"How do we reach Jewish young people?" has long been one of the central mantras of the organized Jewish community, as those of us who work as Jewish professionals can surely attest. But while we wring our hands over at the state of the Jewish future, a remarkable new generation of Jews has been knocking insistently at our door.
Case in point: Almost one year ago, five young Jews disrupted the keynote speech by Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu at the Jewish Federation General Assembly in New Orleans. One by one, at five different points during the speech, the activists stood on their chairs, unfurled banners and shouted out in turn:
Young Jews say the settlements delegitimize Israel!
Young Jews say the Occupation delegitimizes Israel!
Young Jews say the siege of Gaza delegitimizes Israel!
Young Jews say the loyalty oath delegitimizes Israel!
Young Jews say silencing dissent delegitimizes Israel!
With each successive interruption the shouts from the crowd grew louder and angrier. As security attempted to safely walk them out, one protester was put in a choke hold by a convention attendee and wrestled to the floor. Another conventioneer grabbed a banner and tore it in half with his teeth.
At the very same moment, "Young, Jewish, Proud" launched its website, featuring the "Young Jewish Declaration" -- an astonishing statement of purpose that seemed to come directly from the collective heart, mind and gut of this newly formed youth movement:
We exist. We are everywhere. We speak and love and dream in every language...
We remember how to build our homes, and our holiness, out of time and thin air, and so do not need other people's land to do so...
We refuse to have our histories distorted or erased, or appropriated by a corporate war machine. We will not call this liberation...
We commit ourselves to peace. We will stand up with honest bodies, to offer honest bread...
We are young Jews, and we get to decide what that means.
Predictably, the Jewish establishment wasted no time in excoriating the protesters. Some chided them condescendingly for their "misguided" behavior. Others angrily criticized them for "aiding the enemy."
As for me, I watched these events unfold with genuine hope for our Jewish future.
After all, weren't these young people claiming and proclaiming their Jewishness in classic Jewish fashion? Like young Abraham destroying his father's icons, they stood up to the hypocrisy and corruption of their elders. In the heart of the the largest gathering of American Jewish leaders, these proud young Jews called out their community on its most sacred of sacred cows: namely, the unquestioning, unconditional support of the state of Israel.
In all honesty, I can't say I've ever witnessed as authentic an act of young Jewish self-expression as I did that afternoon at the New Orleans General Assembly.
Yes, as a professional Jew, I've participated in the "how can we inspire young people?" conversation more times than I care to admit. I've watched a myriad of Jewish community-sponsored initiatives come and go. And invariably, all of them focused on what we believed was best for Jewish young people.
But while the Jewish establishment has been excellent at creating and funding expensive projects, we seem to be chronically incapable of actually listening. We love to tell young people how we think they should express their Jewishness, but rarely do we stop long enough to really, truly learn what drives and inspires them.
Taglit-Birthright Israel, the Jewish establishment's signature youth initiative, is the most obvious case in point. For well over a decade, we have invested literally hundreds of millions of dollars in providing free, all-expense-paid trips to Israel. The essential goal of these trips, as Birthright's Marketing Director puts it plainly, is to make Israel "an integral part of every Jew's identity."
It's well known that Birthright was born in response to growing reports that American Jewish young people were becoming increasingly disconnected to the state of Israel. But by rushing to address this issue through a massive multimillion dollar community initiative, we successfully avoided asking the deeper questions.
Could it be that we were afraid to know the answers?
Could it be that young people are becoming disenchanted with Israel because they are becoming increasingly troubled by its treatment of Palestinians? Could it be that growing numbers of young Jews regard Israel more as an oppressive colonial project than a source of Jewish pride? Could it be that in the 21st century world, the identities of young Jews are tied less to Jewish ethno-nationalism than to a more universal vision of liberation?
"Young, Jewish, Proud" is decidedly not the product of a Jewish communal initiative. On the contrary it is a grass-roots, self-organized effort of young Jews who seek to express their Jewish identity in a time-honored Jewish manner: by speaking truth to power, by advocating unabashedly for peace, justice and liberation, by standing up to oppression, racism and persecution in Israel/Palestine and throughout the world. They simply aren't buying what the Jewish establishment has been selling them. They are finding their own voices.
We are young Jews, and we get to decide what that means...
I am well aware that it is difficult for a Jewish community so thoroughly focused on Israel to hear Zionism challenged in such a powerful way. But aren't these young people doing precisely what they were raised to do as Jews? Haven't we taught them to take a good, educated look around them, think critically about what they see, and take a stand for what they believe in? Is the Jewish establishment really going to exclude them simply because it doesn't like their conclusions?
