Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Paul LaRosa

Paul LaRosa

GET UPDATES FROM Paul LaRosa

Is Brooklyn the New Paris?

Posted: 03/30/11 10:45 AM ET

Ah to have lived in Paris during the 1920's! Hemingway's Paris -- outdoor cafes, bookstores, bistros, writers, drinking!

Reminds me of a place I know well -- Brooklyn.

The only thing missing is the ubiquitous smoke rising from the lips of the young and literary. Laugh if you like, but I've been thinking more and more that Brooklyn, circa 2011, is very similar to what Paris was like nearly a century ago. Of course, I'm talking about the brownstone belt neighborhoods of Brooklyn Heights, Cobble Hill, Carroll Gardens, Park Slope, Fort Greene, but you can throw DUMBO, Williamsburg and Red Hook in there as well.

Brooklyn does not have the incredible beauty of Paris except... when it does. As the weather warms up (if the weather ever warms up), and you take a walk in the late light of the day in Prospect Park, or down by the water in Dumbo, or through the small-scale streets of Cobble Hill... you'll be surprised by how charming and beautiful Brooklyn can be. Have you ever stood mid-span on the Brooklyn Bridge at sunset?

As for writers, well, we all know they're here and thriving. National Book Critics Circle Award winner Jennifer Egan, author of A Visit from the Goon Squad lives in Fort Greene. Nicole Krauss, a finalist for the National Book Award for Great House lives with her writer-husband Jonathan Safron Foer, the best-selling writer of Extremely Loud and Incredibly Close in a big house in Park Slope. Also in Park Slope, Dave Eggers (A Heartbreaking Work of Staggering Genius) has his own Superhero Supply Co. store that doubles as a writing-instruction program for kids. The great Pete Hamill's heart is in Brooklyn (he was raised in Park Slope) and of course living among is the venerable Paul Auster who the French like nearly as much as Jerry Lewis.

This is just a small sample. There are so many other writers here, not to mention Jonathan Ames who built a whole television series around Brooklyn with Bored to Death. We've also got great independent bookstores as I mentioned in another post. I could go on and on. We've got the street life, the Bohemian lifestyle, readings, the nightlife, boutique coffee, great cheese stores, and farmer's markets galore, AND there are artists' studios all over DUMBO, Red Hook and Gowanus.

A couple of years ago, someone dubbed Brooklyn "the new Manhattan." I'm saying we're way beyond that now. Shove over, Paris -- Brooklyn is here!

 
 
 

Follow Paul LaRosa on Twitter: www.twitter.com/paullarosa

Ah to have lived in Paris during the 1920's! Hemingway's Paris -- outdoor cafes, bookstores, bistros, writers, drinking! Reminds me of a place I know well -- Brooklyn. The only thing missing is the ...
Ah to have lived in Paris during the 1920's! Hemingway's Paris -- outdoor cafes, bookstores, bistros, writers, drinking! Reminds me of a place I know well -- Brooklyn. The only thing missing is the ...
 
 
  • Comments
  • 27
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Bloggers
Recency  | 
Popularity
photo
LearnMe
Native NY-er, father of 2, husband to 1. I teach
05:24 PM on 04/04/2011
Well, have heard 4th Avenue, post zoning change, called a potential Champs-Élysées, though I don't quite see it. Perhaps an answer can be found in the writings of a 12-year-old (mine) - "Paris Dreaming" - http://learnmeproject.com/2011/04/04/paris-dreaming/ - and "You Can Take the Boy Out of Brooklyn" - http://learnmeproject.com/2010/12/02/you-can-take-the-boy-out-of-brooklyn/.
03:34 AM on 04/03/2011
Paul: Have you ever read "A Writer's Guide to Paris" by Eric Maisel? He also wrote a similar guide to San Francisco. Check them out. You might be a candidate to write "A Writer's Guide to Brooklyn."

- Gabriel Boehmer, Communications, Wells Fargo. Opinions expressed here are my own.
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
Paul LaRosa
journalist, tv producer and author
09:36 AM on 04/03/2011
interesting...i'll take a look...thanks.
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
Steve Kettmann
Berlin-based writer
06:02 PM on 04/02/2011
Hi, Paul, I like the post and love Brooklyn. I wrote a Times No. 1 best-seller (OK, as a ghost-writer) there a few years back. But I have to say: If there is a "new Paris," in the sense you mean, it is Berlin.
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
Paul LaRosa
journalist, tv producer and author
10:46 PM on 04/02/2011
thanks steve. never been to berlin but i have been to paris for those who were wondering if i was delusional
03:48 PM on 03/31/2011
Park Slope, Cobble Hill, Brooklyn Heights, Carroll Gardens = White, rich, gentrified, and overpriced... pretending to be Parisian. What a vapid article!
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
Beverly Willett
Writer, lawyer, Vice Chair, Coalition Divo
12:33 PM on 03/31/2011
Amen!
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
jackdaniel58
07:25 AM on 03/31/2011
More like Portlandia.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
c-tom
Badges we don't need no stinking badges
01:33 AM on 03/31/2011
So Brooklyn is as Paris was an incredibly inexpensive place for Americans to live. I didn't know that.
09:51 PM on 03/30/2011
Full disclosure: I am an Upper East Side resident who grew up in Dyker Heights, Brooklyn before the borough had its first Starbucks, a single resident who owned a Bugaboo, and when crime in every neighborhood was real. I've also been to Paris several times (and not just the 8th), so I would be able to identify a correct comparison if I saw it.

