iPhone app iPad app Android phone app Android tablet app More

Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Naomi Klein

Naomi Klein

Posted: June 4, 2010 11:56 AM

Blinding the Witnesses

What's Your Reaction:

There is something way too literal about Israel shooting out the eye of a witness to its crimes.

This photograph of Emily Henochowicz's bandaged face needs to be seen by the world.

2010-06-04-henochewicz1.jpg


Like many of us around the world, Henochowicz, a 21-year-old Cooper Union art student, joined protests on Monday against Israel's outrageous attack on the humanitarian flotilla. But unfortunately, the protest Emily attended was in the Israeli-occupied West Bank, and like so many protests in the West Bank, it was violently attacked by the IDF. According to a report from the International Solidarity Movement, Emily was "hit in the face with a tear gas projectile fired directly at her by an Israeli soldier during the demonstration at Qalandiya checkpoint today." Sören Johanssen, a Swedish activist standing beside Henochowicz, reported that, "They fired many canisters at us in rapid succession. One landed on either side of Emily, then the third one hit her in the face."

This courageous young woman is now the wrenching embodiment of a policy that systematically targets witnesses and human rights advocates -- from Stop the Wall's Mohammad Othman, arrested on his way back from a European speaking tour, to the vicious smear campaign waged against Justice Richard Goldstone.

Visiting Emily's homepage, I was struck that eyeballs are a recurring theme in her work. Not surprising, I suppose, for a visual artist. But an eyeball was how she chose to present herself to the world.

And there are eyeballs all over this beautiful piece:

2010-06-04-thatmood.jpg


She devoted her life to seeing, to witnessing. And for this she lost her left eye.

We owe it to Emily to look at her tragedy -- both its physical and its metaphorical implications -- as hard as we possibly can.

This post originally appeared on MondoWeiss.net.

 
There is something way too literal about Israel shooting out the eye of a witness to its crimes. This photograph of Emily Henochowicz's bandaged face needs to be seen by the world. Like many of u...
There is something way too literal about Israel shooting out the eye of a witness to its crimes. This photograph of Emily Henochowicz's bandaged face needs to be seen by the world. Like many of u...
 
 
  • Comments
  • 1,146
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2 3 4 5  Next ›  Last »  (14 total)
03:20 AM on 06/11/2010
Israel's PIETA

http://www.propheticimagery.com/Gaza%20Poem/The%20Cleansing%20of%20CoExistence.htm

"If a single picture is worth a thousand words, the picture above is worth immeasurably more!
 
In this scene, a Palestinian woman -- ongoing victim of Israel’s oppressive occupation -- comes to the humane aid of a Jew, Emily Henochowicz, who lost an eye after being hit in the face by a tear gas canister fired by a fellow Jew.
 
Emily was standing peacefully during a demonstration in West Bank at the Qalandiya checkpoint on that black Monday, May 31, 2010 -- to protest the Gaza Flotilla massacre -- when Israeli Border Police fired a large number of tear gas canisters directly at the heads of Emily and another International Solidarity Movement activist. 

In addition to losing her left eye, three metal plates were inserted into Emily's head/face, and her jaw is wired shut. The bone surrounding her eye socket, cheekbone and jawbone are all fractured.
-- Dom Martin"
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
02:17 AM on 06/10/2010
Thanks Naomi, a very short but good piece.

I wonder if this NY young artist will be welcomed back
by say Sen. Schumer, Mayor Bloomberg, Cong. Steve Israel,
or Ed Koch ?! Maybe throw a parade for her, I'm sure they
might if Arabs had done this to a Jew or Israeli.

Like many Americans I don't want anything bad to happen
to Israel or anyone anywhere. We just want right wing Israel
to Not INTERFER in US politics and government with it's
AIPAC, ADL, etc. and the spreading of Lie's, the killing
of over 1300 in Gaza, including 330+ CHILDREN !
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
ConstitutionCrusader
11:52 PM on 06/06/2010
Her family, and apparently the US embassy, has demanded an investigation.

http://www.haaretz.com/print-edition/news/u-s-demands-idf-probe-how-american-lost-eye-at-west-bank-protest-1.294566
12:04 AM on 06/07/2010
Israel completed her investigation. She said that the IDF dsid nothing wrong, and did NOT fire any cannisters at the protestors.

The cannisters, to the astonishment of the IDF, levitated and fired themselves.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
ConstitutionCrusader
12:10 AM on 06/07/2010
happens all the time! Actually, they want another investigation to be done by the local police I think.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
02:18 AM on 06/10/2010
magic candles that stayed lit for days...
magic tear gas that wounds and disappears...without ownership...
11:42 PM on 06/06/2010
It's a sad day when gullible people are recruited to become human shields.

It's a sad day when these human shields are actually injured after being manipulated into going into conflict zones manned by heavy military presence.

Sadder still when after being injured, the injuries of these human shields are touted around as trophies, used by by the ruthless and the immoral to recruit more gullible people into becoming human shields.
12:06 AM on 06/07/2010
Human shield?

This was a peaceful demonstration. No one was armed.

