iPhone app iPad app Android phone app Android tablet app More

Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Philip Goldberg

GET UPDATES FROM Philip Goldberg
 

Hindu Jesus: A Different Kind of Christianity

Posted: 12/19/2010 7:22 pm

I grew up hearing about three kinds of Jesus. To the Irish and Italian Catholics in my Brooklyn neighborhood he was the only begotten son of God, Savior of all Mankind. Among the Jews there were two versions: the laudable ethical teacher -- a nice Jewish boy who met with a terrible fate -- and the Jesus that never existed, a creature of mythology, like Apollo or Zeus. In my atheistic home, where religion was the opium of the people, Jesus was largely irrelevant, except as a proponent of the Golden Rule and as the founder of a religion that perpetrated horrors in his name.

Then came the 60s, and I was introduced to a different Jesus, by way of India. Like millions of my contemporaries, my hot pursuit of truth and personal fulfillment led me to the spiritual teachings of the East. I read the sacred texts of Hinduism and Buddhism as well as modern interpreters such as Aldous Huxley, Alan Watts and Huston Smith. It was called mysticism, but I found it, ironically, non-mysterious and eminently rational. I tracked down a yoga class -- not easy to do back then, believe it or not -- and learned to meditate. Throughout my explorations, the name of Jesus cropped up surprisingly often, and always with respect. In Paramahansa Yogananda's seminal memoir, Autobiography of a Yogi, the rabbi of Nazareth is treated with such reverence that I thought I must be missing something.

So I bought a New Testament, and it blew my mind. Because my spiritual reference point was more Hindu than Judeo-Christian, the Gospels seemed more like the Upanishads or the Bhagavad Gita than the churchy dogma I expected to find. The main character was a master teacher, a guru who prodded his disciples not just to better behavior but to union with the divine. His term for the Ground of Being was "Father," but it was easy to evoke the language of the Vedic seers and substitute Brahman or Self. When he tells the crowd at the Sermon on the Mount not to pray conspicuously like the hypocrites, but to "go into your room and shut the door and pray to your Father who is in secret," I saw a guru directing his disciples to meditate. This was a Jesus I could live with: exalted in a way that befits a giant of history, but without the grandiose, cosmos-altering triumphalism that relegates non-believers to either irrelevance or damnation.

I soon learned that Hindus in general, and the swamis and yoga masters who came to the West in particular, saw Jesus in much the same way, as a sadguru (true teacher) and a jivamukti (enlightened being) of the highest order. Some afforded him the status of avatar, placing him on the same level as Krishna, Rama, and other divine incarnations. In keeping with their pluralistic tradition, they considered the teachings of Christ, when followed properly, to be a legitimate pathway to the unified consciousness that is yoga's true aim.

In researching my book, American Veda, I discovered that this perspective has been filtering into America's bloodstream ever since Henry David Thoreau equated Jesus with Buddha and called himself a yogi in Walden. It gathered steam as a stately parade of gurus arrived on our shores and exploded after the Beatles' legendary sojourn on the Ganges in 1968. For a great many angry or alienated Christians, seeing Jesus in this way enabled them to reconcile with their religious heritage; many returned to active participation on terms they could live with, although their Christianity was often closer to that of mystics like Meister Eckhart or Thomas Merton than to the mainstream church. Even Christians whose spiritual lives were, for all practical purposes, more Hindu than anything else have been encouraged by their own gurus to remain connected to their Christian roots. This often entailed seeing Jesus as their ishta devata (preferred form of God). That these prodigal sons and daughters found their way back to the Jesus they love by way of a tradition that has been besieged by missionaries for centuries is one of the great ironies of religious history. And, in similar fashion, thousands of Jews who studied Hinduism and Buddhism have come to see Jesus as a mystical rabbi, a passionate religious reformer and a moral leader whose legacy was sadly corrupted.

The image of Jesus as a sage and sadguru may not sit well with clerics for whom Christ can only be the one true messiah and the hinge of human history. They ought to be glad that millions of people like me, who might otherwise view this season as merely a respite from work, or as humbug, will instead celebrate the birthday of a great holy man.

