iPhone app iPad app Android phone app Android tablet app More

Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Mohamed A. El-Erian

GET UPDATES FROM Mohamed A. El-Erian
 

The Economy Will Do More Than Define the Elections

Posted: 06/25/2012 7:14 pm

Most political observers agree on two things: The economy will be one of the major defining topics in this year's presidential campaign, and probably the overwhelming one; and to boost his re-election prospects, President Obama needs it to stop weakening ­-- if not improve (as reflected in robust job creation, higher labor income, and enhanced consumer and business confidence).

It should therefore come as no surprise that the recently-released monthly employment report, which disappointed across the board, generated such opposing political narratives.

For the Republicans, it was yet another indication that the Obama administration is unable to deliver a robust recovery despite trillions of dollars of deficits, debt and money printing. For the Democrats, it was yet another reminder of the deep mess that Obama inherited back in January 2009 from his Republican predecessor, and the related inevitability of a protracted recovery.

Looking forward, both parties are asking the same question: Was the May jobs report an aberration or does it point to a renewed slowing of the US economy that could even reignite talk of another recession?

While volatile monthly numbers should never be taken as unambiguous signals, recent data do suggest that America's employment machine has lost substantial momentum and, more generally, the economy is having problems maintaining the growth vigor required to attain escape velocity and thus overcome the downward drag of too much debt accumulated over too many years.

After three encouraging monthly employment reports (December 2011 to February 2012, where average net monthly job creation exceeded 200,000 in the context of generally improving economic data), the economy added fewer than 100,000 jobs per month in the next three-month period; worst of all, net new jobs in May came in at a disheartening 69,000. Taking into account those not counted because they have dropped out of the labor force altogether, the proportion of the adult population with jobs today is stuck at around 58 percent. This compares to the mid-60s-percentile numbers that prevailed in the years prior to the 2008 global financial crisis.

All this speaks to both the extent of the economic and financial mess inherited by Obama and the inevitable difficulty of engineering a "normal recovery."

Whoever had come into the White House in January 2009 would have been challenged by an economy that faces unusual and significant impediments in gaining the cyclical traction that has been "typical" in the past - what we labeled back in May 2009 as the "new normal." Indeed, even the unprecedented amount of fiscal and monetary stimulus that has already been applied -- an extraordinary turbocharge if you like -- has not enabled the economy to attain escape velocity.

The message is clear. There are multi-year supply and demand problems that speak loudly to why the economy's recovery remains disappointing. No wonder it has proven so inadequate - especially in light of all the Americans that are out of work, those that are having enormous difficulties making ends meet, those that have already slipped into the poverty trap and the too many that have insufficient savings for their retirement years. And all this in an economy that, under Obama's predecessors, got significantly more unequal in its distribution of income and wealth and, therefore, its social compact.

Regardless of where we are in the election season, more needs to be done now to maintain forward progress.

This is not just about battling the internal headwinds created by the triple legacy that Obama inherited: too much debt; too little investment in education, job training and infrastructure; and too great a loss of competitiveness vis-Ă -vis other countries. It is also about building better defenses against the additional collateral damage that will hit us in the next few months from Europe's ever-deepening debt and growth crises - especially at a time when the usually-buoyant emerging economies seem to be hitting their own soft patch.

This is not the time to risk yet another mid-year economic slowdown that could even risk a recession. And Washington must realize that the urgency of the situation is heightened by what is happening beyond this country's borders.

Now I recognize that the extreme polarization of Congress will stand in the way of a proper policy response out of Washington. Indeed, realism dictates that, unfortunately, we should not expect to see a "first best" policy response. It will certainly not materialize in the run-up to the November elections.

Fortunately, there are steps that the administration can implement, and do so with or without the cooperation of the highly divided and divisive Congress. And while White House officials are only in a position to kick the can down the road for a while, this would avoid us tipping into an even worse situation.

Whether or not the administration succeeds in maintaining the growth and job momentum over the next few months is clearly an important question. And it is one that can only be answered if the administration shows greater resolve and if Congress stops standing in the way of virtually every policy proposal, big or small. Yet we should also realize that this is not the end of the challenges facing the American economy.

