iPhone app iPad app Android phone app Android tablet app More

Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Mikko Alanne

GET UPDATES FROM Mikko Alanne
 

No Justice for Animals

Posted: 09/22/11 01:48 PM ET

This past year, the big American agribusiness tried a novel new way to prevent the nation from seeing the truth about its factory farms -- four states introduced bills that would've made all undercover filming of animals inside them illegal. All four attempts failed.

Now, Finland has brought its own Kafkaesque twist to such efforts.

In December 2009, Finnish media outlets stunned the nation by publishing disturbing video and photographs from inside 30 pig factory farms, the result of a two-month undercover investigation by the leading Finnish animal rights group, Justice for Animals. You can see the images and videos here.

Sights of injured, dead, and dying pigs outraged a country whose factory farmers had always touted their "humane" practices. Members of Parliament and even agribusiness representatives condemned what they saw. Police investigations were promised. There were even calls for the Minister of Agriculture to resign (she didn't).

Now, almost two years later, the events have taken a truly incredible turn.

Instead of charging a single pig factory farmer with cruelty to animals, Finnish authorities are prosecuting the two activists who made the undercover videos, Karry Hedberg and Saila Kivelä. The charges are "aggravated defamation" of the nation's pig farmers and "disturbing the peace."

What makes this prosecution so startling is that not one person has disputed the authenticity of the images, nor claimed that the filming involved break-ins or property damage of any kind. In fact, by their own admission, none of the pig farmers were even aware that any activists had been to their farms until the videos were made public.

But the logic of this prosecution -- at least to Finnish authorities -- is clear: the conditions at the pig farms, while accurately recorded, are in themselves legal, therefore making their exposure illegal and defamatory.

In an unprecedented move, prosecutors are also seeking actual prison time for Hedberg, and demanding that he and Kivelä pay 180,000 euros in damages. Just how unusual is this? To contrast: a recent tear gas attack on a gay rights march in Helsinki that left 88 people injured resulted in only four-month probationary sentences for the three assailants -- a disgrace in itself.

The record of Finnish courts safeguarding the rights of animal activists leaves much to be desired. In 1997, a shotgun-wielding fur farmer received only an 18-month probationary sentence after shooting and wounding three young activists -- one of them critically -- for trespassing on his farm. In addition to bullet wounds, activists also received four-month probationary sentences for breaking two locks at the farm.

The matter of Justice for Animals and their undercover investigation comes before the Finland Proper District Court next month.

We'll see what passes for justice for activists this time.

As for the animals, we already know.

 
 
 
This past year, the big American agribusiness tried a novel new way to prevent the nation from seeing the truth about its factory farms -- four states introduced bills that would've made all undercove...
This past year, the big American agribusiness tried a novel new way to prevent the nation from seeing the truth about its factory farms -- four states introduced bills that would've made all undercove...
 
 
  • Comments
  • 71
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
crom14
04:50 PM on 09/25/2011
Animals are here only because we breed them.
02:15 AM on 09/28/2011
So are most of the fruits, vegetables, and grains we eat. What's your point?
photo
IrieMoon
Don't blame me, I voted for Kodos.
12:34 PM on 09/28/2011
So animals wouldn't exist without humans making them breed?


Funny.
Try telling that to the abundant wildlife located in the woods behind my house.
10:59 AM on 09/25/2011
Here you can find more information about the undercover investigation: http://www.sikatehtaat.fi/english

Oikeutta Eläimille has also published a investigation in 2007. During the investigation 21 Finnish broiler farms, 60 pig factories and 20 egg farms (most of them battery units) were visited. You can find more information here: http://www.oikeuttaelaimille.net/ttnet/index.php?option=com_content&task=view&id=154&Itemid=174

Finland is the world´s biggest fox fur producer and latest investigation shows the reality of Finnish fur farms. Some of these farms are owned by people in very high positions within the industry. Here you can see more information: http://www.tarhauskielto.fi/investigation-into-fur-farms-in-finland-2011 And a petition demanding Finnish government to ban fur farming http://www.thepetitionsite.com/3/ban-fur-farming-in-finland/
photo
richj45
politically correct linux vegetarian
05:32 PM on 09/24/2011
It takes 16 pounds of grain to produce 1 pound of meat and 70% of the grain and cereals we produced are used to feed animals.. One trip to a slaughter house will cure anyone with a brain and sense of passion from ever eating meat again..
TomP100
Got elk?
12:30 AM on 09/25/2011
"It takes 16 pounds of grain to produce 1 pound of meat"
---------------------------

It takes 0 pounds of grain to produce 1 ton of 100% pasture-raised, grass-fed beef or bison.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
frank day
Obama cares about all of U.S.
06:56 PM on 09/25/2011
You can't feed 330 million people grass fed pastured beef.

