10/22/2010
Every worker, at every job needs to stand up and walk out. The ruling class has milked you for too long. And they will sell you out in a heartbeat if it means they will beat earnings. Corporate America has become too big to fail....so they won't. They'll get bailed out by the taxpayers they have been bilking out of wages and jobs for 20 years - and then turn around and pay lobbyists to block legislation meant to protect consumers, taxpayers.

Massive strikes would cripple the business of this country. And workers need to take advantage of their strength in numbers and force the corporations to play by the taxpayers rules and shut-down the government until they start advocating on our behalf, you know, like why we elected them. People need to band together and force changes upon the existing structure - which is oligarchy. We should have let the banks fail...not get bigger and more powerful. There aren't many chances left to save this country (if its even worth saving) before we're a corporately-controlled fascist dictatorship. The extremists are out there infiltrating Congress right now, corrupting "representatives" of the people. The people need to get extreme and preserve our fleeting democracy. Liberty is literally dying.
04:31 PM on 10/22/2010
Dear Anthony,

Please move to France, I really do not want to live in a country that is crippled.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
07:04 AM on 10/23/2010
Here Here !
American workers really do need to get organized and stand up for a fair wage and benefits.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
marijam
Independent
12:32 PM on 10/25/2010
The white collar workers at the Boeing plant in Wichita voted in a union. A short time later Boeing sold the plant to a company from Canada. When they took over, they gave every single person a pink slip and bought off the union. Then they hired a portion of those people back on, but at a reduced salary. If you win, you lose.
02:25 PM on 10/22/2010
There is your proof! Corporations don't think ONLY of money!