iPhone app iPad app Android phone app Android tablet app More

Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Paul Abrams

GET UPDATES FROM Paul Abrams
 

Ask Mitt About Amnesty -- His Own

Posted: 07/15/2012 3:42 pm

One has to wonder if Haley Barbour, the big poobah of the Republican Party, is dusting off his Rolodex looking up the private phone numbers of Rick Santorum or Mitch Daniels.

Former Governor Mitt Romney suddenly made himself available for interviews on five TV news programs on Friday, apparently hoping to puncture the ballooning stories about his own taxes and finances before the weekend.

Although he accomplished next-to-nothing -- except demonstrating that he knows where the news studios he has studiously avoided are located -- the interviewers were all focused on the question of when, exactly, Romney left Bain Capital as that speaks to his association, or not, with certain corporate actions that enriched Romney and his partners while causing employees to lose their jobs, and make taxpayers responsible for their pensions.

Important, to be sure, but Romney's "explanation" need only confuse people to be successful, as he tried hard to do five times on Friday.

But, so what? We already know that at a time when Mitt was indisputably running Bain Capital, he invested in a Chinese company whose business plan was to take American jobs to China. Bain invested in that plan. The more U.S. manufacturing outsourced to that company, the better for Mitt and his partners. That is the smoking-gun/mushroom cloud on the issue of Mitt profiting literally investing in outsourcing and profiting handsomely from it. [Aside: While Mitt is flailing about on outsourcing, trying to attack the president -- who a) did not outsource; and b) never made a dime on it -- the president ought to call Mitt's bluff by to inviting Mitt to join him, right now, in pressing Congress before it recesses to close loopholes for companies who outsource!].

But, for an enterprising national reporter, the next time he/she gets to ask Romney a question, there is a better question, better because it is black-and-white and unspinnable: Did Romney get amnesty from the IRS on taxes owed on his Swiss Bank Account? (For an explanation of "amnesty" for Swiss Bank Account holders, and links to other sources, see my previous article.)

There are three possible answers:

  1. "No" -- in which case the clamor to prove it would be deafening.
  2. "Yes" -- in which case that would be the end of the Romney candidacy.
  3. "I have paid all my taxes, as appropriate, and that is all I am going to say" -- is that not "yes"? The reporter just follows with, "Governor, that could be true even if you received amnesty. I ask again, did you receive amnesty?"

People like Romney helped make the word "amnesty' politically toxic in the immigration debate. Vice-President Biden has already half-jokingly linked "papers please" to Romney's unreported tax returns. Moreover, "amnesty" for a man of Romney's wealth would be immediately linked to the Wall Street bankers who were bailed out, an act that still gnaws in the gut of the body politic of all parties.

If Romney hid income in Switzerland from the IRS so he did not pay taxes, and did so only when he was provided amnesty, not only did the 99% pay taxes in his place, but he may have committed a crime. Whenever he tries to talk about deficits, look who has contributed to it -- estimates are that the Treasury loses $100 billion a year to these tax shelters. That is $1 trillion over the past decade. That would pay for a lot of health care, or schools, or half the infrastructure repair everyone agrees we need.

We do not know, yet, whether Romney did receive amnesty. What other reasons did Americans who do not live in Switzerland set up Swiss accounts other than to hide money from the IRS? Or, like he "retroactively retired," perhaps he was just "retroactively paying taxes" he was always going to pay anyhow, cross-his-heart-and-hope-to-die, he was.

What can Romney do? A "Checkers" speech? What will he refer to -- Ann's two cadillacs and her Olympic horse are not exactly "Pat's cloth coat." His "little dog," Seamus? I wouldn't go there if I were Mitt.

The question for Mitt's wealthy backers -- many of whom probably also received amnesty, and their need to reveal these accounts made them detest President Obama even more -- is whether they want this entire issue aired over-and-over-and-over again for the next few months, or whether they are better off letting it recede by getting Mitt to realize that now is the time to retire.

One Republican governor has already told Romney to reveal his tax returns. So has Haley Barbour. So has Bill Kristol.