 
 
 

Follow Philip Goldberg on Twitter: www.twitter.com/phil_amveda

FOLLOW RELIGION
I grew up hearing about three kinds of Jesus. To the Irish and Italian Catholics in my Brooklyn neighborhood he was the only begotten son of God, Savior of all Mankind. Among the Jews there were two v...
I grew up hearing about three kinds of Jesus. To the Irish and Italian Catholics in my Brooklyn neighborhood he was the only begotten son of God, Savior of all Mankind. Among the Jews there were two v...
 
 
  • Comments
  • 401
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2 3 4 5  Next ›  Last »  (6 total)
02:04 PM on 01/07/2011
My own experience echoes yours -- raised by atheist parents, I fell in love with Yoga in the late 60's, went to India, lived in an ashram for over a year (Ramana Maharshi's). The ashram library had many books on Christian saints and mystics as well as books on the Vedas, Budhhist and other scriptural texts, and I fell in love with Jesus, though I never called myself Christian.
A man who has succesfully integrated Vedic wisdom into Christianity is Bede Griffiths, a Catholic priest who founded an ashram in South India and whose books teach a very different kind of Christianity -- a Christianity for the future?
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
02:23 PM on 12/28/2010
reading the efforts of the exclusivists here, it is troubling. Joshua/Jesus came to lead and show the way as an example, not to invoke worship of his person. The out of context use of John 14:6 and a few other passages out of their context is being used to invert their meaning. Rather than be an example to follow Joshua is converted into someone who can not really ever be an example because he is in substance different from the humans. It destroys the real message and purpose. He chose to refer to himself primarily not as the son of god but as son of man which at root means a human being. Humility and even realization of ones ordinariness is the foundational characteristic of the messiah. I submit that such humility is incompatible with claiming "I am god and you are not" When reading John 14:6 the emphasis is on the word "am" and not the word "I"- the fundamentalist are suppressing the meaning. Now I expect one of our modern day Pharisees to call what I have just said blasphemy. sound familiar?
02:57 PM on 12/25/2010
All I thought when I finished reading this is man created god(s) and re-created god..... and kept on re-creating god until god is what man's image of what god, buddha, allah, the man in the sky, should be like. It makes me wonder if the bible had a typo or a bad translation. Instead of god creating man in his image, maybe its the other way around. After all, we have been here 6000 years (mock, mock). Metaphysically, is 6000 years an eternity seeing as how god created the universe in 6 days? Isn't that long enough to get god right or as the xians say get right with god? Seems like we're still trying to get the man in the sky right. Being a human being I will never be right with god because I stole that red stapler from work.
photo
Pandoras Folly
This Micro-bio is of legendary quality
04:34 PM on 12/27/2010
religion does for God what the legal system does for Justice. i hope you come to understand this.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
tombaan
Live and let live
10:50 PM on 12/27/2010
Religion was required when man was trying to reconcile with his reality around him..now as science has exposed more and more of facts out there.....religion is doing its last fight....
07:36 AM on 12/31/2010
....but then religion is a word and you speak in metaphores to convey some deeper sense or not! Science, last I looked, is more concerned with the how than the why!
01:18 PM on 12/25/2010
"The Avatar appears in different forms, under different names, at different times, in different parts of the world. As His appearance always coincides with the spiritual regeneration of man, the period immediately preceding His manifestation is always one in which humanity suffers from the pangs of the approaching rebirth. Man seems more than ever enslaved by desire, more than ever driven by greed, held by fear, swept by anger. The strong dominate the weak; the rich oppress the poor; large masses of people are exploited for the benefit of the few who are in power. The individual, who finds no peace or rest, seeks to forget himself in excitement. Immorality increases, crime flourishes, religion is ridiculed. Corruption spreads throughout the social order. Class and national hatreds are aroused and fostered. Wars break out. Humanity grows desperate. There seems to be no possibility of stemming the tide of destruction.

"At this moment the Avatar appears. Being the total manifestation of God in human form, He is like a gauge against which man can measure what he is and what he may become. He trues the standard of human values by interpreting them in terms of divinely human life."