Brooklyn is just a fantastic novelty item these days. It's fun to take tourists there to gawk at all the "subversive" people who were brave enough to abandon Manhattan for such a strange new world. Articles/people like this are the reason I hate "new" Brooklyn (and I don't see what "old" Brooklyn has to recommend it). The neighborhoods the author cites as "Parisian" are those which were "bobo" fifteen years ago. At absolute best, Greenpoint, Bushwick, Bed-Stuy, and even Sunset Park and Bay Ridge are slightly Parisian in their burgeoning eclecticism. Not so for yuppie Park Slope. How many "celebrities" have moved to the neighborhoods cited in this article? Once a neighborhood can count glitterati among residents, the "bohemian Paris in the 1920s" dream scene is no longer.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
William Sherman
05:17 PM on 03/30/2011
Sshh! Keep a lid on it please! Don't encourage the transplants do to Brooklyn what they did to Manhattan.

Those cute little coffee shops and bistros will start getting replaced with Starbucks and Subways.
04:07 PM on 03/30/2011
If you focus on the richest and the prettiest part of any city, it can qualify as "New Paris." For god's sake, even parts of Beirut (forgive me, Edward Said, for Orientalizing Beirut) could look like "New Paris." My point is, indeed Brooklyn is getting a lot of media attention as the hip borough of NYC and is fast replacing Manhattan as the marketers poster child for "where to be, if you wanna be hip." But the problem is that in the process the poorer parts of Brooklyn--the less "Parisian" neighborhoods"--get neglected even though they are no less real than Prospect Park and Cobble Hill and the Heights. Ok, now the use of "Paris" as a metaphorical landscape suggesting timeless beauty: isn't it a bit passe? A friend of mine regularly posts notes from Paris saying it's fast degenerating into a seggregated city with the North Africans and Arabs pushed into peripheries to avoid embarrassment. Come on, invent something more modern and representative of the globalized era to suggest beauty and dynamicism!
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
Paul LaRosa
journalist, tv producer and author
08:15 PM on 03/30/2011
ah, sorry you don't like the comparison but i'm betting even parts of paris in the '20s had their problems. believe me, i'm well aware that there are more murders in brooklyn than another other borough but it doesn't take away from what's good and getting better about parts of the burg. i chose this time to focus on the positive aspect of the borough. you can chose the negative if you like...your prerogative.
01:51 PM on 03/31/2011
Dear Paul,

I don't think I chose the "negative". I live in Brooklyn; I just chose to appeal to Huff Post bloggers--who seem to make and break perceptions of what's "New" and what's "old" these days--to be more real and inclusive, and ah, yes, a bit less Eurocentric in their choice of metaphorical landscapes. That's all.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
11:27 PM on 04/01/2011
This sounds like the writing of a middle school girl, comparing her life to some romanticized literary ideal because she just got a latte and an organic cupcake at a coffee shop with hardwood floors (gasp! how bohemian). So you're BETTING that Paris had its rough parts in the 20s? Sorry to burst your romantic bubble, but I've got news for you: Paris in the 1920s was recovering from one of the worst wars in human history; the place was dirty and in shambles and a bunch of Americans lived there because it was cheap, not because it was romantic and beautiful (it wasn't until they wrote that it was). Most of them were alcoholics who got into brawls in cheap bars and gambled away what little money they made. I guarantee you most of the people living in Williamsburg or Park Slope wouldn't go near whatever the modern equivalent of 1920s Paris is, not until someone wrote a book about it and they all decided it would be chic to do so. If you want to live like a lost generation ex-pat, I suggest you put down the organic soy vanilla latte, come out to Brownsville, get an attic apartment, wear the same clothes every day, and decide whether you're going to eat today or not. How romantic!
03:33 PM on 03/30/2011
I've been saying this for years. I've noticed my most Francophile friends seem happiest and more at home in Brooklyn. One sees the sky; there are real neighborhoods; tremendous variety; often beautiful housing stock.
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
Kevin Walsh
03:33 PM on 03/30/2011
Queens is Queens, and has no ambitions or illusions about it being anything else, and if I were still in Brooklyn, I'd have no desire to see it as anything but Brooklyn.

www.forgotten-ny.com
anfractuous
Now I educates'm my way.
12:49 PM on 03/30/2011
And the similarities go on: In 1920's Paris struggling writers used to send their nannies to fulfill their service obligations at the Paris Food Co-op.
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
Paul LaRosa
journalist, tv producer and author
01:25 PM on 03/30/2011
hahaha....i think they sent their nannies to les halles!
01:42 PM on 03/30/2011
Hi Paul, your prose had me snorting. Not coke but it did make me wonder what you may be smoking? And also do you live in Park Slope? In any event, we'd like to officially invite you to guest blog on FIPS to share this brilliant and insightful commentary and get some literary feedback. Love, Allison on behalf of the people of Park Slope.
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
John Petro
12:26 PM on 03/30/2011
After reading "Memoirs of Montparnasse" by John Glassco and Hemmingway's "The Sun Also Rises," I have to agree!
12:26 PM on 03/30/2011
Not to mention the thousands of poor, starving people.
06:34 AM on 03/31/2011
Love Brooklyn Heights. This short film I made walking around the heights on a spring day last week shows how family friendly the place has become. It's hip for children too.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ju_Bo9U81ro
03:51 PM on 03/31/2011
They keep them far away in the banlieues (i.e. Brownsville, Crown Heights, and East New York)