Please describe the human shield activity?
12:28 AM on 06/07/2010
It is a tactic for terrorist organizations to recruit young people and send them into dangerous military zones as human shields.

This is how it works. They usually recruit westerners, as in whites, or people from the same race they're fighting.

They tell these recruits 'you have a right to protest' and 'no cop or soldier has a right to fire on you.'

This is a lie.

In a military zone, for example, anyone who steps into this zone will be fired upon if they do not turn back despite warnings.

The same in military curfews. In Phnom Penh, for example, after a certain hour in the evening, you're not allowed to go outdoors.

If you believe what a recruiter tells you -- that you have an 'absolute right' to protest and walk around any time of the day -- you will go out into the streets after curfew and then bang, bang! you're dead!

In Emily's case, she was used as a propaganda tool sent to protest in a very unstable country where people are running around with guns and rockets.

She thought she had immunity. That the concept of human rights means she can say whatever she want, wherever she want, when she want. She thought being Jew gave her this right to enter a very dangerous situation unharmed.

She was wrong. She was injured badly.

Now Emily's injury is being used to recruit more college kids like her.

ISM does not care about her. They're just using
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
02:19 AM on 06/10/2010
crude comment, she was not a human shield....it seems it is mostly the IDF
that does that...
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
yonatan c
10:27 PM on 06/06/2010
The ISM is just as responsible for this tragedy. They put US students in harms way because it's good PR. This is not the first American student in the wrong place @ the wrong time, clearly directed there by ISM.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
ConstitutionCrusader
11:59 PM on 06/06/2010
Or, you could realize that this girl, and anyone, should have the right to demonstrate or protest anywhere they please without being brutalized by the police. Emily was demonstrating over something she believed in, whether you think she was misguided or not, that is her right.

This is the way Israel treats its citizens who do not agree with the policies of their government. People there are trying to strip the Israeli MP who participated in the flotilla of her citizenship. That is how Israel deals with dissenting opinions.

I have little doubt, based on the many OTHER incidents involving injuries and deaths from Israelis shooting people with tear gas canisters, that they aimed right for her.

"Tristan Anderson, 38, an American citizen, was critically injured on Friday, March 13th by Israeli troops during protests against Israel’s Wall in the West Bank village of Ni’lin. He was hit in his forehead by a new type of high velocity, extended range teargas projectile. Tristan was hit while standing with a fellow protester inside the village, several hours after the army initially attacked a protest march of Ni’ilin’s residents (joined by Israeli and international activists) who attempted to march onto their own lands in the vicinity of the wall." http://justicefortristan.org/
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
ConstitutionCrusader
12:21 AM on 06/07/2010
They totally rearranged his face... look at the brutality - it is evident from the photos.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
yonatan c
12:26 AM on 06/07/2010
She wouldn't have been there if the ISM hadn't put her there.
12:09 AM on 06/07/2010
What was wrong about the place and time? Was the area cordoned off?

The Swede standing next to her said the IDF fired tear gas CANNISTERS at her.

SURE seems like the IDF has a lot of "accidents" with Americans.
Thelonius
Lived in Middle East for
08:41 PM on 06/06/2010
US band the "Pixies" cancels concert in Israel

http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/entertainment_and_arts/10250452.stm
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
ConstitutionCrusader
12:00 AM on 06/07/2010
I adore the Pixies! Right on!
Thelonius
Lived in Middle East for
08:26 PM on 06/06/2010
Informative speech on video by Chris Hedges

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=elU3etpW-YQ

Chris Hedges is a senior fellow at The Nation Institute in New York City. He spent nearly two decades as a foreign correspondent in Central America, the Middle East, Africa and the Balkans. He has reported from more than 50 countries and has worked for The Christian Science Monitor, National Public Radio, The Dallas Morning News and The New York Times, for which he was a foreign correspondent for 15 years. Hedges was part of the team of reporters at The New York Times awarded a Pulitzer Prize in 2002 for the paper’s coverage of global terrorism. He also received the Amnesty International Global Award for Human Rights Journalism in 2002. He has taught at Columbia University, New York University and Princeton University.
06:22 AM on 06/07/2010
That is an excellent link and an extremely informative speech. Thank you for posting it.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
02:23 AM on 06/10/2010
watched part of it, agree mostly...thanks
photo
me again
I'm not wrong....
07:45 PM on 06/06/2010
The IHH, the finding behind this junket is a sponsor of terrorism. How many people would have been killed if their planned bombing of LAX had transpired. The people on this boat did little research to see who the funding was behind the flotilla. It was a provacative action, they knew the potential for violence up front and that they were trying to break a military blockade.
08:20 PM on 06/06/2010
Don't have to make things up to find the thousands of civilians killed by Israel.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
09:04 PM on 06/06/2010
The citizens of the U.S. don’t have to make things up to find the 10s of thousands of civilians killed by the U.S. in Iraq and Afghanistan.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
simonleuf
08:54 PM on 06/06/2010
Only in the eyes of totalitarian regimes and dictators can an aid ships be seen as a "provocative action". And about IHH: Only Israel has blacklisted the IHH, a human aids group, as a terrorist organization. The USA and EU have not. In fact the IHH is an consultative member of Ecosoc, which is the economic and social council of the UN.
12:09 AM on 06/07/2010
An 'aid ship' going to Ashdod to drop off aid is an 'aid ship.'

