More

Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Paul Brandeis Raushenbush

Paul Brandeis Raushenbush

Posted: November 11, 2010 09:50 PM

And What of Tragedy? A Eulogy for Sam Who Died on His 20th Birthday


Editor's Note: Samuel Brandeis Raushenbush was a Huffington Post Blogger and my nephew. He died on Nov. 5 on his 20th Birthday. The Eulogy was delivered on Nov. 10 at Piedmont Community Church, in Piedmont, California. My prayer is that this eulogy might help anyone who has suffered the tragic loss of a loved one.

"Those waves look pretty good." And so it would start. Our family gathered each year in late December at Sam's grandpa and grandma's house on the pacific ocean. And each year Sam would begin a relentless campaign to cajole, invite and shame the rest of us into going into the freezing winter water to do a little body surfing.

We had no power to resist him. Led by Sam, we slowly entered the water, body part by delicate body part. His enthusiasm was infectious as we anticipated, missed and then occasionally rode that perfect wave -- whooping with triumph at the end. Always too soon for Sam we would decide that not being able to feel our feet signaled a time to go in as Sam pleaded: "Just one more wave!" We would then move directly to the hot tub for the intense thawing period, as our bodies turned red like lobsters, or Sam's hair.

Whether it was going into the freezing water, going to some concert a continent away, or being kind and compassionate to a friend in need, Sam's default answer was "yes." This yes drove many of the adults in his life crazy, including me. But ultimately it was the yes of Sam that made him who he was. It was the yes that made him live life fully, and it was the Yes of Sam that we celebrate in his memory.

And what of tragedy? This phrase kept going through my head in the minutes after I heard the news that Sam had died. In tragedy we clench our fists and ask the question: Why? And that is the unanswerable question. The book of Job in the Bible shows us that anyone who pretends to have the answer to that is a fool. Personally, I do not and cannot believe that it was God's will that Sam would die. I do not believe that tragic death is ever the will of God. As one of my mentors, William Sloan Coffin, preached upon the death of his own young son, "The first heart to break when my son died was God's heart. God offers us minimum protection, but maximum support."

It is the support of God and one another that is available to us now as we begin to recover in our grief.

Going forward, each one of us has a decision to make. We can have Sam's death make us more cynical, hopeless, alienated and fearful, and our lives will contract and diminish. This is the scenario where death wins not only the battle, but the war.

The other choice is to make Sam's life inspire us to be more compassionate, hilarious, non-judgmental and loving. If we do that, then Sam's life will ultimately be a triumph that remains with us all of our lives.

My belief is that Sam is now with his Higher Power, whom he called God. And as Sam is with God, his Spirit is with us right here, right now. In some traditions there are those who help God to inspire people to live well and become more enlightened. Now, I am pretty sure that Sam never aspired to be a saint... But if we keep our hearts open to the wisdom that Sam gathered in his short life, we can hear him inspiring us to transform our life for the better: to take care of one another, to make someone laugh, to dance like you just don't care, to keep coming back, to plunge into the water and ride that wave. We can hear him say to us: Yes, yes, yes!

The following litany of gratitude was inspired by a list of things for which Sam had noted he was grateful. My hope is that they might help all of us remember the blessings of this life:

For close friendships, we are grateful.
For travel, we are grateful.
For mental sharpness, we are grateful.
For children, we are grateful.
For quiet time to think, we are grateful.
For AA and the Fellowship, we are grateful.
For people who stuck with us even when we treated them badly, we are grateful.
For those who took care of us when we were young and who have always been there for us, we are grateful.
For families that love us, we are grateful.
For music, we are grateful.
For nature's beauty, we are grateful.
For life, we are grateful.

Amen.

 
 
 
Editor's Note: Samuel Brandeis Raushenbush was a Huffington Post Blogger and my nephew. He died on Nov. 5 on his 20th Birthday. The Eulogy was delivered on Nov. 10 at Piedmont Community Church, in P...
Editor's Note: Samuel Brandeis Raushenbush was a Huffington Post Blogger and my nephew. He died on Nov. 5 on his 20th Birthday. The Eulogy was delivered on Nov. 10 at Piedmont Community Church, in P...
 
 
  • Comments
  • 71
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Bloggers
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2 3  Next ›  Last »  (3 total)
photo
Jenifer Fox
Educator, Author
05:12 PM on 11/26/2010
Paul, FInding life in the tragedy of death is a gift that you bring to the world. Thanks for sharing this.
07:16 AM on 11/22/2010
What of those who claim that god has a plan?