Next.
11:49 AM on 09/26/2011
Hmm, it only takes 1.74kg of feed to produce 1kg of pork from our pigs while grass-fed animals can be raised in places where cereals can't be grown.

As for farmers and farm workers who abuse animals, the book should be thrown at them provided the abuse is genuine and proven. For example, there will be days when a visitor to our croft (small farm) would find a bag of dead piglets. It's not abuse and it's not the result of abuse—sows crush their offspring and we keep the carcasses back until there's a bagful to go to the knackery. Filmed in the right way, that bag of dead piglets would look damning.

In fact, the increasing insistence on "freedom" for sows actually leads to more injuries and deaths among piglets. We could put our sows in farrowing crates for three to four days either side of farrowing and save many piglets. But then we'd be accused of abusing the sows' welfare. So we have to accept gruesome injuries and deaths among piglets:

http://stoneheadcroft.com/2011/03/14/freedom-for-sow-can-be-death-for-piglets/
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
elcerritan
My bio is not micro
01:47 AM on 09/28/2011
Love your website!
12:45 PM on 09/24/2011
This is so EFFED UP- not surprised, money makes everything disappear or u turn.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Neil20
11:13 AM on 09/24/2011
It is unfortunate the world is getting more and more inhumane as each day passes. Despite the general awareness of animal cruelty the people of Finland like in America would rather turn a blind eye to such atrocities. For these heartless people animals are mere commodities to be turned into meat. Money is the sole motivation for these factory farm owners to treat the animals the way they do. Finnish people must wake up to this gruesome fact and bring about a refinement in their treatment of factory animals (and who knows how they treat their pets?) and change in their diets and refinement in their culture. A culturally superior nation will never allow its animals to be treated in such inhumane ways. Sadly the Finnish government seems to be least interested in the welfare of their animals. What a grotesque country?
01:16 PM on 09/24/2011
I GUESS THAT MAKES TWO OF US THAT WON'T BE VISITING:)....I KNOW MOST NATIONS ARE DOING THE SAME, BUT THEY DON'T PUT THE ACTIVISTS ON TRIAL!!!!!!!!!! THE WORLD IS GOING TO SHITTZZZZY. I'D LIKE TO SAVE IT, TAKES A LOT OF PEOPLE TO GET ANGRY!!! I AM ONE OF THEM!!!!!!!!!!!!
10:21 AM on 09/24/2011
I find it hard to have sympathy for groups of people who go out and use fear to get an organazation to change its practices. Terror just isn't a good way to go about reform. I think we have a word for those kinds of people.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
frank day
Obama cares about all of U.S.
08:17 PM on 09/24/2011
Republicans
11:59 AM on 09/25/2011
well then what would you use to make those abusers stop? If you have the answer I am sure that others would be more than open to using them if they work. But that is the problem, when you have abusers who enjoy what they are doing, like abusing these innocent creatures, then telling them that they should be better and to stop this, only makes they laugh. They enjoy what they do, they don't see any evil in what they do, and a slap on the old rotten hand ain't going to do anything. So please if you have the solution to stopping them, let's hear it!
02:15 AM on 09/26/2011
The animal industry is run to make money. If animal rights activist were to tell people about the industry using facts and not crazy stunts meant to get media attention then people might listen and stop buying the products. However, until it stops being profitable the practices will continue.
09:02 PM on 09/23/2011
This is what you call Criminal Justice. In favor of Criminals, not the victims of crime.
01:08 PM on 09/24/2011
COULD NOT AGREE MORE...WENT AWOL ON SOME AGRI GUY THAT THINKS IT'S 'TERRORISM' WTF?!?! DO THE MATH, WE EAT THIS FOOD, IT GETS TAINTED IF NOT CORRECTLY DONE, AND IN A HUMANE LAW, THIS WAS NOT HUMANE PRACTICE, SO WHY THE HELL THE ACTIVISTS ARE BEING BLAMED AND ACCUSED AND ON TRIAL IS BEYOND ME...REMIND ME NEVER TO VISIT FINLAND....USA HAS IT'S OWN PROBLEMS BUT WE DON'T PUT ACTIVISTS ON TRIAL!!!! ALSO, TO END INHUMANE PRACTICE TO ABIDE BY AGRI LAWS, SIMPLY INSTALL 24/7 DIGITAL CAMERAS...I'M QUITE CERTAIN PEOPLE WORKING THERE PROBABLY GET A KICK OUT OF ABUSING ANIMALS B/C THEY CAN'T ABUSE THEIR WIVES OR KIDS INSTEAD...SICK PEOPLE WORK IN THIS INDUSTRY AND I'M FED UP...I WANT A FULL ON WAR STARTED AGAINST ALL NATIONS THAT PRACTICE INHUMANE ABUSE ON ANIMALS..I EAT MEAT, (RARELY BUT I DO ON OCC)...AND I ALWAYS FEEL GUILTY, WONDERING, "DID THIS ANIMAL SUFFER IN WHICH I AM EATING NOW?"...SO I'VE SLOWLY STOPPED EATING MEAT AND STICK TO ONCE A WEEK....I'M DISGUSTED BY THE WORLD IN GENERAL..IT'S HIGH TIME WE GOOD SAMARITANS TAKE OVER BIG TIME!!!!!!!!!!!!
