More

Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Noah Baron

GET UPDATES FROM Noah Baron
 

Destroying Education in the Name of the Free Market

Posted: 06/13/11 11:00 PM ET

As the families of millions of American high school students have noticed, the cost of a college education is now at the highest that anyone can remember. While loans are within the grasp of many, if not most, to pay for the expense of this education, the cost of paying back these loans often prices students out of jobs in the nonprofit or public service sector.

In the past, there were some programs available for debt relief for those students who become teachers for a given number of years, these programs have been trimmed back, or eliminated entirely, in the pursuit of balancing state budgets.

As the cost of a bachelor's degree climbs to more than $40,000 at many private institutions -- reaching almost to the median family income (approximately $50,000 per year)-- the last best hope for millions of American high school students is our nation's state or local universities. Until the 1970s, a college education at one of the City University of New York schools was entirely free. Even until the 2000s, many state schools charged only nominal tuition (almost always under $10,000). Yet in recent years these institutions have been gutted by governments desperate to cut back on spending and have suffered the efforts of a Republican Party very suddenly (and conveniently) interested in avoiding deficits.

These universities have, by some miracle, managed to keep their tuition rates significantly below those of most private universities (for example, Rutgers University costs less than $12,000 per year whereas the price tag for a year at Carnegie Mellon University is about five times that. Budget cuts, however, remain underway. Gov. Chris Christie (R-NJ), for example, cut $500 million from the New Jersey education budget and his administration furthermore failed to correctly file the papers to win a piece of the $400 million in funding for primary and secondary education from the federal government.

These cuts threaten the ability of state schools to provide a worthwhile higher education to students. Nonetheless, thus far American public universities have managed to survive: the quality education offered at the hundreds of state-run institutions of higher education in the United States remain a testament to the fact that, despite the perennial insistence of the GOP, the private sector is not always capable of providing better services at a lower cost. Schools such as University of California -- Berkeley, Boalt Hall (UC Berkeley Law School), University of California -- Los Angeles, University of North Carolina -- Chapel Hill, Rutgers University, University of Michigan -- Ann Arbor, University of Maryland -- College Park, and a litany of other state schools are all ranked by the US News & World Report as within the top 100, if not top 50, educational institutions in the United States.

Whereas in many cases the personal debt associated with attending a private university is unjustifiable, the affordability and quality of education offered by many state universities is frequently the best shot that millions of Americans have at what passes for social mobility these days. These schools offer middle-class and working-class Americans the ability to pursue higher education without taking on an oppressive amount of debt, which will undoubtedly limit their options come graduation day. Despite these seemingly self-evident facts, however, Republicans continually pursue budget cuts for all state-run programs -- public universities included.

If a college degree is to indicate anything other than socio-economic status, then American public higher education must remain fully funded. Private universities continue to raise their tuition not necessarily because of their own increasing costs, rather because they believe that Americans are willing to continue to pay it. Without affordable public universities, the choice, for almost all people, will be between a lifetime of debt or a lifetime of little earning potential.

 

Follow Noah Baron on Twitter: www.twitter.com/noahbbaron

As the families of millions of American high school students have noticed, the cost of a college education is now at the highest that anyone can remember. While loans are within the grasp of many, if ...
As the families of millions of American high school students have noticed, the cost of a college education is now at the highest that anyone can remember. While loans are within the grasp of many, if ...
 