An 'aid ship' going into a maritime blockade chanting 'Khaybar!' and telling the navy to 'go back to Auschwitz!' is 'provocation.'
12:14 AM on 06/07/2010
fanned
batguano
As Long As Grass Grow, Wind Blow & The Sky Is Blue
04:42 PM on 06/06/2010
Beside Emily who was arguably deliberately shot in the head/face and lost her eye, Tristan Anderson, also shot in the head by a tear-gas canister of a new more lethal type, and the Palestinian protest leader Bassem Abu Rahma, who was killed when a tear gas canister hit him with such force it entered his chest. After Tristan was hit in the head the ambulance was held-up by the IDF as is their usual inhumane MO. The record is clear, the IDF intentionally and repeatedly fires directly on protesters to kill and maim. The intent of the IDF is to punish and strike fear into unarmed protesters; some ally of America, killing and maiming our citizens and Obama does nothing to demand an end.
Beside these killed by lethal teargas canisters we must remember another American, Rachel Corrie, killed when an IDF bulldozer ran her over and crushed her to death.

http://www.alternet.org/rights/132522/shooting_of_u.s._activist_by_israeli_army_spotlights_excessive_force_used_against_protesters/

http://observers.france24.com/en/content/20090421-palestinian-man-killed-teargas-canister-israel-security-wall-bilin
07:10 PM on 06/06/2010
its all about brutality and intimidation... and the elimination of witnesses...
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
ConstitutionCrusader
12:05 AM on 06/07/2010
http://justicefortristan.org/
04:08 PM on 06/06/2010
memo to Naomi Klein...Your book The Shock Doctrine is THE MOST IMPORTANT book to appear in the 21st century. It is the MUST READ book to understand the world as a gigantic criminal enterprise. However, your commentary about the sad fate of Emily Henochowicz illustrates your own blindness when it comes to the pretzelyzing truth-twisting propaganda of palestinianism. Oh well...nobody's perfect. I will still recommend The Shock Doctrine to everyone I haven't already recommended it to...
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Front242
04:56 PM on 06/06/2010
I thought I knew what was going on before I picked up a copy. When I read The Shock Doctrine, I realized how much I DIDN'T know.

That's what was really scary.
07:10 PM on 06/06/2010
a must read...
04:05 PM on 06/06/2010
If the Tea Party really cares about America, why are they not pressuring their republican politicians to stop pandering to the Israeli whims and demands? I think I know why. They're just against everything Obama represents. But this situation is not about Obama, this is about America's interest in the world.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Dnietz
politics is obsolete
06:34 PM on 06/06/2010
Go watch the documentary:
Waiting for Armageddon
and you will have your answer
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
03:03 PM on 06/06/2010
eyeless in Gaza
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
Hoosierbrad
I know it when I see it.
04:32 PM on 06/06/2010
Clueless in America.
12:17 AM on 06/07/2010
You're right. We should dump ALL of our enemies. Including the ones who pretend to be allies.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
02:30 AM on 06/10/2010
foolish in Indiana...
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
KataVideo
07:07 PM on 06/06/2010
so... that comment is allowed on here tonight, but I can't say "elliot sanders" on that rush thread? I'm taking screen shots to sent in tomorrow morning.
01:56 PM on 06/06/2010
Reducing world to good and bad leads to trouble

http://www.recordpub.com/news/no_byline_article/4839639
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
KataVideo
06:59 PM on 06/06/2010
it's bad to shoot out the eyes of innocents
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
OrleyHuxwell
Brave New Animal Farm
07:51 PM on 06/06/2010
When dogmatically doing so in ALL instances, yes. But sometimes it's pretty damn clear.
12:17 AM on 06/07/2010
And when would THAT be?
01:24 PM on 06/06/2010
Israeli actions resemble too closely those of the monsters from WWII. Why are historical victims resorting to violent bully tactics? Do they want to be seen as the inheritors of illegal and immoral methods of control?

American politicians are endangering their future and their country by blindly following an extremist movement to remake the Middle East.
06:51 PM on 06/06/2010
Because like most bullies they can. They've continually gotten away with it. They feel entitled. It's their "god" given right. And the US will continue to send them aid.
12:27 PM on 06/06/2010
Naomi, why are you blinding this truth on your Arab friends:
Supreme Court in Egypt rules in favor of petition seeking to strip Egyptian citizenship of man who married woman from Israel. Lawyer: Importance of case is in creating separation fence between Egyptian and Israeli youth
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
Hoosierbrad
I know it when I see it.
04:33 PM on 06/06/2010
It seems as if in this argument neither side would be able to throw the first stone. Could you?
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Dnietz
politics is obsolete
06:59 PM on 06/06/2010
There does not exist one Arab government that is not corrupt or a puppet of ours or both.

Two wrongs don't make a right.

This is about 1.5 million people living in virtual prison. According to the UN 65% of children in Gaza are suffering from illnesses resulting from malnutrition.

Arguing what other people are doing bad is just an attempt to deflect blame.