More

Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Pat LaMarche

GET UPDATES FROM Pat LaMarche

Contempt for the Poor

Posted: 05/16/11 09:15 AM ET

If you work with the poor in the United States it's very easy to believe that this country doesn't like "those people." According to the National Poverty Center nearly fifteen percent of the U.S. lived in poverty in 2009. It's counterproductive to detest 1/6 of the population especially when that translates into loathing fifteen and a half million children.

I work in a homeless shelter and daily learn stories that prove few folks in power think about the poor when they are making the rules which effect them. One of my residents is a sixty-four year old woman who works at a fast food joint. She makes minimum wage and seldom gets more than twenty hours. She's been poor her whole life and always earned minimum wage. Consequently over the years she's allowed "little things" like her dental health to decline and now has no teeth. Because of this she is not selected for counter work at her job and cleans the lobby three to four hours a day.

The budget issues which have made federal and state lawmakers use as justification for cutting basic necessities to the needy resulted the elimination of her state subsidized health insurance because her income exceeded $415 last month.

She stood in my office -- still dressed in her uniform with the famous cheeseburger logo on the left breast side -- and asked me what she was going to do. I muttered, "Join the other 45 million American working poor that have no access to healthcare and then sign up at the poverty clinic in town." I could have told her to quit her job and qualify again, but she's already living in a homeless shelter, she'd never get a home if she did that.

I asked her if her employer appreciated the subsidies it received from the community when shelters and clinics kept their work force in place. "You're right," she shouted, "if the minimum wage was a decent wage I wouldn't have to live here." According to the Taco Bell food chain, which is not number one but they're up there, they sell 2 billion tacos a year. If each taco were five cents more they would have a hundred million more dollars with which they could increase their workers pay. Imagine what the burger joints would be able to do with five cents a cheeseburger -- including provide healthcare.

Homeless Advocate Diane Nilan has a extensive list of homelessness causes in her book "Crossing the Line: Taking steps to end homelessness." But the three main causes are low wages, and healthcare and housing priced out of the reach of the poor.

But it's not just a disregard for low wage workers that makes the country seem self loathing. The education laws don't help. When you are homeless it's hard to keep your kid in school. Actually, that because being homeless makes it hard to do everything. And holding a family together and making sure the kids stay healthy and stay in school is exponentially tough when homeless. Many of our nation's individual truancy laws demand fines and/or jail time for parents with children who miss too much school. And for the child the punishment is often suspension from school.

Let me type that again. The punishment for truancy is being barred from school: reinforcing many barriers to education.

And the last little proof that the lawmakers at-worst don't like the poor and at-best don't consider them when writing laws; is that in many states if a parent cannot provide an adequate home for his or her children those kids get put in foster care. The non-profit Foster Care Alumni of America finds, "The U.S. spends $22 billion dollars ($5 billion from the Federal government and the balance from state/county governments) to provide services for children and youth in foster care. This averages out to $40,000 per child."

Even for a family with just one child, it's a lot cheaper to just give a homeless family a home than to take their kids away. And yet that's what's done.

Come to think of it, the U.S. doesn't just seem to dislike the poor. The U.S. appears to dislike the taxpayer as well -- subsidizing power retailers and fast food joints, clogging the courts with kids who have difficulty getting to school and paying many times over the cost of an dwelling to separate families because they have none -- really wastes tax resources.

 
 
 
 
 
  • Comments
  • 116
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2 3  Next ›  Last »  (3 total)
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
dclintn648
Better a pro than a con
05:11 PM on 07/04/2011
The middle class will become the poor and the poor will starve in the streets, and it's not going to end until we're making wages that rival China and India. These corporate overlords are every bit as greedy and inhuman as Victorian workhouse owners, and our politicians are as corrupt as any third world dictatorship.

Workers are going to have to fight back - HARD - to remind the owners that products and services are NOT produced by magic!!!
12:44 PM on 05/20/2011
Amen! Thanks for spelling it out.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Skeptical Patriot
08:15 AM on 05/17/2011
Yet, the policies of both parties have focused on the middle class. There is a general view that you are poor because you deserve it. It is striking that the political rhetoric and policies literally ignore the poor.
05:47 AM on 06/02/2011
I am not sure you are right about that. The republican leaders focus on helping the rich. The democratic leaders used to focus on helping the poor. Now they seem to want to help the rich and make the middle class poor.