 
  • Comments
  • 47
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Nomccain
02:09 PM on 06/14/2011
In this country where EVERYTHING is for PROFIT, regardless of who it hurts, a college education is already beyond the reach of most middle income Americans. We are witnessing a large number of Americans being priced out of the market for health care, a college education, decent paying jobs which are being shipped overseas for guess what? HIGHER PROFITS! Our own government has betrayed their people and we are now ruled by rich elitists, major corporations including health insurance companies and pharma companies and the military industrial complex. We may very well see an end coming to the capitalist system as we have known it as it's being destroyed by greed and corruption. I suppose it will take a total collapse of the system to wake some of these people up including those in Washington. I wonder where they think they'll spend all those dollars when they are worth NOTHING. It's sad and disgusting and you and I have no say and no power.
02:21 PM on 06/14/2011
You can do something though don't give up. Get organized, impact your local community. Badger your reps. Write letters, make phone calls. Protest the injustice. Occupy your legislative building, occupy other public spaces. Tell them the machine won't work until you have an affordable education. Don't take bs from repubs or dems; there is no reasoning that college students or the poor or working class should be hurting this much when we have spent trillions on useless wars and banks.
photo
darquelourd
You Get What You Play For
01:57 PM on 06/14/2011
you kind of undecut your own argument there at the end by equating a college degree with better socio-economic status

so actually that's ALL a degree is good for? getting a job that pays more? cos that's what you just argued.

until Americans realize the value of a broad liberal arts education all degrees are going to mean is how much your salary is going to be.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
SonicUltimate
03:09 PM on 06/14/2011
You missed the implication if you think the author undercuts his own argument. He is implying that we are heading back to the days where only the children of the wealthy were college educated and the rest of the nation might have graduated high school. The cycle was then a loop of the haves telling the have nots what to do by virtue of nothing more than having the ends to make it possible. Do you really not realize what the cost of a "broad liberal arts education" is these days, and that it is continually going up and out of reach of more and more bright and motivated students?
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Moravecglobal
12:44 PM on 06/14/2011
Saving higher education for the daughters and sons of Californians with wage concessions at the University of California. . As a Californian, I don't care what others earn at private, public universities. If wages better elsewhere, chancellors, vice chancellors, tenured, non tenured faculty, UCOP should apply for the positions. If wages commit employees to UC, leave for better paying position. The sky above UC will not fall.
Californians suffers from the greatest deficit modern times. UC wages, benefits must reflect California's ability to pay, not what others paid elsewhere. Campus chancellors, vice chancellors, tenured & non-tenured faculty, UCOP are replaceable by the more talented.
UC faculty, chancellor, vice chancellor, UCOP wage, benefits concessions:
No furloughs
18 percent reduction in UCOP salaries & $50 million cut.
18 percent prune of campus chancellors', vice chancellors' salaries.
15 percent trim of tenured faculty salaries, increased teaching load
10 percent decrease in non-tenured faculty salaries, as well as increase research, teaching load
100% elimination of all Academic Senate, Academic Council costs, wages.

Rose bushes bloom after pruning.

UC Board of Regents Sherry Lansing, President Yudof can bridge the public trust gap by offering reassurances that UC salaries reflect depressed wages in California. The sky will not fall on UC

Californians are reasonable people. Levy no new taxes until an approved balanced budget: let the Governor/Legislature lead - make the tough-minded (not cold hearted) decisions of elected leadership. Afterwards come to public for continuing, specified taxes.