One reporter posing the amnesty question will cause it all to unravel very quickly for Romney. Or, if he stays in the race, Democrats should punctuate their sentences with the word, "amnesty."

As hot as Tampa will be in August, Santorum may want to start dusting off his vests.

 

Follow Paul Abrams on Twitter: www.twitter.com/pabrams2001

FOLLOW POLITICS
 
 
  • Comments
  • 115
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Bloggers
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2  Next ›  Last »  (2 total)
photo
OutAtFirst
Mountain goat, desert rat and sea dog
02:38 PM on 07/17/2012
As soon as Mitt drops out there will a cacophony from Republicans wailing that they never wanted him in the first place.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
ClintBMD
Now where did I leave that Micro-bio again?
11:12 AM on 07/17/2012
This has been my question for a while. He abruptly closed his Swiss account(s) during the amnesty time frame. That could very well be coincidence. However, the only way to know is for his tax forms release.

However, if this is what happened, he can technically say he's not a felon, but that's only because the government thought the collection of back taxes was more important than prosecution (not to mention the fact that rich people would have blocked the cooperation with Switzerland had it not happened). But technicalities aside, it would make him look like an absolute crumb.

Now, let's see if any reporter has the cajones to actually ask the question. Because Mitt won't release these returns unless compelled to do so by the court.
photo
demisfine
Often correct, NEVER right.
08:57 PM on 07/16/2012
So, it really is NOT Mitt's turn, is it?
photo
Inkosi
The gods themselves rage against stupidity
10:27 AM on 07/17/2012
In his mind - it is! I still can't help feeling the RNC has planned a replay of 2000 and 2004. HBO has been running "Recount" and "Game Change" almost every night. they need to run the Michael Moore movies as well.
photo
demisfine
Often correct, NEVER right.
10:51 AM on 07/17/2012
The Media is complicit in haranguing President Obama.
Journalists have done nothing but parrot whatever Faux says, and Faux promotes what Luntz says, and Luntz says what Rove says....
Huzie
I do not suffer fools....period
12:04 PM on 07/18/2012
Good point, the difference is that Obama's team are far more comet ant than Gore's or Kerry's were. Both good men, would have been good presidents. Could not hit back at the Rovian machinations. Obama is learning
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Alta Pasha
12:52 AM on 07/18/2012
Ann...
photo
arthur99
Anger dwells only in the bosom of fools
08:47 PM on 07/16/2012
this will pick up spped as we approach the election

timing is everything

if he says no, just ask him to have the IRS verify it, no returns, just did he participate in the amnesty program

this should be public info, like any criminal activity, plea deal, etc., FOIA
05:37 AM on 07/17/2012
x2
ThinkCreeps
Seriously, it's time.
07:48 PM on 07/16/2012
Santorum! Riding a foaming brown tide all the way to Tampa.
ThinkCreeps
Seriously, it's time.
07:47 PM on 07/16/2012
Welease Womney's Weturns! It's the only way to weveal the twuth!
photo
Inkosi
The gods themselves rage against stupidity
10:29 AM on 07/17/2012
ThinkCreeps - fanned and faved. Thanks for the laugh.
allm
Republican convert to Democrat
04:30 PM on 07/16/2012
I am waiting for that question with baited breath. The problem is that I don't know a single journalist with the courage to ask him that question. It is a good one, and one that I would like to know the answer to.
photo
KevinMac59
Independently Dependent
09:44 PM on 07/16/2012
That is why he only deals with Fox news.
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
George Heymont
02:54 PM on 07/16/2012
My own personal hope is that Romney gets irrevocably labeled as the face of election fraud. That would make the RNC think twice about pushing its voter identification legislation.
photo
demisfine
Often correct, NEVER right.
08:55 PM on 07/16/2012
If we can make it a two-faced coin with Romney on one side and Rove on the other, I'l join you.
02:37 PM on 07/16/2012
Brilliant question! One that could end it all.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Mike Dehart
Vet, Conservative and Gun Owner
12:50 PM on 07/16/2012
The White House alone has staffers owing over 833k in back taxes and they want to demand Romneys returns. Theres some hypocrites for you.
02:20 PM on 07/16/2012
Both Obama and Romney used Deductions to lower their Taxes. Obama paid 20%, Romney Paid 15%, angry about it??, go scream to your congress men/women who promote these Tax schemes.