Meher Baba
12:21 PM on 12/24/2010
Jesus is definitely one of the greatest teachers to have ever walked on earth. That's reason enough to celebrate Christmas in his memory, and in respect and awe for his teachings.. Whether you subscribe to the full baggage that organized churches come with or not do so..
12:44 AM on 12/24/2010
"Verily, verily, I say unto you, He that entereth not by the
door into the sheepfold, but climbeth up some other way, the
same is a thief and a robber.
But he that entereth in by the door is the shepherd of the
sheep.
To him the porter openeth; and the sheep hear his voice: and
he calleth his own sheep by name, and leadeth them out.
And when he putteth forth his own sheep, he goeth before them,
and the sheep follow him: for they know his voice.
And a stranger will they not follow, but will flee from him:
for they know not the voice of strangers.
This parable spake Jesus unto them: but they understood not
what things they were which he spake unto them.
Then said Jesus unto them again, Verily, verily, I say unto
you, I am the door of the sheep.
All that ever came before me are thieves and robbers: but the
sheep did not hear them.
I am the door: by me if any man enter in, he shall be saved,
and shall go in and out, and find pasture.
The thief cometh not, but for to steal, and to kill, and to
destroy: I am come that they might have life, and that they
might have it more abundantly."
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
cayuse
Soaring Eagle, soaring to Spirit from the ego self
06:22 PM on 12/22/2010
Nice, so many speak only of the Hindu's as a Church without mentioning Krishna.

-Yogananda. The second coming of "Christ" (not Jesus) is when a human being attains "self realization," also called Nirvana

In The Second Coming of Christ: The Resurrection of the Christ. Within You, Paramahansa Yogananda

Paul, ROMANS
11
-But if the Spirit of him that raised up Jesus from the dead dwell in you, he that raised up Christ from the dead shall also quicken your mortal bodies by his Spirit that dwelleth in you.
12
¶ Therefore, brethren, we are debtors, not to the flesh, to live after the flesh.
13
For if ye live after the flesh, ye shall die: but if ye through the Spirit do mortify the deeds of the body, ye shall live.
14
For as many as are led by the Spirit of God, they are the sons of God.
08:09 AM on 12/25/2010
I always felt that is what they meant about the second coming of Christ. It's nice to see another human being see it the same way. I also see Heaven and Nirvana in the same light.
kellygreen
"Ideology is the Science of Idiots" John Adams
12:32 PM on 12/22/2010
There is One Truth...though it goes by many different names.

Wonderful article.
10:14 AM on 12/23/2010
Read the chapter called "One god, many names:"

http://www.boloji.com/hinduism/091.htm
kellygreen
"Ideology is the Science of Idiots" John Adams
08:16 AM on 12/28/2010
If one wishes to focus on the Route Taken....yes.

If one prefers (as I do) to focus on the Destination those Roads converge upon...then, no.

The roads are seperate...and tend to best suit particular people with particular temperments who are lost in particular ways....to reach that destination.

Each road is valuable, because they offer (those best suited) a paved road by which to reach that Destination. It is valuable to maintain that seperateness, to the degree that it prevents people from constantly hopping from one road to another, mixing-and-matching such that they never reach the Destination.

It is a hinderance to maintain that seperateness, to the degree that (the flipside of the first situation) it keeps people focused on and arguing about qualities of the various routes...and keeps them from seeing the Destination that they all converge upon....

Because, at the end of the day, the Destination is what matters.

Not the Route taken to get there.
kellygreen
"Ideology is the Science of Idiots" John Adams
08:18 AM on 12/28/2010
..and by the way.

I highly recommend Joseph Campbell.

Mythology and the theology are just tools by which we try to organize and make sense of things which (ultimately) cannot be expressed in any words.

The Map is not the Territory.
09:20 PM on 12/21/2010
"The Syrian Malabar Nasrani people, also known as Saint Thomas Christians and Nasranis, are an ethnoreligious group from Kerala, India, adhering to the various churches of the Saint Thomas Christian tradition. They are also known as Syrian-Malabar Christians, Suriyani Christiaanikal, Mar Thoma Nasrani, or more popularly as Syrian Christians in view that they use Syriac liturgy since the early days of Christianity in India.

The Syrian Malabar Nasranis are the descendants of the Jewish diaspora in Kerala [2][3][4][5][6][7][8][9][10] who were evangelized by St. Thomas in the Malabar Coast in the earliest days of Christianity"
photo
bryanzth
Honest to Goodness USA Patriot!
08:59 PM on 12/21/2010
I agree with the author, except that of course, he was probably NOT born on 25 Dec, since that was the Saturnalia that the Early Church tried to appropriate.

Yeah, but that's nit picking on my part. I think this was the most interesting topic. A great holy Man.