Of course, supposing for a minute that there might really be a god.
03:47 PM on 11/18/2010
Share and Live, what a treasure our lives can be living and also after death continue to bless!
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Dbos
Single payer universal health insurance agent
11:16 AM on 11/14/2010
my daughter died at 14 for giggles I am grateful
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
joyfree
Jaded by life, but ever hopeful...
02:56 AM on 11/14/2010
Funny, I was just writing a gratitude list this morning at my favorite meeting, too. Actually, it's not all that unusual, since it's November! I'm glad that you have found a good way to work through your loss. Your grandson was indeed a lover of life.
10:51 PM on 11/13/2010
Condolences on your terrible loss, and thanks for sharing with us this beautiful and very moving eulogy.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
PTAOfficerforObama
A micro bio is a terrrible thing to waste.
05:27 AM on 11/13/2010
What a beautiful young man. I am sorry for your loss.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
logicanada
Blogger, radio co-host, writer, editor, voice-over
05:15 AM on 11/13/2010
My grandson of 6 months just passed due to heart failure after 4 open heart surgeries. No exciting waves, no 20 years tempting fate by living on the edge. So few photos and memories. Not even a blog topic. So sorry I cannot empathise with your loss.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Happylib
Don't take your dolly and go home
11:32 AM on 11/13/2010
I am so sorry for your loss. When my sister passed away 7 years ago at the age of 33, I wondered if I would rather never have known her versus the terrible pain and grief I felt, but soon I realized that I would not trade any memory or any minute I spent with her just to feel better.

The loss of a 6 month old baby must be doubly hard as you ponder all that you lost in the future. The deep, dark hole that is grief is actually, I believe, cushioned by the memories and moments you shared with your loved one. My parents lost their first child at the age of two long before I was born and they still, 45 years later, grieve for her. They survived, I survived, you will survive this tragedy. I hear your anger and I know it so well. It too is a cushion that you should hold only long enough to move into healing.

I never knew your grandson and I don't know you, but the love you show him tells me that he was the kind of person that would want his loved ones to be ok. He took a piece of your heart but he purposely left the biggest part here for you to continue on. I will think about you. I will send you healing thoughts. All you have to do right now is breathe, eat, sleep, and cry.
11:59 AM on 11/13/2010
I am sorry for the loss of your grandson... My niece died at five. A loss of a loved one no matter the age, is a loss. We all feel the pain and their palpable absence...
04:50 AM on 11/13/2010
My sincere condolences on the loss of your nephew. I thank you for sharing your thoughts and memories with us. I lost a daughter many years ago, she had just enjoyed her eighteenth birthday. There is not a day that goes by that I don't think of her, she loved life and was so full of promise. Her unfulfilled potential and her presence in our lives is a loss that is incomprehensible to those who have never experienced such a loss. Thank you again.
12:39 AM on 11/13/2010
May kind words expressed from kind hearts comfort you and those who love your nephew. I am so sorry for your loss.
12:27 AM on 11/13/2010
As the father of a near 20-year-old, I can only imagine the heartache of losing one's child at such a young age. My sincerest condolences.
11:55 PM on 11/12/2010
Beautifully written. My condolences.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
Michele Somerville
10:32 PM on 11/12/2010
A sad, lovely eulogy. Those verses of gratitude make a fine Thanksgiving prayer.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
08:42 PM on 11/12/2010
Sorry for your loss Paul. Sam sounds like a great young man we would have all liked.
The death of a young person seems to turn everything on it's head, it is all backwards. It is unimaginable for the parents. Sympathy to all of you .
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
OtayPanky
You're welcome
07:40 PM on 11/12/2010
When you lose a child, there is nothing more noxious than people's misguided comments that try to provide a metaphysical reason for what is beyond all reasoning.

Say you're sorry for the loss. If you're a friend, ask what, if anything, you might do to give support.

And then, shut up.

My condolences, Paul, to you and all those who loved this young man.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
SarcasticFringehead
Mute Nostril Agony
08:18 PM on 11/12/2010
True.
I always grit my teeth when people recite platitudes like:
"It's all part of god's plan."
Or
"God wanted him to be with him again."
Or other such pablum.
12:56 AM on 11/13/2010
I remember when an aunt said to me, regarding her brother (my uncle) who had died, 'God had work for Ronny to do on the other side.'

I could not contain myself and said, "BullS*i#! If he killed Ronny so he could do some silly work he could have done for Himself, then He is totally selfish because He took a man away from his wife and 10 young children, who were mighty poor to begin with and who needed him more than He did."

As I was saying it I knew it would cause a problem as it would surely be repeated to others in the family, but once said I felt really really good about saying it...

They needed to hear how outlandish the idea is.

Then again, if that is what they need to believe to help them cope - then maybe that is what they need to believe. But it just grates my nerves to hear it.