The poor get Medicaid. Medicaid is a State program funded by general tax revenues. but they get Federal assistance sometimes.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
Militant Leftist
American seditionist
03:39 PM on 06/09/2011
Agree. I believe RFK was the last candidate who ran for president on a domestic platform focused on the disenfranchised. In today's America, the poor are either ignored, or vilified by politicians.
photo
GoldStarMom
Reading is Fundamentalism ... in Texas.
07:51 AM on 05/17/2011
Great article and many really fantastic responses. The low volume of replies, however, does not seem to bode well for any positive change any time soon. Any suggestions on how to nudge this in the right dierection to shift it from an interesting discussion and move it closer to becoming an actuality?
01:00 AM on 05/17/2011
Politicians have the oligarchs and corporations backing them and get elected.

However, most of them have no financial common sense and have no idea how ordinary lower class Americans live.

Being poor, even hardworking poor, is something the politicians think you deserve for being a loser.
Simply put, no compassion, sympathy, empathy, OR understanding is forthcoming.

Many non-politicians think the same way....poverty is something you deserve for being inferior....something is wrong with you.

To bad the upper classes couldn't experience poverty for at least a month or two.
It would open their eyes and maybe their hearts.
12:11 AM on 05/17/2011
Hi. My name is Mary. I am a homeless adult living in America.

My story is longer than the space to write, but the short version can be summed up in two words:mental health. I struggle daily with depression, anxiety, an eating disorder and some other associated issues.

To see me during the day, there's no indication that I'm homeless. I might be at the library working on a project on my laptop. I might be displaying my artwork at a local arts festival. I'm a freelance graphic designer and artist.

I'm not addicted to drugs or alcohol, and I don't sit outside panhandling all day. I am not a high school dropout. I can have a coherent conversation with you, discuss current events, entertainment, etc.

In fact, let me share something with you: what we face when we are homeless. The rude treatment, the lack of compassion, the ignorance, the humiliation.

Sure, it sounds like I'm living the high life - laptop, art, etc. Thankfully, I have private sleeping accommodations, and a kitchen to make meals instead of having to eat elsewhere. But, when you are (or have been) homeless, your whole thought process changes. At night, I come home to a bed (for which I am very grateful, mind you) that's not mine. When I go to cook my dinner, I have to hope that someone didn't raid my food supplies.

You want to know what it's like? Come and live in my shoes for a week.
12:25 AM on 05/17/2011
to know you is to love you MAP I am so glad i got to meet you when i went all the way to Carlisle PA Just to spend a few mionutes with Pat & whoever was around at the time. You are an amazing and strong person and will get through this too:)
I wish congress was required to visit skid rowand other places like Pat has befoe all the votes they make that change our lives.. I live in my own home I can barely keep warm. I get HEAP to help with that we live paycheck to pay check as it is loss of a job and we are on the street or movingin with my in laws ...
.
HUFFPOST PUNDIT
noaxe397
10:57 PM on 05/16/2011
Tip of the iceburg, my friend, just the tip of the iceburg.
 
The demonization of welfare recepients has gone on so long and the changes in welfare law (1996) so drastic, that when the economic collapse of 2008 occurred the welfare rolls barely increased.
 
So conservatives and Republicans turned today's unemployed as the new welfare recepient, being paid not to work.
 
Then hate filled conservatives turned their vitriol on WAGE EARNERS who were able to engage in legal tax avoidance to zero out their tax bill (considered nirvana for the well off.) and accussed these WORKING people of being the new dead beats.
 
Republicans and conservatives will not stop until they can, simply stated, criminalize poverty.
12:45 AM on 05/17/2011
yes they sure do think we are trying to avoid paying taxes.. I will be honest I wish I earned enough money to PAY taxes then I would also earn enough money not to need foodstamps or Mainecare or freelunch at school for my kids or HEAP to help heat my house ... THAt would also be nice :0h and HECK yeah i would also earn enough to take my kids to Disney . BUT for now I will be content to keep my childrem warm & fed and in my house I pay for .... would congress like to wlk in my shoes ofr awhile? i currently am a saty at home mom because I can't earn enough money to cover gas & daycare let alone make a l;ittle extra for the aboe mentioned things like paying taxes on what i earn
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
mainemomma
I don't want a micro bio
09:48 PM on 05/16/2011
Thank you for your work with the homeless and poor. I have followed your work in Maine in the past, and am grateful that you are finally voicing these critical issues in to a national audience. You go girl!
06:32 PM on 05/16/2011
Thanks for sneaking in the part at the end about children being torn from everyone they know and love just because their parents lack decent housing. The research backs up your observations. At least three studies have found that 30 percent of America’s foster children could be home right now if their own parents had a decent place to live.