BZ.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
opsudrania
A Humanist and investigative journalist
02:51 PM on 12/21/2010
It is not Christ but "Christ Consciousness", not Krishna but "Krishna Consciousness" and so on. We are not born "A Religion" but a "Homo Species" call it human or homo sapiens" or anything else. But the reality is same. We are all converted later on.

Do we know, accepting the present Gospels of the reality of Jesus, "Where was he during his those lost or unknown years"? People operating at spiritual level have a different behaviour from us - the mundanes; it may appear to us as if s/he is a lunatic or mad. But they are or live in a different plane than us and their vision is far beyond our contemplation. That is why, they are reffered to as "Seers" as well. They can see things beyond the "Three Dimensions", of which this "Seen World" is composed of.

So please hold your breath when you read columns like this. These may appear paradoxical to a novice or even worst - blasphemy to others.

I offer my full admiration to a wonderfully spiritual column.

God bless
Dr. O. P. Sudrania
photo
SILVANUS
Moving to Italy indefinitely. God Bless All.
12:50 PM on 12/21/2010
Ultimately, 'personalities' are of no importance to the Truth any of the 'personalities' you perceive teach/taught, and as long as you are arguing as to who was "special" or "more special", you are as deep in the illusion as you were before you opened your mouth.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
GlennWatson
Two million fans
09:32 AM on 12/21/2010
Thinking Jesus was a guy with a few good ideas is not enough to make one a Christian.
photo
SILVANUS
Moving to Italy indefinitely. God Bless All.
12:47 PM on 12/21/2010
Nor is it enough to EXCLUDE one from being Christian. Stop your specialness crap. That is NOT what Jesus intended.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
GlennWatson
Two million fans
01:48 PM on 12/21/2010
Jesus intened to save souls through the sacrifice of his life. He gave good advice but if thats all you get from him its like pearls before swine.
photo
TYRANNASAURUS
UGH!....people taste like crap!
06:17 PM on 12/22/2010
It's really hard to see what HE intended SILVANUS since he never existed.
01:57 AM on 12/21/2010
The problem is that, like many people today, you are imposing onto Jesus your own ideas and values. In biblical criticism, this is called "eisegesis." There is no "Hindu Jesus." He was a Jew. And that makes all the difference. If you seek the one who called himself the "Son of Man" honestly, you might find yourself agreeing more with those clerics than you think.
photo
Pandoras Folly
This Micro-bio is of legendary quality
09:26 AM on 12/21/2010
there is an exercise, a meditation if you will, i believe it was developed by the Jesuits. Imagine Jesus in an every day scene from his life at home around the kitchen, at the market talking, etc. not healing or preaching or a scene from the bible, and imagine it in every detail possible do this for months imagining every action, his laugh, his speech, how his clothes fall, how he walks, drinks, and then he looks at you. now take all of that away and you are left with that who is truly christ.
photo
bryanzth
Honest to Goodness USA Patriot!
09:04 PM on 12/21/2010
I like what you say we have to take away.

I lIke what Gandhi said, "I like your Christ. I do not like your Christians." ;0)

BZ.
kellygreen
"Ideology is the Science of Idiots" John Adams
12:52 PM on 12/22/2010
Jesus as Fundamental, formless Consciousness.

I knew there was a reason why I've always like the Jesuits. :)
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
GlennWatson
Two million fans
01:49 PM on 12/21/2010
Well said.
01:40 AM on 12/21/2010
This is what you see when freewill is exploited. The Vatican knows it all, and Jesus never went to any India. If you are close to any Catholic priests they might give you hints on reality. There are many thin lines which connect the theories you believe here. And there are many motives and agendas behind it. I see Mr Goldberg only as a victim of one of these inter-faith agendas. If you knew 1 faith, you would never recognize inter-faith. Concepts of inter-faith are as good as those of polygamy. In B.C. 30, son of Julius Ceasar was sent to India secretly, and wasn't dressed up as a King's son, but like a poor man. The evidences of this incident are confused with that of Jesus travelling to India in maybe A.D. 17 or 18.

Everything sells and so did this writeup. I've been living in India for 28 yrs now, and all of my friends are Hindus. People can anyways always make a living by linking anything and everything to Jesus!
11:37 PM on 12/24/2010
you know what happens when you get too close to catholic priests? read the papers, lol.