As if any Liberal pays more Taxes than they should, what Dopes!!.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
ursulasaulie
dignity to all people
02:46 PM on 07/16/2012
wow, staffers make that much money.....Link please with exact figures.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Mike Dehart
Vet, Conservative and Gun Owner
09:33 AM on 07/17/2012
http://www.scribd.com/doc/79290934/Copy-of-FERDI-2010-Final

Executive Office of the President $833,970
YOKEL13
Gimme more! - unofficial GOP motto
11:50 AM on 07/16/2012
Can we all agree on at least one thing?

Willard is running for President, for gosh sakes!
photo
Inkosi
The gods themselves rage against stupidity
10:32 AM on 07/17/2012
The movie "Willard" was on TV this weekend. Nothing like a good rat movie.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
sarahsahasbeen
Je pense...je progresse.
11:24 AM on 07/16/2012
Although this is very important, why is no one asking why Gov. Romney erased all the computer hard drives when he left the governship of MA? There was a supposed $2 billion deficit (later proven to not exist) when he took office, yet he raised $700 million in new taxes and business fees a year. That makes a neat $2.8 billion over four years. When he left, there was a verified $1.3 billion deficit despite his claims of balancing the budget every year.

Where did the $1.5 billion go? Did it wind up being management consultant fees for him managing the state? Without the computer hard drives, nobody knows.
01:32 PM on 07/16/2012
But they should care. Another reason why Romney cannot run on his record as governor.
photo
Inkosi
The gods themselves rage against stupidity
10:33 AM on 07/17/2012
Erasing Gov't public records is a crime!!!
09:27 AM on 07/16/2012
If you made 100 million in your business, then shifted all that to a swish bank,the 100 mill is stillon the books, your still going to pay the taxes on that 100 mill. Now maybe he didn't pay tax on the interest received on that Swisses Acct and received amnesty for that, but interest on a 25 million Acct is only about 250k to500 k and the taxes on that would only be 87.5 to 150k .that's nothing to a guy like Romney, especially since he has s known for 20 years he was running for pres
YOKEL13
Gimme more! - unofficial GOP motto
11:53 AM on 07/16/2012
Greed v. ambition... tough call.
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
Paul Abrams
11:54 AM on 07/16/2012
Not completely accurate. You are assuming that the money just sat there in the Swiss Account. What these people do is take some money, use the Swiss Account to make investments, and then keep the profits in those accounts as well. In addition, the Swiss Banks provide them with what is called "abusive tax shelters", illegal under US law...it was for providing those abuse tax shelters that Union Bank of Switzerland (UBS) was fined over $400M.
08:54 AM on 07/16/2012
Obama's birth certificate (something that has nothing whatsoever to do with his character or fitness to lead) has been made a political issue by the right. Romney's tax returns (which likely reveal a lot about his character and priorities) are fair game to both right and left.
abetterplace
Capitalistic reverand
07:25 AM on 07/16/2012
I think it is just wonderful that all you liberal Obama supporters have found a few bent corners to pry on trying to break Romney, but just remember, for each Romney page, Obama has two. Bain, Swiss Bank Account, Off shore bank account and maybe there can be a conspiracy theory conjured up, while on the other hand, Obama and Rev Wright,Chicago mob connections, Acorn, Islam, place of birth, school records, jobs, economy, etc. Come November, I think the best man will win regardless of the mud slinging and that winner will be Romney.
08:10 AM on 07/16/2012
So basically what you are saying is that you are incapable of rational thought.
How could any rational, thinking person make such a statement?
Seriously, how?
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Alta Pasha
01:01 AM on 07/18/2012
Answer: because they're not rational! Plus, they see the handwriting on the wall... They are supporting the one thing they rallied against with their costumes and racist signs... a liar and a tax cheat!
09:07 AM on 07/16/2012
The Religion and mob connections are conspiracy theories while the bank accounts are legitimate political and legal problem. Of course, you do not seem seem to be the right-thinking type.