But it’s not just the right that doesn’t want to hear it. Much of the traditional left, including most people who Blog on the topic at HuffPo, would much rather write about “fixing” foster care than actually preventing it by helping families. They’ve bought into the middle-class rescue fantasies of the rightwingers, who have demonized all parents who lose their children as abusive, just as they demonize all poor people as lazy.

One classic case-in-point: The editor of NPR who declared that parents, or as she actually called them, “these people,” have no place in a story about foster care – as discussed in this 2008 post to my organization’s Child Welfare Blog: http://bit.ly/lmDYvD

Until the left starts to value impoverished families – including those who lose their children to foster care - the right will have a clear field to exploit so-called “family values.”

Richard Wexler
Executive Director
National Coalition for Child Protection Reform
www.nccpr.org
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
SocratesSiddhartha
"Poverty is the worst form of violence." Gandhi
10:15 PM on 05/16/2011
Thank you for your work Mr. Wexler!
01:09 AM on 05/17/2011
It would be much cheaper to help a family get housing than to put kids in foster care (if lack of housing is the only major problem).

I have said it before and I will say it again....too many politicians have NO common sense or understanding of economics and finance.

Watching the Repugs push trickle down economics and all the rest of it proves my point.
To make up for their lousy financial acumen (judgement), they demonize teachers and the unemployed.
Anything to deflect the blame for what they helped do.

****They already demonized "welfare queens" but now too many (former) hardworking Americans need help (unemployment, food stamps) that now THEY must be demonized.

From what I can see, the American people are starting to wake up.

Yes, it IS class warfare....especially by the upper classes who helped impoverish their fellow Americans and now need excuses to shift the blame.
05:33 PM on 05/16/2011
The fact that we spend more punishing the poor and keeping them poor than we do to lift them up tells the whole story. You get what you pay for.

Soon crime and poverty will be so bad that whole areas of the U.S. will be a "no-go" zone for anyone with anything to lose and how much will that cost the rest of us? The rich are richer than they have ever been. It's those of you in the middle who somehow think the finger is being pointed at you for eking out your little existence that are part of the problem. Whenever someone says "feeding the poor is cheaper than dealing with the consequences of them starving" you somehow think we're coming for your money. No. It is the uber-rich, which you are not and will probably never be if you're reading this, that are robbing ALL OF US of our cherished American Way of Life. If you're standing up for them you are getting nothing for your struggle against yourself and the rest of us. Plutocrats are still taking your country away from you and expecting you to give it to them with a smile and get NOTHING in return...
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
onionboy
Blessed are the Cheese Makers
06:07 PM on 05/16/2011
Soon, the default will be for everyone to go into prison on their 18th birthday and then make the case for why they shouldn't be there. If you have no education, job, money, or support system...they'll just leave you there, figuring it's where you would have ended up anyway. That way they figure they can save a lot of money on court costs too.
photo
jf12
Occupying myself
06:21 PM on 05/16/2011
Sure, like the olde debtors' prisons. We call it living, now, but for most there never will be any escape to ownership from working off and paying off debts.
HUFFPOST PUNDIT
noaxe397
10:59 PM on 05/16/2011
Conservatives won't stop until they suceed in criminalizing pverty.
been2there
Facts have a liberal bias.
04:27 PM on 05/16/2011
People tend to think that their own experience is what everyone else experiences. A person who has never struggled with depression, does not understand that one cannot just "snap out of it." People who have never been poor have no grasp on reality--and their policies reflect that. People believe that those who do not have good teeth, just didn't care--it never occurs to them that the problem might be no dentist, because everyone can see a dentist once a year, right? And there is always a public clinic. Except that there isn't, because the funding is gone, because the corportations are struggling, and--oops, too bad about you and your job, and its benefits.
Welcome to America!
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Silverwolf72
Are We There Yet?
04:54 PM on 05/16/2011
I totally agree with you, I battle with depression and have been poor
08:38 PM on 05/16/2011
I battle with depression and I'm still poor.
01:20 AM on 05/17/2011
I battle severe bipolar disorder and have spent my life between poor and (lower) working class.

I am grateful I have a place to live and my needs taken care of.
Just barely, but I am not complaining.
So many have it much worse than me.

I am ANGRY for the America my kids are dealing with.

