In anticipation of Stanford University's Center for Compassion Altruism and Education's upcoming Science of Compassion conference in Telluride, Colo. on the science of compassion, we are excited to present an article by one of our world-experts on compassion. Dr. Robert Levine is a Professor of Psychology at California State University, Fresno. He is the author of A Geography of Time (Basic Books). -- Dr. James Doty, Director, Center for Compassion and Altruism Research and Education, Stanford University.
By Dr. Robert Levine
Two images: First, as a 6-year-old boy growing up in New York City, I am walking with my father on a crowded midtown street. The rush of pedestrians suddenly backs up before me as people narrow into a single lane to avoid a large object on the sidewalk. To my astonishment, the object turns out to be a human being lying unconscious against a building. My father quickly points to a bottle in a paper bag next to him. Not one of the passing herd seems to actually notice the man -- certainly, none make eye contact -- as they robotically follow the makeshift detour. My father, who I look up to as a model loving, caring man, explains that the poor soul on the sidewalk "just needs to sleep it off." When the prone man suddenly begins to ramble senselessly, my father stops me. "You never know how he'll react." I later came to see these two teachings -- "there's nothing you can do" and "try not to get involved" -- as my anthems of urban survival.
Next, fast forward several years to a market in Rangoon, Burma (now Myanmar). I had spent the previous 12 months travelling in poor Asian cities, but even by those standards this was a scene of misery. Besides the inconceivable poverty, it is sweltering hot, ridiculously crowded and the wind is blowing dust everywhere. Suddenly, a man carrying a huge bag of peanuts calls out in pain and falls to the ground. I then witness an astonishing piece of choreography. Appearing to have rehearsed the scene many times, a half dozen sellers run from their stalls to help, leaving unattended what may be the totality of their possessions. One puts a blanket under the man's head, another opens his shirt, a third questions him carefully about the pain, a fourth gets water, a fifth keeps onlookers from crowding too close, a sixth runs for a doctor. Within minutes, the doctor arrives, and two other locals join in to assist. The performance could have passed for a final exam at paramedic school.
Rousseau once wrote that "cities are the sink of the human race." But as my experiences in New York and Rangoon made clear, no two cities are the same. Places, like individuals, have their own personalities.
In what cities is a needy stranger more likely to receive help? What sort of community teaches a citizen to withhold compassion toward strangers? As a grown-up social psychologist, I have spent much of the past two decades systematically exploring these questions.
My students and I have traveled across the United States and much of the world to observe where passersby are most likely to help a stranger. In each city, we have conducted variations on five different field experiments. Our studies have focused on simple acts of assistance as opposed to Schindler-like acts of heroism: Is an "unnoticed" dropped pen retrieved by a passing pedestrian? Does a man with a hurt leg receive assistance picking up a dropped magazine? Will a blind person be helped across a busy intersection? Will a stranger try to make change for a quarter (or its foreign equivalent)? Do people take the time to mail a stamped and addressed "lost" letter?
We've found vast differences between places. In our most recent experiments in 24 U.S. cities, for example, Stephen Reysen and I found the highest helping rates in Knoxville, Tenn. and the lowest in New York City. In earlier experiments conducted in cities in 23 countries, the people of Rio de Janeiro were the most helpful and those in Kuala Lumpur were the lowest (though New York wasn't far behind). The differences were often considerable. In the blind person experiment, for example, five cities (Rio de Janeiro, San Jose, Lilongwe, Madrid and Prague) helped the pedestrian across the street on every occasion, while in Kuala Lampur, Kiev and Bangkok help was offered less than one-half the time. If you have a hurt leg in downtown San Jose (Costa Rica), Calcutta or Shanghai, our results show that you are more than three times as likely to receive help picking up a dropped magazine than if you are on the streets of New York City, Kiev or Sofia. And if you drop your pen behind you in New York City, you have less than one-third the chance of seeing it again than if you dropped it in Rio de Janeiro.