You see, the May employment report also demonstrated again the deep-seated nature of our unemployment crisis -- from the shockingly high and persistent number of long-term unemployed (stuck at 5.4 million Americans or 43 percent of officially-recorded unemployment) to the disastrous incidence of joblessness among the young (e.g., a 24.1 percent unemployment rate for 16-19 year olds in the labor force) and those that did not complete their high school education (a 14.6 percent unemployment rate relative to 4.5 percent for those with at least a bachelor's degree). Here, there is an unacceptably high risk that unemployed citizens can become unemployable if they remain out of work much longer.

For the economy to grow robustly for a number of years -- which is the only way that unemployment would come down properly, spreading poverty would be reversed, and the country would stand a chance of "safely de-levering" after the many years of excessive debt creation and credit entitlements -- Washington needs to move simultaneously and boldly on a number of different policy fronts. Otherwise, actions taken in any one area would be quickly undermined by lack of progress elsewhere. This is especially true for the long list of required but repeatedly delayed reforms in housing and housing finance; federal, state and local budgets; the labor market; education; regulation; lending; infrastructure and more.

Success here speaks to much more than whether it is Obama or Romney who wins the November presidential elections. It also relates to whether our political system as a whole can regain over time the ability to agree on a common economic vision, and to pursue it with the proper sense of shared responsibility, adequate seriousness and focused implementation.

Anything short of this would entail something that America is yet to experience in its proud history: the highly unsettling prospect that our our children's generation may end up worse off than ours. We should certainly not go there.

This piece appeared in the inaugural issue of Huffington.

 
FOLLOW BUSINESS
Most political observers agree on two things: The economy will be one of the major defining topics in this year's presidential campaign, and probably the overwhelming one; and to boost his re-election...
Most political observers agree on two things: The economy will be one of the major defining topics in this year's presidential campaign, and probably the overwhelming one; and to boost his re-election...
 
 
  • Comments
  • 543
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Highlights
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2 3 4 5  Next ›  Last »  (11 total)
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
drularter
Arrogance is confidence in someone you don't like.
02:52 PM on 08/01/2012
I can not wait to vote. Obama for America. Let's finish cleaning up the Republican's mess. Vote Democrat all the way through!!
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
frank1946
Tell the Truth
11:16 PM on 07/01/2012
Hey Mo, no Tax Revenue, no Growth, 80 % Spending to GDP and Obamacare, Tax Increases and
Europe Collapse looks grim to me !

A Perfect Storm is coming. Enormous Deficits, loss of Revenue and Growth, Viola, welcome to
France !

Send In the Clowns, don't bother.................there HERE.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Roosevelt Democrat
10:09 PM on 07/01/2012
A Prediction if unemployment is below 8% President Obama wins re-election if not he doesn't.

http://www.davemanuel.com/historical-unemployment-rates-in-the-united-states.php

Want to have fun with the numbers?

Compare President Obama's & President Reagan's first term unemployment numbers.
07:00 AM on 07/02/2012
But Reagan had a lot more good days then bad
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
10:08 PM on 07/01/2012
A government that increases the freedom of their citizens will succeed. Nothing else matters.
09:09 PM on 07/01/2012
food packing machine
Frozen French Fries production line covers the whole process from French fries making to its packing. Vegetable processing machine can help you cut, peel,dice or slice vegetables into beautiful shapes. Juice making machines are suitable for extracting sugarcanes and soybean milk. For meat processing, Amisy has steaming, slicing and smoking machines, etc. As to ice cream machine Amisy allows machines suitable for making soft, hard ice creams and fried ice. Besides, Amisy offers different mobile food cart based on different working principles.
08:31 PM on 07/01/2012
By this point in an ongoing crisis all should be aware that we face a new problem and that none of the old solutions are effective.

Our two-party government has become entrenched and increasingly polarized. Political compromise does not produce better legislation, it produces legislation that is ineffective and far more costly than presented because its spoils are shared among those who fund political campaigns and literally write the laws.

The states and the people have at times willing given up powers reserved to them by the Federal constitution to find that giving an inch results in a mile in a capitalistic society! Federal Constitutional amendments have become next to impossible.