photo
richj45
politically correct linux vegetarian
05:25 PM on 09/24/2011
give meat up totally. its easy to do and you will no longer be part of the problem.. I gave it up 25 years ago and I've never missed it..
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
sabelmouse
i love to tumble , ask me why .
06:39 AM on 09/25/2011
i had to have my daughter read this to me. caplocks are not good for reading but spaces between lines are .
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
deweaver
Scientist, businessman, semi-retired
03:30 PM on 09/23/2011
Good for Finland. The animal welfare people have gone crazy with their anthropomorphism and need to get their chain pulled.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
almchrl13
07:04 PM on 09/23/2011
It about unnecessary suffering.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Dana Dallabetta
03:15 AM on 09/24/2011
Big word small heart.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
03:24 PM on 09/23/2011
It’s very easy to document abuse wherever animals are used for food or entertainment. I hope I live to see the day they’re no longer legally exploited.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Chad Wheeler
05:41 PM on 09/26/2011
it's also very easy to stage it, or pay someone to be cruel on film. I am not naive enough to believe that there aren't sadists who are cruel to animals, but I have read about enough cases of staged cruelty to make me leery of them.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
10:44 AM on 09/29/2011
"Staged?" Dogs are “man’s best friend” and they’re constantly found tortured, neglected and abused. Video footage of abused occurring in a lab, circus, or slaughterhouse isn’t staged.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
lambdin1
What's this?
02:58 PM on 09/23/2011
It involves money. Greed is world wide. When ever GREED is threatened action is taken against those who threaten GREED!!! It may appear that the states here failed to pass laws you cited but beware that there are other means by which GREED can silent those that it wishes.
08:29 AM on 09/24/2011
Did you consider the GREED is on the part of those who want cheaper food?
Why doesn't everyone insist on free range coddled animal products instead of fast food hamburgers?
Because they are GREEDY.
Of course every meal would cost $40 but, tough luck for those in lower income brackets.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
slocomgp
Reality has a liberal bias........
09:41 AM on 09/24/2011
Do you really think everybody is aware of the conditions? Isn't that what the article is about? The producers of the video are being prosecuted for filming the truth and putting it in front of the consumers. Duh.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
sabelmouse
i love to tumble , ask me why .
11:46 AM on 09/24/2011
coddled is a strange word to use. do you think the absence of torturous conditions is coodling?
personally i'd rather pay a reasonable price for free rang meat then outrages prices for brand name processed foods .
and i'm poor by the way though luckily not living in a food desert.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Bea Elliott
12:07 PM on 09/23/2011
It's clear that on a global level the animal industries make their own "justice". The rules always hinge on their monetary gain. Beware to anyone that wants to expose their dirty secrets on how "meat products" "live". Such a hideous sin it is - That keeping it hidden is worth being named for corruption instead.

I'm in gratitude to the activists who revealed the gruesome reality. I support their efforts completely. Press on!
11:09 AM on 09/23/2011
Is there anything we can do to pressure the Finnish government? Any officials to contact to express our shock at their country's handling of this issue?
Great article by the way!
photo
Deep Thinking Man
Always Remember, A Wet Bird Never Flies At Night !
07:57 PM on 09/24/2011
DS...you might try sending the Finnish Dept of AG an email voicing your dis-pleasure.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
SusanElizabeth1949
My micro-bio may be empty but my head isn't.
06:05 PM on 09/25/2011
I have a rather strong feeling that a Finnish elected or appointed official will give as much weight to e-mails of protest from the US (or any where other then Finland as a US elected/appointed official would give to e-mails from non US citizens/residents.