iPhone app iPad app Android phone app Android tablet app More

Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Oz Garcia

Oz Garcia

GET UPDATES FROM Oz Garcia

Why Do We Think Overweight Is Normal?

Posted: 04/12/11 08:47 AM ET

I read an article the other day that struck me. It talked about a study done at New York's Columbia University Medical Center, which found that our society's perception of what is considered normal weight is changing. I realized that this is one of the biggest issues in the obesity crisis that we are facing, perhaps without even realizing it.

For the study, over 200 mothers and children were recruited at an urban-area children's health clinic and interviewed about their medical histories and social backgrounds. All participants had their height, weight and body mass index measured.

Almost two-thirds of the mothers were recorded as obese or, at the very least, overweight and close to 40 percent of the children (who ranged from ages seven to 13) were also deemed either overweight or obese. Most participants (typically the overweight ones) were surprised by the number scale and had often dramatically underestimated their weight.

The Columbia University researchers presented findings at a recent American Heart Association conference that showed the heavier the mothers and children were, the more likely they were to misjudge their weight.

In fact, 82 percent of the obese women underestimated their weight, compared to just 13 percent of women whose weights were considered normal. In addition, 86 percent of overweight children underestimated their weight, while only 15 percent of the normal-weight children did so.

Even more alarming was that close to half of the mothers who had an overweight child believed their child's weight to be normal. In most cases, overweight children belonged to overweight mothers.

The study uncovered an interesting trend: the more overweight the women, the more overweight their children tended to be. This goes to show that children are led by example and how important it is for parents to strive to live healthy lives so that their children can, in turn, internalize the importance of overall wellness.

Children cannot be expected to make good nutritional choices on their own at such a young age. The children in this study were, on average, seven to 13. During this age range, children tend to be considerably impressionable. If their parents are eating fast food at every meal, why should they be expected to make healthier choices? While it's possible that the child will choose a different path than his or her parents, it's not likely. Parents set the example and it is important that they become a positive authority during mealtime.

The concept of this skewed perception of weight is quite thought-provoking. I wasn't at all surprised that the overweight mothers were raising overweight children, but I was surprised that many of these mothers actually found their overweight or obese child's weight to be normal. This means that these mothers had no intention of working on helping their child obtain a healthy weight, which is downright dangerous.

As people as a whole get larger in size, we compare them to even bigger individuals, and then they seem 'not so big.' As the obesity level increases, those who were once obese become merely overweight. We begin to not question the increase in obesity.

As a nutritionist, I see the other side of this study. The side where nutritionally fit parents raise healthy children.

All of my clients look and feel great and they have not all been blessed with perfect frames; they are of all shapes and sizes. However, they come to me for advice on how to maximize the level of nutrition in their diets and by strictly following my results they are able to maximize their results and their body types. Not surprisingly, my clients with children have healthy, well-functioning children because they set good dietary examples.

My point in this is that people are generally in control of their bodies, unless there is a malfunction somewhere, which can still usually be regulated. Most people are not prone to obesity, but many people are not taught moderation, which is the unfortunate truth in our ever-growing obese culture.

This study lends further proof to the theory that the parents are the major problem in this growing childhood obesity crisis. An overweight child who is not pushed to become healthier will grow to believe that his or her eating habits are normal and that is not okay.

First Lady Michelle Obama has done a wonderful job this past year in educating the global community on the importance of our food choices, whether it is in the cafeteria, at the dinner table or when fine dining. I truly hope we are on the road to putting an end to this problem.

 

Follow Oz Garcia on Twitter: www.twitter.com/@ozgarcia

I read an article the other day that struck me. It talked about a study done at New York's Columbia University Medical Center, which found that our society's perception of what is considered normal we...
I read an article the other day that struck me. It talked about a study done at New York's Columbia University Medical Center, which found that our society's perception of what is considered normal we...
 
 
  • Comments
  • 583
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2 3 4 5  Next ›  Last »  (12 total)
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
noteaforme
The Tea Party parties like it's 1399.
09:06 AM on 04/16/2011
What people including (and I'm ashamed to admit this) many of us on the left (and many of my otherwise enlightened friends) refuse to acknowledge is that this is not about "personal responsibility" and failure to have self-restraint. Obesity reflects race, class, and gender inequity in this country plain and simple, as well an economy and culture that make it very difficult to change one's eating habits. I'm not overweight and have never been but I attribute that to advantages I have, not some special magical self-denial gene. I'm tired of puritanical people insulting the obese. Unless it's Chris Christie.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
rowdiman
Um, Boehner: WE WON.
06:12 PM on 04/15/2011
My mom was a terrible cook, sounds awful, but it's true.

Most of my food went into a napkin in my top drawer or to the English Bulldog under the table.