In the Torah portion for the first day of Rosh Hashanah, we read that when God saves the life of young Ishmael in the wilderness, "God heeded the cries of the boy where he is" (Genesis 21:17). In other words, God was able to find Ishmael by truly listening to him. Not where God wanted him to be or were God thought he should be, but where he was.
This New Year, I fervently hope our community can do the same with our newest adult generation. These young people certainly have every reason to be disenchanted with the organized Jewish community, but for some reason they refuse to go away. They're here, and they're knocking loudly at our door.
Do we, the gatekeepers of the Jewish community, have the vision, the faith and the courage to open it up and let them in?
Follow Rabbi Brant Rosen on Twitter: www.twitter.com/rabbibrant
Hannah Weisfeld: Supporting Upgrade in Palestine's Status
Divest This!: Young, Jewish and Proud - Oy!
In my opinon, the efforts by many on the left to delegitimize israel has pushed many jews closer to israel, and the simplistic arguments against israel have pushed many to look at the facts for themselves and in that way become stronger supporters of israel.
And then I think that presenting themselves as generational phenomenon is generalization too far. And it might be so far off that it removes any credibility to the message they try to bring.
And the problem I see is not that young American Jews don't know Israel but that they don't understand Israelis, don't understand issues Israel is faced with and why Israelis accept certain policies and decisions. Because if one chastises Netanyahu or Liberman he or she ignores the fact that they are leaders of parties that won democratic elections and have support of majority of Israelis, people that have rights, including right to make mistakes. And really are not seeking world's love but just consideration and fair treatment.
So, I'm not worried that five individuals decided to have a demonstration perhaps in not the most appropriate manner. I'm more concerned that their behavior might be presented and right and somewhat heroic even though it is not, not right, not proper. And I'm saddened that the Author doesn't feel that it is important to stress - goal does not excuse any mean to reach it.
BTW: Being elected by a minority and in power by a coalition of parties does not make them holy or above the criticism of anyone.
Yes, Rabbi, Jewish tradition encourages lively debate and challenging ideas, but that doesn't mean doing so in such a rude and childish manner.
You may be proud of such antics, but I definitely hold my children and would like to see other Jewish young adults held to a higher standard.
So there were 5 (five) "young Jews" who oppose Netanyahu and the perceived policy of his government. And they went to protest against him, at an assembly attended by hundreds who support him. And a website (among thousands of others) proclaimed some defiant slogan or another.
So?? How does one reach sweeping generalisations based on such facts? How does one jump -- in the space of one blog -- from 5 protesters and one website to characterising an entire generation -- numerous members of which I have seen demonstrating in support of Israel?
If I were young and Jewish, I would object to being morphed into a pawn. I would object to assumptions that are clearly based not on a careful examination of facts, but on their fanciful "interpretation" in the service of a pre-conceived ideological goal.
Plenty of young Israelis stand with people in the West Bank to protest the Wall, limits on Palestinian freedom of movement and house demolitions.
These are no pawns. They think for themselves, independent of the groupthink of the state. THe goal is to move the discussion so that there can be peaceful coexistence. Not a bad idea.
Ideas over ideologies--it takes independent thought and commitment to rationality .
There are no "policies of the state" -- except in the minds of Israel-haters & fringe anarchists. There are policies of political parties & governments they form. And yes, it's perfectly legitimate to criticise/protest actions/decisions by one government or another.
But that's NOT what Israel-haters do. They don't "protest" Likud policies while supporting -- say -- Qadima or Labor. They hate ("protest" isn't the right word in this case) not a particular policy, but the very substance, the IDEA of a State of the Jews. They may point to particular policies (only as buzzwords -- "settlements", "occupation", etc.), but that's deceitful. It's not like they'd reconcile themselves with the existence of the Jewish state -- would that state dismantle settlements, etc. It's not like they accepted it when there was no "settlement" & no "occupation". Beyond the deceit, what they REALLY want is to destroy the State of the Jews. Jews are -- for these "people" -- not entitled to national self-determination.
As for "plenty" of Israelis ("plenty" meaning
However -- all that is unimportant. What is important is unmasking your double-talk and attempt at deceit.
I did not ask you "how was Israel established" -- I do not need YOU to tell me that. I asked you to recognize Israel as the Nation State of the Jewish People, just as you demand a state for the Palestinian people. That means that anyone who sees him/herself as a "refugee" gets to "return" to the Palestinian State, NOT to the Jewish State. No double-talk. Yes or No?