*****My adult nephew told some horrified working class church friends that he pulled out his tooth with pliers. (After swallowing some booze.)
They asked him why did he do such a crazy thing?
He answered that he had a bad toothache and NO money.
03:51 PM on 05/16/2011
As usual...add $0.05 here/$0.02 there and you're going to nickle and dime your way into...he!! no. I'm all for helping the truely poor and downtrodden (which this woman surely seems to be), but come on...we're already being "fleeced" enough as it is.


Sure, you can ALWAYS find some sad story out there...and you can always find a scenerio were someone just flat "stepped up and takes care of business"...

Get on with it...your job/career/profession is NOT coming back. It's well past time to do something to earn a $.
photo
HUFFPOST COMMUNITY MODERATOR
anotherwomanfromva
Trickle down didn't work; It's time for trickle up
05:35 PM on 05/16/2011
You know what, it could just be an extra 5 cents or an extra 20 cents. If all working people gave just an extra dollar towards helping the poor how far could that go??? It doesn't have to lead to anything else.
photo
Diane Nilan
traveling the country to give voice & visibility t
05:52 PM on 05/16/2011
Being fleeced by the poor??? Even the most accomplished fleecers are rank amateurs compared with Wall Street robber barons and DC power mongers. Remove your head from that dark cavern in the lower part of your anatomy. You're either one of the have-lots or you're in a short-lived denial and will be joining the have-nots soon.
03:34 PM on 05/16/2011
15%? That's a lot of poor people. There's one obvious solution. Soylent Green is both nutritious and delicious!
08:42 PM on 05/16/2011
Now that's funny.
photo
libobstruction
Am I my brothers keeper...NO, I am not
02:59 PM on 05/16/2011
To simply accuse anyone or any entity of "dis-liking" the poor (or any other class or catagory of people) is disengenious and quite frankly, absurd. Maybe you should give your own money to the cause if you're so inclined, maybe live on the streets along with the homeless, etc....put your money where your mouth is, so to speak.
photo
jf12
Occupying myself
06:12 PM on 05/16/2011
The fish are long gone, and even the trash fish are too polluted to eat.
AtlantaBluebelle
What micro-bio?
06:40 PM on 05/16/2011
Perhaps we should, Jesus did. I refer you to Matthew chapter 19, verses 16-24: "...21: Jesus said unto him, "If thou wilt be perfect go and sell that thou hast and give to the poor, and thou shalt have treasure in heaven: and come and follow me." KJV

Unfortunately, many right-wing Christians today believe that the poor are "bad" and are being "punished by God". They believe in the so-called gospel of success. "Today we are witnessing the emergence, all around us, of what has been called the "gospel of success." Its basic message is that if you want to climb the ladder to worldly success and enjoy all the good things this life has to offer, then get Jesus on your team, and he will fulfill your fondest ambition. He will help you live out the American dream of wealth and prosperity."
linkie: http://www.theexaminer.org/volume2/number2/gospel.htm
photo
HUFFPOST COMMUNITY MODERATOR
anotherwomanfromva
Trickle down didn't work; It's time for trickle up
01:59 PM on 05/16/2011
The sad part is most of us are one paycheck away from losing our home and yet it seems these same people have no empathy for other Americans in similar situations. If I lost my job, got sick and lost my savings paying medical bills, or any number of tragedies and I would end up in a shelter too. It doesn't matter that I was a taxpayer for 20+ years, people would still look down on me.

It used to be in this country, that you helped your neighbor in times of trouble. Now, it seems it's everyman for himself. These politicians pit the poor against each other while they laugh all the way to the bank with their corporate supporters. And it's just sad.
03:55 PM on 05/16/2011
We DO help people. However, we can NOT help everyone.

As all the religious people say...The Lord helps those that help themselves...start with stepping up and helping yourself before you ask me for something.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Dee Amschler
on the edge
04:41 PM on 05/16/2011
Problem is, the religious say it but the Bible doesn't. That's not anything that can be traced to Christ or his Father.
IMOPINIONH8D
because I want it empty...
05:03 PM on 05/16/2011
Jesus said " what you do to the lest of you, you do to me" . I dont know what religious people you are hanging out with but they better rethink their thinking.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
onionboy
Blessed are the Cheese Makers
06:11 PM on 05/16/2011
Medical care based on employment is archaic.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
SocratesSiddhartha
"Poverty is the worst form of violence." Gandhi
10:23 PM on 05/16/2011
Short, sweet and to the point, fanned!