Our most important finding, however, is that the helpfulness of a city is systematically related to specific social, economic and demographic characteristics. In our U.S. study, for example, we found that more helpful cities had smaller population sizes, populations densities, more vital economies and slower paces of life. (For more details of these studies, see: "The Kindness of Strangers," published in American Scientist, available at http://www.boblevine.net.)
Later this month the first-ever conference on "The Science of Compassion" will be held in Telluride, Colo. The notion of studying compassion scientifically may rub some people the wrong way. Is there anything to be gained by reducing humanism to numbers? Our studies indicate there very well might be. By understanding the conditions that bring out the best in people, we may be able to create more compassionate environments.
Robert Levine has studied the likelihood people will assist a stranger in need in different cities and countries. In one series of field experiments, he compared helpfulness toward strangers in 36 U.S. cities; in another, across 23 countries. Levine is a professor of psychology and former associate dean of the College of Science and Mathematics at California State University, Fresno. He has also served as a visiting professor at Universidade Federal Fluminense in Niteroi, Brazil, at Sapporo Medical University in Japan, and at Stockholm University in Sweden. Levine has published many articles in professional journals as well as articles in trade periodicals such as Discover, American Demographics, The New York Times, Utne Reader, and American Scientist. His book, A Geography of Time, was awarded the Otto Klineberg Intercultural and International Relations Award. It has been the subject of feature stories around the world, including Newsweek, The New York Times Magazine, CNN, the BBC, ABC's Primetime, and NPR's "All Things Considered" and Marketplace. It has been translated into six languages. His book, The Power of Persuasion: How We're Bought and Sold, has been translated into seven languages. He has won awards for both his teaching and research. Levine is currently president of the Western Psychological Association.
For more on mindfulness, click here.
For more by Project Compassion Stanford, click here.
Stranger then told old man that he was moving and considering this city (where he's talking to old man). But, stranger said, he wanted to first know what the people were like here.
Old man paused and then asked the stranger what the people were like in the city he was moving from.
Stranger replied, "Oh, they're unfriendly, mean-spirited, and only look out for themselves. Not pleasant people at all".
Old man replied, "Well, unfortunately, I think you'll find that people in this city are the same way".
Stranger left, and awhile later, another stranger came up to the old man and asked the same question.
When old man asked him what people in his current city were like, Stranger replied, "Oh, they're great. They're kind, helpful, wonderful people".
Old man replied, "Well, I think you'll find that people are that way in this city, too".
Heard this years ago and always thought it was a cool story.
By those standard, where I live should be shangri la. However, Minnesota Ice would be far more appropriate.
Everyone here is related....Maybe its the inbreeding :-P
Not gone to Knoxville, but lived in Nashville many years. Not gone to Asian city Burma either, been to Seoul, the" City of Calm", full of polite people, but if I am stuck do not know if they would pull me out. Calcutta, poor folks would go out of their ways to offer a helping hand, or the most suspicious looking dude would give up their seat easily in a crowded train to offer it to you. Then there are pick-pocketers. Madrid is a happy city, and then in Barcelona almost got badly robbed in a subway, suddenly got surrounded by five, somehow escaped. In Kansas, with flat tire in the middle of traffic, total stranger showed up to take me to a safe location and changed my flats. Then took off.
I say look no more...there is always someone standing next to you.
I have a different observation-- you remain a stranger in a small town,even after years-- though the folks are more polite.
My students and I have traveled across the United States and much of the world to observe where passersby are most likely to help a stranger. In each city, we have conducted variations on five different field experiments.
And who paid for this useless research, it was probably another one of those grants given out to study some mundane useless subjects that the money would be better spent on something useful like medical research. How many will benefit from this? Not many, if anyone at all. Such a waste of time and money.
I think he/she is saying she doesn't like it when Canadians come into the US and "bad mouth" things about the US....
In other words, she lives in the US; she's not Canadian.
I'm sorry.
I just realized that YOU are Canadian.
I think....
(Btw, I'm a neutral bystander in this. Matter of fact, I was born in Lynn Lake, Manitoba, Canada. My parents immigrated to US when I was a small child. We visited relatives in Canada (they lived in Toronto) every summer growing up. I liked Toronto and still do).
Again, sorry I butted in here between the two of you....