As a result, I was very underweight while she was pleasantly plump!
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
TheBlondeRaven
11:41 AM on 04/15/2011
What always annoys me is that when a person gets to 100 pounds overweight, it's not a issue of liking chocolate too much, there are emotional issues behind it, yet people keep hammering on and on about working out and watching one's diet, however the actual solution is a shrink's office.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
noteaforme
The Tea Party parties like it's 1399.
09:09 AM on 04/16/2011
A lot of the people I see in that weight range are working in low wage jobs, are single parents with nothing to look forward to in life but that hamburger loaded with addictive fats and sugars...and all her co-workers are her size. It's a lot more complicated than psychiatric issues.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
TheBlondeRaven
11:34 AM on 04/15/2011
You're so wrong. No one thinks being overweight is normal, and most overweight people get abuse for their weight from both family, friends and strangers.
02:13 AM on 04/15/2011
I think overweight subject is a very sore subject in United Stages. What people consider healthy here, everywhere else in the world is considered overweight. When I first moved to US from Russia, I remember going out to a restaurant, when I got my order I got confused because I thought it was an order for 5 people, but the waiter assured me it was just for me. But what really makes me sad, is that parents don't teach their children about nutrition, because they don't know anything about it them selves. If no body knows how to stay healthy now, where is the future going?
Follow my health and fitness blog http://www.lovingfit.com
08:02 PM on 04/14/2011
Because the same people that think fat kids are "healthy" are the same ones that think a Denny's Grand Slam is an appropriately sized breakfast.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
Sinister Minister
There's no way out of here alive.
11:16 AM on 04/14/2011
Obese people don't think they are overweight, and anorexic people don't think they are underweight.

Go figure.

How much money did we spend on this study?
04:07 PM on 04/14/2011
No matter what people weigh, they think of themselves as normal.
06:37 AM on 04/14/2011
I have always been skinny and eat horribly.
My mother asked me how I managed to stay trim and I explained that I use food for food and drugs for drugs. She and my sister would never smoke pot but have no problem polishing off large amounts of ice cream after dinner. I enjoy eating enough to satisfy my nutritional needs but don't use eating to make me happy.
04:13 AM on 04/14/2011
During the course of my research, I’ve found that there’s two main villains causing overweight and obesity problems. They are: poor diets / food choices and a lack of physical activity. Sadly, I’ve found research that suggests children and preteen adolescents are eating more food away from the home, snacking more habitually on junk food, and drinking more sugar-sweetened beverages. Convenience has become a major theme for our food choices today, thus leading more of us to consume fast food, restaurant meals, or cheap prepackaged meals to prepare in the microwave.
http://www.fightobesity.net/definition-of-teenage-obesity.html
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Fred Butters
12:28 AM on 04/14/2011
A friend of mine was trying to convince me that the BMI scale was completely inaccurate by saying "According to that thing, I'm even overweight!"

He's about 50Lbs overweight... but it's hard to notice that when he compares himself to other overweight people. It truly has become the norm.
11:18 PM on 04/13/2011
We think overweight is normal because it is now. We look around and see people who are over weight and feel it's normal. Who's fault is it? It could be the fast food. It could be our unhealthy lifestyles. There is hope. I also once felt hopeless when it came to my weight. I found a diet that worked for me and changed my lifestyle and eating habits. I now devote my time to helping others with this diet. See more on my site at www.hcgplan.net
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
rowdiman
Um, Boehner: WE WON.
10:22 PM on 04/13/2011
Eat less; move more.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
MexiChick67
Que? Que? Queee?
01:42 AM on 04/15/2011
Make better choices in food. Starving yourself does not help. Makes things worst, esp. in women.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
rowdiman
Um, Boehner: WE WON.
06:03 PM on 04/15/2011
Eating 5-6 small protein mini-meals throughout the day and just moving around more keeps your metabolism going....burns more fat calories and builds muscle.

You are so right about women starving. Totally shuts down your metabolism, not to mention negatively affects almost every organ in your body.
09:59 PM on 04/13/2011
Want to loose weight real fast follow The Diet Solution Program
http://941fd7yeofuw5u7nn1lgxzem4v.hop.clickbank.net/
05:21 PM on 04/13/2011
I think that it would help if a woman could go into a clothing store and the sizes be in inches like with men's clothing. I said this to a friend and they said that women did not want to hear that they have a 36 inch waist even if it is true. I think that denial of ones size is detrimental. It doesn't make you one bit smaller if someone says you are a 28 waist or a size 8. Perhaps hearing the number measurement would give some people a wake up call. I know for a fact that sizes have gotten larger. It is easy to hide when sizes are in increments of 4,6,8,10 and so forth. Label clothes with the real size!
06:04 PM on 04/13/2011
mens clothes sizes lie as much as women's now.

a 28" pair of shorts from Old Navy is a lot larger than a 28" pair from Hollister . . .
11:47 PM on 04/13/2011
Really? How can they call something 28" if it's not 28"? Sizes can be arbitrary but not measurements.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
TheBlondeRaven
11:39 AM on 04/15/2011
I live in England, where women's sizing is often given in inches. It doesn't make a difference. A size 26 in a trendy store is smaller than those in stores aimed for older people. Vanity sizing in shoes is enormous, e.g. a 23 cm shoe often fit someone with a 21 cm foot.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
TucsonEd
03:25 PM on 04/13/2011
Perhaps eating is the only comfort Americans can afford anymore. We have no job security, so we have no guarantee that we will have health care, any money we put in our 401K is NOT safe. We have no idea what tomorrow will bring, but dang we CAN afford something good to eat and it helps quiet our fears. I'm sure Americans know they're fat, but we pretend we don't. Heck we pretend we live in the greatest country on Earth so what's a little lie about our fat?
04:50 PM on 04/13/2011
Jogging is a better stress reliever than eating . . . no?

Cheaper too!