Advocate for all Californians and University of California
photo
Brown Buddha
harvest is plentiful but the laborers are few
11:47 AM on 06/14/2011
Republicans need dumb citizens.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Boliche Peter Hulbert
10:58 AM on 06/14/2011
We need to push community colleges, if colleges see a steep drop in their attendance that is the only way things will change. But as long as the myth of the 4 year college exist more of the same is going to occur.
09:37 AM on 06/14/2011
The writer obviously thinks the GOP are the bad guys here. What he fails to grasp is that most states have to balance their budgets and don't have the luxury of printing more money for good causes. The cuts have to come from somewhere, and as long as the Democrats keep defending outrageous benefits packages for public employee unions the cuts must come from somewhere else. The reason education is so conveniently hit is that young people don't vote in the numbers that retirees vote. If young adults would get out and vote the politicians (of both parties) would be more sensitive to their legitimate needs, of which education should be at the top of the list.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
laura r
11:49 AM on 06/14/2011
So, who was in office as President went the 2008 Crash hit? The deregulated markets caused the crash.
The GOP policies have been very destructive to the American economy.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
12:21 PM on 06/14/2011
deregulate­d markets? serious?
The Federal Register, which lists new regulations, averaged 72,844 pages annually during the Carter years from 1977 to 1980. Then the average fell to 54,335 during the Reagan years, rose to 59, 527 during the Bush I years, to 71,590 during the Clinton years, and, finally, to a record 75,526 during the administration of that great believer in laissez-faire, George W. Bush. So, far from moving away from regulation, the U.S. economy became even more regulated.
The problem comes from years of bad regulation that favor a select few that can lobby congress and the president to write regulation in their favor and regulators looking the other way.
photo
heron77
Drive on the right
01:04 PM on 06/14/2011
You forgot to mention that congress has that responsibility and in 2008, we had a Democratic congress. Two villains that should be mentioned were the chairmen of the two finance committees, Chris Dodd and Barney Frank. They refused to respond to a request for action by Bush.
12:11 PM on 06/14/2011
You nailed it, bobcarden54. I would add that when they run out of our money, cynical politicians purposely threaten cuts in education and public services such as law enforcement and fire fighters to scare the populous into voting for higher taxes. What they won't do, of course, is reign in out-of-control public employees' unions by limiting benefits and pay. The unions always get their money first because the politicians know that a chunk will end up in their campaign coffers. A perfect example of this is what Jerry Brown just did here in California. The Supreme Court ordered over 40,000 felons released due to prison overcrowding; at the same time Brown pushed through a sweet benefit deal for the prison union which will wind up costing CA billions of dollars.
justhinking
I'll listen if you will
12:48 PM on 06/14/2011
Really, it is the unions fault. With all that has been written on the meltdown and the resulting financial problems you still think it is the unions fault? The unions in your personal universe must be really powerful and extremely rich to outspend corporations and the wealthy. How much do you think the prison employees make, say $250,000/yr plus benefits. I bet they don't even have to show up for work. Or maybe in your world only unions get to contribute to politicans and own media outlets. I bet the wealthy would love to own a politician or two just like those prison unions. Better get used to paying for prisons, with the GOP eliminating jobs, cutting middle class compensation, defunding education and removing safety nets the prisons are going to be a busy place.
02:32 PM on 06/14/2011
Unions aren't perfect but don't you think we ought to be concerned about our firefighters teachers and yes, cops? I don't know what happened in California but I feel like the union bashing tactic is used to pit people against each other when the true criminals are the banks who robbed people blind and the people who wanted to go to war in Iraq and Afghanistan. Not to mention tax breaks for people who didn't need them and largely hoarded all that money anyway.
Paulo1
Thanks for reading, (even if you disagree)
09:31 AM on 06/14/2011
Proposal: You get A's and the Government pays for the whole thing including living expenses and you don't have to pay back a dime. You get B's or better and do either four years in the military or four years of hard community service and the government forgives your student loans. All others can rely on Grandma's trust fund or a job. This way we increase incentive, decrease debt, raise standards and give poor kids an incentive to do well in schools.
justhinking
I'll listen if you will
12:51 PM on 06/14/2011
Then you get a bunch of people majoring in political science or some other easy major. Private, for profit schools would be giving 'A's to everyone just so they can get their hands on the money. But I like the thinking in terms of rewarding those that are truly interested in self improvement and willilng to work for it.
02:37 PM on 06/14/2011
Why is poli sic an easy major? I think any major like that dependson the teacher and the school you go to. You can be as engaged as like and go far with it.
07:30 AM on 06/14/2011
The country should be progressing, not regressing. How civil is a country that denies its people affordable healthcare and affordable education?

Republicans do not value education--that much is clear. One only needs to look at some of the candidates who will be running for President. We aren’t dumb enough YET to take them seriously, but not to worry, the GOP is working on that.