We need to call a constitutional convention! Define once and for all whether a corporation (and a fetus) enjoys all liberties of a person. Finally decide upon whether the President is elected by the legislature or the popular, national vote. Better define the interstate commerce clause to either allow the federal government to regulate ALL commerce or clearly define where its regulatory powers end.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
inthedesert
Those who never question will fall for anything.
06:48 PM on 07/01/2012
And STILL not ONE bankster has done the perp walk in front of CNN cameras on their way to prison.
Amazing.
And, they NEVER will.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Roosevelt Democrat
10:12 PM on 07/01/2012
It's worse than that Financial Institutions indictments are way down under Attorney General Holder when compared to the Bush years!
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
inthedesert
Those who never question will fall for anything.
06:44 PM on 07/01/2012
To believe that either BO or MR can find the solutions to the continued-freefall of America is utter stupidity and nothing more than "wishful thinking". The way America is NOW will be the new norm for this once great nation. Both candidates have, apparently, completely "written off" the Middle Class, the poor, the blacks and any other group that is not latino. The problems of illegals from Mexico is now what is on the "minds" of both parties. Screw the rest of us. It's beyond amazing that the self-inflicted "issues" of illegals now trump the problems of the rest of us. I am sitting out this election. I refuse to wake up on the morning of November 7 and KNOW that I contributed to the continuing dissolution of America by both parties.
photo
xsited1
Moderated for my own good
05:37 PM on 07/01/2012
This author neglects to mention why the economy crashed in the first place. The warning signs were there, but they were not heeded. I read an economics book explaining the coming crash in 2006. When Congress did nothing in 2007 and 2008 I took my money out of the stock market. Thank goodness I did. Our government tends to do the opposite of what is necessary to improve the economy. It's as if they want the American economy to fail.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
10:10 PM on 07/01/2012
Politicians seek power first and foremost. Results are secondary. The founders understood this. We do not.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Oortcloud
05:30 PM on 07/01/2012
We have a glut of low to no-skill workers and a dearth of well-educated technical professionals. Low-skill jobs are offshore and will not return. The low-no skill segment, which is onerously large, will remain on the dole for generations to come. Until we make education a priority over oil wars, our economy will not improve.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
pa104inf
09:54 PM on 07/01/2012
To stop the oil wars all we need to do is actually drill and refine in this country, but, of course, our current President is opposed to that needed course of action.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
pa104inf
04:58 PM on 07/01/2012
Democrats, Obama inherited the economic mess almost four years ago. It is now his mess not George W. Bush's mess! Grow up!
07:05 AM on 07/02/2012
Bush had 9-11 Obama just looks for some one to blame
maddening
scoreboard
04:40 PM on 07/01/2012
Let's at least start blaming some American businesses for not hiring when they can. Some are not hiring not because of "uncertainty" but because they have figured out how to do without.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
pa104inf
09:56 PM on 07/01/2012
So what is your suggestion to force business to hire unneeded workers? I guess the government can since we just found out it is ok for Americans to be forced to buy a product they don't want.
maddening
scoreboard
06:51 AM on 07/02/2012
It's called social responsibility. Regarding health insurance, do you want to keep paying for the free-loaders that don't buy insurance but get sick or injured and use emergency rooms? That's not very teapublican of you.
03:50 PM on 07/01/2012
Does it take nearly 20 paragraphs to identify what is going on, on the ground in the United States. Wages are stagnant while the cost of living is rising. This a decades old problem.

However,Americans were making up this cost of living difference with credit (via credit cards or home equity loans, neither which are advisable) or a bubble stock market where anyone could multiply their money quickly, but those days are over.

If the average American is expected to participate in fueling economic activity using simply their declining incomes, why would anyone expect the economy to improve.

Or in more simple terms, stagnant wages produce stagnant consumption.
It is that simple.
03:49 PM on 07/01/2012
"Washington needs to move simultaneously and boldly on a number of different policy fronts. "
Which fronts, which policies, and why?
Silence....
This is another example of why HuffPost is the internet capital of the world for morons...
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Nomccain
03:04 PM on 07/01/2012
This is the reason why you can expect absolutely no cooperation from the OBSTRUCTIONISTS REPUBLICANS between now and the election. They are totally willing to play politics with this issue to regain power in Washington. They've become a disgrace to bipartisanship and to our political process and do NOT DESERVE TO BE RE-ELECTED.